Skip to main content

ETHNOS_APP

Home • Search • Journals • List 0

Isomorphism through algorithms

Institutional dependencies in the case of Facebook

Bibliographic Data

ID5260690
AuthorsRobyn Caplan (0000-0002-6407-3116, Rutgers, the State University of New Jersey, corresponding author), Drick Boyd (0000-0002-7722-7778, Microsoft (United States)), Danah Boyd
Year2018
Volume5
Issue1
Publication date2018-01-01
Peer ReviewedYes
Open AccessYes
TypeARTICLE
VenueBig Data & Society (JOURNAL)
Journal identifiersISSN: 2053-9517 • E-ISSN: 2053-9517
PublisherSAGE Publications Inc (PUBLISHER)
DOI10.1177/2053951718757253
OpenAlexW2788918314
LanguageEN
Citations received129
References cited19

Algorithms and data-driven technologies are increasingly being embraced by a variety of different sectors and institutions. This paper examines how algorithms and data-driven technologies, enacted by an organization like Facebook, can induce similarity across an industry. Using theories from organizational sociology and neoinstitutionalism, this paper traces the bureaucratic roots of Big Data and algorithms to examine the institutional dependencies that emerge and are mediated through data-driven and algorithmic logics. This type of analysis sheds light on how organizational contexts are embedded into algorithms, which can then become embedded within other organizational and individual practices. By investigating technical practices as organizational and bureaucratic, discussions about accountability and decision-making can be reframed

Accountability · Big data · Bureaucracy · Data mining · Data science · Economics · Knowledge management · Management · Organizational analysis · Organizational theory · Political science · Politics · Sociology · Blockchain Technology Applications and Security · Computer Science · Ethics and Social Impacts of AI · Information Systems Theories and Implementation · Artificial Intelligence

  • From Risk Transfer to Risk Prevention

    Open Access•Johann Ole Willers, Alexander Gamerdinger•Journal of Organizational Sociology•2026

  • Epistemic oligarchisation

    Open Access•Sven Ulpts, Sheena F Bartscherer et al.•Science as Culture•2026

  • Platform dependency of news media across different media systems

    Nicholas Nicoli, Theodora A Maniou et al.•Journal of Digital Media & Policy•2025

  • Vaakakupissa vaarat ja vastuu

    Open Access•Liisa Niemi, Minna Koivula et al.•Media & viestintä•2021

  • Dataa näkyvissä

    Open Access•Henrik Rydenfelt, Lauri Haapanen et al.•Media & viestintä•2021

  • Le numéro entier - Full Issue - Edição completa

    Open Access•François Demers, Florence Le Cam et al.•Sur le journalisme About…•2023

  • More of the shareable same

    Open Access•Darsana Vijay•Sur le journalisme About…•2023

  • How platform power undermines diversity-oriented innovation

    Open Access•Paul Helm•Internet Policy Review•2024

  • Optimizing Content with A/B Headline Testing

    Open Access•Nick Hagar, Nicholas Diakopoulos•Media and Communication•2019

  • Digital Journalism as Symptom, Response, and Agent of Change in the Platformed Media Environment

    J Burge, Jean Burgess et al.•Definitions of Digital Journalism…•2021

  • Towards Fairness, Accountability, and Transparency in Platform Governance

    Open Access•Robert Gorwa•AoIR Selected Papers of Internet…•2020

  • Locating and Theorizing Platform Power

    Open Access•Thomas Poell, D B Nieborg et al.•AoIR Selected Papers of Internet…•2023

  • In(ter)dependence in Platformed Creation

    Open Access•Angèle Christin, Angele L Christin et al.•AoIR Selected Papers of Internet…•2021

  • ChatGPT for Social Work Science

    Open Access•Desmond Upton Patton, Aviv Y Landau et al.•Journal of the Society for Social…•2023

  • Praxisprofile als mixed-methods Ansatz zur Analyse performativer Öffentlichkeiten

    Open Access•Wolfgang Reißmann, Miriam Siemon et al.•Studies in Communication Sciences•2022

  • The relevance internet users assign to algorithmic-selection applications in everyday life

    Open Access•Michael V Reiss, Noemi Festic et al.•Studies in Communication Sciences•2021

  • AI as Governance

    Open Access•Henry Farrell•Annual Review of Political Science•2025

  • Care and Scale

    Open Access•N Seaver•Cultural Anthropology•2021

  • Reframing platform power

    Open Access•José Van Dijck, D B Nieborg et al.•Internet Policy Review•2019

  • Algorithmic governance

    Open Access•Christian Katzenbach, Lena Ulbricht•Internet Policy Review•2019

  • The Public and Their Platforms

    Open Access•Mark Carrigan, Lambros Fatsis•Public and Their Platforms•2021

  • The Public and Their Platforms

    Open Access•Mark Carrigan, Lambros Fatsis•The Public and Their Platforms•2021

  • The Networked Leviathan

    Open Access•Paul Gowder•Networked Leviathan•2023

  • Social Media and Democracy

    Open Access•Arye L Hillman, Ronen Gradwohl et al.•Social Media and Democracy•2020

  • Misinformation, Disinformation, and Online Propaganda

    Open Access•Allison M Gue, Benjamin Lyons•Social Media and Democracy•2020

  • Social Media, Echo Chambers, and Political Polarization

    Open Access•Pablo Barberá Aresté, Pablo Barberá•Social Media and Democracy•2020

  • The Moral Economy of High-Tech Modernism

    Open Access•Henry Farrell, Marion Fourcade•Daedalus•2023

  • Escape Me If You Can

    Open Access•Felix M Simon•Digital Journalism•2023

  • How Do Funding Models and Organizational Legacy Shape News Organizations’ Social Media Strategies? A Comparison of Public Service and Private Sector News Media in Six Countries

    Annika Sehl, Alessio Cornia et al.•Digital Journalism•2021

  • Invisible Friend or Foe?How Journalists Use and Perceive Algorithmic-Driven Tools in Their Research Process

    Yael De Haan, Eric Van Den Berg et al.•Digital Journalism•2022

  • Navigating the Scholarly Terrain

    Open Access•Scott A Eldridge, Karl He et al.•Digital Journalism•2019

  • Spaces of Negotiation

    Open Access•Thomas Poell, D B Nieborg et al.•Digital Journalism•2022

  • Sourcing the Sources

    Open Access•Gerret Von Nordheim, Karin Boczek et al.•Digital Journalism•2018

  • Funding Intermediaries

    Charis Papaevangelou•Digital Journalism•2023

  • Meta-structural intelligence

    Open Access•Asif Mahmood•Innovation The European Journal…•2026

  • Algorithmic personalization

    Open Access•Václav Moravec, Nik Hynek et al.•Humanities and Social Sciences…•2025

  • Platforms and Institutions in the Post-Pandemic University

    Open Access•Mark Carrigan, Katy Jordan•Postdigital Science and Education•2022

  • Predictores de Interacción Online y Medios Públicos

    Open Access•Marcela Campos Rueda•Revista de la Asociación Española…•2023

  • Affective authority, gender, and platformed communication

    Open Access•Qingqing Hu•Frontiers in Communication•2026

  • Shifting Power Dynamics

    Bouziane Zaid, Mohammed Ibahrine et al.•Digital Journalism•2025

  • The War in Ukraine Through the Prism of Visual Disinformation and the Limits of Specialized Fact-Checking. A Case-Study at Le Monde

    Open Access•Pauline Zecchinon, Olivier Standaert•Digital Journalism•2025

  • The News Feed is Not a Black Box

    Naoise McNally, M Bastos•Digital Journalism•2025

  • AI ‘Everywhere and Nowhere’

    Open Access•Bronwyn Jones, Rhia Jones et al.•Digital Journalism•2022

  • Do Facebook and Google Care about Journalism? Mapping the Relationship between Affordances of GNI and FJP Tools and Journalistic Norms

    Venetia Papa, Theodoros Kouros•Digital Journalism•2023

  • Twitter in the News

    Corinna Oschatz, Sebastian Stier et al.•Digital Journalism•2022

  • Trustable News from China? How Chinese Journalists Negotiate Epistemic Authority in Transnational Digital News Production

    Tucker Wang-Hai•Digital Journalism•2025

  • Contextualizing Platform Dependence and Publisher Disentanglements in India

    Simran Agarwal•Digital Journalism•2025

  • A Balancing Act

    Open Access•Sina Blassnig, Edina Strikovic et al.•Digital Journalism•2025

  • Journalism (Ethics) in the Loop

    Damon Kiesow•Digital Journalism•2024

  • Algori̇tmi̇k Kürasyon Ve Yaratici Üreti̇m

    Open Access•Necati Vardar, Çağrı Gümüş•The Turkish Online Journal of…•2026

  • Who is responsible for interventions against problematic comments? Comparing user attitudes in Germany and the United States

    Open Access•Martin J Riedl, Teresa K Naab et al.•Policy & Internet•2021

  • Safe from “harm”

    Open Access•Julia R Decook, Kelley Cotter et al.•Policy & Internet•2022

  • How harassment and hate speech policies have changed over time

    Open Access•Elizabeth Dubois, Anna Reepschlager•Policy & Internet•2024

  • The logics of innovation. Institutional logics and isomorphic pressures in public service media innovation labs in the age of artificial intelligence

    Open Access•Carolin Hilker, Nadja Schaetz et al.•Journalism•2026

  • Google as Journalists’ Invisible Research Assistant? The Impact of Algorithmically-Driven Search Results in Journalistic Information Gathering Routines

    Open Access•Yael De Haan, Nele Goutier et al.•Journalism Studies•2026

  • Between rules, norms and shared understandings

    Open Access•Emmanuel Economou, Edwina Luck et al.•Journal of Communication Management•2023

  • Search in the Newsroom

    Open Access•Daniel Trielli•Media and Communication•2025

  • Uninvited Dinner Guests

    Open Access•Gerret Von Nordheim, Katharina Kleinen‐von Königslöw•Media and Communication•2021

  • A Relational Approach to How Media Engage With Their Audiences in Social Media

    Open Access•Mark Badham, Markus Mykkänen•Media and Communication•2022

  • Institutional Polymorphism

    Open Access•Jacob Ørmen, Andreas Gregersen et al.•Television & New Media•2023

  • Antifeminist opinion leaders on YouTube

    Open Access•Tania Brandariz Portela, David del Pino-Díaz et al.•Frontiers in Human Dynamics•2025

  • Influencers in Parliament? Platform Pressures and Normative Conflict in Political Social Media Adoption

    Open Access•Annina Claesson•Social Media + Society•2025

  • Communicating About and Through Platform Values

    Open Access•Tianchan Mao, Charlie C Su et al.•Social Media + Society•2025

  • Insta-News

    Jeremy Saks, Ashley Hopkins•Journalism Practice•2024

  • Challenges and Needs in Algorithmic Literacy for Journalists

    Paulo Couraceiro, Caterina Foà et al.•Journalism Practice•2025

  • Visual Mis/disinformation in Journalism and Public Communications

    Tony Thomson, Daniel Angus et al.•Journalism Practice•2020

  • Commercialization of Creative Videos in China in the Digital Platform Age

    Open Access•Zhongxuan Lin•Television & New Media•2020

  • Public scholarship in the platform university

    Mark Carrigan•Globalisation Societies and…•2021

  • Platform Configuration and Digital Materiality

    Open Access•Sherwin Chua•Journalism Studies•2023

  • Do Algorithms Do It Better? Analysing Occupational Ideology in the Age of Computational Journalism

    Lia‐paschalia Spyridou, Chris Danezis et al.•Journalism Studies•2024

  • Facebook, news media and platform dependency

    Open Access•James Meese, Edward Hurcombe•New Media & Society•2020

  • Discipline and promote

    Open Access•Lucas Graves, C W Anderson•New Media & Society•2020

  • Different stakes, different struggles, and different practices to survive

    Open Access•Jane Yeahin Pyo•New Media & Society•2022

  • Clickbait news and algorithmic curation

    Open Access•Juliane A Lischka, Marcel Garz•New Media & Society•2021

  • The inter-institutional impact of digital platform companies on democracy

    Open Access•Katharine Dommett•New Media & Society•2021

  • Mediated by the giants

    Open Access•Salla-Maaria Laaksonen, Minna Koivula et al.•New Media & Society•2022

  • Governing principles

    Open Access•Rebecca Scharlach, Blake Hallinan et al.•New Media & Society•2023

  • What I miss most

    Open Access•Alexis Haskell, Logan Molyneux•New Media & Society•2025

  • When pigs fly”

    Open Access•Shuaishuai Wang•New Media & Society•2025

  • Sure, I saw sales, but it consumed me” from resilience to erosion in the digital hustle economy

    Open Access•Nicola Ens, Attila Márton•New Media & Society•2021

  • Platforms, journalism and the amplification of terror

    James P Walsh•Information Communication & Society•2026

  • How gatekeeping became digital

    Michael L Siciliano•International Journal of Cultural…•2022

  • Platform frictions, platform power, and the politics of platformization

    Open Access•Pawel Popiel, Krishnan Vasudevan•Information Communication & Society•2024

  • Being aware of algorithmic personalization? Insights from three European Countries

    Open Access•Maximilian Eder, Annika Sehl•Information Communication & Society•2026

  • Organisation und digitale Technologien . Predictive Policing im organisationalen Kontext

    Stefanie Büchner, Henrik Dosdall•Soziale Systeme•2022

  • Trusting tech firms’ big data for political microtargeting? A qualitative analysis of parties’ communication managers risk and trust perceptions

    Natascha Löffler•Journal of Information Technology…•2023

  • The digital touch and the untouched

    Open Access•Samora Harry Ayivor•Cogent Arts and Humanities•2026

  • Global Platforms and Local Networks

    Open Access•James Meese, Edward Hurcombe et al.•Digital Platform Regulation•2022

  • Algorithmic indifference

    Open Access•Nick Hagar, Nicholas Diakopoulos•New Media & Society•2023

  • Love is love

    Open Access•C Philip Larson, Ashley R Carter et al.•New Media & Society•2023

  • What is platform governance

    Robert Gorwa•Information Communication & Society•2019

  • Surveillance evangelism

    Open Access•Samuel Singler•Theoretical Criminology•2025

  • Bureaucrats on Douyin

    Open Access•Yifan Chen, Q Gong•Asian Studies Review•2024

  • Manufacturing the influencity

    Open Access•Xin Li•Geoforum•2025

  • News recommender systems

    Open Access•Eliza Mitova, Sina Blassnig et al.•Annals of the International…•2022

  • Going with the Mainstream

    Open Access•Taewoo Kang, Tim P Vos et al.•The International Journal of…•2026

  • Platform configurations and isomorphism

    Open Access•Ragnhild Kr Olsen, Oscar Westlund et al.•Convergence The International…•2026

  • Postcolonial digital reflexivity

    Open Access•Ivan N Gallegos•AI & Society•2026

  • “Reliable and Cheap”

    Open Access•Agustin Ferrari Braun•Media Culture & Society•2026

  • The benefits of being between (many) fields

    Open Access•Gabrielle Berman, Kate Williams et al.•Big Data & Society•2025

  • Social media and the public interest

    Open Access•Philip M Napoli•Telecommunications Policy•2015

  • The Black Box Society

    Frank Pasquale•Black Box Society•2015

  • Why media companies insist they're not media companies, why they're wrong, and why it matters

    Open Access•Philip M Napoli, Philip Napoli et al.•First Monday•2017

  • Automated Media

    Open Access•Philip M Napoli•Communication Theory•2014

  • Media Performance

    Denis Mcquail, David Pritchard•Canadian Journal of Communication•1993

  • Journalism is twerking? How web analytics is changing the process of gatekeeping

    Open Access•Edson C Tandoc•New Media & Society•2014

  • Giving in or giving up

    Open Access•Edson C Tandoc, Patrick Ferrucci et al.•Computers in Human Behavior•2016

  • The politics of 'platforms

    Open Access•Tarleton Gillespie•New Media & Society•2010

  • Critical Questions for Big Data

    Drick Boyd, Danah Boyd et al.•Information Communication & Society•2012

  • Toward an Ethics of Algorithms

    Open Access•Mike Ananny•Science Technology & Human Values•2016

  • Algorithms as culture

    Open Access•N Seaver•Big Data & Society•2017

  • The Iron Cage Revisited

    P Dimaggio, Paul J Dimaggio et al.•American Sociological Review•1983

  • Institutionalized Organizations

    J W Meyer, Brian Rowan•American Journal of Sociology•1977

Unique citing works129
Citations per year16,13
Citation span2018 - 2026 (9)
Citation velocitycurrent
Highly citedYes
Citation typesNeutral: 111

Tools

Open DOISci-HubOpen Access
Ethnos_APP • Open Source Project • MIT License • Frontend v2.0.0 • Privacy and Cookies • API Documentation: api.ethnos.app/docs • API Source Code: GitHub • DOI: 10.5281/zenodo.17049435 • Frontend Source Code: GitHub • DOI: 10.5281/zenodo.17050053 • cruz.rio.br • Expectantes Misericordiae