Skip to main content

ETHNOS_APP

Home • Search • Journals • List 0

Call It Consumption! Re-Conceptualizing Ecotourism as Consumption and Consumptive

Bibliographic Data

ID5877490
AuthorsZoe A Meletis (0000-0003-1631-6707, Duke University), Lisa M Campbell (0000-0001-8731-3699, Duke University)
Year2007
Volume1
Issue4
Pages850-870
Publication date2007-07-01
Peer ReviewedYes
Open AccessYes
TypeARTICLE
VenueGeography Compass (JOURNAL)
Journal identifiersISSN: 1749-8198 • E-ISSN: 1749-8198
PublisherWiley (PUBLISHER • GB)
DOI10.1111/j.1749-8198.2007.00048.x
OpenAlexW2160068530
LanguageEN
Citations received28
References cited68

Labeling ecotourism as 'non-consumptive' and contrasting it with direct uses of wildlife through activities such as hunting is common practice among organizations and academics primarily concerned with conservation. We interrogate this binary opposition by questioning the assumptions underlying it, namely that 'the direct consumption of wildlife' (i) does not occur in ecotourism; (ii) is incompatible with ecotourism; (iii) is the primary concern; and (iv) is inferior to ecotourism as both a conservation and development strategy. Based on a review of the relevant theoretical and case-study based literature, as well as our own research, we argue that categorizing ecotourism as 'non-consumptive' is not only inaccurate, but also has consequences for both environments and people. We suggest ways in which ecotourism can be re-conceptualized in order to better achieve its goals of conserving both nature and culture, and of contributing to both conservation and development

Archaeology · Business · Economics · Ecotourism · Environmental ethics · Environmental planning · Environmental resource management · Geography · Political science · Politics · Social science · Sociology · Tourism · Wildlife · Wildlife conservation · Diverse Aspects of Tourism Research · Environmental Education and Sustainability · Law · Tourism, Volunteerism, and Development · Ecology

  • Ecological Spatial Regulation in China

    Open Access•Dan Lin, Lin Dan•Sociology and Anthropology•2016

  • Governança ambiental e turismo

    Open Access•Monica De Nazaré Ferreira De Araujo, Ligia Terezinha Lopes Simonian•PASOS Revista de Turismo y…•2016

  • The whale watched and whaled

    Open Access•B E Singleton•Journal of Political Ecology•2021

  • Eco-tourism, Conservancies and Sustainable Development

    Open Access•Victor N Muzvidziwa•Journal of Human Ecology•2013

  • Geo-political genetics

    Open Access•Lisa M Campbell, Matthew H Godfrey•Geoforum•2010

  • Situating the wildlife spectacle

    Olga Yudina, Bryan S R Grimwood•Journal of Sustainable Tourism•2015

  • The potential for expansion of whale shark ( Rhincodon typus ) tourism in St. Helena

    Joshua Drew, Kenickie Andrews et al.•Journal of Ecotourism•2022

  • Tourism and the treadmill of production

    Lauren Griffin, Gregory Pavela et al.•Environmental Sociology•2015

  • Capital, Subsistence, and Lakeside Violence

    Open Access•Harold A Perkins•Human Geography•2010

  • Using qualitative models to define sustainable management for the commons in data poor conditions

    Open Access•Francesca Mancini, George M Coghill et al.•Environmental Science & Policy•2016

  • Framing a Supermantra

    B E Singleton•Forum for Development Studies•2016

  • Last-chance tourism

    Harvey Lemelin, J Dawson et al.•Current Issues in Tourism•2010

  • Destructive creation

    Open Access•Bram Büscher, Ronald Fletcher et al.•Journal of Sustainable Tourism•2016

  • Ecotourism for Conservation

    Open Access•Amanda L Stronza, Amanda Stronza et al.•Annual Review of Environment and…•2019

  • Tourists and turtles

    Open Access•ZoeA Meletis, EmmaC Harrison•Conservation and Society•2010

  • Studying Sea Turtle Conservation and Learning about the World

    Open Access•Lisa M Campbell, LisaM Campbell•Conservation and Society•2010

  • Ecotourism and the development of indigenous communities

    Open Access•Jessica Coria, Enrique Calfucura•Ecological Economics•2012

  • Monitoring tourists’ specialisation and implementing adaptive governance is necessary to avoid failure of the wildlife tourism commons

    Open Access•Francesca Mancini, Ben Leyshon et al.•Tourism Management•2020

  • Ethical tourism and development

    Jim Butcher•Tourism Recreation Research•2015

  • Benevolent and Benign? Using Environmental Justice to Investigate Waste‐related Impacts of Ecotourism in Destination Communities

    Open Access•Zoe A Meletis, Lisa M Campbell•Antipode•2009

  • Wildlife as a tourism resource in Nunavut

    Open Access•Laine Chanteloup•Polar Record•2013

  • Dolphin-Safe Tuna from California to Thailand

    Ian G Baird, Noah Quastel•Annals of the Association of…•2011

  • Border Crossings

    Gabriela Valdivia, W Wolford et al.•Annals of the Association of…•2014

  • Commoditizing the safari and making space for conflict

    Open Access•Bilal Butt•Political Geography•2012

  • The Park Multiple

    Open Access•W Van Engelen, Annet Pauwelussen et al.•Science Technology & Human Values•2025

  • The whale multiple

    Open Access•Myung-Ae Choi, Myung‐Ae Choi•Environment and Planning A…•2017

  • Reliving off The Swamp

    Open Access•Adam Keul•Geographical Review•2014

  • Trouble in Paradise

    Lauren Griffin•Capitalism Nature Socialism•2016

  • The green republic

    Sterling Evans•The green republic•1999

  • Volunteer tourism

    S Wearing•Volunteer Tourism•2001

  • Sustainable Tourism Development in Developing Countries

    Gössling, Stefan Gößling•Journal of Sustainable Tourism•2000

  • A Decommodified Experience? Exploring Aesthetic, Economic and Ethical Values for Volunteer Ecotourism in Costa Rica

    Noella J Gray, Lisa M Campbell•Journal of Sustainable Tourism•2007

  • African Wildlife & Livelihoods

    David Hulme, Marshall Murphree•African Wildlife & Livelihoods•2001

  • Tourism, ecotourism, and protected areas

    Héctor Ceballos-Lascurain•Tourism, ecotourism, and…•1996

  • The Moralisation of Tourism

    Jim Butcher•Moralisation of Tourism•2005

  • From Nature Tourism to Ecotourism? The Case of the Ngorongoro Conservation Area, Tanzania

    Susan Charnley•Human Organization•2005

  • Conservation and Economic Benefits of Wildlife-Based Marine Tourism

    Clevo Wilson, Clem Tisdell•Human Dimensions of Wildlife•2003

  • Ecological footprint analysis as a tool to assess tourism sustainability

    Open Access•Gössling, Stefan Gößling et al.•Ecological Economics•2002

  • Dialectics of Authentication

    Irena Ateljevic, Stephen Doorne•Journal of Tourism and Cultural…•2005

  • Ecological footprints and appropriated carrying capacity

    Open Access•William E Rees•Environment and Urbanization•1992

  • Visitor Attitudes Toward a Modified Natural Attraction

    Mike Hughes, Angus Morrison-Saunders•Society & Natural Resources•2003

  • Environmental initiatives in Costa Rica

    Lori Ann Thrupp•Society & Natural Resources•1990

  • Representation and images of people, place and nature in grenada's tourism

    Velvet Nelson•Geografiska Annaler Series B…•2005

  • Development narratives, or making the best of blueprint development

    Open Access•Emma Roe, Emery M Roe•World Development•1991

  • Ecotourism and the empowerment of local communities

    Open Access•R Scheyvens•Tourism Management•1999

  • Managing ecotourism

    Open Access•Stephen Boyd, Stephen W Boyd et al.•Tourism Management•1996

  • Sea turtles as a non-consumptive tourism resource especially in Australia

    Open Access•Clevo Wilson, Clem Tisdell•Tourism Management•2001

  • Ecotourism

    Open Access•Sheryl Ross, G Wall•Tourism Management•1999

  • Western environmental values and nature-based tourism in Kenya

    Open Access•John S Akama•Tourism Management•1996

  • Tourism, Terrorism And Turmoil In Nepal

    Open Access•Keshav Bhattarai, Dennis Conway et al.•Annals of Tourism Research•2005

  • Ecotourism Questioned

    Open Access•Kreg Lindberg, Jeremy Enriquez et al.•Annals of Tourism Research•1996

  • Ecotourism in rural developing communities

    Open Access•Lisa M Campbell•Annals of Tourism Research•1999

  • The gaze, spectacle and ecotourism

    Open Access•Chris Ryan, Karen Hughes et al.•Annals of Tourism Research•2000

  • Ecotourism and sustainable development

    Open Access•Abigail Rome•Annals of Tourism Research•2000

  • Tourist perception of environmental impact

    Open Access•Melinda Hillery, Blair E Nancarrow et al.•Annals of Tourism Research•2001

  • Magnitude of ecotourism in Costa Rica and Kenya

    Open Access•David B Weaver•Annals of Tourism Research•1999

  • Comprehensive and minimalist dimensions of ecotourism

    Open Access•David B Weaver•Annals of Tourism Research•2005

  • An ecotourism assessment of Tortuguero, Costa Rica

    Open Access•David N B Lee, David J Snepenger•Annals of Tourism Research•1992

  • Ecotourism versus tourism in a Thai national park

    Open Access•Glen T Hvenegaard, Philip Dearden•Annals of Tourism Research•1998

  • Nature tourism and rural development in Tortuguero

    Open Access•Susan E Place•Annals of Tourism Research•1991

  • Consuming narratives

    Open Access•Raymond L Bryant, Michael K Goodman•Transactions of the Institute of…•2004

  • Consuming Ethics

    Open Access•Clive Barnett, Paul Cloke et al.•Antipode•2005

  • The tourist

    Dean Maccannell•The tourist•1999

  • Ethics in Political Ecology

    Open Access•Raymond L Bryant, Lucy Jarosz•Political Geography•2004

  • Geography and Ethics

    Open Access•Jeff Popke•Progress in Human Geography•2006

  • Performing tourism, staging tourism

    Open Access•T Edensor•Tourist Studies•2001

  • Conservation Narratives in Costa Rica

    Open Access•Lisa M Campbell•Development and Change•2002

  • Tourism and Indigenous Peoples

    Richard J Butler, Richard Butler et al.•Tourism and Indigenous Peoples•2007

  • The Rise of Yuppie Coffees and the Reimagination of Class in the United States

    Open Access•William Roseberry•American Anthropologist•1996

  • Anthropology of Tourism

    Amanda Stronza•Annual Review of Anthropology•2001

  • Bursting the Bubble

    Open Access•James G Carrier, Donald Macleod et al.•Journal of the Royal Anthropologica…•2005

  • Ecotourism and Authenticity

    Paige West, James G Carrier•Current Anthropology•2004

  • Staged Authenticity

    Dean Maccannell•American Journal of Sociology•1973

  • Balancing Conservation with Development in Small-Scale Fisheries

    Open Access•Emily Harriet Young•Human Ecology•1999

Unique citing works28
Citations per year1,65
Citation span2009 - 2025 (17)
Citation velocityrecent
Highly citedNo
Citation typesNeutral: 23

Tools

Open DOISci-Hub
Ethnos_APP • Open Source Project • MIT License • Frontend v2.0.0 • Privacy and Cookies • API Documentation: api.ethnos.app/docs • API Source Code: GitHub • DOI: 10.5281/zenodo.17049435 • Frontend Source Code: GitHub • DOI: 10.5281/zenodo.17050053 • cruz.rio.br • Expectantes Misericordiae