Skip to main content

ETHNOS_APP

Home • Search • Journals • List 0

Waiting for Godot

Regime Change Without Democratization in the Middle East

Bibliographic Data

ID5774980
AuthorsHolger Albrecht (0000-0003-3487-397X), Oliver Schlumberger (0000-0002-1651-5418)
Year2004
Volume25
Issue4
Pages371-392
Publication date2004-10-01
Peer ReviewedYes
Open AccessYes
TypeARTICLE
VenueInternational Political Science Review (JOURNAL)
Journal identifiersISSN: 0192-5121 • E-ISSN: 1460-373X
PublisherSAGE Publishing (PUBLISHER • US)
DOI10.1177/0192512104045085
OpenAlexW2084395037
LanguageEN
Citations received113
References cited37

When will Middle Eastern countries democratize?" is the normative question that guided the literature on regime change in the Arab world during the 1990s. Since significant political changes but no systemic transitions have occurred, this question needs reformulation: what accounts for the persistence of Arab authoritarianism? Escaping thus from the teleological tunnel permits the identification of two major developments. The first is an oscillation between controlled political liberalizations and deliberalizations, and the second consists of five areas of change within regimes: legitimation, elites, institution building, co-optation, and regimes' reactions to external influences. The second trend is particularly crucial for understanding the durability of authoritarianism in the Arab world. Our findings clarify differences, but also provide bases for comparison between the Arab world and those developing regions where political transition did occur

Dissent · Legitimation · Regime change · Political Conflict and Governance · Political Influence and Corporate Strategies · Turkey's Politics and Society

  • Committed to Rights

    Open Access•Audrey L Comstock•Committed to Rights : Volume 1•2021

  • Egyptian Students and Politics beyond Protest

    Farah Ramzy•Egyptian Students and Politics…•2025

  • Authoritarian Resilience in Mena Countries in the Era of Autocratization

    Open Access•Inmaculada Szmolka, Francesco Cavatorta•Revista de Estudios Internacionales…•2024

  • The social contract in Egypt, Lebanon and Tunisia

    Open Access•Michael Loewe, Holger Albrecht•Journal of International…•2023

  • Wir sind die Medien

    Open Access•Marcus Michaelsen, Orsolya Friedrich•Wir sind die Medien•2013

  • More Freedom, Less Terror

    Dalia Dassa Kaye, Frederic Wehrey et al.•More freedom, less terror?•2008

  • Schooling the Nation

    Open Access•Hania Sobhy•Schooling the Nation•2023

  • Youth Activism and Contentious Politics in Egypt

    Open Access•Nadine Sika•Youth Activism and Contentious…•2017

  • Contesting Authoritarianism

    Dina Bishara•Contesting Authoritarianism•2018

  • Promoting Democracy, Reinforcing Authoritarianism

    Open Access•Benjamin Schuetze•Promoting Democracy, Reinforcing…•2019

  • Arab Media Systems

    Open Access•Open Book Publishers Staff, Carola Richter et al.•Arab Media Systems•2021

  • Who are in charge, who do i work with, and who are my friends

    Open Access•N Huhe, Max Gallop et al.•Social Networks•2021

  • Durable, Yet Different

    Open Access•André Bank, Thomas Richter et al.•Journal of Arabian Studies•2014

  • Tunisie

    Open Access•Michel Camau•L Année du Maghreb•2008

  • Legitimationsstrategien von Autokratien im Vergleich

    Open Access•Julia Grauvogel, Christian Von Soest•Zeitschrift für Vergleichende…•2017

  • Promising democracy, legitimizing autocracy? Perceptions of regime democraticness among university students in Morocco

    Open Access•Kressen Thyen•Zeitschrift für Vergleichende…•2017

  • Legitimation towards whom

    Open Access•Maria Josua•Zeitschrift für Vergleichende…•2017

  • The Role of Constitutional Law in Shaping Government Structures and Stability in the Middle East

    Open Access•Khaled Khalaf Abed Rabbo Aldrou, Sabah Mousa Al-Momani et al.•Central European Journal of…•2025

  • NGO Policy in Pre- and Post-Mubarak Egypt

    Open Access•Catherine E Herrold•Nonprofit Policy Forum•2015

  • The Impact of the Arab Spring on Islamist Strategies

    Open Access•Ioana Emy Matesan•Journal of Strategic Security•2012

  • The 2011 Mena Revolutions

    Open Access•Jessie G Rumsey•Journal of Strategic Security•2012

  • Democratization beyond Capitalist Time

    Roberto Roccu•Middle East Critique•2019

  • Analyzing Authoritarian Regime Legitimation

    Julie Pruzan-Jørgensen•Middle East Critique•2010

  • Examining the ‘Post’ in Post-Democratization

    Morten Valbjørn, André Bank•Middle East Critique•2010

  • Measuring Egyptian Regime Legitimacy

    M Sedgwick•Middle East Critique•2010

  • The European Mediterranean Policy after the Arab Spring

    Patricia Bauer•Middle East Critique•2015

  • Weaponizing Democratization

    Sarah Elizabeth Hynek•Middle East Critique•2023

  • Beyond Lies the Wub

    Andrea Teti•Middle East Critique•2012

  • The Islamic Republic

    Elisheva Machlis•Middle East Critique•2016

  • Upgrading Post-democratization Studies

    Morten Valbjørn•Middle East Critique•2012

  • The Convergence of Governance

    Francesco Cavatorta•Middle East Critique•2010

  • Union for the Mediterranean —Pragmatic Multilateralism and the Depoliticization of EU-Middle Eastern Relations

    Peter Seeberg•Middle East Critique•2010

  • Déjà Vu in the Kingdom of Jordan

    Nur Koprulu, Pricillah Marisa•Contemporary Arab Affairs•2022

  • Inter-state tensions and regional integration

    Khalid Sekkat•Contemporary Arab Affairs•2014

  • Framing Arab socio-political space

    Sari Hanafi•Contemporary Arab Affairs•2010

  • Political advertising effectiveness in war-time Syria

    Open Access•Ali B Mahmoud, Nicholas Grigoriou et al.•Media War & Conflict•2019

  • Media pushing for political transformation

    Open Access•Carola Richter, Indira Dupuis et al.•International Communication Gazette•2020

  • Methodology Matters in Iran

    Open Access•Paola Rivetti•Anthropology of the Middle East•2017

  • Elite Coalitions and Power Balance across African Regimes

    Open Access•Clionadh Raleigh, Daniel Wigmore-Shepherd•Ethnopolitics•2020

  • Political and social mobilization in the Middle East and North Africa after the 2011 uprisings

    Francesco Cavatorta, Janine A Clark•Globalizations•2022

  • Neoliberal co-optation and authoritarian renewal

    Nadine Kreitmeyr•Globalizations•2018

  • Turkey as a Great Power? Back to Reality

    Open Access•Ąžuolas Bagdonas•Turkish Studies•2015

  • Political Parties Matter

    Open Access•Gul M Kurtoglu Eskisar, GÜL M KURTOĞLU-ESKİŞAR•Japanese Journal of Political…•2008

  • Des transitions africaines au monde arabe, 1991-2011

    Celine Thiriot•Revue internationale de politique…•2013

  • The Arab Uprisings in Theoretical Perspective – An Introduction

    M Pace, Massimo Ramaioli et al.•Mediterranean Politics•2012

  • Three Ways of Revisiting the (post-) Democratization Debate After the Arab Uprisings

    Morten Valbjørn•Mediterranean Politics•2013

  • The Ties that do not Bind

    Oliver Schlumberger•Mediterranean Politics•2011

  • Democratization in the Middle East and North Africa

    Philippe C Schmitter, Nadine Sika•Mediterranean Politics•2016

  • The Arab uprisings and the return of repression

    Open Access•Maria Josua, Mirjam Edel•Mediterranean Politics•2021

  • Decentralization in the Arab world

    Thomas Demmelhuber, Roland Sturm et al.•Mediterranean Politics•2018

  • The tide that failed to rise

    Pamela Abbott, Andrea Teti et al.•Mediterranean Politics•2018

  • Enduring Ambiguity

    Teije H Donker•Mediterranean Politics•2010

  • Dynamics of transformation, elite change and new social mobilization in the Arab World

    Open Access•Muriel Asseburg, Heiko Wimmen•Mediterranean Politics•2015

  • There and back again

    Nadine Sika, Balázs Szent-Iványi•Democratization•2026

  • Explaining police support for the use of force and vigilante violence in Ghana

    Justice Tankebe•Policing & Society•2011

  • Challenges for democracy in countries affected by the ‘Arab Spring’

    Borna Zgurić•Islam and Christian–Muslim…•2012

  • The Iranian Nuclear Negotiations as a Two-Level Game

    Steve Hurst•Diplomacy and Statecraft•2016

  • Evaluating Authoritarian Performance

    Open Access•Andrew Leber, Jonas Bergan Draege•Governance•2026

  • Blue blood or true blood

    Open Access•Fenja Søndergaard Møller•Conflict Management and Peace…•2017

  • Liberalizing Autocracies in the Gulf Region? Reform Strategies in the Face of a Cultural-Economic Syndrome

    Open Access•Brigitte Weiffen•World Development•2008

  • The social contract as a tool of analysis

    Open Access•Michael Loewe, Tina Zintl et al.•World Development•2020

  • Fire in Cairo”

    Open Access•Éric Rougier•World Development•2015

  • The Lived Social Contract in Schools

    Open Access•Hania Sobhy•World Development•2020

  • Regime Change and Arab Countries' Lobbying in the United States

    Open Access•Sergey Kostyaev, Sergey Kostyaev Sergey Kostyaev•Arab Studies Quarterly•2013

  • Political Change in North Africa and the Arab Middle East

    Open Access•Inmaculada Szmolka•Arab Studies Quarterly•2014

  • Authoritarianism, Civil Society and Democracy in the Middle East

    Open Access•Farhad Kazemi, Augustus Richard Norton•Middle East Studies Association…•2006

  • Does unemployment spark collective contentious action? Evidence from a Moroccan social movement

    Montserrat Emperador Badimon•Journal of Contemporary African…•2013

  • More than Repression

    Francesco Cavatorta•Journal of Contemporary African…•2007

  • Authoritarian regimes in democratic regional organisations? Exploring regional dimensions of authoritarianism in an increasingly democratic West Africa

    Edward Stoddard•Journal of Contemporary African…•2017

  • Beautiful authoritarianism

    Open Access•Mustafa Menshawy•Third World Quarterly•2026

  • Planning for Sustainability in Non-democratic Polities

    Open Access•Laurence Crot•Urban Studies•2013

  • The Tunisian General Labor Union and the Advent of Democracy

    Kasper Ly Netterstrøm•The Middle East Journal•2016

  • The consequences of trust and repression on the rise and fall of movements in authoritarian regimes

    Open Access•Nadine Sika•International Journal of…•2024

  • Morocco

    Frédéric Vairel•Mediterranean Politics•2008

  • Cultural diplomacy and the reconfiguration of soft power

    Andreas M Wüst, Andreas Wust et al.•Mediterranean Politics•2022

  • Static imaginations and the possibilities of radical change

    Open Access•Federico Caprotti, Eleanor Gao et al.•Area•2012

  • Responses of far right parties to refugees in hybrid regimes

    Gul M Kurtoglu Eskisar, Tugcan Durmuslar•New Community•2023

  • Perceived Competence and Benevolence of Political Institutions as Culturally Universal Facilitators of Political Trust

    Open Access•Dejun Tony Kong•Cross-Cultural Research•2014

  • Vive la grande famille des médias tunisiens ’ Media reform, authoritarian resilience and societal responses in Tunisia

    Rikke Hostrup Haugbølle, Francesco Cavatorta•The Journal of North African…•2011

  • Forgetting democratization? Recasting power and authority in a plural Muslim world

    Frédéric Volpi, Francesco Cavatorta•Democratization•2006

  • Estructura de poder y desafíos populares. La respuesta del régimen marroquí al Movimiento 20 de Febrero

    Open Access•Laura Feliu, Laura Feliu Martínez et al.•Revista de Estudios Políticos•2016

  • The Missing Link? US Policy and the International Dimensions of Failed Democratic Transitions in the Arab World

    Open Access•Lars Berger•Political Studies•2011

  • Autocracies and policy accumulation

    Open Access•Christian Aschenbrenner, Christoph Knill et al.•Journal of Public Policy•2023

  • How to Keep Officers in the Barracks

    Holger Albrecht, Ferdinand Eibl•International Studies Quarterly•2018

  • How Authoritarianism Transforms

    Open Access•Oliver Schlumberger, Mirjam Edel et al.•Government and Opposition•2024

  • Utilitarian and modern

    Sabri Ciftci, Ethan M Bernick•Democratization•2015

  • Explaining (and re-explaining) political change in the Middle East during the Arab Spring

    Frédéric Volpi•Democratization•2013

  • Legitimacy and protest under authoritarianism

    Kressen Thyen, Johannes Gerschewski•Democratization•2018

  • Reflections on self-reflections – On framing the analytical implications of the Arab uprisings for the study of Arab politics

    Morten Valbjørn•Democratization•2015

  • The two sides of functional cooperation with authoritarian regimes

    Tina Freyburg•Democratization•2012

  • Elections, legitimacy, and compliance in authoritarian regimes

    Sean Williamson•Democratization•2021

  • Divided they stand, divided they fail

    Francesco Cavatorta•Democratization•2009

  • Executive Elections in the Arab World

    Open Access•Jason Brownlee•Comparative Political Studies•2011

  • Searching Where the Light Shines

    Lisa Anderson•Annual Review of Political Science•2006

  • Authoritarian Personality vs Institutional Performance – Understanding Military Rule in Africa

    Carlos García-Rivero•Politikon•2022

  • Identity, procedures and performance

    Christian Von Soest, Julia Grauvogel•Contemporary Politics•2017

  • What autocracies say (and what citizens hear)

    Alexander Dukalskis, Johannes Gerschewski•Contemporary Politics•2017

  • Exploring business history of the Middle East and North Africa region

    Stephanie Decker, Christina Lubinski et al.•Business History•2025

  • The three pillars of stability

    Johannes Gerschewski•Democratization•2013

  • How do sources of traditional legitimacy constrain popular uprisings? The case of the Kingdom of Swaziland

    Fenja Søndergaard Møller•Small Wars and Insurgencies•2019

  • Democracy Without Democrats?

    Ghassan Salame•Democracy Without Democrats?•1994

  • The role of the military in underdeveloped countries.

    John J Johnson•The role of the military in…•1962

  • Revolution from above

    Ellen Kay Trimberger•Revolution from above•1978

  • Polyarchy

    Robert Alan Dahl•Polyarchy•1973

  • Logik der Forschung

    Open Access•Karl Popper•Logik der Forschung•1935

  • The third wave

    Samuel P Huntington•The third wave•1991

  • Democracy and the Market

    Open Access•Adam Przeworski•Democracy and the Market•1991

  • Sultanistic Regimes

    H E Chehabi, Houchang Chehabi et al.•Sultanistic regimes•1998

  • Democracy in Developing Countries

    Naomi Chazan, Christian Coulon et al.•Democracy in Developing Countries•1988

  • NGOs, Ingos, GO-NGOs and DO-NGOs

    Sheila Carapico•Middle East Report•2000

  • Arab Elites

    Gamal Abdelnasser, André Bank et al.•Arab Elites•2004

  • Egyptian Politics Under Sadat

    Raymond Hinnebusch, Raymond A Jr Hinnebusch•Egyptian Politics Under Sadat•1988

  • Reflections on the Dilemma of reform in the middle east

    Augustus Richard Norton•Critique Critical Middle Eastern…•1998

  • Political Elites in the Middle East

    Walt Carroll, George Lenczowski•MERIP Reports•1976

  • La question de la démocratie dans les travaux sur le monde arabe

    Steven Heydemann•Critique internationale•2002

  • Egypt's 2000 Parliamentary Elections

    Open Access•Mona Makram‐Ebeid•Middle East Policy•2001

  • Democracy in Developing Countries, Vol. II

    Robert Melson, L Diamond et al.•The International Journal of…•1989

  • The politics of ‘uncivil’ society in Egypt

    Open Access•Maha Abdel Rahman•Review of African Political Economy•2002

  • Cold War, post-Cold War

    Open Access•Efraim Karsh•Review of International Studies•1997

  • Towards Arab liberal governance

    Larbi Sadiki•Third World Quarterly•1997

  • Transformation of the corporatist state in the Middle East

    Anoushiravan Ehteshami, E C Murphy•Third World Quarterly•1996

  • Elites in the Middle East

    Elia T Zureik, Elia Zureik et al.•Contemporary Sociology A Journal…•1982

  • Arab Politics

    Open Access•Robert O Freedman•Political Science Quarterly•1978

  • Distant neighbours

    David Capitanchik•International Affairs•1996

  • Change and democratisation in the Arab world

    As’ad Abukhalil, As'ad AbuKhalil•Third World Quarterly•1997

  • Comparing and Miscomparing

    Open Access•Giovanni Sartori•Journal of Theoretical Politics•1991

  • Democratization in the Arab World? Depoliticization in Morocco

    Open Access•Abdeslam Maghraoui, Abdeslam M Maghraoui•Journal of democracy•2002

  • Democratization in the Arab World? The Decline of Pluralism in Mubarak’s Egypt

    Open Access•Jason Brownlee•Journal of democracy•2002

  • Democratization in the Arab World? The Trap of Liberalized Autocracy

    Open Access•Daniel Brumberg•Journal of democracy•2002

  • Democratic Opposition and Democratization Theory

    Open Access•Alfred Stepan•Government and Opposition•1997

  • The Arab middle east and the question of democratization

    Oliver Schlumberger•Democratization•2000

  • Absolutism and the Resilience of Monarchy in the Middle East

    Open Access•Lisa Anderson•Political Science Quarterly•1991

  • Arab Politics. The Search For Legitimacy

    Michael C Coulson•Verfassung in Recht und Übersee•1979

  • Human rights discourse and practice as crisis management

    Rolf Schwarz•The Journal of North African…•2002

  • Political Petrolism and Contemporary Arab Politics, 1967-1983

    B Korany•Journal of Asian and African…•1986

Unique citing works113
Citations per year5,65
Citation span2006 - 2026 (21)
Citation velocitycurrent
Highly citedYes
Citation typesNeutral: 113

Tools

Open DOISci-Hub
Ethnos_APP • Open Source Project • MIT License • Frontend v2.0.0 • Privacy and Cookies • API Documentation: api.ethnos.app/docs • API Source Code: GitHub • DOI: 10.5281/zenodo.17049435 • Frontend Source Code: GitHub • DOI: 10.5281/zenodo.17050053 • cruz.rio.br • Expectantes Misericordiae