Skip to main content

ETHNOS_APP

Home • Search • Journals • List 0

The City in the Country

Wilderness Gentrification and the Rent Gap

Bibliographic Data

ID4768024
AuthorsEliza Jane Darling (The Graduate Center, CUNY, corresponding author), Eliza Darling (0000-0002-7007-6735, Graduate School and University Center, City University of New York, 365 Fifth Avenue, New York, NY 10016, USA)
Year2005
Volume37
Issue6
Pages1015-1032
Publication date2005-06-01
Peer ReviewedYes
Open AccessYes
TypeARTICLE
VenueEnvironment and Planning A Economy and Space (JOURNAL)
Journal identifiersISSN: 0308-518X • E-ISSN: 1472-3409
PublisherSAGE Publications Inc (PUBLISHER)
DOI10.1068/a37158
OpenAlexW1969850937
LanguageEN
Citations received122
References cited29

In this paper I explore the efficacy of applying Neil Smith's theory of the rent gap to rural gentrification in New York State's Adirondack Park, making three central claims. In the first place, although the underlying impetus for both rural and urban gentrification (namely, the maximization of profit on the part of a variety of gentrifying agents from individual owner-occupants to large-scale developers) is essentially the same, some fundamental differences between the determination of what constitutes 'undercapitalized' ground rent in the city and the wilderness leads to subsequent differences in the geographical expression of gentrification in each area. In the second, the unique land-management practices instituted by the State of New York in this region have set up the conditions for a singular type of disinvestment not typically found in the city, rendering disinvestment a central aspect of Adirondack gentrification but in a different way than the disinvestment which anchors Smith's argument. Finally, I argue that the 'postproductivist' theories which have recently gained currency in the extant rural gentrification literature are not applicable to the empirical realities of Adirondack land use, suggesting that rural areas themselves may be sufficiently differentiated to render the idea of an overarching, homogeneous 'rural gentrification' suspect and pointing to the need for a more refined and specific set of labels to indicate a variety of landscape-specific gentrification models in the hinterlands

Development economics · Disinvestment · Economic geography · Economic growth · Economics · Gentrification · Geography · Incentive · Market economy · Political economy · Political science · Redevelopment · Sociology · Wilderness · Forest Management and Policy · Land Use and Ecosystem Services · Law · Rural development and sustainability

  • Nowa” wiejska klasa średnia

    Open Access•Maria Halamska, Dominika Zwęglińska-Gałecka•Studia Socjologiczne•2023

  • Home and away from home

    Rowland Atkinson, Felicity Picken et al.•Urban Research & Practice•2009

  • Gentrificación lenta

    Open Access•Gustavo Durán Saavedra, Juan Mérida•Scripta Nova Revista Electrónica…•2023

  • Land Administration System structured Land rent residuals and China’s urban sprawl – A Case Study of Dashi, Guangzhou

    Open Access•Xuan Liu, Liu Xuan et al.•Urbani izziv•2012

  • Gentrification

    Open Access•Loretta Lees•International Encyclopedia of the…•2015

  • Le capital environnemental, nouvelle clé d'interprétation de la gentrification rurale ?

    Open Access•Frédéric Richard, Greta Tommasi et al.•Norois•2017

  • Gentrificación en Chile

    Open Access•Ernesto López-Morales•Revista de geografía Norte Grande•2013

  • “Land of Confusion”

    Rucitarahma Ristiawan, Khusnul Bayu Aji•Tourism Planning & Development•2026

  • Yeni Umut Mekânı Olarak Kırsal

    Open Access•Arzu Başaran Uysal•İDEALKENT•2024

  • Vergessenes Land. Perspektiven auf rurale Entwicklung

    Bernd Belina, Andreas Kallert et al.•PROKLA Zeitschrift für kritische…•2021

  • Planning and Development Challenges in Western Gateway Communities

    Philip Stoker, Danya Rumore et al.•Journal of the American Planning…•2021

  • A quantitative assessment of spatial patterns of socio-demographic change in coastal Maine

    Open Access•Jing Yuan, Kate Beard et al.•Applied Geography•2021

  • Rural Soundscape

    Maichi Match Chen, Jie Zhang et al.•The Professional Geographer•2021

  • Recent Urban-to-Rural Migration and Its Impact on the Heritage of Depopulated Rural Areas in Southern Transylvania

    Open Access•Alexandru Dragan, Raluca Tatiana Ispas et al.•Heritage•2024

  • Are energy megaprojects socially disruptive? Assessing the impacts of the As Pontes fossil fueled power plant in Spain

    Open Access•Xaquin S Perez Sindin•Energy Research & Social Science•2021

  • Spatial and temporal scale in comparative approaches to rural gentrification

    Open Access•Peter B Nelson•Dialogues in Human Geography•2018

  • Response to Phillips and Smith

    Open Access•J Dwight Hines•Dialogues in Human Geography•2018

  • Theriophobia

    Justin Harmon•World Leisure & Recreation•2023

  • Entrepreneurial Back‐to‐Landers

    Open Access•Candan Turkkan•Population Space and Place•2024

  • Counterurbanisation and rural gentrification

    Open Access•Martin Phillips•Population Space and Place•2009

  • Rural gentrification, the booming B&B industry and linked migration in China

    Open Access•Chen Chen, Zhanyi Luo et al.•Population Space and Place•2024

  • The Social Value of Second Homes in Rural Communities

    Nick Gallent•Housing Theory and Society•2013

  • How Much Does Property Cost Up There?”

    Ryanne Pilgeram•Society & Natural Resources•2018

  • Rural gentrification and nature in the Old and New Wests

    Jeremy Bryson, William Wyckoff•Journal of Cultural Geography•2010

  • Understanding the multiple dynamics of the countryside – Examples from forest cases in northern Europe

    Open Access•E C H Keskitalo, Gun Lidestav et al.•Journal of Rural Studies•2020

  • Understanding the underutilization of rural housing land in China

    Open Access•Jinlong Gao, Yuanyuan Cai et al.•Journal of Rural Studies•2021

  • Local perspectives on rural housing affordability and implications for the localism agenda in England

    Open Access•Nick Gallent, Steve Robinson•Journal of Rural Studies•2011

  • Seasonal gentrification and its (dis)contents

    Open Access•Coşku Kocabıyık, Maarten Loopmans•Journal of Rural Studies•2020

  • Rural gentrification in Russia

    Open Access•Natalia Mamonova, Lee-Ann Sutherland et al.•Journal of Rural Studies•2015

  • State-led commodification of rural China and the sustainable provision of public goods in question

    Open Access•Mingrui Shen, Jianfa Shen•Journal of Rural Studies•2019

  • Land dispossession, rural gentrification and displacement

    Open Access•Renhao Yang, Maarten Loopmans•Journal of Rural Studies•2022

  • The rural geographies of Barbara Kingsolver's Prodigal Summer

    Open Access•Alistair Fraser•Journal of Rural Studies•2014

  • Holistic gentrification and the recreation of rurality

    Open Access•Yue Du•Journal of Rural Studies•2022

  • The actions of key agents in facilitating rural super-gentrification

    Open Access•Danielle Sheppard, Pemberton et al.•Journal of Rural Studies•2023

  • The diverse geographies of rural gentrification in Scotland

    Open Access•Alan Stockdale, Aileen Stockdale•Journal of Rural Studies•2009

  • Producing an ideal village

    Open Access•Xueke Yang, Honggang Xu•Journal of Rural Studies•2022

  • Relational rurals

    Open Access•Jesse Heley, Laura Jones•Journal of Rural Studies•2012

  • Return of the gentleman farmer

    Open Access•Lee-Ann Sutherland, Lee‐ann Sutherland•Journal of Rural Studies•2012

  • Understanding rural gentrification in China

    Open Access•Sijie Li, Yingnan Zhang et al.•Journal of Rural Studies•2024

  • Saying “No” to (the) Oxygen Capital? Amenity migration, counter-territorialization, and uneven rural landscape change in the Kaz Dağları (Ida Mountains) of western Turkey

    Open Access•Patrick T Hurley, Yilmaz Ari•Journal of Rural Studies•2018

  • Creating land markets for rural revitalization

    Open Access•Keisyu Kan•Journal of Rural Studies•2020

  • Gentrification and neo-rural populations in the Québec countryside

    Open Access•Laurie Guimond, Myriam Simard•Journal of Rural Studies•2010

  • Aestheticisation, rent-seeking, and rural gentrification amidst China's rapid urbanisation

    Open Access•J Qian, Shenjing He et al.•Journal of Rural Studies•2013

  • Agriculture and inequalities

    Open Access•Lee-Ann Sutherland, Lee‐ann Sutherland•Journal of Rural Studies•2018

  • The gentrification of a post-industrial English rural village

    Open Access•Martin Phillips, Darren Smith et al.•Journal of Rural Studies•2022

  • The Oregon Way

    Open Access•Robert F Young•Journal of Planning Education and…•2015

  • Rural geography

    Open Access•James J Mccarthy•Progress in Human Geography•2007

  • Geographies of long-distance family migration

    Open Access•Darren Smith•Progress in Human Geography•2011

  • Comparative approaches to gentrification

    Open Access•Martin Phillips, Darren Smith•Dialogues in Human Geography•2018

  • Rural-urban interfaces and changing forms of relational and planetary rurality

    Open Access•J Qian, Shenjing He et al.•Journal of Rural Studies•2025

  • Baroque rurality in an English village

    Open Access•Martin Phillips•Journal of Rural Studies•2013

  • Emerging paradigm in redressing the imbalanced “state-village” power relationship

    Open Access•Jin Zhu, Jinwei Hao et al.•Journal of Rural Studies•2025

  • Rethinking the effects of gentrification on the health of Black communities in the United States

    Scott Whittaker, Carolyn B Swope et al.•Journal of Urban Affairs•2023

  • Amenity migration

    Open Access•Hannah Gosnell, J Abrams•GeoJournal•2009

  • Resort-induced Changes in Small Mountain Communities in British Columbia, Canada

    Open Access•Sanjay K Nepal, Tazim Jamal et al.•Mountain Research and Development•2011

  • On and beyond gentrifiers

    Open Access•Yawei Zhao•Housing Studies•2024

  • Re-placing displacement in gentrification studies

    Open Access•Martin Phillips, Darren Smith et al.•Geoforum•2020

  • Horsification

    Open Access•Lee-Ann Sutherland, Lee‐ann Sutherland•Geoforum•2021

  • When guesthouse meets home

    Open Access•Yawei Zhao•Geoforum•2019

  • Building SoHo in Shenzhen

    Open Access•Keisyu Kan, Karita Kan•Geoforum•2020

  • Maps and contradictions

    Open Access•Seth Gustafson•Geoforum•2015

  • Rural gentrification as white flight

    Open Access•J Dwight Hines•Journal of Rural Studies•2026

  • Private enterprises as intermediaries in rural commercial gentrification

    Open Access•Peipei Chen, Xueke Yang•Journal of Rural Studies•2026

  • Thank God for the greatest country on earth

    Crockford•Religion State & Society•2018

  • Ländliche Gentrifizierung. Aufwertung und Verdrängung jenseits der Großstädte – Vorschlag für ein Forschungsprogramm

    Open Access•Michael Mießner, M Naumann•Geographica Helvetica•2021

  • A Cultural Model of Farmer Land Conservation

    M Paolisso, Priscilla Weeks et al.•Human Organization•2013

  • Writing the New West

    Open Access•Paul Robbins, Katie Meehan et al.•Rural Sociology•2009

  • Mapping the Socioeconomic Landscape of Rural Sweden

    Martin Hedlund•Regional Studies•2014

  • We live in nature all the time

    Open Access•Pia Heike Johansen, Jens Kaae Fisker et al.•Geoforum•2021

  • Placing Food Systems in First World Political Ecology

    Open Access•Ryan E Galt•Geography Compass•2013

  • The rural housing crisis

    Stefan Kordel, M Naumann•Housing Studies•2024

  • Urban renewal simulation with spatial, economic and policy dynamics

    Open Access•Guiwen Liu, Sijing Chen et al.•Land Use Policy•2019

  • How rent facilitates capital accumulation

    Open Access•Xiaoliang Hu, Hongbo Li et al.•Land Use Policy•2024

  • Attitudes to housing and planning policy in rural localities

    Open Access•Menelaos Gkartzios, Mark Scott•Land Use Policy•2013

  • Spatial determinants of land redevelopment in the urban renewal processes in Shenzhen, China

    Open Access•Yani Lai, Bo Tang et al.•Land Use Policy•2021

  • (Dis)connecting rent gap and gentrification in verticalizing cities

    Open Access•Ernesto López-Morales, Nicolás Herrera et al.•Cities•2024

  • Local government intervention in tourism-driven rural gentrification

    Open Access•Xiaolong Ma, Weifeng Su•Tourism Management•2024

  • Alternative counter-urbanisation and the collage rural

    Open Access•Xinhui Wu, Xun Li et al.•Habitat International•2025

  • The emergence of counter-urbanisation in China

    Open Access•Li Yu, Yiran Wang et al.•Habitat International•2024

  • Cultural reinvention or cultural erasure? A study on rural gentrification, land leasing, and cultural change

    Open Access•Jiexiang Zhao, Jiangang Zhu et al.•Habitat International•2025

  • Tourism-induced land acquisition in protected areas

    Open Access•Jingyu Li, Arie Stoffelen et al.•Annals of Tourism Research•2024

  • Amenity/lifestyle migration to the Global South

    Gerhard Rainer•Third World Quarterly•2019

  • Planetary Rent Gaps

    Open Access•Tom Slater•Antipode•2017

  • The Post‐Industrial Regime of Production/Consumption and the Rural Gentrification of the New West Archipelago

    Open Access•J Dwight Hines•Antipode•2012

  • A Hostile Takeover of Nature? Placing Value in Conservation Finance

    Open Access•Kelly Kay•Antipode•2018

  • Finance, Home Building, and Urban Residential Structuring

    Open Access•Geir Inge Orderud•Antipode•2011

  • Gentrifying the peri-urban

    Open Access•Delik Hudalah, Haryo Winarso et al.•Urban Studies•2016

  • Apprehending Land Value Through Tourism in Indonesia

    Open Access•Rucitarahma Ristiawan, Edward H Huijbens et al.•Tijdschrift voor Economische en…•2024

  • A Process of Change and a Changing Process

    Open Access•Brian Doucet•Tijdschrift voor Economische en…•2014

  • Expanding Frontiers of Commercial Gentrification

    Open Access•Xing Huang, Hao Gu•Tijdschrift voor Economische en…•2024

  • Beyond post‐politics

    Open Access•Evangelia Apostolopoulou•Transactions of the Institute of…•2019

  • Latino Immigrants and Rural Gentrification

    L Nelson, Laurie Trautman et al.•Annals of the Association of…•2015

  • Of reds and rednecks

    Open Access•Eliza Jane Darling•Dialectical Anthropology•2009

  • Gentrifying the African Landscape

    Open Access•Connor Joseph Cavanagh, Teklehaymanot G Weldemichel et al.•Annals of the American…•2020

  • Moving from “superstar” cities to “ordinary” cities to reclaim middle-class status

    Nina Martins, Grey Shipman et al.•Urban Geography•2025

  • Du new urbanism au new ruralism

    Open Access•Serge Schmitz•Géocarrefour•2008

  • Interactive gentrification in rural tourism in China

    Mengzhen Zhang, Menghan Wang et al.•Tourism Geographies•2025

  • Going Bush

    Open Access•Lauren Costello•Geographical Research•2007

  • Connecting country and city

    Open Access•Levi Van Sant, Taylor Shelton et al.•Geography Compass•2023

  • Evolving interdependencies between two waves of gentrifiers in the wax and wane of a 'Utopian Village

    Open Access•Jinwei Hao, Jin Zhu et al.•Geographical Journal•2025

  • City Form and Everyday Life

    Jon Caulfield•City Form and Everyday Life•1994

  • Toward a Theory of Gentrification A Back to the City Movement by Capital, not People

    N T Smith, Neil Smith•Journal of the American Planning…•1979

  • Constructing the Countryside

    Marsden Terry•Constructing the Countryside•1993

  • The Machine in the Garden

    Lesley Marx, Leo Marx•The machine in the garden•2000

  • Social Change And The Middle Classes

    Tim Butler, Mike Savage•Social Change and the Middle…•2013

  • Extending the temporal and spatial limits of gentrification

    Open Access•Darren Smith•International Journal of…•2002

  • Rural Gentrification and Livestock Raising

    Open Access•Mark Friedberger•Rural History•1996

  • Rural gentrification and the processes of class colonisation

    Open Access•Martin Phillips•Journal of Rural Studies•1993

  • Investigations of the British rural middle classes — Part 2

    Open Access•Martin Phillips•Journal of Rural Studies•1998

  • Rural planning

    Open Access•Brian P Mclaughlin, Brian Mclaughlin•Journal of Rural Studies•1988

  • The future of the British rural landscape

    Open Access•Nigel Roome•Journal of Rural Studies•1988

  • Investigations of the british rural middle classes — Part 1

    Open Access•Martin Phillips•Journal of Rural Studies•1998

  • Socio-cultural representations of greentrified Pennine rurality

    Open Access•Darren Smith, D P Smith et al.•Journal of Rural Studies•2001

  • Regulating the new rural spaces

    Open Access•Philip Lowe, Jonathan Murdoch et al.•Journal of Rural Studies•1993

  • Other geographies of gentrification

    Open Access•Martin Phillips•Progress in Human Geography•2004

  • Gentrification and Capital

    Open Access•N T Smith, Neil Smith•Antipode•1979

  • The Rent Gap Debunked

    Open Access•Steven C Bourassa•Urban Studies•1993

  • Contested Terrain

    David Tatham, Philip G Terrie•Journal of American History•1998

  • The production, symbolization and socialization of gentrification

    Open Access•Martin Phillips•Transactions of the Institute of…•2002

  • The Blind Men and the Elephant

    Chris Hamnett•Transactions of the Institute of…•1991

  • An Australian View of the Rent Gap Hypothesis

    Blair Badcock•Annals of the Association of…•1989

  • Gentrification and the Rent Gap

    N T Smith, Neil Smith•Annals of the Association of…•1987

  • Alternative Explanations for Inner-City Gentrification

    David Ley•Annals of the Association of…•1986

  • The condition of postmodernity

    David Harvey•The condition of postmodernity•1989

  • The New Urban Frontier

    Neil Smith•The New Urban Frontier•2005

  • New Globalism, New Urbanism

    Open Access•N T Smith, Neil Smith•Antipode•2002

  • Life on the Upslope

    Open Access•C A Mills•Environment and Planning D…•1988

  • New Times and Spaces? The Perils of Transition Models

    Open Access•Nigel Thrift, N J Thrift•Environment and Planning D…•1989

  • Rural gatekeepers and 'greentrified' Pennine rurality

    Darren P Smith, Darren Smith•Social & Cultural Geography•2002

Unique citing works122
Citations per year6,42
Citation span2007 - 2026 (20)
Citation velocitycurrent
Highly citedYes
Citation typesNeutral: 118

Tools

Open DOISci-Hub
Ethnos_APP • Open Source Project • MIT License • Frontend v2.0.0 • Privacy and Cookies • API Documentation: api.ethnos.app/docs • API Source Code: GitHub • DOI: 10.5281/zenodo.17049435 • Frontend Source Code: GitHub • DOI: 10.5281/zenodo.17050053 • cruz.rio.br • Expectantes Misericordiae