Einstein as a Disciple of Galileo A Comparative Study of Concept Development in Physics

The ArgumentIn this paper I present and argue for a model of conceptual development in science and apply it to the transition from classical to modern physics associated with Einstein. The model claims a continuous and rational transition between incompatible subsequent conceptual systems in mathematical science and explains its mechanism. The model was developed in a study of the transition from preclassical to classical mechanics. I argue for a strong structural analogy between the transition from preclassical to classical mechanics on the one hand and from classical to modern physics on the other. The first transition is briefly sketched here by reference to Galileo and his disciples; in the second transition Planck and Lorentz on the one hand and Einstein on the other play the respective roles.A detailed and documented reconstruction of the transition from preclassical to classical mechanics on the basis of this model has already been published and is only briefly referred to in the paper. The transition from classical to modern physics is portrayed here much more extensively-though of course merely in broad brush strokes. Einstein-s role in this transition is reconstructed in the light of a conceptualization of his scientific knowledge as an active structure of thought, shaped by his intellectual experience. In this way, the development of his individual thinking is shown to be part of the overall process of conceptual transformation from classical to modern physics. The reconstruction sketched in this paper is to be considered as a proposal to be substantiated, reformed, and improved by future detailed studies

Analogy · Classical mechanics · Classical physics · Conceptualization · Einstein · Epistemology · Modern physics · Physics · Quantum · Quantum mechanics · Theoretical physics · Chemistry · Historical Philosophy and Science · History of Science and Medicine · Philosophy · Philosophy and History of Science

• A note on the prehistory of indistinguishable particles

  Open Access•Daniela Monaldi•Studies in History and Philosophy…•2009

  Incluir item

• Exploring the limits of classical physics

  Open Access•Jochen Büttner, Joachim Renn et al.•Studies in History and Philosophy…•2003

  Incluir item

• Von der klassischen Trägheit zur dynamischen Raumzeit

  Open Access•Joachim Renn, Jürgen Renn•Berichte zur Wissenschaftsgeschicht…•1997

  Incluir item

• The Mystery of the Einstein-Poincaré Connection

  Olivier Darrigol•Isis•2004

  Incluir item