Skip to main content

ETHNOS_APP

Home • Search • Journals • List 0

The agreement hierarchy

Bibliographic Data

ID5775855
AuthorsGreville G Corbett (0000-0002-2667-9870, University of Surrey, corresponding author)
Year1979
Volume15
Issue2
Pages203-224
Publication date1979-09-01
Peer ReviewedYes
Open AccessYes
TypeARTICLE
VenueJournal of Linguistics (JOURNAL)
Journal identifiersISSN: 0022-2267 • E-ISSN: 1469-7742
PublisherCambridge University Press (CUP) (PUBLISHER)
DOI10.1017/s0022226700016352
OpenAlexW2149368929
LanguageEN
Citations received98
References cited8

Consideration of the problem of alternative agreement forms (§ 1) leads us to postulate a hierarchy of agreement positions (§ 2) which allows us to make predictions as to the possibility and relative frequency of semantic as compared to syntactic agreement. The hierarchy is justified by data from a variety of languages which permit alternative agreements (§ 3). Confirming evidence comes from a study of the instances where agreement in case and person is required in different languages (§ 4). The status of the hierarchy and the type of prediction it makes are discussed. It is suggested that the hierarchy determines the main divisions of a measure called SYNTACTIC DISTANCE and that other factors (word order, distance between controller and agreeing element, depth of stacking) determine relative degrees of distance within these main divisions (§ 5). The basic claim of the paper is that as syntactic distance increases so does the likelihood of semantic agreement

Agreement · linguistics and terminology studies

  • The evolutionary trends of grammatical gender in Indo-Aryan languages

    Marc Allassonnière-Tang, Matthew Dunn et al.•Language Dynamics and Change•2020

  • Syntactic and semantic agreement in Eegimaa (Banjal)

    Serge Sagna•Studies in Language•2019

  • Person shift at narrative peak

    Open Access•Anna Margetts•Language•2015

  • Analysis of Agreement Errors Made by Third-Year Students

    Carmen Schlig•Hispania•2003

  • A Two-Tiered Theory of Control

    Idan Landau, Samuel Jay Keyser•Two-Tiered Theory of Control•2015

  • Dependency, Constituency, and Linear Order

    William Croft•Radical Construction Grammar•2001

  • Heads, Arguments, and Adjuncts

    William Croft•Radical Construction Grammar•2001

  • A Radical Approach to Syntactic Relations

    William Croft•Radical Construction Grammar•2001

  • Syntactic Theory and the Theory of Language

    William Croft•Radical Construction Grammar•2001

  • Language Comprehension and ProductionPreparation of this chapter was supported by NIH Grant HD051610 to R.T. and NIH Grant HD18708 to C.C. Its contents are solely the responsibility of the authors and do not necessarily represent the official views of NICHD or NIH.

    Open Access•Charles Clifton, Andrea S Meyer et al.•Handbook of Psychology, Second…•2012

  • Syntactic Argumentation and Radical Construction Grammar

    William Croft•Radical Construction Grammar•2001

  • The Voice Continuum

    William Croft•Radical Construction Grammar•2001

  • Parts of Speech

    William Croft•Radical Construction Grammar•2001

  • Clausal Syntactic Roles (“Grammatical Relations”)

    William Croft•Radical Construction Grammar•2001

  • The Coordination—Subordination Continuum

    William Croft•Radical Construction Grammar•2001

  • Syntactic Categories and Semantic Relativity

    William Croft•Radical Construction Grammar•2001

  • Making Syntax of Sense

    Kathleen M Eberhard, J Cooper Cutting et al.•Psychological Review•2005

  • Anatolian morphosyntax

    Annette Teffeteller•Perspectives on historical syntax•2015

  • Dutch Double Gender Nouns

    Open Access•Chiara Semplicini•Journal of Germanic Linguistics•2012

  • Definiteness, Gender, and Hybrids

    Open Access•Hans-Olav Enger, Hans‐olav Enger et al.•Journal of Germanic Linguistics•2012

  • The Diachrony of Semantic Gender Agreement

    Open Access•Margot Kraaikamp•Journal of Germanic Linguistics•2017

  • Pronominal Gender in Spoken Dutch

    Jenny Audring•Journal of Germanic Linguistics•2006

  • Characteristic Features of the Development of Agreement in the History of Russian

    Open Access•Iván Igartua•Russian Linguistics•2000

  • Ten Men and Women Got Married Today

    Lucas Champollion•Journal of Semantics•2016

  • Gender agreement with common nouns

    Open Access•A A Danilova•Rhema•2023

  • Number Agreement Attraction in Czech Comprehension

    Open Access•Jan Chromý, Radim Lacina et al.•Open MIND•2023

  • Hybrid agreement with English quantifier partitives

    Open Access•Troy Messick•Glossa a journal of general…•2023

  • The Agreement Hierarchy and (generalized) semantic agreement

    Open Access•Greville G Corbett•Glossa a journal of general…•2023

  • The head of the nominal is N, not D

    Open Access•Benjamin Bruening•Glossa a journal of general…•2020

  • Plural reference dominance, markedness and semantic categorization in Hiaki pluralia tantum

    Open Access•Heidi Harley, Meg Harvey•Glossa a journal of general…•2025

  • Grammatical Gender

    Ruth Kramer•Annual Review of Linguistics•2020

  • Chinese does have independent tense elements

    Zhiyi Zhang, Shikun Li et al.•Chinese Semiotic Studies•2021

  • Nominal and pronominal gender

    Thomas Berg•Language Typology and Universals•2020

  • Plural marking on noun-associated forms

    Francesca Di Garbo•Language Typology and Universals•2020

  • A diachronic and areal typology of agreement in Germanic

    Magnus Breder Birkenes, Jürg Fleischer et al.•Language Typology and Universals•2020

  • Dead and dying duals meet the Agreement Hierarchy

    Open Access•Greville G Corbett, Leńka Scholze•Language Typology and Universals•2026

  • Weighing Psycholinguistic and Social Factors for Semantic Agreement in Dutch Pronouns

    Open Access•Lien De Vos, Gert De Sutter et al.•Journal of Germanic Linguistics•2021

  • Pronominal Gender in Dutch

    Open Access•Kristel Doreleijers, Jeroen Van Craenenbroeck et al.•Journal of Germanic Linguistics•2025

  • Yolanda Fernández-Pena, Reconciling synchrony, diachrony and usage in verb number agreement with complex collective subjects. New York and London

    Open Access•Magnus Levin•English Language and Linguistics•2022

  • Animacy-based concord in Chiyao

    Kristina Riedel, Julius Taji•South African Journal of African…•2022

  • Two types of the 3rd person feature in English

    Open Access•Kaori Furuya•Ampersand•2017

  • Verbal number in Muyu

    Open Access•Alexander Zahrer•Studies in Language•2026

  • Scandinavian pancake sentences revisited

    Open Access•Hans-Olav Enger, Hans‐olav Enger•Nordic Journal of Linguistics•2013

  • Авmомаmuческая обрабоmка mексmа на есmесmвенном языке

    Open Access•Greville G Corbett•Russian Linguistics•1992

  • Gender in Russian

    Open Access•Greville G Corbett•Russian Linguistics•1982

  • Predicate agreement with quantifier phrases containing the words polovina or tret’ and an approximative marker

    Open Access•Yulia M Kuvshinskaya, Yulia Kuvshinskaya•Russian Linguistics•2017

  • The loss of inflection as grammar complication

    Open Access•Helen Sims‐Williams, Hans-Olav Enger et al.•Diachronica•2021

  • A Theory of Agreement and Its Application to Serbo-Croatian

    Stephen Wechsler, Larisa Zlatic•Language•2000

  • Autonomy and Functionalist Linguistics

    William Croft•Language•1995

  • The Morphology/Syntax Interface

    Greville G Corbett•Language•1987

  • Hybrid agreement in English

    Open Access•J B Kim, Jong-Bok Kim•Linguistics•2004

  • In the periphery of an indefinite pronoun. Forms and functions of conceptual agreement with jemand

    Open Access•Sophie Ellsäßer•Zeitschrift für Sprachwissenschaft•2023

  • Scrambling in the nominal domain

    Open Access•Qiushi Chen•Natural Language and Linguistic…•2026

  • Juxtapositional vs. possessive-like encoding in Russian specificational constructions

    Open Access•Natalia Logvinova, Наталья Логвинова•Russian Linguistics•2026

  • Gender agreement in Chicewa

    Open Access•Greville G Corbett, Alfred D Mtenje•Studies in African Linguistics•1987

  • Only case-syncretic nouns attract

    Open Access•Radim Lacina, Anna Laurinavichyute et al.•Journal of Memory and Language•2025

  • Variation in the input

    Yulia Rodina•Language Sciences•2014

  • The role of morphology in setting production biases in agreement

    Open Access•J Carlos Acuña-Fariña, Carlos Acuña-Fariña•Language Sciences•2018

  • Contact-Induced Complexification in the Gender System of Istro-Romanian

    Open Access•Michele Loporcaro, Francesco Gardani et al.•Journal of Language Contact•2021

  • What is Difficult about Grammatical Gender? Evidence from Heritage Russian

    Open Access•Oksana Laleko•Journal of Language Contact•2018

  • A Functional Discourse Grammar Account of Set Nouns in Dutch and its Implications for Lexicography

    Evelien Keizer, Wim Honselaar•International Journal of…•2009

  • Rethinking agreement

    Open Access•Andrej A Kibrik, Аndrej А Kibrik•Cognitive Linguistics•2019

  • Establishing verb agreement with disjunctively conjoined subjects

    Peter G Peterson•Australian Journal of Linguistics•1986

  • Number agreement with collective nouns in New Zealand English

    L Bauer•Australian Journal of Linguistics•1988

  • Interaction between linguistic theory and language processing in SLA

    Open Access•Florence Myles•Second language Research•1995

  • DP-internal semantic agreement

    Open Access•Idan Landau•Natural Language and Linguistic…•2016

  • Feature sharing in agreement

    Open Access•Dag Haug, Dag Trygve Truslew Haug et al.•Natural Language and Linguistic…•2016

  • Mixed agreement, the person feature, and the index/concord distinction

    Open Access•Stephen Wechsler•Natural Language and Linguistic…•2011

  • Distance Effects in Number Agreement

    Judith Schweppe•Discourse Processes•2013

  • The Syntax-Morphology Interface in Ancient Greek

    Nadav Asraf•Mnemosyne•2022

  • Of a Monster

    Open Access•Troy Messick•Linguistic Inquiry•2023

  • The atoms of language

    Open Access•Bozhil Hristov, BOZHIL P HRISTOV•Journal of Linguistics•2015

  • Romance disagreements

    Open Access•Frans Plank•Journal of Linguistics•1984

  • Canonical gender

    Open Access•Greville G Corbett, Sebastian Fedden•Journal of Linguistics•2015

  • The syntax of semantic agreement in English

    Peter W Smith•Journal of Linguistics•2017

  • Agreement, attraction and architectural opportunism

    Open Access•Carlos Acuña-Fariña, Juan Carlos Acuña-Fariña•Journal of Linguistics•2012

  • Gender Agreement Mismatches in Heritage Greek

    Open Access•Artemis Alexiadou, Vasiliki Rizou et al.•Languages•2020

  • Agreement Asymmetries with Adjectives in Heritage Greek

    Open Access•Artemis Alexiadou, Vasiliki Rizou et al.•Languages•2023

  • Radical Construction Grammar

    William Croft•Radical Construction Grammar•2001

  • Functions of nominal classification

    Open Access•Ellen Contini-Morava, Ellen Contini–morava et al.•Language Sciences•2013

  • On the diachrony of gender in Asia Minor Greek

    Petros Karatsareas•Language Sciences•2014

  • An empirical study of honorific mismatches in Korean

    Open Access•Sanghoun Song, Jae-Woong Choe et al.•Language Sciences•2019

  • When stones falls

    Open Access•Farzad Sharifian, Ahmad Reza Lotfi•Language Sciences•2007

  • A typology of northwestern Bantu gender systems

    Open Access•Francesca Di Garbo, Annemarie Verkerk•Linguistics•2022

  • Agreement Features

    Open Access•Stephen Wechsler•Language and Linguistics Compass•2009

  • It's all about gender

    Open Access•Dorit Ravid, Rachel Schiff•Morphology•2015

  • Splits, internal and external, as a window into the nature of features

    Open Access•Greville G Corbett•Morphology•2022

  • Gender assignment and gender agreement

    Open Access•Jenny Audring•Morphology•2008

  • Gender at the Edge

    Halldór Ármann Sigurðsson•Linguistic Inquiry•2019

  • First Conjunct Agreement

    Alan Munn•Linguistic Inquiry•1999

  • Interactions of Gender and Number Agreement

    Open Access•Zorica Puškar•Syntax•2018

  • The linguistics and psycholinguistics of agreement

    Open Access•Carlos Acuña-Fariña, Juan Carlos Acuña-Fariña•Lingua•2009

  • Gender and number agreement in comprehension in Spanish

    Open Access•J Carlos Acuña-Fariña, Carlos Acuña-Fariña et al.•Lingua•2014

  • Anaphora by pronouns

    Open Access•Bernd Wiese•Linguistics•1983

  • Dutch collective nouns and conceptual profiling

    Open Access•Frank Joosten, Gert De Sutter et al.•Linguistics•2007

  • The Amar mechanism

    Open Access•Mark L O Van De Velde•Linguistics•2022

  • The two faces of agreement

    Open Access•Alex Alsina, Boban Arsenijević•Language•2012

  • Number Agreement in British and American English

    Open Access•Kathryn Bock, Sally Butterfield et al.•Language•2006

  • Subject and Topic

    Charles N Li•Subject and Topic•2026

  • Grammatika sovremennogo russkogo literaturnogo jazyka

    Open Access•Alexander V Isačenko, Alexander Isačenko et al.•Language•1974

  • Agreement in Contemporary Standard Russian

    Roger W Phillips, Dina B Crockett•The Slavic and East European…•1977

  • The Russian Language since the Revolution

    Richard D Schupbach, Bernard Comrie et al.•The Russian Review•1979

  • The ergative

    Open Access•Bernard Comrie•Lingua•1973

  • Formal semantics of natural language

    Open Access•Edward L Keenan•Lingua•1978

Unique citing works98
Citations per year2,23
Citation span1982 - 2026 (45)
Citation velocitycurrent
Highly citedNo
Citation typesNeutral: 94

Tools

Open DOISci-Hub
Ethnos_APP • Open Source Project • MIT License • Frontend v2.0.0 • Privacy and Cookies • API Documentation: api.ethnos.app/docs • API Source Code: GitHub • DOI: 10.5281/zenodo.17049435 • Frontend Source Code: GitHub • DOI: 10.5281/zenodo.17050053 • cruz.rio.br • Expectantes Misericordiae