Skip to main content

ETHNOS_APP

Home • Search • Journals • List 0

Ecological reflexivity

Characterising an elusive virtue for governance in the Anthropocene

Bibliographic Data

ID4772499
AuthorsJeffrey Pickering (0000-0002-1862-3623, University of Canberra, corresponding author), Jonathan Pickering (University of Canberra)
Year2019
Volume28
Issue7
Pages1145-1166
Publication date2019-11-10
Peer ReviewedYes
Open AccessNo
TypeARTICLE
VenueEnvironmental Politics (JOURNAL)
Journal identifiersISSN: 0964-4016 • E-ISSN: 1743-8934
PublisherInforma UK Limited (PUBLISHER • GB)
DOI10.1080/09644016.2018.1487148
OpenAlexW2809091571
LanguageEN
Citations received32
References cited57

Reflexivity – the capacity of an agent, structure or process to change in the light of reflection on its performance – has attracted widespread support among political theorists as a virtue for environmental governance. Dryzek argues that a distinctively ecological form of reflexivity becomes crucial for governing in the Anthropocene. But there remains a need to clarify the conceptual scope of ecological reflexivity and to ascertain whether it has distinctive analytical value. A new conceptual framework for ecological reflexivity is outlined, comprising three components: recognition, rethinking and response. Through a comparative analysis of reflexivity and four related concepts – adaptive and transformative governance, experimental governance, social learning and anticipatory governance – ecological reflexivity is shown to be especially well equipped to take account of political contestation over the nature and direction of change required to respond to ecological risks

Anthropocene · Biology · Corporate governance · Earth system science · Ecological systems theory · Economics · Environmental ethics · Epistemology · Political science · Politics · Reflexivity · Social science · Sociology · Transformative learning · Virtue · Climate Change and Geoengineering · Environmental Philosophy and Ethics · Law · Sustainability and Climate Change Governance · Ecology

  • Earth system law

    Open Access•Louis J Kotzé, Richard E Kim•Earth System Governance•2019

  • New directions in earth system governance research

    Open Access•Stuart Burch, Aarti Gupta et al.•Earth System Governance•2019

  • Radical changes are needed for transformations to a good Anthropocene

    Open Access•Timon Mcphearson, Christopher M Raymond et al.•npj Urban Sustainability•2021

  • Ecosystems and Ordering

    Open Access•Cristiana Maglia, Elana Wilson Rowe•Global Studies Quarterly•2023

  • Judicial Response to Ecological Environment Risk in China—From the Perspective of Social Systems Theory

    Open Access•Tian Sang, Peng Liu et al.•International Journal of…•2022

  • Living labs from a governance perspective

    Open Access•Jitske Van Popering‐verkerk, Michael Duijn et al.•Environmental Science & Policy•2026

  • Rethinking the Environmental Virtue of Ecological Justice from the Interdependencies of Non-Human Capabilities and Synergetic Flourishing

    Open Access•Cristian Moyano-Fernández•Philosophies•2023

  • Unpacking Authoritarian Environmental Governance

    J A Zinda•Sociology of Development•2023

  • Enhancing the social acceptance of sustainability transitions

    Open Access•Auvikki De Boon•Environmental Innovation and…•2026

  • Knowledge governance for the Anthropocene

    Open Access•Serge Clément•Global Policy•2022

  • Does climate transparency enhance the reflexive capacity of state actors to improve mitigation performance? The case of Indonesia

    Open Access•Nila Kamil, Sam Bush et al.•Earth System Governance•2021

  • Governance for Earth system tipping points – A research agenda

    Open Access•Manjana Milkoreit, Edith Boyd et al.•Earth System Governance•2024

  • The valuation of a mine – values, facts and contested notions of sustainability in the prospecting for new mines

    Open Access•Monika Berg•Environmental Sociology•2024

  • Four approaches to anticipatory climate governance

    Open Access•Karlijn Muiderman, Aarti Gupta et al.•Wiley Interdisciplinary Reviews…•2020

  • Exploring the links between climate transparency and mitigation policy through a reflexive capacity lens

    Open Access•Nila Kamil, Sylvia Karlsson-Vinkhuyzen•International Environmental…•2023

  • From environmental policy consensus to socio-environmental policy controversy

    Open Access•Kimberley Vandenhole•Environmental Science & Policy•2025

  • Multi-level learning for systemic transformation

    Open Access•Stephen Williams, Steve Williams et al.•Environmental Science & Policy•2024

  • Political science and the Earth system

    Open Access•Manjana Milkoreit•The British Journal of Politics…•2025

  • Reflexive Peacebuilding

    Dahlia Simangan•Global Society•2021

  • Unpacking the agricultural innovation and diffusion for modernizing the smallholders in rural China

    Open Access•Cheng Chen, Jinlong Gao et al.•Journal of Rural Studies•2024

  • Governing agricultural innovation

    Open Access•Auvikki De Boon, Camilla Sandström et al.•Journal of Rural Studies•2021

  • Nuclear denial in Japan

    Open Access•Michael C Dreiling, Tomoyasu Nakamura et al.•Theory and Society•2023

  • Transformative capacities for navigating system change

    Open Access•Christopher J Orr, Stuart Burch•Sustainability Science•2025

  • Too much hope in us? A qualitative inquiry into the deficit of ecological reflexivity in UN sustainability discourses

    Open Access•Joohee Lee, Manuela G Hartwig•Futures•2025

  • Opportunities for and barriers to anticipatory governance of two lake social–ecological systems in Germany and Canada

    Open Access•Louis Tanguay, Laura M Herzog et al.•People and Nature•2023

  • Facing mass extinction, it is prudent to decolonise lands & laws

    Jeremy Bendik-Keymer•Griffith Law Review•2020

  • Making sense of ecomodernism

    Daniel Lara-De La Fuente•Environmental Politics•2024

  • Deep-time organizations

    Open Access•Frederic Hanusch, Felix Biermann et al.•The Anthropocene Review•2020

  • The environmental state between pre-emption and inoperosity

    Luigi Pellizzoni•Environmental Politics•2020

  • The future of 'environmental' policy in the Anthropocene

    Open Access•Felix Biermann, Frank Biermann•Environmental Politics•2021

  • Geoengineering, climate change and ecological security

    Matt Mcdonald•Environmental Politics•2023

  • The gaze from afar

    Open Access•Carl Cassegard, Karl Malmqvist et al.•Environmental Politics•2025

  • Risk Society

    Ulrich Beck•Risk Society•2013

  • Democratizing Global Climate Governance

    Open Access•Hayley Stevenson, John S Dryzek•Democratizing Global Climate…•2014

  • Climate Governance at the Crossroads

    Matthew J Hoffmann, Matthew Hoffmann•Climate governance at the…•2011

  • Ignorance and Surprise

    M Gro, Matthias Gross•Ignorance and surprise•2010

  • Contextualizing Reflexive Governance

    Open Access•Carolyn M Hendriks, J Grin•Journal of Environmental Policy &…•2007

  • Moving Outside or Inside? Objectification and Reflexivity in the Governance of Socio-Technical Systems

    Adrian Smith, Andy Stirling•Journal of Environmental Policy &…•2007

  • ‘Earth system’ analysis and the second Copernican revolution

    Open Access•Hans Joachim Schellnhuber•Nature•1999

  • Anticipatory Governance

    Ray Quay•Journal of the American Planning…•2010

  • Resilience and Stability of Ecological Systems

    C S Holling•Annual Review of Ecology and…•1973

  • The Struggle to Govern the Commons

    Open Access•Thomas Dietz, Elinor Ostrom et al.•Science•2003

  • Adaptive Governance of Social-Ecological Systems

    Open Access•Carl Folke, Thomas Hahn et al.•Annual Review of Environment and…•2005

  • Geology of mankind

    Open Access•Paul J Crutzen, Sheldon A Zabel•Nature•2002

  • A Theory of Justice

    Open Access•John Rawls•Theory of Justice•1999

  • Listening for Democracy

    Amy Dobson, Andrew Dobson•Listening For Democracy…•2014

  • Risk Society

    Ulrich Beck•Encyclopedia of Social Theory•2005

  • Defining Environmental Justice

    David Schlosberg•DEFINING ENVIRONMENTAL JUSTICE:…•2007

  • Reflexive Governance for Sustainable Development

    J-P Voss, R P M Kemp et al.•Reflexive Governance for…•2006

  • Public uptake of science

    Open Access•Brian Wynne•Public Understanding of Science•1993

  • Deliberation as a catalyst for reflexive environmental governance

    Open Access•John S Dryzek, Jeffrey Pickering et al.•Ecological Economics•2017

  • Varieties of experimentalism

    Open Access•Christopher Ansell, Christopher K Ansell et al.•Ecological Economics•2016

  • Societal transformation in response to global environmental change

    Open Access•Giuseppe Feola, Michael K Goodman•AMBIO•2015

  • Learning in International Organizations in Global Environmental Governance

    Bernd Siebenhüner•Global Environmental Politics•2008

  • Adaptive co-management and the paradox of learning

    Open Access•Derek Armitage, Melissa Marschke et al.•Global Environmental Change•2007

  • A conceptual framework for analysing adaptive capacity and multi-level learning processes in resource governance regimes

    Open Access•Claudia Pahl-Wostl, Claudia Pahl‐wostl•Global Environmental Change•2009

  • Plausible and desirable futures in the Anthropocene

    Open Access•Xuemei Bai, Sander Van Der Leeuw et al.•Global Environmental Change•2015

  • Maladaptation

    Open Access•Jon Barnett, Saffron O''Neill•Global Environmental Change•2009

  • Resilience thinking meets social theory

    Open Access•Muriel Côte, Andrea J Nightingale•Progress in Human Geography•2011

  • Anticipatory governance for social-ecological resilience

    Open Access•Edith Boyd, Emily Boyd et al.•AMBIO•2015

  • The Politics of the Anthropocene

    John S Dryzek, Jeffrey Pickering et al.•Politics of the Anthropocene•2018

  • Assembling an experimentalist regime

    Open Access•Christine Overdevest, Jonathan Zeitlin•Regulation & Governance•2014

  • A Dilemma of Green Democracy

    Open Access•John K Wong, James K Wong•Political Studies•2016

  • Global Experimentalist Governance

    Open Access•Gráinne De Búrca, Robert O Keohane et al.•British Journal of Political…•2014

  • Institutions for the Anthropocene

    Open Access•John S Dryzek•British Journal of Political…•2016

  • Systematising Policy Learning

    Open Access•Claire A Dunlop, Claudio M Radaelli•Political Studies•2012

  • Global environmental change II

    Open Access•Karen O’brien•Progress in Human Geography•2011

  • Understanding 'anticipatory governance

    Open Access•David H Guston•Social Studies of Science•2013

  • What is Social Learning

    Open Access•Myer S Reed, Mark S Reed et al.•Conservation Ecology•2010

  • The Politics of Reflexive Governance

    Open Access•Jan-Peter Voß, Basil Bornemann•Conservation Ecology•2011

  • Are adaptations self-organized, autonomous, and harmonious? Assessing the social-ecological resilience literature

    Open Access•Thomas Hahn, Thomas P Hahn et al.•Conservation Ecology•2017

  • Ecological modernisation and institutional reflexivity

    Arthur P J Mol•Environmental Politics•1996

  • Rethinking Sustainability in the Anthropocene

    Manuel Arias Maldonado, Manuel Arias-Maldonado•Environmental Politics•2013

  • Resilience Thinking

    Open Access•Carl Folke, R Carpenter et al.•Conservation Ecology•2010

  • Sustainability Learning in Natural Resource Use and Management

    Open Access•J D Tàbara, Claudia Pahl-Wostl et al.•Conservation Ecology•2007

  • A decade of adaptive governance scholarship

    Open Access•Brian C Chaffin, Hannah Gosnell et al.•Conservation Ecology•2014

  • Resilience, Adaptability and Transformability in Social-ecological Systems

    Open Access•Brian Walker, C S Holling et al.•Conservation Ecology•2004

  • The trajectory of the Anthropocene

    Open Access•Will Steffen, Wendy Broadgate et al.•The Anthropocene Review•2015

  • Reflexive Modernization

    Open Access•Scott Lash•Theory Culture & Society•1993

  • Anti-reflexivity

    Open Access•Aaron M Mccright, Riley E Dunlap•Theory Culture & Society•2010

  • Against Reflexivity as an Academic Virtue and Source of Privileged Knowledge

    Open Access•Michael Lynch, Michael S Lynch•Theory Culture & Society•2000

Unique citing works32
Citations per year4,57
Citation span2019 - 2026 (8)
Citation velocitycurrent
Highly citedNo
Citation typesNeutral: 30

Tools

Open DOISci-Hub
Ethnos_APP • Open Source Project • MIT License • Frontend v2.0.0 • Privacy and Cookies • API Documentation: api.ethnos.app/docs • API Source Code: GitHub • DOI: 10.5281/zenodo.17049435 • Frontend Source Code: GitHub • DOI: 10.5281/zenodo.17050053 • cruz.rio.br • Expectantes Misericordiae