Skip to main content

ETHNOS_APP

Home • Search • Journals • List 0

Wars that Make States and Wars that Make Nations

Organised Violence, Nationalism and State Formation in the Balkans

Bibliographic Data

ID4776649
AuthorsSiniša Malešević (0000-0002-1864-6382, University College Dublin, corresponding author)
Year2012
Volume53
Issue1
Pages31-63
Publication date2012-04-01
Peer ReviewedYes
Open AccessYes
TypeARTICLE
VenueEuropean Journal of Sociology (JOURNAL)
Journal identifiersISSN: 0003-9756 • E-ISSN: 1474-0583
PublisherCambridge University Press (CUP) (PUBLISHER)
DOI10.1017/s0003975612000021
OpenAlexW2031555039
LanguageEN
Citations received17
References cited55

Since the beginning of the 19th century the Balkans has been a synonym for aggressive nationalism and unbridled violence; the two phenomena traditionally understood to be the key obstacles for its social development. This paper contests such views by arguing that it was the absence of protracted warfare and coherent nationalist doctrines that distinguishes the history of South Eastern Europe from the rest of the continent. Drawing critically on bellicose historical sociology and modernist theories of nationalism - with a spotlight on the work of Charles Tilly and Ernest Gellner. Drawing critically on bellicose historical sociology and modernists theories of nationalism the paper makes a case that it was not the abundance of nationalism and organised violence but rather their historical scarcity that proved decisive for the slow pace of social development in the Balkans

Geography · Nationalism · Pace · Political economy · Political science · Politics · Sociology · State (computer science) · Balkans: History, Politics, Society · Central European national history · Italian Fascism and Post-war Society · Law

  • Human Rights as an Ideology? Obstacles and Benefits

    Open Access•Lea David•Critical Sociology•2020

  • Crime, violence, and coercive power

    Siniša Malešević•Journal of Political Power•2022

  • A cultural route for Ottoman heritage in Europe

    Aleksandra Terzić, Elka Dogramadjieva•Journal of Heritage Tourism•2022

  • Synchronous nationalisms – reading the history of nationalism in South–Eastern Europe between and beyond the binaries

    Open Access•Raul Cârstocea•National Identities•2021

  • Reporting from the Frontline

    Iakovos D Michaïlidis, Iakovos Michailidis•Media History•2018

  • Citizenship in the Name of the Mother

    B Grossman-Thompson, Dannah Dennis•positions asia critique•2017

  • The Past Can't Heal Us

    Open Access•Lea David•Past Can't Heal Us•2020

  • From sacrifice to prestige

    Siniša Malešević•Visual Studies•2017

  • Democracy, Development and Industrial Policy in Nigeria

    Open Access•Abel B S Gaiya, F Aremu et al.•THEORIA An International Journal…•2021

  • Decolonizing Palestine

    C Lund, Robert Vitalis et al.•The AAG Review of Books•2022

  • Nation‐building policies in the Balkans

    Open Access•Harris Mylonas•Nations and Nationalism•2019

  • Nationalism, populism or peopleism? Clarifying the distinction through a two‐dimensional lens

    Open Access•Marina Vulović, Emilia Palonen•Nations and Nationalism•2022

  • Perceptions of Contested Ottoman Heritage in Europe

    Elka Dogramadjieva, Aleksandra Terzić•Heritage & Society•2025

  • Charles Tilly’s Theories About the Origins of European Nation-States, Social Movements, Contentious Politics, and Democracy

    Open Access•Ernesto Castañeda•American Behavioral Scientist•2025

  • The mirage of Balkan Piedmont

    Open Access•Siniša Malešević•Nations and Nationalism•2017

  • Is War Becoming Obsolete? A Sociological Analysis

    Open Access•Siniša Malešević•The Sociological Review•2014

  • Heroes, villains and naked nations

    Open Access•Lea David, Carol et al.•Ethnic and Racial Studies•2024

  • The Formation of national States in Western Europe

    Charles Tilly•The Formation of national States…•1975

  • The Third World Security Predicament

    Mohammed Ayoob•The Third World Security…•1995

  • Nations and Nationalism since 1780

    Open Access•E J Hobsbawm, Eric Hobsbawm•Nations and Nationalism Since 1780•2012

  • Nationalism and the state

    John Breuilly•Nationalism and the state•1982

  • States and Power in Africa: Comparative Lessons in Authority and Control

    Jeffrey Herbst•States and Power in Africa•2015

  • A Theory of the Origin of the State

    Open Access•Robert L Carneiro•Science•1970

  • Birth of the Leviathan

    Open Access•Thomas Ertman•Birth of the Leviathan•1997

  • War and Society in Early Modern Europe

    Frank Tallett•War and Society in Early Modern…•2016

  • Nations and Nationalism

    Howard Wollman, Philip J Spencer et al.•Nations and Nationalism•2019

  • The Balkans

    Mark Biondich•The Balkans•2011

  • The Balkan Revolutionary Tradition

    Dimitrije Djordjevic, Stephen Fischer-Galati et al.•Balkan Revolutionary Tradition•1981

  • The Nationalization of the Masses

    George L Mosse, Victoria De Grazia•Nationalization of the Masses•2023

  • The Balkans

    Open Access•Dennis P Hupchick, D Hupchick•Balkans•2002

  • A History of the Balkans 1804–1945

    Stevan K Pavlowitch•History of the Balkans 1804-1945•2014

  • The Sources of Social Power

    Open Access•Michael Mann•Sources of Social Power Vol. 2•1993

  • History Derailed

    Iván T Berend•History Derailed•2003

  • The Balkan Wars 1912-1913

    Richard C W Hall, Richard C Hall•The Balkan Wars 1912-1913•2002

  • Ernest Gellner and Contemporary Social Thought

    Open Access•Alan Macfarlane, M Mann et al.•Ernest Gellner and Contemporary…•2007

  • Imagining the Balkans

    Maria Todorova, Marii︠a︡ Nikolaeva Todorova•Imagining the Balkans•2009

  • Fascists

    Open Access•Michael Mann•Fascists•2004

  • War and State Formation in Ancient China and Early Modern Europe

    Open Access•Victoria Tin-Bor Hui•War and State Formation in…•2005

  • Ethno-symbolism and Nationalism

    Anthony D Smith•Ethno-Symbolism and Nationalism•2009

  • The Sociology of War and Violence

    Open Access•Siniša Malešević•Sociology of War and Violence•2010

  • The Balkan Wars, 1912-1913

    Edward J Erickson, Richard C W Hall et al.•The Journal of Military History•2001

  • Medieval Warfare

    Charles R Bowlus, Maurice Keen•The Journal of Military History•2000

  • Identity as Ideology

    Open Access•Siniša Malešević•Identity As Ideology•2006

  • Tilly Tally

    Open Access•Brian D Taylor, Roxana Botea•International Studies Review•2008

  • Ottomans into Europeans

    Hikmet Karčić•Europe Asia Studies•2012

  • World military and social expenditures

    Open Access•Kathryn E Newcomer•Women s Studies International Forum•1982

  • The Nationalization of the Masses

    Richard Bradley•History of European Ideas•1994

  • Coercion, capital, and European states, 990–1990

    Peter Baldwin•History of European Ideas•1992

  • Nationalism, Globalization, and Orthodoxy

    Anthony Oberschall, Roudometof et al.•Contemporary Sociology A Journal…•2002

  • Balkan Worlds

    Fatma Muge Gocek, Traian Stoianovich•Contemporary Sociology A Journal…•1996

  • The Life and Times of Vuk Stefanovič Karadzič, 1787-1864

    Mary Coote, Duncan Wilson•The Slavic and East European…•1971

  • Balkan ghosts

    Open Access•Paul Dickler, Paul D Dickler•Orbis•1993

  • Modern Greece

    Judith Gurney•International Affairs•1978

  • The Balkans

    Robert Legvold, Dennis P Hupchick•Foreign Affairs•2002

  • Charles Tilly as a Theorist of Nationalism

    Open Access•Rogers Brubaker•The American Sociologist•2010

  • The Political Economy of State Building in Sub-Saharan Africa

    Cameron G Thies•The Journal of Politics•2007

  • Uneven Development and Nationalism

    Open Access•A W Orridge•Political Studies•1981

  • Uneven Development and Nationalism

    Open Access•A W Orridge•Political Studies•1981

  • Turkish nationalism and ethno‐symbolic analysis

    Open Access•Nergis Canefe•Nations and Nationalism•2002

  • Whence nationalism

    Open Access•Slobodan Drakulic•Nations and Nationalism•2008

  • The Absence of Middle Eastern Great Powers

    Open Access•I S Lustick•International Organization•1997

  • The Social Philosophy of Ernest Gellner

    John A Hall, I C Jarvie et al.•The Social Philosophy of Ernest…•1996

  • Gellner's Structural-Functional-Culturalism

    Open Access•Chris Hann•Czech Sociological Review•2001

  • The State of the Nation

    Josep R Llobera, John A Hall•Journal of the Royal Anthropologica…•1999

  • Blood and Debt

    Miguel Angel Centeno•Blood and Debt•2015

  • The Mosaic Moment

    Philip S Gorski•American Journal of Sociology•2000

Unique citing works17
Citations per year1,42
Citation span2014 - 2025 (12)
Citation velocityrecent
Highly citedNo
Citation typesNeutral: 16

Tools

Open DOISci-Hub
Ethnos_APP • Open Source Project • MIT License • Frontend v2.0.0 • Privacy and Cookies • API Documentation: api.ethnos.app/docs • API Source Code: GitHub • DOI: 10.5281/zenodo.17049435 • Frontend Source Code: GitHub • DOI: 10.5281/zenodo.17050053 • cruz.rio.br • Expectantes Misericordiae