Skip to main content

ETHNOS_APP

Home • Search • Journals • List 0

With, against and beyond Lefebvre

Planetary urbanization and epistemic plurality

Bibliographic Data

ID4475907
AuthorsM Buckley (0000-0003-4742-1796, The Scarborough Hospital, corresponding author), Kendra Strau (0000-0003-3216-5793, Simon Fraser University), Kendra Strauss (Simon Fraser University)
Year2016
Volume34
Issue4
Pages617-636
Publication date2016-08-01
Peer ReviewedYes
Open AccessYes
TypeARTICLE
VenueEnvironment and Planning D Society and Space (JOURNAL)
Journal identifiersISSN: 0263-7758 • E-ISSN: 1472-3433
PublisherSAGE Publications Inc (PUBLISHER)
DOI10.1177/0263775816628872
OpenAlexW2341098258
LanguageEN
Citations received89
References cited50

In this paper, we discuss a number of recent efforts to critique, dismantle and problematize the categorical ontologies of 'the urban' and articulate an overarching epistemological framework for urban theory. Our intervention in these debates, which to date have focused primarily on Henri Lefebvre's hypothesis regarding 'planetary urbanization', highlights the absence of an engagement with the long legacy within feminist urban scholarship of confronting and dismantling the categories of the 'urban' and 'rural'. We argue that attending to this legacy foregrounds two conceptual and intellectual challenges that Lefebvre sets for us in his writings on the urban phenomenon. The first relates to Lefebvre's arguments about the central role that a focus on difference and everyday life must play in understanding late capitalist urbanization and the urban condition. The second relates to Lefebvre's articulation of the simultaneous problem and imperative of epistemological plurality within urban theory, including the role he ascribed to intellectual cooperation on the study of the urban phenomenon. We conclude by offering some thoughts on the importance Lefebvre attached to residual forms of difference - both lived and epistemological - in urban research and action, and by extension, probe some of the limits of Lefebvrian frameworks for understanding the contemporary urban condition

Aesthetics · Articulation (sociology · Epistemology · Phenomenon · Political science · Politics · Scholarship · Sociology · Urban theory · Urbanization · Housing, Finance, and Neoliberalism · Law · Philosophy · Political Economy and Marxism · Urban Planning and Governance · Urban Studies

  • New Urban Spaces

    Neil Brenner•New Urban Spaces•2019

  • A Manifesto for the Just City

    Open Access•Roberto Rocco, Caroline Newton•A Manifesto for the Just City•2022

  • Urbanisation Through Brick Kilns

    Open Access•Pratik Mishra•Urbanisation•2020

  • The Interweaving of Everyday and Structural Perspectives

    Open Access•Marius Mlejnek, Petra Lütke•Urban Planning•2023

  • Dirty Landscapes

    Open Access•A Carse•Infrastructure, Environment, and…•2019

  • From Edenic Apocalypse to Gardens against Eden

    Open Access•Natasha Myers•Infrastructure, Environment, and…•2019

  • Here Comes the Sun

    Open Access•C B Jensen•Infrastructure, Environment, and…•2019

  • Reproducing Operational Landscapes

    Open Access•Bosman Batubara, Kei Otsuki et al.•International Journal of Urban…•2026

  • Patterns of Loss

    Open Access•Ivan N Alov, Marko D Petrović et al.•Urban Science•2026

  • From Segregation to Fragmentation

    Open Access•Víctor Picó Gutiérrez, Federico E González-Ramírez et al.•Urban Science•2025

  • Water urbanism and “living with flooding”

    Gillian Lawson, Mirko Guaralda et al.•Housing and Society•2021

  • Planetary rural geographies

    Open Access•Chi-Mao Wang, Damian Maye et al.•Dialogues in Human Geography•2023

  • Stuck inside the urban with the dialectical blues again

    Open Access•Jean-Paul D Addie•Cambridge Journal of Regions…•2020

  • Politics of rhythm and crisis in the slow death of higher education

    Open Access•Robert Shaw, Magdalena Blazek•Critical Studies in Education•2023

  • Post-City (II)

    Open Access•Dmitri Zamiatin•Sotsiologicheskoe Obozrenie /…•2019

  • Cities as aesthetic subjects

    Open Access•Delacey Tedesco, Matt Davies•Globalizations•2022

  • The urban domination of the planet

    Open Access•Kristina Grange, Michael Gunder•Planning Theory•2018

  • Diverse methodologies of care

    Open Access•Emma L Sharp, Kenzi Yee et al.•Asia Pacific Viewpoint•2024

  • Incorporation of urban differences in Tokyo, Mexico City, and Los Angeles

    Open Access•Naomi C Hanakata, Naomi Hanakata et al.•City•2022

  • The path you will choose won’t be a fairy tale’

    M D Gergan, Mabel Gergan et al.•Space and Polity•2020

  • Urban flood resilience

    Sarah Sharma, Sarah E Sharma•Review of International Political…•2022

  • The pandemic as gender arrhythmia

    Open Access•H Thorpe, Julie Brice et al.•Gender Work and Organization•2023

  • Gendering the city

    Melissa Butcher, Kate Maclean•Gender Place & Culture•2018

  • Envisioning gender, indigeneity and urban change

    Kate Maclean•Gender Place & Culture•2018

  • Understanding and researching urban extreme poverty

    Open Access•Chloe Yap, Colin Mcfarlane•Environment and Urbanization•2019

  • The gentrification of a post-industrial English rural village

    Open Access•Martin Phillips, Darren Smith et al.•Journal of Rural Studies•2022

  • Subaltern urbanism as a way of life

    Talent Moyo•Journal of Urban Affairs•2022

  • Moving urban political ecology beyond the ‘urbanization of nature’

    Open Access•Yannis Tzaninis, Tait Mandler et al.•Progress in Human Geography•2020

  • Strategic geographies

    Open Access•Sam Halvorsen•Progress in Human Geography•2025

  • Intersectional rhythmanalysis

    Open Access•Emily Reid-Musson•Progress in Human Geography•2017

  • The spaces of diaspora’s revitalization

    Open Access•I Ashutosh•Progress in Human Geography•2019

  • Diversity, representation, and the limits of engaged pluralism in (economic) geography

    Open Access•Emily Rosenman, Jessa Loomis et al.•Progress in Human Geography•2019

  • Relational comparison revisited

    Open Access•Gillian Hart•Progress in Human Geography•2016

  • The Construction State Unbound? Struggles Over the Seoul Metropolitan Region’s Greenbelt in an Era of Planetary Urbanization

    Open Access•Laam Hae, Jamie Doucette•International Journal of Urban…•2025

  • Decolonising feminist explorations of urban futures

    Elsa Koleth, Linda Peake et al.•Urban Geography•2023

  • Fossil urbanism

    Michael Simpson•Urban Geography•2020

  • We dredge because it doesn’t work”

    Seth Gustafson•Urban Geography•2020

  • Reterritorialization practices and strategies of campesinos in the urban frontier of Bogotá, Colombia

    Open Access•Germán A Quimbayo Ruiz, Juha Kotilainen et al.•Land Use Policy•2020

  • Transnational migration and the gendered right to the city in Buenos Aires

    Open Access•Tanja Bastia•Cities•2018

  • No flooding, no traffic jams here, no jobs either”

    Open Access•Thi-Thanh-Hien Pham, Khac Minh Tran et al.•Habitat International•2023

  • An urban political ecology for a world of cities

    Open Access•Roger Keil•Urban Studies•2020

  • Introduction

    Open Access•Jennifer Robinson•Urban Studies•2022

  • Infrastructure-led development and the peri-urban question

    Open Access•Juan Miguel Kanai, Seth Schindler•Urban Studies•2022

  • Dreaming dialectically

    Open Access•Ben A Gerlofs•Urban Studies•2020

  • Constitutive outsides or hidden abodes? Totality and ideology in critical urban theory

    Open Access•William Conroy•Urban Studies•2024

  • Socialist worldmaking

    Open Access•Łukasz Stanek•Urban Studies•2022

  • The constitution of the city and the critique of critical urban theory

    Open Access•Aaron J Scott•Urban Studies•2022

  • Extended urbanisation and the agrarian question

    Open Access•Swarnabh Ghosh, Ayan Meer•Urban Studies•2021

  • Hybrid networks, everyday life and social control

    Open Access•Shaun Smith•Urban Studies•2019

  • Re‐arranging the urban

    Open Access•The Urban Re‐Arrangements Collective, Adam Abdullah et al.•Transactions of the Institute of…•2023

  • Feminist political economy in geography

    Open Access•Marion Werner, Kendra Strau et al.•Geoforum•2016

  • Subaltern counter-urbanism

    Open Access•Tom Cowan, Thomas Cowan•Geoforum•2018

  • The spatial politics of depoliticization

    Open Access•Ville Kellokumpu•Nordia Geographical Publications•2023

  • Planetary concerns

    Alex Loftus•City•2018

  • The Anarchist Roots of Geography

    James Derrick Sidaway, Richard White et al.•The AAG Review of Books•2017

  • The Anarchist Roots of Geography

    Simon Springer•Anarchist Roots of Geography•2016

  • Queerying Peripheries

    Open Access•Bastian Neuhauser•Geography Compass•2025

  • The Co-production of Space, Politics and Subjectivities in India's Urban Peripheries

    Open Access•Shubhra Gururani, Loraine Kennedy•South Asia Multidisciplinary…•2021

  • Rural-urban interfaces and changing forms of relational and planetary rurality

    Open Access•J Qian, Shenjing He et al.•Journal of Rural Studies•2025

  • The Crisis in Crisis

    Joseph Masco•Current Anthropology•2017

  • Transformaciones urbanas y sostenibilidad territorial en la Pan-Amazonía

    Open Access•Revista Bitácora Urbano Territorial•Bitácora Urbano Territorial•2024

  • Extended Agrarian Question in Concessionary Capitalism

    Open Access•Bosman Batubara, Noer Fauzi Rachman•Agrarian South Journal of…•2022

  • The makeshift and the contingent

    Open Access•Rhys Dafydd Jones•Environment and Planning D…•2019

  • Between the colossal and the catastrophic

    Open Access•Neil Brenner, Swarnabh Ghosh•Environment and Planning A…•2022

  • Out in Space

    Open Access•Hillary Angelo, Kian Goh•International Journal of Urban…•2021

  • Planetary urbanization

    Open Access•N Oswin•Environment and Planning D…•2018

  • Splanetary Urbanization

    Open Access•Cindi Katz•International Journal of Urban…•2021

  • Planetary urbanization and totality

    Open Access•Kanishka Goonewardena•Environment and Planning D…•2018

  • Fragments for the Future

    Open Access•Jane Dyson, Craig Jeffrey•Annals of the American…•2022

  • Placing planetary urbanization in other fields of vision

    Open Access•Linda Peake, Darren Patrick et al.•Environment and Planning D…•2018

  • Itinerant urbanization

    Open Access•Tony Crowley, D Asher Ghertner•Environment and Planning D…•2022

  • Planetary urbanization in ruins

    Open Access•Cian O’callaghan•Environment and Planning D…•2018

  • Pushing the limits of urban research

    Open Access•Stefan Kipfer•Environment and Planning D…•2018

  • Debating planetary urbanization

    Open Access•Neil Brenner•Environment and Planning D…•2018

  • Masters of the universe

    Open Access•Kate D Derickson, Kate Derickson•Environment and Planning D…•2018

  • Journeys through planetary urbanization

    Open Access•Christian Schmid•Environment and Planning D…•2018

  • The urban under erasure

    Open Access•Rajyashree N Reddy•Environment and Planning D…•2018

  • Maximum exposure

    Open Access•Abdoumaliq Simone•Environment and Planning D…•2019

  • Extended urbanization in and from Brazil

    Open Access•Rodrigo Castriota, João Bosco Moura Tonucci Filho•Environment and Planning D…•2018

  • Planetary urbanization

    Open Access•Sue Ruddick, Linda Peake et al.•Environment and Planning D…•2018

  • Fragment urbanism

    Open Access•Colin Mcfarlane•Environment and Planning D…•2018

  • Territory, sustainability, and beyond

    Open Access•Germán A Quimbayo Ruiz•Environment and Planning E Nature…•2020

  • Planetary Urban Involution in the Tokyo Suburbs

    Open Access•Lieba Faier•International Journal of Urban…•2021

  • Critical Urban Theory in the 'Urban Age

    Open Access•N Oswin, Geraldine Pratt•International Journal of Urban…•2021

  • Theory From Empty Land

    Open Access•Asa Roast•International Journal of Urban…•2022

  • Indigenous Urbanism as an Analytic

    Open Access•Heather Dorries•International Journal of Urban…•2023

  • Climate riskscapes in world port cities

    Open Access•Anders Blok•Global Networks•2020

  • Feminisms, women's histories and heritage in 'inner city' London and Paris

    Open Access•Miranda Armstrong, M C Armstrong et al.•The Sociological Review•2025

  • Urban Developmentalism in East Asia

    Open Access•Jamie Doucette, Bae-Gyoon Park et al.•Critical Sociology•2018

  • Rethinking Feminist Interventions into the Urban

    Linda Peake, Martina Rieker•Rethinking Feminist Interventions…•2013

  • The Politics of the Encounter

    Andy Merrifield, Deborah Cowen et al.•Politics of the Encounter•2013

  • Urban Environments

    Open Access•David Simon•Annual Review of Environment and…•2008

  • Henri Lefebvre

    Open Access•Kanishka Goonewardena•The Wiley‐Blackwell Companion to…•2011

  • Rural-Urban Dynamics

    Katherine V Gough, Jytte Agergaard et al.•Rural-urban dynamics•2009

  • Gender, Work and Space

    Susan Hanson, Geraldine Pratt•Gender, Work and Space•2003

  • Golden Gulag

    Ruth Wilson Gilmore•Golden Gulag•2019

  • Black Feminist Thought

    Patricia Hill Collins•Black Feminist Thought•2013

  • Understanding Henri Lefebvre

    Stuart Elden•Understanding Henri Lefebvre•2004

  • Fatal Couplings of Power and Difference

    Ruth Wilson Gilmore•The Professional Geographer•2002

  • Space, Difference, Everyday Life

    Kanishka Goonewardena, Stefan Kipfer et al.•Space, Difference, Everyday Life•2008

  • Lefebvre, Love and Struggle

    R Shields•Lefebvre, Love and Struggle•1998

  • Spatializing Blackness

    Rashad Shabazz•Spatializing Blackness•2015

  • Beyond city limits

    Mark Davidson, Kurt Iveson•City•2015

  • Towards a new epistemology of the urban

    Neil Brenner, Christian Schmid•City•2015

  • Building a better theory of the urban

    Richard Walker•City•2015

  • Urban revolution now. Henri Lefebvre in social research and architecture

    G Carabelli•Space and Polity•2016

  • New frontiers in twenty-first century urban conflict and violence

    Open Access•Caroline O N Moser, Caroline Moser et al.•Environment and Urbanization•2014

  • Urban geography I

    Open Access•Kate D Derickson•Progress in Human Geography•2014

  • Henri Lefebvre

    Open Access•Stefan Kipfer, Parastou Saberi et al.•Progress in Human Geography•2012

  • Gender, Class, and Urban Space

    Liz Bondi•Urban Geography•1998

  • World, City, Queer

    Open Access•N Oswin•Antipode•2015

  • Rethinking Local Activism

    Open Access•Eleanor Jupp•Urban Studies•2012

  • Global cities, transnational flows and gender dimensions

    Open Access•B S A Yeoh, Brenda Yeoh et al.•Tijdschrift voor Economische en…•2000

  • The Queer Afterlife of the Postcolonial City

    Open Access•Bobby Benedicto•Antipode•2014

  • Situating the Anthropocene

    Sue Ruddick•Urban Geography•2015

  • The condition of postmodernity

    David Harvey•The condition of postmodernity•1989

  • Knitting and the City

    Open Access•Laura Price•Geography Compass•2015

  • A New Space for Knowledge and People? Henri Lefebvre, Representations of Space, and the Production of 22@Barcelona

    Open Access•Greig Charnock, Ramon Ribera-Fumaz•Environment and Planning D…•2011

  • The 'Urban Age' in Question

    Open Access•Neil Brenner, Christian Schmid•International Journal of Urban…•2014

  • Race' and Sexuality

    Open Access•Linda Peake•Environment and Planning D…•1993

  • Boys Town

    Open Access•Rosalyn Deutsche•Environment and Planning D…•1991

  • Gender, Class, and Space

    Open Access•Geraldine Pratt, Hanson et al.•Environment and Planning D…•1988

  • Where's the Difference? The Heterosexualization of Alterity in Henri Lefebvre and Jacques Lacan

    Open Access•Virginia Blum, Virginia L Blum et al.•Environment and Planning D…•1996

  • Towards an Understanding of the Gender Division of Urban Space

    Open Access•L Mcdowell•Environment and Planning D…•1983

  • Reconstituting the Possible

    Open Access•David Pinder•International Journal of Urban…•2015

  • The Urban Question under Planetary Urbanization

    Open Access•Andy Merrifield•International Journal of Urban…•2013

  • Locating Globalization

    Open Access•Richa Nagar, Violet Lawson et al.•Economic Geography•2002

  • Rethinking queer migration through the body

    Andrew Gorman-Murray•Social & Cultural Geography•2007

  • Get Thee to a Big City

    K Weston•GLQ A Journal of Lesbian and Gay…•1995

  • Out of the Closets, Into the Woods

    Open Access•Scott Herring•American Quarterly•2007

  • Masculine Cities and Feminine Suburbs

    Susan Saegert•Signs: Journal of Women in…•1980

  • Feminist Theory

    Nassira Hedjerassi, Bell Hooks et al.•Feminist Theory•2014

  • In a Queer Time and Place

    Jack Halberstam, J Jack Halberstam•In a Queer Time and Place•2022

  • Theses on Urbanization

    Neil Brenner•Public Culture•2013

Unique citing works89
Citations per year8,9
Citation span2016 - 2026 (11)
Citation velocitycurrent
Highly citedNo
Citation typesNeutral: 89

Tools

Open DOISci-Hub
Ethnos_APP • Open Source Project • MIT License • Frontend v2.0.0 • Privacy and Cookies • API Documentation: api.ethnos.app/docs • API Source Code: GitHub • DOI: 10.5281/zenodo.17049435 • Frontend Source Code: GitHub • DOI: 10.5281/zenodo.17050053 • cruz.rio.br • Expectantes Misericordiae