Skip to main content

ETHNOS_APP

Home • Search • Journals • List 0

Stratification by Skin Color in Contemporary Mexico

Bibliographic Data

ID4522016
AuthorsA Villarreal (0000-0003-1560-1717, The University of Texas at Austin, corresponding author)
Year2010
Volume75
Issue5
Pages652-678
Publication date2010-10-01
Peer ReviewedYes
Open AccessYes
TypeARTICLE
VenueAmerican Sociological Review (JOURNAL)
Journal identifiersISSN: 0003-1224 • E-ISSN: 1939-8271
PublisherSAGE Publications Inc (PUBLISHER)
DOI10.1177/0003122410378232
OpenAlexW2094060775
LanguageEN
Citations received157
References cited69

Latin America is often used as a backdrop against which U.S. race relations are compared. Yet research on race in Latin America focuses almost exclusively on countries in the region with a large recognized presence of individuals of African descent such as Brazil. Racial categories in these countries are based on skin color distinctions along a black-white continuum. By contrast, the main socially recognized ethnic distinction in Indo-Latin American countries such as Mexico, between indigenous and non-indigenous residents, is not based primarily on phenotypical differences, but rather on cultural practices and language use. Many Mexicans today nevertheless express a preference for whiter skin and European features, even though no clear system of skin color categorization appears to exist. In this study, I use data from a nationally-representative panel survey of Mexican adults to examine the extent of skin-color-based social stratification in contemporary Mexico. Despite extreme ambiguity in skin color classification, I find considerable agreement among survey interviewers about who belongs to three skin color categories. The results also provide evidence of profound social stratification by skin color. Individuals with darker skin tone have significantly lower levels of educational attainment and occupational status, and they are more likely to live in poverty and less likely to be affluent, even after controlling for other individual characteristics

Categorization · Dark skin · Ethnic group · Geography · Indigenous · Latin Americans · Political science · Poverty · Skin color · Social class · Social science · Social stratification · Sociology · Anthropology · Demography · Dermatology · Medicine · Racial and Ethnic Identity Research · Social and Cultural Dynamics

  • The Infracategorical Model of Inequality, Colorism, and the Erasure of Black Sociology

    Open Access•E P Monk•Sociology of Race and Ethnicity•2026

  • Exclusion and Discrimination in the Labor Market

    Maitreyi Bordia Das•2013

  • Ascribed Race and Interactions with Law Enforcement

    Open Access•Jay Jennings, Ajay Singh et al.•Criminal Justice Review•2026

  • Movilidad ocupacional intergeneracional en Colombia

    Open Access•Carlos Augusto Viáfara López•Sociedad y Economía•2023

  • Persistently high incidence rates of childhood acute leukemias from 2010 to 2017 in Mexico City

    Open Access•Janet Flores-Lujano, Janet Flores‐Lujano et al.•Frontiers in Public Health•2022

  • Effects of physical appearance of ad endorsers featured in gay-targeted ads, explained by endorser match-up and identification

    Javier Flores-Zamora•International Journal of…•2023

  • What Moves Love? Skin‐Tone Discrimination in the Dating Market in Mexico

    Open Access•Claudia Josselyn Barranco‐Santamaria, Raymundo M Campos-Vázquez•Social Science Quarterly•2026

  • The intersecting associations between race and ethnicity, skin color, and perceived unfair treatment by police

    J G Finkeldey, C R Dennison et al.•Journal of Ethnicity in Criminal…•2023

  • More than a Game

    Open Access•Samantha Eddy•Humanities•2020

  • The Hidden Rules of Race

    Andrea Flynn, Dorian T Warren et al.•Hidden Rules of Race•2017

  • Privilege at Play

    Hugo Ceron-Anaya, Hugo Ceron‐anaya•Privilege at Play•2019

  • Politics beyond Black and White

    Lauren D Davenport•Politics Beyond Black and White•2018

  • Translating “Race” and “Raza” between the U nited S tates and M exico

    Open Access•J Hartigan•North American Dialogue•2013

  • Beyond pigmentocracy

    Open Access•Javier Castillo, Mauricio Salgado•Frontiers in Sociology•2026

  • Childhood Racism and Cardiometabolic Risk in Latina Mothers Across the First Postpartum Year

    Rebeca Harris, Rebeca Alvarado Harris et al.•Psychosomatic Medicine•2024

  • Hybrid Identities

    Open Access•Panu Minkkinen•Legalities•2024

  • Mejorando La Raza

    Open Access•Mara Cecilia Ostfeld, Nicole Yadon et al.•Social Forces•2021

  • De qué me ves cara

    Abigail Nieves Delgado, Vivette García Deister et al.•AIBR, Revista de Antropologia…•2017

  • The Endogeneity of Race

    Open Access•A Villarreal, Stanley R Bailey•Social Forces•2019

  • Interrogando la gramática racial de la blanquitud

    Open Access•Darío Hernán Vásquez-Padilla, Castriela Esther Hernández-Reyes•Latin American Research Review•2020

  • Whiteness wars in Las niñas bien

    Mónica García Blizzard•Latin American and Caribbean…•2023

  • Arrested Realities

    Open Access•Leanne M Confer, Samantha Kopf•Race and Justice•2025

  • To be or not to be? Material incentives and indigenous identification in Latin America

    R D Flores, David Sulmont•Ethnic and Racial Studies•2021

  • Ethnic Inequality in Mexican Education

    Millie Creighton, Mathew J Creighton et al.•Social Forces•2016

  • Group Threat, Racial/Ethnic Animus, and Punitiveness in Latin America

    Open Access•Peter S Lehmann, Cecilia Chouhy et al.•Race and Justice•2022

  • Intergenerational Mobility and Gender in Mexico

    F Torche•Social Forces•2015

  • Race/Ethnicity, Perceived Skin Color, and the Likelihood of Adult Arrest

    Open Access•J G Finkeldey, Stephen Demuth•Race and Justice•2021

  • Not in the Eye of the Beholder

    Open Access•Alice Krozer, Andrea Gómez•Latin American Research Review•2023

  • Racial Stratification Among Latinos in the Mortgage Market

    Open Access•José Loya•Race and Social Problems•2022

  • Skin Color and System Support in Latin America

    Open Access•Peter M Sánchez, David Doherty et al.•The Journal of Race Ethnicity and…•2021

  • Differences in Body Weight According to Skin Color and Sex in Mexican Adults

    Open Access•Luis Ortiz-Hernández, Itzel Patricia Miranda-Quezada•Journal of Racial and Ethnic…•2023

  • Setting the Tone

    Open Access•Jacqueline M Chen, Andrew Francis-Tan•Race and Social Problems•2022

  • How Prevalent are Colortocracies in Latin America

    Open Access•Ryan A Smith, Rubia R Valente•Du Bois Review Social Science…•2026

  • Desigualdades socioeconómicas y étnico-raciales en la mortalidad de un hijo durante su niñez en México. ¿Qué tanto importa el color de la piel

    Open Access•Jesús-Daniel Zazueta-Borboa•Revista Brasileira de Estudos de…•2023

  • Health Implications of Colorism

    Open Access•Jasmine Patterson, Karri L Grob et al.•Journal of Racial and Ethnic…•2025

  • Racial stratification in self-rated health among Black Mexicans and White Mexicans

    Open Access•Guadalupe Marquez-Velarde, Nicole E Jones et al.•SSM - Population Health•2019

  • Color disparities in cognitive aging among Puerto Ricans on the archipelago

    Open Access•Mao‐mei Liu, Michael Crowe et al.•SSM - Population Health•2021

  • Race as Social Construct

    Open Access•Helmuth Nyborg•Psych•2019

  • Skin Tone Differences in Social Mobility in Mexico

    Open Access•Luis Monroy‐gómez‐franco, Roberto Vélez-Grajales•Journal of Economics Race and…•2020

  • Immigrant Perceptions of U.S.-Born Receptivity and the Shaping of American Identity

    Open Access•Michael Jones‐correa, Helen B Marrow et al.•RSF The Russell Sage Foundation…•2018

  • Pathways to Skin Color Stratification

    Open Access•M Abascal, Denia Garcia•Sociological Science•2022

  • Colorism Revisited

    Open Access•Mauricio Bucca•Sociological Science•2024

  • Alarma

    Susana Vargas Cervante•TSQ Transgender Studies Quarterly•2014

  • A Social Cartography of Trans Homicides

    Open Access•Natália Heringer Mendonça, Natalia Heringer et al.•Sociology Compass•2026

  • If all you have is a hammer, everything looks like a nail

    Open Access•Christina Steidl, Regina Werum•Sociology Compass•2019

  • Picturing Tragedy

    Open Access•Gabriela Ruhl Ibarra, Jonathan Van ‘t Riet et al.•Mass Communication & Society•2024

  • The color of death

    Quincy Thomas Stewart, R J Cobb et al.•Ethnicity and Health•2018

  • Whiteness, Mestizaje, and social equity

    Felipe Blanco•Administrative Theory & Praxis•2024

  • Applying Intersectionality in Organizations

    Open Access•Mayra Ruiz Castro, Mayra Ruiz‐Castro et al.•Gender Work and Organization•2016

  • The Impact of Interviewer Effects on Skin Color Assessment in a Cross-National Context

    Open Access•Alex Cernat, Joseph W Sakshaug et al.•International Journal of Public…•2018

  • The Heredity Matrix

    Carlos Lopez-Beltran, A Nieves Delgado et al.•Science as Culture•2022

  • Unequal gradients

    Open Access•Luis Monroy‐gómez‐franco, Roberto Vélez-Grajales et al.•Journal of Population Economics•2026

  • Drop out from primary to secondary school in Mexico

    Benjamin G Gibbs, T B Heaton•International Journal of…•2013

  • Exchanging fluids

    Open Access•Tomás Cabeza De Baca, Aurelio José Figueredo et al.•Politics and the Life Sciences•2020

  • Merit and blame in unequal societies

    Open Access•Mauricio Bucca•Research in Social Stratification…•2016

  • How skin color, class status, and gender intersect in the labor market

    Open Access•Felipe A Dias, Felipe Dias•Research in Social Stratification…•2020

  • Pigmentocracies

    Open Access•E Telles, R D Flores et al.•Research in Social Stratification…•2015

  • U.S. Sanctuary Policies and Mexicans’ Migration Preferences

    Open Access•K Zhirkov, Rachel Smilan-Goldstein•International Migration Review•2025

  • Colorism in the Rental Housing Market

    Open Access•Amelia R Branigan, Matthew Hall et al.•Social Psychology Quarterly•2023

  • Posición socioeconómica, discriminación y color de piel en México

    Open Access•Luis Ortiz-Hernández, Luis Ortiz Hernandez et al.•Perfiles Latinoamericanos•2017

  • Entre confusiones y distracciones

    Open Access•Monica G Moreno Figueroa•Estudios Sociológicos de El…•2022

  • Blanquitud vs. blancura, mestizaje y privilegio en México de los siglos XIX a XXI, una propuesta de interpretación

    Open Access•Federico Navarrete Linares•Estudios Sociológicos de El…•2022

  • Cuántas palabras vale una vida? Cobertura mediática y contexto local de homicidios en México

    Open Access•Juan Honey Wuest, J Wüest et al.•Revista Mexicana de Ciencias…•2023

  • Ethnoracial and Educational Homogamy in Mexico

    Open Access•Braulio Güémez, Patricio Solís•Population Research and Policy…•2022

  • Latino internacional, no güeros, no morenos”. Racismo colorista en la publicidad en México

    Open Access•Juris Tipa•Boletín de Antropología•2020

  • Nationalism and National Identity in North America

    Open Access•Dillon P Byrd•Nationalities Papers•2023

  • Contextual Boundaries

    Open Access•Peter Catron, María Vignau Loría et al.•Demography•2024

  • Skin Color and Social Mobility

    Open Access•Raymundo M Campos-Vázquez, Eduardo M Medina-Cortina•Demography•2019

  • Racial Inequality in Education in Brazil

    Open Access•L J Marteleto, Molly Dondero•Demography•2016

  • The Color of Electoral Success

    Open Access•Raymundo M Campos-Vázquez, Carolina Rivas‐Herrera•Social Science Quarterly•2021

  • Why Can’t I Be Latina, Female, and Professional? Clinical Implications of Social Discourses that Render Class Invisible

    María del Mar Fariña•Smith College Studies in Social…•2020

  • Layers of Inequality

    Open Access•Luis Monroy‐gómez‐franco, Roberto Vélez-Grajales et al.•The Review of Black Political…•2021

  • Places, History and Memories

    Open Access•Raúl Castro Pérez, Raúl Castro-Pérez et al.•SAGE Open•2025

  • Serving (Fetishized) Time

    Open Access•Lauren J DeCarvalho, Nadia I Martínez‐carrillo•The Journal of Popular Culture•2018

  • Ethnoracial identity, skin color, and national pride in Latin America

    Open Access•Marisa Sarah Meno•International Journal of…•2025

  • Towards Hemispheric Conversations in the Americas

    Open Access•Daniel P Gámez, María Belén Noroña et al.•Antipode•2024

  • Nadie Me Ve Como Latinx

    Open Access•Luis Mendez, Teresa Satterfield•Language Culture and Society•2024

  • Educational outcomes of Asian and Hispanic Americans

    Open Access•I Ryabov•Research in Social Stratification…•2015

  • Does Skin Tone Matter? Immigrant Mobility in the U.S. Labor Market

    Open Access•Joohee Han•Demography•2020

  • Skin Tone and Mexicans’ Perceptions of Discrimination in New Immigrant Destinations

    Open Access•Helen B Marrow, D G Okamoto et al.•Social Psychology Quarterly•2022

  • Reassessing Arrest Disparity Using Skin Tone as a Continuous Variable

    Open Access•Soren Brockdorf•Race and Social Problems•2025

  • Measures of 'Race' and the analysis of racial inequality in Brazil

    Open Access•Stanley R Bailey, Mara Loveman et al.•Social Science Research•2013

  • "Contínuo Racial, Mobilidade Social E "Embranquecimento

    Open Access•Carlos A Costa Ribeiro, Carlos Ribeiro•Revista Brasileira de Ciências…•2018

  • Histories of Colorism and Implications for Education

    Verna M Keith, Carla R Monroe•Theory Into Practice•2016

  • Skin Tone and Inequality of Socioeconomic Outcomes in Mexico

    Open Access•Patricio Solís, Braulio Güémez et al.•Sociology of Race and Ethnicity•2025

  • Unwelcome Immigrants Knocking on the Door

    Open Access•Jeongnam Hwang, Jeongho Choi•International Migration Review•2026

  • Colorism

    Open Access•Ray, Victor Ray•The Blackwell Encyclopedia of…•2019

  • Electoral Discrimination

    Open Access•Matthew W Johnson, Marcus Johnson•World Politics•2020

  • Measuring Perceived Skin Color

    M Abrajano, Christopher S Elmendorf et al.•The Journal of Politics•2023

  • Phenotypic Preference in Mexican Migrants

    Open Access•Rosario Aguilar, D Alex Hughes et al.•Political Behavior•2019

  • Avoiding backlash

    Open Access•René Rejón•Ethnicities•2023

  • The Pigmentocracy of Executive Approval

    Open Access•Swaran P Singh, Ryan E Carlin•Comparative Political Studies•2025

  • Las Vidas Negras Importan

    Open Access•Danielle P Clealand•Annual Review of Political Science•2022

  • The Fluidity of Racial Classifications

    Open Access•Lauren D Davenport, Lauren Davenport•Annual Review of Political Science•2020

  • Dinámicas de estratificación socioespacial en ciudades del norte y sur de Chile

    Open Access•Félix Rojo-Mendoza, Félix Rojo Mendoza et al.•Revista de Urbanismo•2023

  • Minding the curve

    Open Access•Harold J Toro•British Journal of Sociology•2021

  • Parental Control over Mate Choice to Prevent Marriages with Out-group Members

    Open Access•A P Buunk, Thomas V Pollet et al.•Human Nature•2012

  • Beyond Money Whitening

    Open Access•W D Roth, Patricio Solís et al.•American Sociological Review•2022

  • Colored Perceptions

    Open Access•Denia Garcia, M Abascal•American Behavioral Scientist•2016

  • Away from home, into the fields

    Open Access•Christina J Diaz, Erick Samayoa et al.•Social Science & Medicine•2024

  • The Puerto Rican nation on the move

    Jorge Duany•The Puerto Rican nation on the move•2002

  • Changing race

    Clara E Rodríguez•Changing race•2000

  • Race and Racism a Comparative Perspective

    Pierre L Van Den Berghe•Race and Racism a Comparative…•1972

  • México Profundo

    Guillermo Bonfil Batalla, Philip A Dennis•México Profundo•1996

  • Making Race and Nation

    Open Access•Anthony W Marx•Making Race and Nation•1997

  • Statistical Methods for Rates and Proportions

    Open Access•Joseph L Fleiss, Bruce Levin et al.•Statistical methods for rates and…•2003

  • Exits from the Labyrinth

    Claudio Lomnitz-Adler, Claudio Lomnitz‐adler•Exits from the Labyrinth•1992

  • Shades of Citizenship

    Melissa Nobles•Shades of Citizenship•2000

  • An Analysis of Sample Attrition in Panel Data

    John Fitzgerald, Peter Gottschalk et al.•The Journal of Human Resources•1998

  • Hierarchical linear models

    Anthony S Bryk, Stephen W Raudenbush•Hierarchical linear models•2002

  • Racism in a racial democracy

    France Winddance Twine•Racism in a racial democracy•1998

  • Racism, Revolution, and lndigenismo

    Alan Knight•Idea of Race in Latin America,…•1990

  • A Coefficient of Agreement for Nominal Scales

    Open Access•Jacob Cohen•Educational and Psychological…•1960

  • Afro-Latin America, 1800-2000

    George Reid-Andrews, George Reid Andrews•Afro-Latin America, 1800-2000•2004

  • Slaves of the White God

    Colin A Palmer•Slaves of the White God•1976

  • Crossing Borders, Reinforcing Borders

    P Vila•Crossing Borders, Reinforcing…•2000

  • Indians into Mexicans

    David Frye•Indians into Mexicans•1996

  • Race in Another America

    E Telles, Edward Eric Telles•Race in Another America•2004

  • On the Cunning of Imperialist Reason

    Open Access•Pierre Bourdieu, L Wacquant•Theory Culture & Society•1999

  • The Forging of the Cosmic Race

    Irving A Leonard, Colin M Maclachlan et al.•Hispanic American Historical Review•1981

  • The Forging of the Cosmic Race

    Irving A Leonard•Hispanic American Historical Review•1981

  • The Course of Mexican History

    Charles Gibson•Hispanic American Historical Review•1980

  • Indigenism, Mestizaje, and National Identity in Mexico during the 1940s and the 1950s

    Anne T Doremus, Anne Doremus•Mexican Studies/Estudios Mexicanos•2001

  • Population, Ethnicity, and Nation-Building

    David Blatt, D W E Blatt et al.•International Migration Review•1996

  • Being Indian in Hueyapan

    Open Access•Judith Friedlander•Being Indian in Hueyapan•2006

  • Class, Ethnicity, and Community in Southern Mexico

    Colin P Clarke, Colin Clarke et al.•Class, Ethnicity, and Community…•2000

  • An analysis of the Latin Americanization of race in the United States

    Open Access•Edward Murguia, Rogelio Sáenz•Race and Society•2002

  • Latino Phenotypic Discrimination Revisited

    Open Access•Rodolfo Espino, Michael M Franz•Social Science Quarterly•2002

  • A new Mexican nationalism? Indigenous rights, constitutional reform and the conflicting meanings of multiculturalism

    Open Access•Guillermo De La Peña•Nations and Nationalism•2006

  • Multiracial versus Collective Black Categories

    Open Access•Stanley R Bailey, E Telles et al.•Ethnicities•2006

  • Phenotype and Life Chances Among Chicanos

    Open Access•Carlos H Arce, Edward Murguia et al.•Hispanic Journal of Behavioral…•1987

  • Race and Class in Latin America

    Howard F Cline, Magnus Mörner•The American Historical Review•1971

  • Does it matter who answers the race question? Racial classification and income inequality in Brazil

    Open Access•E Telles, Edward E Telles et al.•Demography•1998

  • How Puerto Rico Became White

    Open Access•Mara Loveman, Jeronimo Oliveira Muniz•American Sociological Review•2007

  • Group Dominance and the Myth of Racial Democracy

    Open Access•Stanley R Bailey•American Sociological Review•2004

  • Race of the Interviewer and Perception of Skin Color

    Mark Hill, Mark E Hill•American Sociological Review•2002

  • Does Money Whiten? Intergenerational Changes in Racial Classification in Brazil

    Open Access•L F Schwartzman•American Sociological Review•2007

  • Weighted kappa

    Jacob Cohen•Psychological Bulletin•1968

  • Manuel Gamio and Official Indigenismo in Mexico

    David A Brading•Bulletin of Latin American Research•1988

  • Toward a Comparative Analysis of Race Relations Since Abolition in Brazil and the United States

    Open Access•Thomas E Skidmore•Journal of Latin American Studies•1972

  • Social Dimensions of Race

    Patricia Seed•Hispanic American Historical Review•1982

  • Fire and Blood

    Michael C Meyer, T R Fehrenbach•Hispanic American Historical Review•1974

  • Class and Ethnicity in Mexico

    Open Access•Hugo G Nutini•Ethnology•1997

  • The Significance of Color Remains

    Michael Hughes, Michael D Hughes et al.•Social Forces•1990

  • Blacks, Black Indians, Afromexicans

    Open Access•L A Lewis•American Ethnologist•2000

  • Ethnic Relations in Southeastern Mexico1

    Open Access•Benjamin N Colby, Pierre L Van Den Berghe•American Anthropologist•1961

  • Ethnic Classification in Southeastern Puerto Rico

    Clarence C Gravlee•Social Forces•2005

  • Race Mixture

    E Telles, Edward E Telles et al.•Annual Review of Sociology•2009

  • Social and Cultural Policies Toward Indigenous Peoples

    Guillermo De La Peña•Annual Review of Anthropology•2005

  • History and Significance of the Emic/Etic Distinction

    Marvin Harris•Annual Review of Anthropology•1976

  • Unmixing for Race Making in Brazil

    Stanley R Bailey•American Journal of Sociology•2008

  • The Race Construct and Public Opinion

    Stanley R Bailey•American Journal of Sociology•2002

  • Skin Tone and Stratification in the Black Community

    Verna M Keith, Cedric Herring•American Journal of Sociology•1991

  • An assessment of the Latin Americanization thesis

    C A Sue, Christina Sue•Ethnic and Racial Studies•2009

  • Racial ambiguity among the Brazilian population

    E Telles, Edward E Telles•Ethnic and Racial Studies•2002

  • Race and Class in Colonial Latin America

    Open Access•Robert Mccaa, Stuart B Schwartz et al.•Comparative Studies in Society…•1979

  • Internationally Comparable Measures of Occupational Status for the 1988 International Standard Classification of Occupations

    Open Access•Harry B G Ganzeboom, Donald J Treiman•Social Science Research•1996

Unique citing works157
Citations per year10,47
Citation span2011 - 2026 (16)
Citation velocitycurrent
Highly citedYes
Citation typesNeutral: 156

Tools

Open DOISci-Hub
Ethnos_APP • Open Source Project • MIT License • Frontend v2.0.0 • Privacy and Cookies • API Documentation: api.ethnos.app/docs • API Source Code: GitHub • DOI: 10.5281/zenodo.17049435 • Frontend Source Code: GitHub • DOI: 10.5281/zenodo.17050053 • cruz.rio.br • Expectantes Misericordiae