Skip to main content

ETHNOS_APP

Home • Search • Journals • List 0

Evolution of Homo in the Middle and Late Pleistocene

Bibliographic Data

ID5708673
AuthorsK Harvati (0000-0001-5998-4794, University of Tübingen, corresponding author), Hugo Reyes‐centeno (0000-0002-0179-3941, University of Kentucky), Hugo Reyes-Centeno
Year2022
Volume173
Pages103279
Publication date2022-12-01
Peer ReviewedYes
Open AccessYes
TypeARTICLE
VenueJournal of Human Evolution (JOURNAL)
Journal identifiersISSN: 0047-2484 • E-ISSN: 1095-8606
PublisherElsevier BV (PUBLISHER)
DOI10.1016/j.jhevol.2022.103279
PMID36375244
OpenAlexW4309098259
LanguageEN
Citations received13
References cited169

The Middle and Late Pleistocene is arguably the most interesting period in human evolution. This broad period witnessed the evolution of our own lineage, as well as that of our sister taxon, the Neanderthals, and related Denisovans. It is exceptionally rich in both fossil and archaeological remains, and uniquely benefits from insights gained through molecular approaches, such as paleogenetics and paleoproteomics, that are currently not widely applicable in earlier contexts. This wealth of information paints a highly complex picture, often described as 'the Muddle in the Middle,' defying the common adage that 'more evidence is needed' to resolve it. Here we review competing phylogenetic scenarios and the historical and theoretical developments that shaped our approaches to the fossil record, as well as some of the many remaining open questions associated with this period. We propose that advancing our understanding of this critical time requires more than the addition of data and will necessitate a major shift in our conceptual and theoretical framework

Archaeology · Biology · Evolutionary biology · Fossil Record · Geography · Human evolution · Lineage (genetic) · Period (music) · Pleistocene · Evolution and Paleontology Studies · Forensic Anthropology and Bioarchaeology Studies · Geology · Paleontology · Pleistocene-Era Hominins and Archaeology

  • Fifty years of paleoanthropology in Journal of Human Evolution

    Open Access•C Zanolli, A B Taylor•Journal of Human Evolution•2023

  • Terminologies associated with “early Homo sapiens ” and their evolutionary status

    Yuhao Zhao, Song Xing•Prehistoric Archaeology•2024

  • Technology and taphonomy of the Middle Paleolithic assemblage from the Uzun Mera site in Macedonia

    Open Access•Darko Stojanovski, G L F Berruti et al.•Quaternary Environments and Humans•2025

  • Homo heidelbergensis and The Origins of The Middle Stone Age

    Open Access•David L G Miedzianogora, Ceri Shipton et al.•African Archaeological Review•2025

  • Moving away from 'the Muddle in the Middle' toward solving the Chibanian puzzle

    Open Access•C J Bae, Leslie C Aiello et al.•Evolutionary Anthropology Issues…•2024

  • The Swanscombe fossil at 90

    Open Access•Emma E Bird, C Stringer•Journal of the Royal Anthropologica…•2026

  • The morphological affinities of the fossil cranium from Kabua, Kenya

    Open Access•Anna Mt Bosman, Abel Marinus Bosman et al.•Journal of the Royal Anthropologica…•2026

  • Earliest centripetal flaking system in eastern Eurasia reveals human behavioral complexity in late Middle Pleistocene China

    Open Access•Yu-chao Zhao, Zhan-Yang Li et al.•Journal of Human Evolution•2026

  • Can controversial samples lead to reliable conclusions? A reply to

    Open Access•Dimitris S Kostopoulos, Georgios Th Lazaridis•Journal of Human Evolution•2026

  • Facial morphologies of Middle Pleistocene Europe

    Open Access•Siri Topsø Olsen, Suzanna White•Journal of Human Evolution•2025

  • Virtual reconstruction and geometric morphometric analysis of the Kocabaş hominin fossil from Turkey

    Open Access•T Mori, Alessandro Riga et al.•Journal of Human Evolution•2024

  • New Late Middle Pleistocene human remains at the Payre site (Marine Isotopic Stage 7, Ardèche, Southeast France)

    Open Access•Constance Cavillac, Amélie Vialet et al.•Journal of Human Evolution•2025

  • Neanderthal Cranio-Cervical Features

    Open Access•Marco Boggioni, Andrea Papini et al.•Evolutionary Anthropology Issues…•2025

  • L'homme fossile de la Chapelle-aux-Saints

    Open Access•Marcellin Boule•1909

  • Nuclear DNA sequences from the Middle Pleistocene Sima de los Huesos hominins

    Open Access•Matthias Meyer, J L Arsuaga et al.•Nature•2016

  • Origins of modern human ancestry

    Open Access•Anders Bergstrom, C Stringer et al.•Nature•2021

  • Genetic history of an archaic hominin group from Denisova Cave in Siberia

    Open Access•David Reich, Richard E Green et al.•Nature•2010

  • DNA sequence of the mitochondrial hypervariable region II from the Neandertal type specimen

    Open Access•Matthias Krings, Helga Geisert et al.•Proceedings of the National…•1999

  • Neandertal DNA Sequences and the Origin of Modern Humans

    Open Access•Matthias Krings, Anne C Stone et al.•Cell•1997

  • Altitude adaptation in Tibetans caused by introgression of Denisovan-like DNA

    Open Access•Emilia Huerta-Sanchez, Emilia Huerta‐sánchez et al.•Nature•2014

  • Early modern human diversity suggests subdivided population structure and a complex out-of-Africa scenario

    Open Access•Philipp Gunz, Fred L Bookstein et al.•Proceedings of the National…•2009

  • Earliest evidence of modern human life history in North African early Homo sapiens

    Open Access•T M Smith, Paul Tafforeau et al.•Proceedings of the National…•2007

  • The genomic landscape of Neanderthal ancestry in present-day humans

    Open Access•Sriram Sankararaman, Swapan Mallick et al.•Nature•2014

  • A New Cave Man from Rhodesia, South Africa

    Open Access•Arthur Smith Woodward•Nature•1921

  • Hominids and hybrids

    Open Access•Ian Tattersall, Jeffrey H Schwartz•Proceedings of the National…•1999

  • Southern African ancient genomes estimate modern human divergence to 350,000 to 260,000 years ago

    Open Access•Carina Schlebusch, Helena Malmström et al.•Science•2017

  • An early modern human from Romania with a recent Neanderthal ancestor

    Open Access•Qiaomei Fu, Mateja Hajdinjak et al.•Nature•2015

  • Deeply divergent archaic mitochondrial genome provides lower time boundary for African gene flow into Neanderthals

    Open Access•Cosimo Posth, Christoph Wißing et al.•Nature Communications•2017

  • Late Pleistocene archaic human crania from Xuchang, China

    Open Access•Zhan-Yang Li, Zhanyang Li et al.•Science•2017

  • A Hominid from the Lower Pleistocene of Atapuerca, Spain

    Open Access•José Marı́a Bermúdez De Castro, J L Arsuaga et al.•Science•1997

  • Human remains from Zhirendong, South China, and modern human emergence in East Asia

    Open Access•Wu Liu, Changzhu Jin et al.•Proceedings of the National…•2010

  • Neanderthal taxonomy reconsidered

    Open Access•K Harvati, Stephen R Frost et al.•Proceedings of the National…•2004

  • The age of Homo naledi and associated sediments in the Rising Star Cave, South Africa

    Open Access•Paul H G M Dirks, Eric M Roberts et al.•eLife•2017

  • The early Upper Paleolithic human skeleton from the Abrigo do Lagar Velho (Portugal) and modern human emergence in Iberia

    Open Access•Cidália Duarte, João Maurício et al.•Proceedings of the National…•1999

  • A Draft Sequence of the Neandertal Genome

    Open Access•Richard E Green, Johannes Krause et al.•Science•2010

  • Taxonomic Categories in Fossil Hominids

    Open Access•E Mayr•Cold Spring Harbor Symposia on…•1950

  • The earliest modern humans outside Africa

    Open Access•Israel Hershkovitz, Gerhard W Weber et al.•Science•2018

  • Molecular analysis of Neanderthal DNA from the northern Caucasus

    Open Access•Igor V Ovchinnikov, Anders Götherström et al.•Nature•2000

  • A new species of Homo from the Late Pleistocene of the Philippines

    Open Access•Florent Détroit, Augusto Mijares et al.•Nature•2019

  • Homo floresiensis-like fossils from the early Middle Pleistocene of Flores

    Open Access•Gerrit D Van Den Bergh, Yousuke Kaifu et al.•Nature•2016

  • The origin and evolution of Homo sapiens

    Open Access•C Stringer•Philosophical Transactions of the…•2016

  • Modern human incursion into Neanderthal territories 54,000 years ago at Mandrin, France

    Open Access•Ludovic Slimak, C Zanolli et al.•Science Advances•2022

  • Human cranial anatomy and the differential preservation of population history and climate signatures

    Open Access•K Harvati, T D Weaver•The Anatomical Record Part A:…•2006

  • The genetic history of Ice Age Europe

    Open Access•Qiaomei Fu, Cosimo Posth et al.•Nature•2016

  • Neandertals and modern humans in Western Asia.

    Open Access•Milford H Wolpoff•American Journal of Physical…•1999

  • Evolutionary Perspective on Narmada Hominin Fossils

    Open Access•Anek R Sankhyan•Advances in Anthropology•2020

  • Genetic differences among subspecies of the saddle‐back tamarin ( Saguinus fuscicollis )

    Open Access•James M Cheverud, Susan C Jacobs et al.•American Journal of Primatology•1993

  • Phenotypic traits of primate hybrids

    Open Access•Rebecca Rogers Ackermann•Evolutionary Anthropology Issues…•2010

  • Delimitating species in paleoanthropology

    Open Access•Tim D White•Evolutionary Anthropology Issues…•2014

  • Population structure and the evolution of Homo sapiens in Africa

    Open Access•R G Klein•Evolutionary Anthropology Issues…•2019

  • Human evolution in the Middle Pleistocene

    Open Access•G P Rightmire•Evolutionary Anthropology Issues…•1998

  • The morphological distinctiveness of Homo sapiens and its recognition in the fossil record

    Open Access•I Tattersall, Jeffrey H Schwartz•Evolutionary Anthropology Issues…•2008

  • The strange blood

    Open Access•Dietmar Zinner, Michael L Arnold et al.•Evolutionary Anthropology Issues…•2011

  • A process‐based approach to hominin taxonomy provides new perspectives on hominin speciation

    Open Access•Laura A Van Holstein, R A Foley•Evolutionary Anthropology Issues…•2022

  • Hybridization in human evolution

    Open Access•Rebecca Rogers Ackermann, Michael L Arnold et al.•Evolutionary Anthropology Issues…•2019

  • Paleoanthropology

    Open Access•I Tattersall•Evolutionary Anthropology Issues…•2000

  • Gene Flow Happens

    Open Access•Anne D Yoder•Evolutionary Anthropology Issues…•2014

  • Resolving the “muddle in the middle”

    Open Access•M Roksandic, Predrag Radović et al.•Evolutionary Anthropology Issues…•2022

  • The naming of Homo bodoensis by Roksandic and colleagues does not resolve issues surrounding Middle Pleistocene human evolution

    Open Access•E Delson, C Stringer•Evolutionary Anthropology Issues…•2022

  • Statistical and biological definitions of “anatomically modern” humans

    Open Access•O M Pearson•Evolutionary Anthropology Issues…•2008

  • In the shadow of the modern synthesis? Alternative perspectives on the last fifty years of paleoanthropology

    Open Access•R A Foley, Robert Foley•Evolutionary Anthropology Issues…•2001

  • Muddying the muddle in the middle even more

    Open Access•Esteban E Sarmiento, Martin Pickford•Evolutionary Anthropology Issues…•2022

  • Twentieth anniversary of Homo antecessor (1997‐2017)

    Open Access•José Marı́a Bermúdez De Castro, José María Bermúdez De Castro et al.•Evolutionary Anthropology Issues…•2017

  • The Assimilation Model of modern human origins in light of current genetic and genomic knowledge

    Open Access•Fred H Smith, James C M Ahern et al.•Quaternary International•2017

  • Diagnosing Homo sapiens in the fossil record

    Open Access•Christopher Brian Stringer, L T Buck•Annals of Human Biology•2014

  • Ancestors

    Open Access•Robin Dennell•Journal of Archaeological Science•1986

  • Evolutionary history of the primates

    Open Access•Glenn C Conroy•International Journal of…•1980

  • Out of Africa and into Asia

    Open Access•Hugo Reyes‐centeno, Hugo Reyes-Centeno•Quaternary International•2016

  • The significance of the fossil hominid skull from Petralona, Greece

    Open Access•Christopher B Stringer, F Clark Howell et al.•Journal of Archaeological Science•1979

  • Population relationships of later Pleistocene hominids

    Open Access•Christopher B Stringer•Journal of Archaeological Science•1974

  • Neanderthals Revisited

    Open Access•Jean-Jacques Hublin, Katerina Harvati et al.•Neanderthals Revisited•2006

  • Huanglong Cave

    Open Access•Wu Liu, Xianzhu Wu et al.•Quaternary International•2009

  • Handbook of Paleoanthropology

    Open Access•T Hardt, Winfried Henke et al.•Handbook of Paleoanthropology•2013

  • Modern human teeth from Late Pleistocene Luna Cave (Guangxi, China)

    Open Access•C J Bae, Wei Wang et al.•Quaternary International•2014

  • The assimilation model, modern human origins in Europe, and the extinction of Neandertals

    Open Access•Fred H Smith, I Janković et al.•Quaternary International•2005

  • The endocranial anatomy of maba 1

    Open Access•Xiu‐jie Wu, E Bruner•American Journal of Physical…•2016

  • On species and races of living and fossil man

    Open Access•Theodosius Dobzhansky•American Journal of Physical…•1944

  • A proper study for mankind

    Open Access•Clifford J Jolly•American Journal of Physical…•2001

  • The special features and status of the Saldanha skull

    Open Access•M R Drennan, Martin Drennan•American Journal of Physical…•1955

  • Direct dating of human fossils

    Open Access•Rainer Grün•American Journal of Physical…•2006

  • Genomic validation of the differential preservation of population history in modern human cranial anatomy

    Open Access•Hugo Reyes‐centeno, Silvia Ghirotto et al.•American Journal of Physical…•2017

  • Cioclovina (Romania)

    Open Access•K Harvati, Philipp Gunz et al.•Journal of Human Evolution•2007

  • Cranial remains of Middle Pleistocene European hominids

    Open Access•Milford H Wolpoff•Journal of Human Evolution•1980

  • Some further notes on the morphology and dating of the Petralona hominid

    Open Access•C Stringer, C B Stringer•Journal of Human Evolution•1983

  • The Neanderthal taxonomic position

    Open Access•K Harvati•Journal of Human Evolution•2003

  • Morphological description and comparison of the dental remains from Atapuerca-Sima de los Huesos site (Spain)

    Open Access•María Martinón‐torre, Maria Martinón-Torres et al.•Journal of Human Evolution•2012

  • Homo in the middle pleistocene

    Open Access•G P Rightmire•Evolutionary Anthropology Issues…•2008

  • The origin of anatomically modern humans and their behavior in africa and eurasia

    Open Access•A P Derevianko•Archaeology Ethnology and…•2011

  • The Fate of the "Classic" Neanderthals

    C Loring Brace, George A Agogino et al.•Current Anthropology•1964

  • The Morphology of Permanent Molars from the Paleolithic Layers of Denisova Cave

    Open Access•Alisa Zubova, Tatiana Chikisheva et al.•Archaeology Ethnology and…•2017

  • Is Homo heidelbergensis a distinct species? New insight on the Mauer mandible

    Open Access•A Mounier, François Marchal et al.•Journal of Human Evolution•2009

  • Species recognition in human paleontology

    Open Access•Ian Tattersall•Journal of Human Evolution•1986

  • A re-examination of presumed Neandertal-like fossils

    Open Access•Albert P Santa Luca•Journal of Human Evolution•1978

  • The effects of hybridization on growth allometry and craniofacial form in Sulawesi macaques

    Open Access•M A Schillaci, Jeffery W Froehlich et al.•Journal of Human Evolution•2005

  • How many species of hominid should there be

    Open Access•R A Foley•Journal of Human Evolution•1991

  • Reconstruction of hominid phylogeny

    Open Access•E Delson, Niles Eldredge et al.•Journal of Human Evolution•1977

  • Identifying the morphological signatures of hybridization in primate and human evolution

    Open Access•Rebecca Rogers Ackermann, Jeffrey Rogers et al.•Journal of Human Evolution•2006

  • Conceptual issues in hominin taxonomy

    Open Access•Sheela Athreya, A Hopkins•American Journal of Physical…•2021

  • Morphological description and evolutionary significance of 300 ka hominin facial bones from Hualongdong, China

    Open Access•Xiu‐jie Wu, Xiujie Wu et al.•Journal of Human Evolution•2021

  • Virtual ancestor reconstruction

    Open Access•A Mounier, M M Lahr•Journal of Human Evolution•2016

  • Evolution of cranial capacity revisited

    Open Access•Xiu‐jie Wu, Xiu-Jie Wu et al.•Journal of Human Evolution•2022

  • Evaluating developmental shape changes in Homo antecessor subadult facial morphology

    Sarah E Freidline, Philipp Gunz et al.•Journal of Human Evolution•2013

  • Evolution of middle-late Pleistocene human cranio-facial form

    Open Access•K Harvati, Jean-Jacques Hublin et al.•Journal of Human Evolution•2010

  • Mass spectrometric U-series dating of Huanglong Cave in Hubei Province, central China

    G Shen, Xianzhu Wu et al.•Journal of Human Evolution•2013

  • Further evidence for phenotypic signatures of hybridization in descendant baboon populations

    Open Access•Rebecca Rogers Ackermann, Lauren Schroeder et al.•Journal of Human Evolution•2014

  • Systematics and the Origin of Species from the View-Point of a Zoologist

    Sheng‐xi Wu, Ernst Mayr•Geographical Journal•1943

  • The Fossil Evidence for Modern Human Origins in Africa

    Open Access•Leslie C Aiello, Leslie C Aiello Reader et al.•American Anthropologist•1993

  • Early Upper Paleolithic Man and Late Middle Paleolithic Tools

    Open Access•David S Brose, Milford H Wolpoff•American Anthropologist•1971

  • The "Neanderthal Man" and the Ancestors of "Homo Sapiens

    Open Access•Franz Weidenreich•American Anthropologist•1943

  • Right for the Wrong Reasons

    Trenton W Holliday, Joanna R Gautney et al.•Current Anthropology•2014

  • Species Concepts, Reticulation, and Human Evolution

    Trenton W Holliday•Current Anthropology•2003

  • The status of Homo heidelbergensis (Schoetensack 1908)

    Open Access•C Stringer•Evolutionary Anthropology Issues…•2012

Unique citing works13
Citations per year4,33
Citation span2023 - 2026 (4)
Citation velocitycurrent
Highly citedNo
Citation typesNeutral: 12

Tools

Open DOIOpen Access
Ethnos_APP • Open Source Project • MIT License • Frontend v2.0.0 • Privacy and Cookies • API Documentation: api.ethnos.app/docs • API Source Code: GitHub • DOI: 10.5281/zenodo.17049435 • Frontend Source Code: GitHub • DOI: 10.5281/zenodo.17050053 • cruz.rio.br • Expectantes Misericordiae