Why Do We Ask "What If?" Reflections on the Function of Alternate History
Bibliographic Data
| ID | 4496368 |
|---|---|
| Authors | Gavriel D Rosenfeld (0000-0001-9469-5373, Fairfield University, corresponding author), Gavriel Rosenfeld |
| Year | 2002 |
| Volume | 41 |
| Issue | 4 |
| Pages | 90-103 |
| Publication date | 2002-12-01 |
| Peer Reviewed | Yes |
| Open Access | Yes |
| Type | ARTICLE |
| Venue | History and Theory (JOURNAL) |
| Journal identifiers | ISSN: 0018-2656 • E-ISSN: 1468-2303 |
| Publisher | Wiley (PUBLISHER • GB) |
| DOI | 10.1111/1468-2303.00222 |
| OpenAlex | W2060651239 |
| Language | EN |
| Citations received | 25 |
The new prominence of alternate history in Western popular culture has increasingly prompted scholars to historicize it as a broader phenomenon. What has largely escaped notice until now, however, has been the question of the underlying function of alternate history as a genre of speculative narrative representation. In this essay, I argue that writers and scholars have long produced "allohistorical narratives" out of fundamentally presentist motives. Allohistorical tales have assumed different typological forms depending upon how their authors have viewed the present. Nightmare scenarios, for example, have depicted the alternate past as worse than the real historical record in order to vindicate the present, while fantasy scenarios have portrayed the alternate past as superior to the real historical record in order to express dissatisfaction with the present. The presentist character of alternate histories allows them to shed light upon the evolving place of various historical events in the collective memory of a given society. In this essay, I examine American alternate histories of three popular themes-the Nazis winning World War II, the South winning the Civil War, and the American Revolution failing to occur-in order to show how present-day concerns have influenced how these events have been remembered. In the process, I hope to demonstrate that alternate histories lend themselves quite well to being studied as documents of memory. By examining accounts of what never happened, we can better understand the memory of what did
Aesthetics · Art · Collective memory · Epistemology · Fantasy · Literature · Narrative · Notice · Order (exchange) · Phenomenon · Political science · Politics · Presentism · Representation (politics) · Sociology · Folklore, Mythology, and Literature Studies · Gothic Literature and Media Analysis · History · Law · Narrative Theory and Analysis · Philosophy
"The Ways We Wonder "What If
Unilateral jurisdiction
Possibilities of the Past
Security and Identity in Jewish Utopias of the Late Twentieth and Twenty-First Centuries
Introduction—Historical Fiction and the 1960s
Alternative History Genre in the Fine Literature. The Role of European Myth in Cryptohistorical Writing
Storia controfattuale e great men in Erodoto e Tucidide
Sideways televised
Antycypacja i wyobraźnia. Tekstowa „przyszła Polska”
Uchronian Scenarios in the Context of Irish Literature
R. F. Burton Revisited
What if there had only been half the oil? Rewriting history to envision the consequences of peak oil
Affective future and non-existent history
What if?’
Historical science fiction
Life Writing, Cultural Memory, and Historical Mediation in Julie Otsuka's When the Emperor was Divine
A New Paradigm for the Second Amendment
Whose History? Engaging History Students through Historical Fiction
Using Counterfactual History to Enhance Students’ Historical Understanding
Other worlds
What-If at Waterloo. Carl von Clausewitz’s use of historical counterfactuals in his history of the Campaign of 1815
Scenarios and counterfactuals as modal narratives
Une morale internationale de la mise en accusation
Ethical reasoning and justification in international relations
When to Use Counterfactuals in Causal Historiography
| Unique citing works | 25 |
|---|---|
| Citations per year | 1,14 |
| Citation span | 2004 - 2026 (23) |
| Citation velocity | current |
| Highly cited | No |
| Citation types | Neutral: 21 |