The Politics of Symbolic Laws

Sex offender residence restrictions are largely symbolic laws that address constituent demands to do something about sex crimes without actually reducing sex offenses. While the majority of US states have implemented such restrictions, this exploratory study examines three states that have resisted the allure of these symbolic laws. Using data from state government archives, we analyze expressive and instrumental rationales for rejecting residence restrictions to explore what facilitates the failure of a symbolic law. We find that while supporters and opponents both made largely instrumental arguments, opponents framed their instrumental arguments in expressive terms. Legislators’ policy positions, reliance on empirical evidence, and testimony from bureaucrats also contributed to the failure of residence restrictions in these states. Our findings help explain why empirically ineffective sex offender laws appeal to the public and politicians, how these laws might be scaled back, and how symbolic laws may lose their power in some contexts

Appeal · Criminology · Government (linguistics · Political science · Politics · Power (physics · Residence · Resistance (ecology · Sociology · State (computer science · The Symbolic · Computer Science · Crime Patterns and Interventions · Criminal Justice and Corrections Analysis · Law · Psychology · Psychopathy, Forensic Psychiatry, Sexual Offending

• Journal of Sociology and Social Welfare Vol. 48, No. 1

  Wendy Murphy, J M Carroll et al.•The Journal of Sociology & Social…•2021

  Add to list

• Changing Views of Sex Offender Policies

  Joshua J Reynolds, Victoria Estrada-Reynolds•Basic and Applied Social Psychology•2026

  Add to list

• Narratives in Sex Offender Management Laws

  Mauricio P Yabar•The Journal of Sociology & Social…•2021

  Add to list

• Breaking the Pendulum

  Philip Goodman, Joshua Page et al.•Breaking the Pendulum•2017

  Add to list

• The Politics of Rights

  Stuart A Scheingold, Stuart Scheingold•The politics of rights•2004

  Add to list

• The Culture of Control

  David Garland•Culture of Control•2001

  Add to list

• The Impact of Sex Offender Residence Restrictions

  Open Access•Jill S Levenson, Leo P Cotter•International Journal of Offender…•2005

  Add to list

• Innovation and Diffusion Models in Policy Research

  Frances Stokes Berry, William D Berry•Theories of the Policy Process•2018

  Add to list

• The Politics of Imprisonment

  Vanessa Barker•The politics of imprisonment•2009

  Add to list

• Advancing Criminology and Criminal Justice Policy

  Julie Mestre, Julie Mestre Brancale et al.•Advancing Criminology and…•2016

  Add to list

• Protecting Our Kids

  Emily Horowitz•Protecting Our Kids•2015

  Add to list

• Punishment and DemocracyThree Strikes and You're Out in California

  Franklin E Zimring, Gordon Hawkins et al.•Punishment and Democracy•2003

  Add to list

• The contexts and politics of evidence-based sex offender policy

  Open Access•Chrysanthi S Leon•Criminology & Public Policy•2011

  Add to list

• Residence restriction buffer zones and the banishment of sex offenders

  Open Access•Kristen M Zgoba•Criminology & Public Policy•2011

  Add to list

• Evidence of Ineffectiveness

  Open Access•Richard Tewksbury•Criminology & Public Policy•2014

  Add to list

• Policy implications of sex offender residence restrictions laws

  Open Access•Richard Tewksbury•Criminology & Public Policy•2011

  Add to list

• The need to debate the fate of sex offender community notification laws

  Open Access•Lisa L Sample•Criminology & Public Policy•2011

  Add to list

• What is smart sex offender policy

  Open Access•Karen J Terry•Criminology & Public Policy•2011

  Add to list

• Residence restrictions

  Open Access•Keri B Burchfield•Criminology & Public Policy•2011

  Add to list

• Sex offender policies in an era of zero tolerance

  Open Access•Jill S Levenson•Criminology & Public Policy•2011

  Add to list

• The policy implications of residence restrictions on sex offender housing in Upstate NY

  Open Access•Kelly M Socia•Criminology & Public Policy•2011

  Add to list

• Residence Restrictions Are Ineffective, Inefficient, and Inadequate

  Open Access•Kelly M Socia•Criminology & Public Policy•2014

  Add to list

• Sex Offender Residency Restrictions

  Open Access•Elizabeth Ehrhardt Mustaine•Criminology & Public Policy•2014

  Add to list

• Place a moratorium on the passage of sex offender residence restriction laws

  Open Access•J C Barnes•Criminology & Public Policy•2011

  Add to list

• The Effect and Implications of Sex Offender Residence Restrictions

  Open Access•Beth M Huebner, Kimberly R Kras et al.•Criminology & Public Policy•2014

  Add to list

• Affective Versus Effective Justice

  Open Access•Arie Freiberg•Punishment & Society•2001

  Add to list

• Public Protection, Partnership and Risk Penality

  Open Access•Hazel Kemshall, Mike Maguire•Punishment & Society•2001

  Add to list

• Mass probation

  Open Access•Michelle S Phelps•Punishment & Society•2016

  Add to list

• Pedophiles and Cyber-predators as Contaminating Forces

  Open Access•Mona Lynch•Law & Social Inquiry•2002

  Add to list

• Megan's Law

  Open Access•Jonathan Simon•Law & Social Inquiry•2000

  Add to list

• Making Meaning of Megan's Law

  Open Access•Rose Corrigan•Law & Social Inquiry•2006

  Add to list

• Constructing Hysteria

  Open Access•Monica Williams•Law & Social Inquiry•2016

  Add to list

• Moral Panic

  Joanne Meyerowitz, Philip Jenkins•Journal of American History•1999

  Add to list

• Interpreting the U.S. Human Trafficking Debate Through the Lens of Symbolic Politics

  Open Access•Barbara Ann Stolz•Law & Policy•2007

  Add to list

• Failures

  Open Access•Craig Volden•State Politics & Policy Quarterly•2016

  Add to list

• Risk‐Based Policy Narratives

  Open Access•Andrea Lawlor, Deserai A Crow•Policy Studies Journal•2018

  Add to list

• Measuring Citizen and Government Ideology in the American States, 1960-93

  William D Berry, Evan J Ringquist et al.•American Journal of Political…•1998

  Add to list

• The implementation of county residence restrictions in New York

  Kelly M Socia•Psychology Public Policy and Law•2012

  Add to list

• The Sex Offender Housing Dilemma

  Open Access•R Allen Hays•Contemporary Sociology A Journal…•2019

  Add to list

• Symbolic Crusade

  Dieter T Hessel, Dieter Hessel et al.•Review of Religious Research•1964

  Add to list

• Symbol and Substance

  Open Access•John R Sutton•Law & Society Review•2013

  Add to list

• Transforming Symbolic Law into Organizational Action

  Ryken Grattet, Jenne et al.•Social Forces•2008

  Add to list