Skip to main content

ETHNOS_APP

Home • Search • Journals • List 0

Mess among Disciplines

Interdisciplinarity in Environmental Research

Bibliographic Data

ID5147754
AuthorsAndrea Donaldson (0000-0003-0891-327X, Newcastle University, corresponding author), Andrew Donaldson, Neil Ward (0000-0002-0732-2278, University of East Anglia, corresponding author), Sue Bradley (Newcastle University, corresponding author)
Year2010
Volume42
Issue7
Pages1521-1536
Publication date2010-07-01
Peer ReviewedYes
Open AccessYes
TypeARTICLE
VenueEnvironment and Planning A Economy and Space (JOURNAL)
Journal identifiersISSN: 0308-518X • E-ISSN: 1472-3409
PublisherSAGE Publications Inc (PUBLISHER)
DOI10.1068/a42483
OpenAlexW2148925266
LanguageEN
Citations received26
References cited30

This paper discusses interdisciplinary collaboration between social and natural scientists from the perspective of 'mess'. The literature on interdisciplinarity has generated a series of conventions about what it means to conduct interdisciplinary research. Building on the experience of a research project that brought social and natural scientists together with local residents to study flooding, we argue that interdisciplinarity can be understood as a response to mess, to the irreducibly complex problems of the world. Mess can be dealt with as an epistemological or ontological problem. We argue that discursive conventions focus on the epistemological dimensions of mess and thus have their limits. By considering the ontological dimensions of mess the whole range of objects that are involved in interdisciplinary research is brought into focus

Engineering ethics · Epistemology · Geography · Social science · Sociology · Climate Change Communication and Perception · Computer Science · Engineering · Interdisciplinary Research and Collaboration · Philosophy · Sustainability and Climate Change Governance

  • Interdisciplinarity and Geography

    Open Access•Louise J Bracken•International Encyclopedia of…•2017

  • Defining Terms for Integrated (Multi-Inter-Trans-Disciplinary) Sustainability Research

    Open Access•Paul V Stock, Paul Stock et al.•Sustainability•2011

  • Ecosystem services and the idea of shared values

    Open Access•Katherine N Irvine, Liz O’brien et al.•Ecosystem Services•2016

  • Mess in Science and Wicked Problems

    Jutta Schickore•Perspectives on Science•2020

  • Ontology and integrative research on Global Environmental Change

    Open Access•Rony Emmenegger, Rory Rowan et al.•Current Opinion in Environmental…•2017

  • Climate change and transdisciplinary science

    Open Access•Nicole Klenk, Katie Meehan•Environmental Science & Policy•2015

  • The persistence of ‘normal’ catchment management despite the participatory turn

    Open Access•Brian R Cook, Brian Cook et al.•Social Studies of Science•2013

  • Beyond disciplines

    Open Access•Gary Kass•Geo Geography and Environment•2025

  • A typology of interdisciplinary collaborations

    Open Access•Benjamin Hofmann, Ueli Reber et al.•Sustainability Science•2025

  • They don’t know what they are talking about’

    Open Access•Joshua J Ramisch•Geoforum•2014

  • Collaboration, creativity, conflict and chaos

    Open Access•Rose Cairns, Sabine Hielscher et al.•Sustainability Science•2020

  • Epistemic stability and epistemic adaptability

    Open Access•Annemarie Horn, Eduardo Urias et al.•Sustainability Science•2022

  • Transforming universities

    Open Access•Derk A Loorbach, Julia M Wittmayer•Sustainability Science•2023

  • A new normative economics for the formation of shared social values

    Open Access•Neil Ravenscroft•Sustainability Science•2019

  • Guiding carbon farming using interdisciplinary mixed methods mapping

    Open Access•Beth Ft Brockett, Alison L Browne et al.•People and Nature•2019

  • Radical interdisciplinarity

    Open Access•Karen Crespo Triveño, Rebecca Covarrubias et al.•Futures•2026

  • Integrating scientific and local knowledge to address environmental conflicts

    Open Access•Dennis Avilés Irahola, Alejandro Mora-Motta et al.•Human Ecology•2022

  • Moving from features to functions

    Open Access•Andy Yuille, Jessica Davies et al.•Health & Place•2024

  • Changes in perceptions of transdisciplinary science over time

    Open Access•Laura M Frescoln, J G Arbuckle et al.•Futures•2015

  • Thinking complex interconnections

    Open Access•Tim Schwanen•Transactions of the Institute of…•2017

  • Bridging the geo‐divide

    Open Access•Kate Donovan, Katherine Donovan et al.•Transactions of the Institute of…•2010

  • The wicked city

    Open Access•Clive Barnett•Transactions of the Institute of…•2021

  • Political Ecology

    Open Access•Brian Grabbatin, Joseph Rossi et al.•Geography Compass•2012

  • Experimental geographies

    Open Access•Angela Last•Geography Compass•2012

  • Bringing Britain into being

    Open Access•Cathrine Degnen, K Tyler•The Sociological Review•2017

  • Amongst the disciplines

    Open Access•Cathrine Degnen, K Tyler•The Sociological Review•2017

  • The methodology of the social sciences

    Max Weber•The methodology of the social…•1968

  • Science in action

    Bruno Latour•Science in action•1987

  • The new production of knowledge

    Camille Limoges, Helga Nowotny et al.•The new production of knowledge•1994

  • The invention of modern science

    Isabelle Stengers•The invention of modern science•2000

  • Q Methodology

    Bruce Mckeown, Dan Thomas et al.•Q Methodology•1988

  • Representing and Intervening

    Open Access•Ian Hacking•Representing and Intervening•1983

  • Interdisciplinarity and boundary work

    Open Access•C Clare Hinrichs•Agriculture and Human Values•2008

  • Interdisciplinarity and social power

    Open Access•Erica Schoenberger•Progress in Human Geography•2001

  • Institutional Ecology, `Translations' and Boundary Objects

    Open Access•Susan Leigh Star, James Griesemer et al.•Social Studies of Science•1989

  • Futures of Transdisciplinarity

    Open Access•Roderick J Lawrence, Carole Després•Futures•2004

  • What do you mean?’ The importance of language in developing interdisciplinary research

    Open Access•Louise J Bracken, Elizabeth Oughton et al.•Transactions of the Institute of…•2006

  • The emergence of interdisciplinary knowledge in problem‐focused research

    Open Access•Anna Wesselink•Area•2009

  • The lively process of interdisciplinarity

    Open Access•Henry Buller•Area•2009

  • Structuring subjectivities? Using Q methodology in human geography

    Open Access•Sally Eden, Andrea Donaldson et al.•Area•2005

  • Interdisciplinarity within and beyond geography

    Open Access•Louise J Bracken, Elizabeth Oughton et al.•Area•2009

  • Logics of interdisciplinarity

    A Barry, G Born et al.•Economy and Society•2008

  • We Have Never Been Modern

    T Hugh Crawford, Tony Crawford•Configurations•1994

  • After Method

    John Law•After Method•2004

  • Pandora's hope

    Bruno Latour•Pandora's hope•1999

  • Mapping knowledge controversies

    Open Access•Sarah Whatmore, Sarah J Whatmore•Progress in Human Geography•2009

  • Object Lessons

    Open Access•John Law, Vicky Singleton•Organization•2005

  • Barriers to Research Collaboration across Disciplines

    Open Access•Philip Lowe, Jeremy Phillipson•Environment and Planning A…•2009

  • Researching the Sustainable City

    Open Access•Robert Evans, Simon Marvin•Environment and Planning A…•2006

  • The Body Multiple

    A Mol, Barbara Herrnstein Smith et al.•The Body Multiple•2002

  • Politiques de la nature

    Bruno Latour•Politiques de la nature•2004

  • Politics of Nature

    Bruno Latour, Caitlin Porter et al.•Politics of Nature•2004

  • The economy of qualities

    Michel Callon, Cécile Méadel et al.•Economy and Society•2002

Unique citing works26
Citations per year1,63
Citation span2010 - 2026 (17)
Citation velocitycurrent
Highly citedNo
Citation typesNeutral: 26

Tools

Open DOISci-Hub
Ethnos_APP • Open Source Project • MIT License • Frontend v2.0.0 • Privacy and Cookies • API Documentation: api.ethnos.app/docs • API Source Code: GitHub • DOI: 10.5281/zenodo.17049435 • Frontend Source Code: GitHub • DOI: 10.5281/zenodo.17050053 • cruz.rio.br • Expectantes Misericordiae