From Catastrophe to Hope

In his recent book, Amir Eshel focuses on over thirty recent German-, Hebrew-, and English-language novels to develop a reading method-the "hermeneutics of futurity"-that would replace moralizing approaches to past traumas, including German guilt over the Holocaust and Israeli denial of Palestinian suffering. Futurity demonstrates how various narratives imagine a future liberated from denial, guilt, and thus traumatic repetition. In so doing Eshel emphasizes human agency to counter the "hermeneutics of suspicion" that has long dominated a great deal of literary theory, and focuses on how novelists construct human choices and their consequences. He covers two generations of German-language novels spanning the Adenauer era to the present, and two generations of Israeli writers reflecting on 1948 and later, 1967. In order to develop fully the concept of futurity he also writes on recent American and English novels, often with implicitly political themes.The book succeeds in demonstrating the value of how various novelists read the past otherwise in order to reconstruct the present and future. At the same time, Eshel conceives human agency and "choice" so capaciously that the book often neglects the institutional constraints on agency that afflict victims of traumas in particular. His treatment of Martin Walser's controversial fictionalized memoir is exemplary of this problem in an otherwise stimulating work

Aesthetics · Agency (philosophy) · Art · Construct (python library) · Denial · Epistemology · German · Hermeneutics · Human condition · Linguistics · Literature · Memoir · Narrative · Political science · Politics · Psychoanalysis · Reading (process) · Sociology · The Holocaust · German History and Society · History · Law · Literature and Cultural Memory · Philosophy · Psychology