"On John Bates Clark's "Naive Productivity Ethics

This article explores in detail the reactions among American economists to John Bates Clark's famously controversial claim that the marginal productivity theory of factor pricing and distribution is necessarily just. The general debate around Clark's "naïve productivity ethics," as George Stigler sharply called it, transcended the then existing distinctions within the discipline and involved figures of virtually all theoretical and ideological persuasions-from prolabor progressives such as Richard T. Ely to staunch conservatives such as Thomas Nixon Carver. Our reconstruction reveals that, contrary to several standard historical accounts, for American early twentieth-century marginalism, let alone American economics at large, Clark's solution to the ethical problem of distributive justice was far more divisive than consolidating

Art history · BATES · Distributive property · Economic Justice · Economics · George (robot · Ideology · Law and economics · Neoclassical economics · Political science · Positive economics · Productivity · Sociology · Economic Theory and Institutions · Historical Economic and Social Studies · History · Law · Philosophy · Political Economy and Marxism

• Herbert Metford Thompson and the Generalization of the “Old Rent Concept”

  Luca Fiorito, Matthew McCaffrey et al.•History of Political Economy•2026

  Incluir item

• Natural forces matter

  Open Access•Luca Fiorito, Massimiliano Vatiero•Ecological Economics•2025

  Incluir item

• The Theory of Wages Adjusted to Recent Theories of Value

  Thomas Nixon Carver•The Quarterly Journal of Economics•1894

  Incluir item

• The Mythology of Capital or of Static Equilibrium? The Böhm-Bawerk/Clark Controversy

  Open Access•Avi J Cohen•Journal of the History of…•2008

  Incluir item

• The Place of Value Theory in Economics

  Walton H Hamilton•Journal of Political Economy•1918

  Incluir item

• The Marginal Theory of Distribution

  Thomas Nixon Carver•Journal of Political Economy•1905

  Incluir item

• The Distribution of Wealth . Thomas Nixon Carver

  H J Davenport•Journal of Political Economy•1904

  Incluir item

• The Marginal Productivity Theory of Distribution

  U S Parker•Journal of Political Economy•1907

  Incluir item

• A Note on Professor Clark's Illustration of Marginal Productivity

  F H Knight•Journal of Political Economy•1925

  Incluir item

• The Distribution of Wealth. A Theory of Wages and Interest

  F Y Edgeworth, John Bates Clark•The Economic Journal•1900

  Incluir item

• A Decade of Economic Theory

  Open Access•Richard T Ely•The Annals of the American…•1900

  Incluir item

• Value and Distribution

  N B Dearle, Herbert Joseph Devenport•The Economic Journal•1908

  Incluir item

• The Impact of the Union

  E H Phelps Brown, David Wright et al.•The Economic Journal•1952

  Incluir item

• History of Economic Thought

  C R Fay, Lewis H Haney•The Economic Journal•1911

  Incluir item

• Elementary Principles of Economics

  H D Henderson, Irving Fisher•The Economic Journal•1913

  Incluir item

• Marketplace Morals and the American Economists

  Michael S Morgan, Mary S Morgan•History of Political Economy•1994

  Incluir item

• A Certain Amount of 'Recantation

  Luca Fiorito•History of Political Economy•2016

  Incluir item

• A Certain Rude Honesty

  Thomas C Leonard•History of Political Economy•2003

  Incluir item

• Davenport's Economics

  Open Access•John Maurice Clark•Political Science Quarterly•1914

  Incluir item

• The Neoclassical Advent

  Open Access•J Persky•The Journal of Economic…•2000

  Incluir item