Aristotle, Equity, and Democracy

Aristotelian equity (epieikeia) has often been relegated to scholarly discussions of retributive justice. Recently, however, political theorists have recast equity as the virtue of a sympathetic democratic citizen. I build on this literature by offering a more precise explanation of equity’s internal structure and political significance. In particular, I reveal equity’s deliberative dimension. For Aristotle, equitable citizens, statesmen, and legislators correct or go beyond the law, as appropriate, not only when they render retrospective judgments about matters of punishment or distribution, but also when they deliberate about future-oriented questions of legislation or political action. In addition, I show, more concretely, the role of equity in democratic citizenship. Drawing upon the Aristotelian Constitution of the Athenians, I argue that the Athenian demos exemplified equity when it brought about the reconciliation and the amnesty of 403 BC. Attention to this episode clarifies the conceptual linkages between equity, deliberation, sympathy, and democracy

Amnesty · Constitution · Deliberation · Democracy · Economics · Equity (law · Law and economics · Political science · Politics · Positive economics · Sociology · Virtue · American Constitutional Law and Politics · Law · Legal principles and applications · Political Philosophy and Ethics

• From Tyrannicide to Revolution

  Open Access•Jordan Jochim•American Political Science Review•2020

  Add to list