Skip to main content

ETHNOS_APP

Home • Search • Journals • List 0

Urban-Rural Mortality Differentials

An Unresolved Debate

Bibliographic Data

ID4987007
AuthorsRobert Woods (0000-0002-7116-9191), Bob Woods (0000-0002-6781-651X, Institute of Geography, corresponding author)
Year2003
Volume29
Issue1
Pages29-46
Publication date2003-03-01
Peer ReviewedYes
Open AccessYes
TypeARTICLE
VenuePopulation and Development Review (JOURNAL)
Journal identifiersISSN: 0098-7921 • E-ISSN: 1728-4457
PublisherWiley (PUBLISHER • GB)
DOI10.1111/j.1728-4457.2003.00029.x
OpenAlexW1991523001
LanguageEN
Citations received123
References cited39

Historians and demographers have long debated the existence, causes, and consequences of historical differences between urban and rural mortality levels. In Europe it has been usual to observe excess mortality in cities compared to the countryside, but in East Asia, by contrast, it has been found that urban areas had relatively favorable mortality environments. The debate continues because a number of pertinent questions remain to be resolved. For example, the way in which mortality is measured may influence the apparent extent of the differential, as may the way in which"urban" and"rural" are defined. Cultural factors need to be taken into account, including the practices of childrearing and the conventions surrounding baptism. Examples drawn from Japan, China, England, and France illustrate the issues involved in comparative analysis, while the urban-rural mortality continuum is examined for nineteenth-century England and Wales using log-normal distributions

Baptism · China · Development economics · Economics · Geography · Mortality rate · Political science · Rural area · Sociology · Demographic Trends and Gender Preferences · Demography · Historical Economic and Social Studies · Historical Studies on Reproduction, Gender, Health, and Societal Changes · Law

  • The mortality gradient in town and country

    Open Access•Marcos Castillo, M Dribe•The Economic History Review•2026

  • Institutional Frameworks of the Development of Non-Government Universities in Russia

    Open Access•Mariya Neuvazhaeva•Journal of Economic Sociology•2012

  • Four Methods for Defining Organizational Boundaries in Sociology

    Open Access•Igor Chirikov•Journal of Economic Sociology•2012

  • Workshop on Applied Behavioral Finance Studies

    Open Access•Dilyara Ibragimova•Journal of Economic Sociology•2012

  • Understanding Growth in Europe, 1700–1870

    Open Access•Joel Mokyr, Hans-Joachim Voth•Journal of Economic Sociology•2012

  • Forging Industrial Policy

    Open Access•Frank Dobbins, Frank Dobbin•Journal of Economic Sociology•2012

  • Lasting Monuments and Durable Institutions

    Open Access•Nam C Kim•Journal of Archaeological Research•2013

  • Urban environmental degradation and the standard of living

    Antonio Escudero, Miguel Pérez De Perceval Verde et al.•Continuity and Change•2015

  • The Potential of Internal Migration to Shape Rural and Urban Populations Across Africa, Asia, and Latin America

    Open Access•Ashira Menashe‐oren, Philippe Bocquier•Population and Development Review•2025

  • Urbanization Is No Longer Driven by Migration in Low- and Middle-Income Countries (1985-2015)

    Open Access•Ashira Menashe‐oren, Philippe Bocquier•Population and Development Review•2021

  • Estimating warfare-related civilian mortality in the early modern period

    Open Access•Bram Van Besouw, Daniel R Curtis•Explorations in Economic History•2022

  • Revealing associations between urban infrastructure and U5MR in sub-Saharan Africa through interpretable machine learning

    Open Access•Ziheng Meng, Tianyue Jiang et al.•Sustainable Cities and Society•2026

  • The Cambridge Economic History of Modern Europe

    Open Access•Stephen Broadberry, Kevin H O''Rourke et al.•Cambridge Economic History of…•2010

  • The Early Roman Empire

    Open Access•Willem Jongman, Willem M Jongman•The Cambridge economic history of…•2007

  • Women in the Roman Republic

    Open Access•Phyllis Culham•The Cambridge Companion to the…•2004

  • Roman Art during the Republic

    Open Access•Ann Kuttner, Ann L Kuttner•The Cambridge Companion to the…•2014

  • The Early Roman Empire

    Open Access•Elio Lo Cascio•The Cambridge economic history of…•2007

  • Under Roman Roofs

    Open Access•Karl-Joachim Hölkeskamp, Karl–joachim Hölkeskamp•The Cambridge Companion to the…•2014

  • Roman Religion

    Open Access•Jörg Rüpke•The Cambridge Companion to the…•2014

  • Women in the Roman Republic

    Open Access•Phyllis Culham•The Cambridge Companion to the…•2014

  • The Early Roman Empire

    Open Access•Neville Morley•The Cambridge economic history of…•2007

  • The Republican Economy and Roman Law

    Open Access•Jean-Jacques Aubert, Jean‐Jacques Aubert•The Cambridge Companion to the…•2014

  • The Cambridge Companion to the Roman Republic

    Open Access•Harriet I Flower•The Cambridge Companion to the…•2014

  • Cemeteries and catacombs

    Open Access•Leonard Victor Rutgers•Cambridge Companion to Ancient Rome•2013

  • Law and Economic Institutions

    Open Access•Bruce W Frier, Dennis P Kehoe et al.•The Cambridge economic history of…•2007

  • Spectacle and Political Culture in the Roman Republic

    Open Access•Harriet I Flower•The Cambridge Companion to the…•2014

  • Classical Greece

    Open Access•Astrid Möller•The Cambridge economic history of…•2007

  • Civic rituals and political spaces in republican and imperial Rome

    Open Access•Adam Ziolkowski•Cambridge Companion to Ancient Rome•2013

  • The Early Republic

    Open Access•S P Oakley•The Cambridge Companion to the…•2014

  • Rome and the Greek World

    Open Access•Erich S Gruen•The Cambridge Companion to the…•2014

  • Early Iron Age Greece

    Open Access•Ivan Morris, Ian Morris•The Cambridge economic history of…•2007

  • The city in Ruins

    Open Access•Catharine Edwards•Cambridge Companion to Ancient Rome•2013

  • Marriages, families, households

    Open Access•Beryl Rawson•Cambridge Companion to Ancient Rome•2013

  • Early Rome and Italy

    Open Access•Jean-Paul Morel•The Cambridge economic history of…•2007

  • Hellenistic Greece and Western Asia Minor

    Open Access•Gary Reger•The Cambridge economic history of…•2007

  • Riots

    Open Access•Gregory S Aldrete•Cambridge Companion to Ancient Rome•2013

  • Household and Gender

    Open Access•Richard P Saller, Richard Saller•The Cambridge economic history of…•2007

  • The Roman Army and Navy

    Open Access•David Potter•The Cambridge Companion to the…•2014

  • The Late Republic

    Open Access•William V Harris•The Cambridge economic history of…•2007

  • The Crisis of the Republic

    Open Access•Jurgen Von Ungern-Sternberg, Jürgen von Ungern‐Sternberg et al.•The Cambridge Companion to the…•2014

  • (Sub)urban surroundings

    Open Access•Robert Witcher•Cambridge Companion to Ancient Rome•2013

  • Roma Aeterna

    Open Access•Ingrid D Rowland, Ingrid Rowland•Cambridge Companion to Ancient Rome•2013

  • Immigration and cosmopolitanization

    Open Access•Claudia Moatti•Cambridge Companion to Ancient Rome•2013

  • The Rise of Empire in the West (264–50b.c.)

    Open Access•Josiah Osgood•The Cambridge Companion to the…•2014

  • Rome and Carthage

    Open Access•John F Lazenby•The Cambridge Companion to the…•2014

  • ‘Romans, play on!’

    Open Access•Nicholas Purcell•Cambridge Companion to Ancient Rome•2013

  • Slavesand freedmen

    Open Access•Elisabeth Herrmann−Otto, Elisabeth Herrmann-Otto•Cambridge Companion to Ancient Rome•2013

  • Literature in the Roman Republic

    Open Access•Elaine Fantham•The Cambridge Companion to the…•2014

  • Archaic Greece

    Open Access•Robin Osborne•The Cambridge economic history of…•2007

  • The Early Roman Empire

    Open Access•Dennis P Kehoe, Dennis Kehoe•The Cambridge economic history of…•2007

  • Structuring time

    Open Access•Michele Renee Salzman•Cambridge Companion to Ancient Rome•2013

  • Water supply, drainage and watermills

    Open Access•Christer Bruun•Cambridge Companion to Ancient Rome•2013

  • Sex and the city

    Open Access•Thomas A J Mcginn•Cambridge Companion to Ancient Rome•2013

  • The urban topography of Rome

    Open Access•Elisha Ann Dumser•Cambridge Companion to Ancient Rome•2013

  • Italy during the Roman Republic, 338–31b.c.

    Open Access•Kathryn Lomas•The Cambridge Companion to the…•2014

  • Classical Greece

    Open Access•John K Davies•The Cambridge economic history of…•2007

  • The Transition to Late Antiquity

    Open Access•Andrea Giardina•The Cambridge economic history of…•2007

  • Classical Greece

    Open Access•Sitta Von Reden•The Cambridge economic history of…•2007

  • Regions and neighbourhoods

    Open Access•J Bert Lott•Cambridge Companion to Ancient Rome•2013

  • The Great Transformation

    Open Access•Brent D Shaw•The Cambridge Companion to the…•2014

  • Traffic and land transportation in and near Rome

    Open Access•Ray Laurence•Cambridge Companion to Ancient Rome•2013

  • Counting bricks and stacking wood

    Open Access•Shawn Graham•Cambridge Companion to Ancient Rome•2013

  • The Three Horsemen of Riches

    Nico Voigtländer, Hans-Joachim Voth•The Review of Economic Studies•2013

  • Information Technology and Economic Change

    Jeremiah E Dittmar, Jeremiah Dittmar•The Quarterly Journal of Economics•2011

  • The Persian Near East

    Open Access•Peter Ross Bedford•The Cambridge economic history of…•2007

  • The emergence of the city

    Open Access•Alexandre Grandazzi•Cambridge Companion to Ancient Rome•2013

  • The food supply of the capital

    Open Access•Paul Erdkamp•Cambridge Companion to Ancient Rome•2013

  • An Examination of Urban Versus Rural Mortality in China Using Community and Individual Data

    Z Zimmer, Toshiko Kaneda et al.•The Journals of Gerontology…•2007

  • Spatial analysis of cardiovascular mortality and associated factors around the world

    Open Access•Emerson Augusto Baptista, Bernardo L Queiroz•BMC Public Health•2022

  • Individual-level factors attributable to urban-rural disparity in mortality among older adults in China

    Open Access•Yuan Zhao, Xin Xu et al.•BMC Public Health•2020

  • What was Killing Babies in Rostock? An Investigation of Infant Mortality Using Individual-Level Cause-of-Death Data, 1800–1904

    Open Access•Michael Mühlichen, Laura Ann Cilek•Historical Life Course Studies•2024

  • Social Strata Differentials in Reproductive Behavior among Agricultural Families in the Krummhörn Region (East Frisia, 1720-1874)

    Open Access•Kai P Willführ, Charlotte Störmer•Historical Life Course Studies•2015

  • Darwin beats malthus

    Open Access•Katharina Mühlhoff•Cliometrica•2022

  • Living Conditions in Côte D'ivoire and Ghana, 1925–1985

    Denis Cogneau, Léa Rouanet•Economic History of Developing…•2011

  • Urban environment and mortality differentials in Spain

    Open Access•M Voigt, Dariya Ordanovich et al.•Population Space and Place•2019

  • A spatial analysis of childhood mortality in West Africa

    Open Access•Deborah Balk, Thomas W Pullum et al.•Population Space and Place•2004

  • The global distribution of infant mortality

    Open Access•Adam Storeygard, Deborah Balk et al.•Population Space and Place•2008

  • The ideal neighbourhoods of successful ageing

    Open Access•Pui-Hang Wong, Karima Kourtit et al.•Health & Place•2021

  • Missing girls’ in interwar Poland

    Bartosz Ogórek, Mikołaj Szołtysek•The History of the Family•2022

  • Family patriarchy and child sex ratios in historical Europe

    Open Access•Mikołaj Szołtysek, Francisco J Beltrán Tapia et al.•The History of the Family•2022

  • It might not be a nuisance in a country cottage’

    Open Access•Keir Waddington•Rural History•2012

  • Economic Development and the Escape from High Mortality

    Open Access•Javier A Birchenall•World Development•2007

  • The Standard of Living of the Workers in a Spanish Industrial Town

    Open Access•José Joaquín Garcia Gómez, Antonio Escudero Gutierrez•Social Indicators Research•2017

  • The Democratization of Longevity

    Open Access•Lionel Kesztenbaum, Jean-Laurent Rosenthal et al.•New Approaches to Death in Cities…•2016

  • Sociology of Spatial Inequality, The

    Ann R Tickamyer, Linda M Lobao et al.•Sociology of Spatial Inequality•2007

  • The Cambridge Companion to Ancient Rome

    Open Access•Gregory S Aldrete, Alexandre Grandazzi et al.•Cambridge Companion to Ancient Rome•2013

  • Socioeconomic inequalities in neonatal and postneonatal mortality

    Open Access•Alireza Khajavi, Farhad Pishgar et al.•International Journal for Equity…•2017

  • The Cambridge Economic History of the Greco-Roman World

    Open Access•Ivan Morris, Robert Sallares et al.•The Cambridge economic history of…•2007

  • Revisiting the relationship between height and lifespan in an urban setting

    Open Access•Francisco J Marco-Gracia, Víctor A Luque De Haro et al.•Revista de historia industrial•2026

  • Phenotype‐environment mismatch due to epigenetic inheritance? Programming the offspring's epigenome and the consequences of migration

    Open Access•Kai P Willführ, Mikko Myrskylä•American Journal of Human Biology•2013

  • Geographic mortality differentials and the quality-quantity trade-off

    Open Access•Sinara Gharibyan, David Gomtsyan et al.•Journal of Population Economics•2026

  • Environment, Urbanization, and Public Health

    Open Access•Ann Zulawski•Latin American Research Review•2022

  • The geography of maternal mortality in early twentieth century England and Wales

    A Reid•Annales de Démographie Historique•2020

  • The geography of maternal mortality in early twentieth century England and Wales

    A Reid•Annales de Démographie Historique•2020

  • Infant Mortality in Mother and Baby Homes in 20th Century Ireland

    Open Access•Liam Delaney, Mark E Mcgovern et al.•Population Research and Policy…•2024

  • Cultural and Genetic Influences on the “Biological Standard of Living”

    Max Blum, Matthias Blum•Historical Methods A Journal of…•2013

  • Sewers’ diffusion and the decline of mortality

    Open Access•Lionel Kesztenbaum, Jean-Laurent Rosenthal et al.•Journal of Urban Economics•2017

  • Pandemics and cities

    Open Access•Remi Jedwab, Noel D Johnson et al.•Journal of Urban Economics•2024

  • Place and Child Health

    Open Access•Payal Hathi, Sabrina Haque et al.•Demography•2017

  • Leaders and Laggards in Life Expectancy Among European Scholars From the Sixteenth to the Early Twentieth Century

    Open Access•Robert Stelter, David De La Croix et al.•Demography•2021

  • The City in late imperial China

    William Skinner•The City in late imperial China•1977

  • The Demography of Victorian England and Wales

    Open Access•Robert Woods, Bob Woods•Demography of Victorian England…•2000

  • Fatal Years

    H Preston, Samuel H Preston et al.•Fatal Years•1991

  • English Population History from Family Reconstitution 1580–1837

    Open Access•Edward Anthony Wrigley, R S Davies et al.•English Population History from…•1997

  • European Urbanization, 1500-1800

    John De Vries, Jan De Vries•European Urbanization, 1500-1800•2013

  • One Quarter of Humanity

    James Z Lee, Feng Wang et al.•One Quarter of Humanity•1999

  • Everyday Things in Premodern Japan

    Susan B Hanley•Everyday Things in Premodern…•1997

  • Urban health in developing countries

    Open Access•Trudy Harpham, Catherine Molyneux•Progress in Development Studies•2001

  • Naissances. L'accouchement avant l'âge de la clinique

    Mireille Laget, Agathe Lafortune-Martel•Renaissance and Reformation•1969

  • Urbanisation in Europe and China during the second millennium

    Open Access•Robert Woods, Bob Woods•International Journal of…•2003

  • African mortality and the new `urban penalty

    Open Access•W T S Gould•Health & Place•1998

  • Urban History in Later Imperial China

    F W Mole•Ming Studies•1995

  • Urbanization and National Development

    Hilda H Golden, Leo Jakobson et al.•Contemporary Sociology A Journal…•1973

  • Peking

    Mary Backus Rankin, Susan Naguin et al.•Harvard Journal of Asiatic Studies•2002

  • The Savage Wars of Peace

    Karen Wigen, Alan Macfarlane•Monumenta Nipponica•1998

  • The Growth of Cities in the Nineteenth Century. A Study in Statistics

    F Y Edgeworth, Adna Ferrin Weber•The Economic Journal•1899

  • Natural Decrease in Early Modern Cities

    Allan Sharlin•Past & Present•1978

  • The Historical Demography of Pre-Modern Japan

    William Lavely, Akira Hayami•Journal of Japanese Studies•2002

  • Generative and Parasitic Cities

    Bert F Hoselitz•Economic Development and Cultural…•1955

  • Urbanization and the Development of Pre-Industrial Areas

    Kingsley Davis, Hilda Hertz Golden•Economic Development and Cultural…•1954

  • Le Epidemie nella Storia Demografica Italiana (Secoli XIV-XIX)

    Viviana Egidi, Lorenzo Del Panta•Population Studies•1982

  • Is There Evidence of Birth Control in Late Imperial China

    Open Access•Arthur P Wolf•Population and Development Review•2001

  • The Poverty of Cities in Developing Regions

    Martin Brockerhoff, Ellen Brennan et al.•Population and Development Review•1998

  • Positive Check or Chinese Checks

    Open Access•James Lee, Cameron Campbell et al.•The Journal of Asian Studies•2002

  • European Urbanization, 1500-1800

    C W Chalklin, John De Vries et al.•The Economic History Review•1985

  • Urbanization, Mortality, and the Standard of Living Debate

    Open Access•Simon Szreter, Gerry Mooney et al.•The Economic History Review•1998

  • Did Montaigne Love His Children? Demography and the Hypothesis of Parental Indifference

    Robert Woods, Bob Woods•The Journal of Interdisciplinary…•2003

  • The Rise and Fall of Great Cities

    Richard Rodger, Richard Lawton•The Economic History Review•1990

  • People, Cities and Wealth

    N F R Crafts, Nicholas Crafts et al.•The Economic History Review•1988

  • Mortalité de l'enfance au XIXe siècle à Paris et dans le département de la Seine

    Open Access•Etienne Van De Walle, H Preston et al.•Population•1974

Unique citing works123
Citations per year5,59
Citation span2004 - 2026 (23)
Citation velocitycurrent
Highly citedYes
Citation typesNeutral: 111

Tools

Open DOISci-Hub
Ethnos_APP • Open Source Project • MIT License • Frontend v2.0.0 • Privacy and Cookies • API Documentation: api.ethnos.app/docs • API Source Code: GitHub • DOI: 10.5281/zenodo.17049435 • Frontend Source Code: GitHub • DOI: 10.5281/zenodo.17050053 • cruz.rio.br • Expectantes Misericordiae