Between hearts and minds

Although Russian authorities point to the supposed success of Britain's late colonial counter-insurgency campaigns as a model even in the 21st century, their grasp of the historical lessons is partial at best. This article considers the applicability and relevance of the counter-insurgency experience of the late British colonial state to present-day ethno-religious conflicts in the North Caucasus. The article suggests that the flexibility of British arrangements for counter-insurgency was a major factor in achieving long-term stability for the gradual transition to indigenous self-rule. The key practice was to devolve responsibility and power to indigenous elites operating with a high degree of autonomy. The article then proposes guidelines relevant to the conditions of the present and the near future that will affect prospects both for full-fledged democratization of Russia and for effective state-building, also vitally important for the development of the North Caucasus. The article concludes that the most relevant factor in the British counter-insurgency experience is to win the hearts and minds of the population. However, this cannot be achieved without a legitimate indigenous administration capable of taking full responsibility and ownership of the campaign. Otherwise, diminished political access and accountability create propitious conditions for adherents of radical movements, who are increasingly capable of and prepared to use violence and who are the only de facto rival political forces within the Russian Federation

Autonomy · Colonialism · Democracy · Democratization · Indigenous · Insurgency · Political economy · Political science · Politics · Population · Power (physics · Sociology · State (computer science · Defense, Military, and Policy Studies · European and Russian Geopolitical Military Strategies · Law · Military History and Strategy

• Repress, coopt, persuade? Russia's counterinsurgency warfare from Kabul to Kyiv

  Mason W Krusch•Small Wars and Insurgencies•2024

  Add to list