Elite Revisionists and Popular Beliefs

Christopher Columbus, Hero or Villain

Bibliographic Data

ID5773781
AuthorsHoward Schuman (corresponding author), Barry Schwartz (0000-0001-6947-9871), Hilary Darcy
Year2005
Volume69
Issue1
Pages2-29
Publication date2005-01-01
Peer ReviewedYes
Open AccessNo
TypeARTICLE
VenuePublic Opinion Quarterly (JOURNAL)
Journal identifiersISSN: 0033-362X • E-ISSN: 1537-5331
PublisherOxford University Press (PUBLISHER • GB)
DOI10.1093/poq/nfi001
OpenAlexW2108591592
LanguageEN
Citations received38
References cited50

According to revisionist historians and American Indian activists, Christopher Columbus deserves condemnation for having brought slavery, disease, and death to America's indigenous peoples. We ask whether the general public's beliefs about Columbus show signs of reflecting these critical accounts, which increased markedly as the 1992 Quincentenary approached. Our national surveys, using several different question wordings, indicate that most Americans continue to admire Columbus because, as tradition puts it, "he discovered America," though only a small number of mainly older respondents speak of him in the heroic terms common in earlier years. At the same time, the percentage of Americans who reject traditional beliefs about Columbus is also small and is divided between those who simply acknowledge the priority of Indians as the "First Americans" and those who go further to view Columbus as a villain. The latter group of respondents, we find, show a critical stance toward modal American beliefs much more broadly. We also analyze American history school textbooks for evidence of influence from revisionist writings, and we consider representations of Columbus in the mass media as well. Revisionist history can be seen as one consequence of the "minority rights revolution" that began after World War II and has achieved considerable success, but the endurance of Columbus's reputation-to a considerable extent even among the minorities who have the least reason to respect him-raises important questions about the inertia of tradition, the politics of collective memory, and the difference between elite and popular beliefs

Elite · HERO · Politics and Society in Latin America · Social and Cultural Dynamics · Southeast Asian Sociopolitical Studies

Tools

Open DOISci-Hub