Skip to main content

ETHNOS_APP

Home • Search • Journals • List 0

Seeing from the South

Refocusing Urban Planning on the Globe's Central Urban Issues

Bibliographic Data

ID5828010
AuthorsWatson (0000-0001-9965-6891, University of Cape Town, corresponding author)
Year2009
Volume46
Issue11
Pages2259-2275
Publication date2009-09-15
Peer ReviewedYes
Open AccessYes
TypeARTICLE
VenueUrban Studies (JOURNAL)
Journal identifiersISSN: 0042-0980 • E-ISSN: 1360-063X
PublisherSAGE Publishing (PUBLISHER • US)
DOI10.1177/0042098009342598
OpenAlexW2152768411
LanguageEN
Citations received432
References cited39

Urban planning in many parts of the world reflects an increasing gap between current approaches and growing problems of poverty, inequality, informality, rapid urbanisation and spatial fragmentation, particularly (but not only) in cities of the global South. Given past dominance of the global North in shaping planning theory and practice, this article argues that a perspective from the global South can be useful in unsettling taken-for-granted assumptions about how planning addresses these issues. The article takes a first step in this direction by proposing a 'clash of rationalities', between techno-managerial and marketised systems of government administration, service provision and planning (in those parts of the world where these apply) and increasingly marginalised urban populations surviving largely under conditions of informality. It draws together theoretical resources beyond the boundaries of conventional planning theory to understand the nature of this conflict, and the nature of the 'interface' between those involved, where unpredictable encounter and contestation also open the possibility for exploring alternative approaches to planning

Dominance (genetics · Globe · Housing, Finance, and Neoliberalism · Urban and Rural Development Challenges · Urban Planning and Governance

  • From the Medellín miracle to the postponed city

    Open Access•Simon De Boeck, Jorge Pérez Jaramillo et al.•Cities•2026

  • Placemaking in an almost post-authoritarian Myanmar

    Open Access•Jayde Lin Roberts•Urban Studies•2026

  • Ambivalent attachments

    Open Access•Johannes Bhanye, Abraham R Matamanda et al.•Cities•2026

  • Making the Peri-Urban Citizen

    Open Access•Mussa S Muhoja•Urban Forum•2026

  • Bulldozer violence

    Open Access•Michal Hu, Mehebub Sahana•Progress in Human Geography•2026

  • Spatially differentiated urban growth in Indian megacities

    Open Access•Ratnadeep Dutta, Alexandre Pereira Santos•Habitat International•2026

  • Governing incompletion and incompleteness

    Open Access•Ziqiu Ren, Ziqiu id_orcid 0000-0001-5640-087X Ren et al.•Urban Studies•2026

  • Mapping urban underutilization in data-scarce global South Cities

    Open Access•Amal Saleh Mohammed Al hothaufi, Yike Hu et al.•Habitat International•2026

  • Co-production and informal settlement redevelopment

    Open Access•Gideon Abagna Azunre•Geoforum•2026

  • The Making of the Modern Iranian Capital

    Open Access•Elmira Jafari•Architecture and the Built…•2022

  • Local Activism in Urban Neighborhood Governance

    Open Access•Aya Elwageeh•Architecture and the Built…•2023

  • Financeirização, governança urbana e poder empresarial nas cidades brasileiras

    Open Access•Erick Omena De Melo•Cadernos Metrópole•2021

  • Práticas e processos de produção do espaço urbano

    Open Access•Lucas Amaral De Oliveira, Rafael De Aguiar Arantes•Estudos de Sociologia•2022

  • What Are the Land Delivery and Land Holding Mechanisms for African Informal Light Manufacturing Clusters

    Open Access•John Harris, John C Harris•Urban Forum•2019

  • Towards a Political Economy of Transportation Policy and Practice in Nairobi

    Open Access•Jacqueline M Klopp•Urban Forum•2012

  • Superdiversity and Urban Planning

    Simon Pemberton•Oxford Handbook of Superdiversity•2022

  • Spatial Consciousness

    Open Access•Daniel Galland, Marius Grønning•The Wiley Blackwell Encyclopedia…•2019

  • Informality

    Open Access•Ronita Bardhan, Arpita Jana et al.•The Wiley Blackwell Encyclopedia…•2019

  • Urban Planning

    Open Access•Magdalena Vicuña, Daniel Galland•The Wiley Blackwell Encyclopedia…•2018

  • Informal Settlers

    Open Access•Miguel A Martínez, Sonia Roitman•The Wiley Blackwell Encyclopedia…•2019

  • Apartheid

    Open Access•Thulisile N Mphambukeli•The Wiley Blackwell Encyclopedia…•2019

  • Global S outh/ N orth

    Open Access•Charlotte Lemanski•The Wiley Blackwell Encyclopedia…•2019

  • Les villes non occidentales

    Open Access•Gabriel Fauveau, Gabriel Fauveaud•Les villes non occidentales•2017

  • A Manifesto for the Just City

    Open Access•Roberto Rocco, Caroline Newton•A Manifesto for the Just City•2022

  • ‘The planned city sweeps the poor away…’

    Open Access•Watson, Vanessa Watson•Progress in Planning•2009

  • Co-production and collaboration in planning – The difference

    Watson, Vanessa Watson•Planning Theory & Practice•2014

  • Temporal regimes in heritage and urban planning

    Open Access•Joar Skrede•Time & Society•2026

  • Khulna

    Open Access•Tapan Kumar Dhar, Tapan Dhar et al.•Cities•2026

  • A “Field” Under Construction: The State of Planning in Latin America and the Southern Turn in Planning

    Daniel Galland, Pablo Elinbaum•disP - The Planning Review•2018

  • Beyond participation

    Open Access•Yang Yu, Chris Hamnett et al.•Journal of Rural Studies•2026

  • Ganz gewöhnliche Viertel

    Open Access•Raffael Beier•sub\urban zeitschrift für…•2020

  • “We are All Refugees”

    Efadul Huq, Faranak Miraftab•Planning Theory & Practice•2020

  • The politics of conservation planning

    Open Access•Elisabetta Pietrostefani, Nancy Holman•Progress in Planning•2021

  • Ontological locationalities and the pluriversal turn in urban planning

    Open Access•Paul Boniface Akaabre•Dialogues in Urban Research•2025

  • Homelessness in Southern California

    Open Access•Deyanira Nevarez Martinez•Radical Housing Journal•2021

  • The aspiration gap

    Open Access•Francisco Benita, Rafael Martinez•Social Sciences & Humanities Open•2026

  • Ghana’s informal economic sector in the face of a pandemic

    Open Access•Philipa Birago Akuoko, Vincent Aggrey et al.•Social Sciences & Humanities Open•2021

  • Planning Temporariness

    Open Access•Debayan Chatterjee, Khushboo Khanna•Urbanisation•2023

  • Evolution Characteristics and Influencing Factors of City Networks in China

    Open Access•Daming Xu, Weiliang Shen•ISPRS International Journal of…•2024

  • Reconciling multiple forms of flood risk knowledge and institutional responses

    Open Access•Denis Arinabo•International Journal of Disaster…•2023

  • Between the “Structural” and the “Everyday”

    Open Access•Nadine Appelhans, Sophie Schramm•Urban Planning•2023

  • “Emancipatory Circuits of Knowledge” for Urban Equality

    Open Access•Stephanie Butcher, Camila Cociña et al.•Urban Planning•2022

  • Temporal Dynamics of Power Distribution in Mobile Urban Co-Policies

    Open Access•Laura Sobral, Predrag Milić et al.•Urban Planning•2025

  • Socio-Spatial Segregation and the Spatial Structure of ‘Ordinary’ Activities in the Global South

    Open Access•Pablo Muñoz Unceta, Birgit Hausleitner et al.•Urban Planning•2020

  • “They Sold Us Illusions”

    Open Access•Raksha Vasudevan, Bjørn Sletto•Urban Planning•2020

  • National Urban Policies as Instruments for Global Urban Agendas Localization

    Open Access•Francesca Ferlicca•Urban Planning•2025

  • Informal and Community‐Based Agglomeration

    Open Access•Maria Daels, Carl Grodach•Urban Planning•2025

  • Temporal Entanglements, Fragmented Spaces

    Open Access•Argun Can, Lakshmi Priya Rajendran et al.•Urban Planning•2025

  • Integrating Emerging Design‐Build Technologies for Resilient Housing in the Navajo Nation

    Open Access•Sina Mostafavi, Asma Mehan et al.•Urban Planning•2025

  • Forms of (Collective) Life

    Camillo Boano•Architecture and Culture•2020

  • Vulnerability portrayals across climate risk discourses in Bhubaneswar

    Debadutta Parida, Agrawal•Climate and Development•2024

  • Exploring co-production in redirecting climate urbanism

    Anjali Karol Mohan, Gayathri Muraleedharan•Climate and Development•2025

  • Planning as polycentric

    Open Access•Emmanuel Frimpong Boamah•Planning Theory•2023

  • Critical Pragmatism, Bureaucratic Discretion, and the Making of an Urban Climate Program at Usaid

    Open Access•Hung Dao Vo•Planning Theory & Practice•2026

  • Learning from Mistakes

    Andrea Restrepo-Mieth•Planning Theory & Practice•2023

  • Genealogy of the gray spaces discourse in contemporary urban planning

    Ayda Kianfar, Mojtaba Rafieian•International Planning Studies•2025

  • Diary of a public space user

    Open Access•Raynhard Supra, Karina Landman•International Planning Studies•2025

  • Peri-urbanization in Sacaba, Bolivia

    Open Access•Paola J Ledo Espinoza•International Planning Studies•2021

  • Losing ground

    Neha Sunil Rane, Neha Rane et al.•International Planning Studies•2025

  • Exploring perspectives on sustainability and planning from national and local planners for effective practice

    Hsi‐chuan Wang•Local Environment•2023

  • Financing Housing Development in an Underdeveloped Financial Market

    Open Access•Godwin Kavaarpuo, Kwabena Mintah et al.•Housing Policy Debate•2024

  • Urban Discipline for Urban Policy

    Erlis Saputra, Eric Saputra et al.•Urban Policy and Research•2025

  • The public interest- schools of thought in planning

    Open Access•Ailin Sheydayi, Hashem Dadashpoor•Progress in Planning•2022

  • Informal adaptation to flooding in North Jakarta, Indonesia

    Open Access•Adam Madigliani Prana, Maria Rita Dionisio et al.•Progress in Planning•2024

  • Is green truly public? Unpacking green space dynamics, mechanisms of change, and recreational consequences amid Abuja’s urban growth

    Open Access•Shafi’u Adamu, Huang Yong et al.•Progress in Planning•2026

  • A research agenda for studying evidence-informed practice in urban planning

    Open Access•Du Toit, Amy Pieterse•Planning Practice and Research•2026

  • Unpacking the intricacies of urban development in Eswatini

    Mfaniseni Fana Sihlongonyane•Planning Perspectives•2021

  • The persistence and rise of master planning in urban Africa

    Open Access•Philip Harrison, Sylvia Croese•Planning Perspectives•2023

  • Tracing the degenerative regeneration

    Sahand Lotfi, Ali Asadinia et al.•Planning Perspectives•2025

  • Instrumental and normative perspectives on non-compliance with urban planning and development regulations in Ghana

    Open Access•Prince Aboagye Anokye, Stephen Biliyitorb Liwur et al.•Land Use Policy•2026

  • The Routledge Handbook of Planning Megacities in the Global South

    Enrique Silva•Journal of the American Planning…•2022

  • Trendy urbanists, innovation laboratories and best practices

    Open Access•Ryan Anders Whitney•Town Planning Review•2022

  • Planners and the new urban agenda

    Bruce Stiftel•Town Planning Review•2021

  • Olivier Sykes, David Shaw and Brian Webb, International Planning Studies

    Open Access•Giulio Verdini•Town Planning Review•2025

  • Building resilience in urban slums

    Open Access•Z R M Abdullah Kaiser, Afzal Hossain Sakil et al.•Discover Global Society•2025

  • Transforming underutilized urban spaces into green infrastructure in Global South cities

    Open Access•Amal Saleh Mohammed Al hothaufi, Yike Hu et al.•Sustainable Cities and Society•2025

  • Do informal settlements contribute to sprawl in Sub-Saharan African cities

    Open Access•Tamilwai J Kolowa, Michiel N Daams et al.•Sustainable Cities and Society•2024

  • Resonating the ‘culture’ debate in urban planning

    Open Access•Patrick Brandful Cobbinah, Michael Osei Asibey et al.•City Culture and Society•2020

  • The Role of Spatial Development Frameworks in Transformation of the eThekwini Municipality, KwaZulu-Natal, South Africa

    Open Access•Godfrey Musvoto, Gill Lincoln et al.•Urban Forum•2016

  • Instagrammers, Urban Renewal and the Johannesburg Inner City

    Open Access•Gijsbert Hoogendoorn, James Gregory et al.•Urban Forum•2016

  • Integral Theory

    Open Access•Ruth Massey•Urban Forum•2015

  • Persist or Perish. The Dynamics of Irrigated Agriculture in Urbanising Dar es Salaam, Tanzania

    Open Access•Matthijs T Wessels, Shaaban M Mgana•Urban Forum•2024

  • Mapping Hope

    Open Access•John Harris, John C Harris et al.•Urban Forum•2019

  • On the Liberal Moral Project of Planning in South Africa

    Open Access•Tanja Winkler•Urban Forum•2011

  • Towards Facilitative and Pro-poor Land-Use Management in South African Urban Areas

    Open Access•Tristan Görgens, Stuart Paul Denoon-Stevens et al.•Urban Forum•2013

  • Juxtacity

    Open Access•Amanda Hammar, Marianne Millstein•Urban Forum•2020

  • From Shacks to Skyscrapers

    Open Access•Lena Fält•Urban Forum•2016

  • Why Do Planners Think That Planning Has Failed Post-Apartheid? The Case of eThekwini Municipality, Durban, South Africa

    Open Access•Sogen Moodley•Urban Forum•2019

  • The Darker Side of Muddling Through

    Open Access•Anele Horn•Urban Forum•2020

  • Urbanisation of Hope or Despair? Urban Planning Dilemma in Ghana

    Open Access•Patrick Brandful Cobbinah, Michael Poku‐boansi et al.•Urban Forum•2016

  • (W)Escaping the Challenges of the City

    Open Access•Liza Rose Cirolia•Urban Forum•2014

  • Quality Housing

    Open Access•Uyi Ezeanah•Urban Forum•2021

  • Spluma, Zoning and Effective Land Use Management in South Africa

    Open Access•Verna Nel•Urban Forum•2016

  • Insurgency and Juxtacity in the Age of Urban Divides

    Open Access•Faranak Miraftab•Urban Forum•2020

  • Official Risks and Everyday Disasters

    Open Access•Phillip Garjay Innis•Urban Forum•2023

  • Place and Function of African Cities in the Global Urban Network

    Open Access•Victor Onyebueke, Victor Udemezue Onyebueke•Urban Forum•2011

  • Urban Informality as a Site of Critical Analysis

    Open Access•Nicola Banks, Melanie Lombard et al.•The Journal of Development Studies•2020

  • At the Borderlands of Informal Practices of the State

    Margot Rubin•The Journal of Development Studies•2018

  • The Delhi Bias

    Open Access•N P Narayanan•Singapore Journal of Tropical…•2020

  • Provincializing urban appropriation

    Open Access•Mary Lawhon, Joseph Pierce et al.•Singapore Journal of Tropical…•2018

  • Rationality and power

    Bent Flyvbjerg•Rationality and power•1998

  • Collaborative Planning

    Open Access•Patsy Healey•Collaborative Planning•1997

  • Geopolitics and the Post‐Colonial

    Open Access•David Slater•Geopolitics and the Post-Colonial•2004

  • Ordinary Cities

    Jennifer Robinson, Jennifer G Robinson et al.•Ordinary Cities•2013

  • Planning and Social Control

    Open Access•Oren Yiftachel•Journal of Planning Literature•1998

  • Powers of Freedom

    Open Access•Nikolas Rose, Nikolas S Rose•Powers of Freedom•1999

  • Whose Reality Counts

    Robert Chamber, Robert Chambers•Whose Reality Counts•1997

  • Neo-liberalism and the End of Liberal Democracy

    Wendy Brown•Theory & Event•2003

  • Deep Difference

    Open Access•Watson•Planning Theory•2006

  • Essay

    Open Access•Oren Yiftachel•Planning Theory•2006

  • The Usefulness of Normative Planning Theories in the Context of Sub-Saharan Africa

    Open Access•Watson•Planning Theory•2002

  • The control of Discretion

    Open Access•Philip Booth•Planning Theory•2007

  • Consensus Building

    Open Access•Judith E Innes•Planning Theory•2004

  • Globalization and social exclusion in cities

    Open Access•Jo Beall•Environment and Urbanization•2002

  • Do We Learn from Planning Practice

    Open Access•Watson•Journal of Planning Education and…•2002

  • Planning in contemporary Africa

    Open Access•Emmanuel Nkurunziza•Habitat International•2005

  • Urbanization by implosion

    Open Access•Mohammad A Qadeer•Habitat International•2004

  • Paradigms lost, paradigms regained? Development studies in the twenty-first century

    Frans J Schuurman•Third World Quarterly•2000

  • Toronto Inc? Planning the Competitive City in the New Toronto

    Open Access•Stefan Kipfer, Roger Keil•Antipode•2002

  • On the Edge of Reason

    Open Access•Philip Harrison•Urban Studies•2006

  • Reframing Justice in a Globalizing World

    Nancy Fraser•New left review•2005

  • Agon'izing Over Consensus

    Open Access•Jack Hillier•Planning Theory•2003

  • Governing Cities

    Open Access•Thomas Osborne, Nikolas Rose•Environment and Planning D…•1999

  • Anthropology, Development and Modernities

    Alberto Arce, Norman Long•Anthropology, Development and…•2003

  • Conflicting rationalities

    Watson, Vanessa Watson•Planning Theory & Practice•2003

  • For the City Yet to Come

    Abdoumaliq Simone•For the City yet to Come•2004

  • Seeing the State

    Open Access•Stuart Corbridge, Glyn Williams et al.•Seeing the State•2005

  • Urban Informality

    Ananya Roy•Journal of the American Planning…•2005

  • Evaluating participatory development

    Glyn Williams•Third World Quarterly•2004

  • After post-development

    Jan Nederveen Pieterse•Third World Quarterly•2000

  • Beyond the Third World

    Arturo Escobar•Third World Quarterly•2004

  • Development

    K G Nustad•Third World Quarterly•2001

  • Spatial Phenomenotechnics

    Open Access•Thomas Osborne, Nikolas Rose•Environment and Planning D…•2004

  • Spatial rationalities

    Margo Huxley•Social & Cultural Geography•2006

  • Seeing Like a State

    James C Scott•Seeing Like a State•2017

Unique citing works432
Citations per year25,41
Citation span2009 - 2026 (18)
Citation velocitycurrent
Highly citedYes
Citation typesNeutral: 417

Tools

Open DOISci-Hub
Ethnos_APP • Open Source Project • MIT License • Frontend v2.0.0 • Privacy and Cookies • API Documentation: api.ethnos.app/docs • API Source Code: GitHub • DOI: 10.5281/zenodo.17049435 • Frontend Source Code: GitHub • DOI: 10.5281/zenodo.17050053 • cruz.rio.br • Expectantes Misericordiae