Skip to main content

ETHNOS_APP

Home • Search • Journals • List 0

Circular Dynamics of International Norms and Institutions

Localizations Beyond Their Original Contexts

Bibliographic Data

ID6147013
AuthorsLisbeth Zimmermann (0000-0003-1323-8344, Goethe University Frankfurt, corresponding author)
Year2024
Volume5
Issue1
Publication date2024-12-27
Peer ReviewedYes
Open AccessYes
TypeARTICLE
VenueGlobal Studies Quarterly (JOURNAL)
Journal identifiersISSN: 2634-3797 • E-ISSN: 2634-3797
PublisherOxford University Press (OUP) (PUBLISHER)
DOI10.1093/isagsq/ksaf013
OpenAlexW4409030757
LanguageEN
Citations received4
References cited81

The dynamics of international norms and institutional models are often described as either top-down diffusion and localization or as bottom-up resistance and alternative norm-making. However, both frameworks have their limitations in explaining the complex patterns of normative and institutional change, highlighting the need for a new perspective. This article argues for a more circular understanding of these dynamics. Localizations often spread laterally into other local contexts, and upward into international ones, shaping normative and institutional change. The article illustrates these dynamics based on two cases of impunity-related norms and institutions in Latin America. This perspective not only complements existing frameworks on the dynamics of norms and institutions but also points to a research agenda that aims to answer the question of when and how initial localizations can have impacts beyond their original context

Dynamics (music · Pedagogy · Political science · Sociology · Global Peace and Security Dynamics · International Development and Aid · Peacebuilding and International Security

  • A difficult change

    Ali Baydarol•Journal of Southeast European and…•2026

  • Relational city actorness in global migration governance

    Open Access•Nele Thomann•Urban Studies•2026

  • The EU as a green normative power? Unpacking dynamics of norm diffusion in forest biodiversity politics

    Open Access•Antonio Basilicata, Mireia Pecurul-Botines et al.•Policy Sciences•2026

  • Localization in World Politics

    Open Access•Adam Kochański, Emily Scott et al.•Global Studies Quarterly•2024

  • International Intervention Instruments against Corruption in Central America

    Open Access•Laura Zamudio-González•International Intervention…•2020

  • Transnational Legal Orders

    Open Access•Terence C Halliday, Gregory Shaffer•Transnational Legal Orders•2015

  • The Persistent Power of Human Rights

    Open Access•Thomas Risse, Stephen C Ropp et al.•Persistent Power of Human Rights•2013

  • International Socialization in Europe

    Open Access•Frank Schimmelfennig, Stefan Engert et al.•International Socialization in…•2006

  • Whose Ideas Matter?

    Atanu Acharya, Amitav Acharya•Whose Ideas Matter?•2009

  • Global Governance and Local Peace

    Susanna P Campbell•Global Governance and Local Peace•2018

  • Global Norms with a Local Face

    Open Access•Lisbeth Zimmermann•Global Norms with a Local Face•2017

  • Translating International Women's Rights

    Open Access•Susanne Zwingel•Translating International Women's…•2016

  • Mobilizing for Human Rights

    Open Access•Beth A Simmons•Mobilizing for Human Rights•2009

  • The Power of Human Rights

    Open Access•Steve C Ropp, Thomas Risse-Kappen et al.•Power of Human Rights•1999

  • Who Is the Citizen in Citizen Security

    Open Access•R G Emerson•Latin American Research Review•2020

  • Understanding Everyday Peace in Cambodia

    Open Access•Sungyong Lee•Journal of Peacebuilding &…•2020

  • The R2P and Norm Diffusion

    Atanu Acharya•Global Responsibility to Protect•2013

  • Lost in Translation? Civil Society, Faith-Based Organizations and the Negotiation of International Norms

    Aaron P Boesenecker, Leslie Vinjamuri•International Journal of…•2011

  • How to Translate ‘Good Governance’ into Tajik? An American Good Governance Fund and Norm Localisation in Tajikistan

    Karolina Kluczewska•Journal of Intervention and…•2019

  • Same Same or Different? Norm Diffusion Between Resistance, Compliance, and Localization in Post-conflict States

    Open Access•Lisbeth Zimmermann•International Studies Perspectives•2014

  • What Isn't a Norm? Redefining the Conceptual Boundaries of “Norms” in the Human Rights Literature

    Open Access•Michelle Jurkovich•International Studies Review•2019

  • Diffusion, contestation and localisation in post-war states

    Open Access•Simone Tholen, Lisa Groß•Journal of International…•2015

  • Revisiting transnational actors from a spatial perspective

    Antje Dietze, Katja Naumann•European Review of History Revue…•2018

  • Fragmented local normative orders, unresolved localizations, and the contesting of gender equality norms in Turkey

    Hüsrev Tabak, Seven Erdogan et al.•Asian Journal of Women s Studies•2022

  • South Korea's Embrace of Good Donorship Norms

    Open Access•Seok Joon Kim, David Connolly•Pacific Focus•2020

  • Varieties of localization

    Open Access•Thomas Rudolf Eimer, Susanne Lütz et al.•Review of International Political…•2016

  • Localization as Resistance

    Open Access•David Capie•Security Dialogue•2008

  • Resiliency dynamics of norm clusters

    Open Access•Jeffrey S Lantis, Carmen Wunderlich•Review of International Studies•2018

  • Appropriation and the dualism of human rights

    Mathias Großklaus•Third World Quarterly•2015

  • Understanding Policy Transfer

    Open Access•Mark Evans, J S Davies et al.•Public Administration•1999

  • Decoupling Values from Action

    Open Access•L Swi, Liam Swiss•International Journal of…•2009

  • The Promise of Hybrid Courts

    Open Access•Laura A Dickinson, Laura Dickinson•American Journal of International…•2003

  • Circuits, the everyday and international relations

    Open Access•Roger Mac Ginty•Cooperation and Conflict•2019

  • From Europeanisation to Diffusion

    Tanja A Börzel, Thomas Risse•West European Politics•2011

  • Conceptualizing norm diffusion and norm contestation in the European neighbourhood

    Open Access•Assem Dandashly, Gergana Noutcheva•Democratization•2022

  • Renegotiating ‘law and order

    Rachel Sieder•Democratization•2003

  • Activists beyond borders

    Margaret E Keck•Activists beyond borders•1998

  • Criminalizing Violence against Women in Politics

    Open Access•Juliana Restrepo Sanín•Politics & Gender•2022

  • Rhetorical Adaptation and Resistance to International Norms

    Open Access•Jennifer M Dixon•Perspectives on Politics•2017

  • Norm Subsidiarity and Regional Orders

    Open Access•Atanu Acharya, Amitav Acharya•International Studies Quarterly•2011

  • Norm Contestation and Normative Transformation in Global Peacebuilding Order(s)

    Open Access•Oliver Jütersonke, Kazushige Kobayashi et al.•International Studies Quarterly•2021

  • The Co-Constitution of Order

    Open Access•Marcos Tourinho•International Organization•2021

  • Introduction

    Beth A Simmons, Frank Dobbins et al.•International Organization•2006

  • International Norm Dynamics and Political Change

    Open Access•Martha Finnemore, Kathryn Sikkink•International Organization•1998

  • Global prohibition regimes

    Open Access•Ethan A Nadelmann•International Organization•1990

  • Lost in Translation? Nonstate Actors and the Transnational Movement of Procedural Law

    Open Access•Benjamin Brake, Peter J Katzenstein•International Organization•2013

  • Learning from Abroad

    Open Access•David P Dolowitz, D Marsh•Governance•2000

  • Becoming Global Governors

    Open Access•Matthias Hofferberth, Daniel Lambach•Global Studies Quarterly•2022

  • Where is the local? Critical localism and peacebuilding

    Roger Mac Ginty•Third World Quarterly•2015

  • How Do Norms Travel? Theorizing International Women's Rights in Transnational Perspective1

    Open Access•Susanne Zwingel•International Studies Quarterly•2011

  • Power in International Politics

    Michael Barnett, Raymond Duvall•International Organization•2005

  • Peasant activism and the rise of food sovereignty

    Open Access•Richard Dunford•European Journal of International…•2015

  • How Ideas Spread

    Atanu Acharya, Amitav Acharya•International Organization•2004

  • The agency of the governed in transfer and diffusion studies

    Anke Draude•Third World Thematics A TWQ Journal•2017

  • Affectedness in international institutions

    Jan Sändig, Jochen Von Bernstorff et al.•Third World Thematics A TWQ Journal•2018

  • Unlocking the agency of the governed

    Lisbeth Zimmermann, Nicole Deitelhoff et al.•Third World Thematics A TWQ Journal•2017

  • Affectedness, empowerment and norm contestation - children and young people as social agents in international politics

    Open Access•Anna Holzscheiter•Third World Thematics A TWQ Journal•2018

  • Global Norm Diffusion in East Asia

    Open Access•Jochen Prantl, Ryoko Nakano•International Relations•2011

  • Realising the Right of Return

    Open Access•Megan Bradley•Geopolitics•2023

  • Changing Global Norms through Reactive Diffusion

    Open Access•Nitsan Chorev•American Sociological Review•2012

  • Democratic Legitimacy and Public Insecurity

    Open Access•Orlando J Pérez•Political Science Quarterly•2003

  • Vernacularization on the ground

    Open Access•P Levitt, Sally Engle Merry et al.•Global Networks•2009

  • A new type of hybrid actor in global governance

    Theresa Reinold•Verfassung in Recht und Übersee•2020

  • Working Children as Social Subjects

    Open Access•M Liebel•Childhood•2003

  • From Pariah State to Global Protagonist

    Open Access•Kathryn Sikkink•Latin American Politics and Society•2008

  • Flexible Justice

    Open Access•Daniel M Goldstein•Critique of Anthropology•2005

  • Intra-conservative Bloc Contestations on Gender Equality in Turkey - Norm Reception in Fragmented Normative Orders

    Open Access•Hüsrev Tabak, Seven Erdogan et al.•Journal of Asian and African…•2023

  • The Recursivity of Law

    Terence C Halliday, Bruce G Carruthers•American Journal of Sociology•2007

  • World Society and the Nation-State

    J W Meyer, John Boli et al.•American Journal of Sociology•1997

Unique citing works4
Citations per year2
Citation span2024 - 2026 (3)
Citation velocitycurrent
Highly citedNo
Citation typesNeutral: 4

Tools

Open DOIOpen Access
Ethnos_APP • Open Source Project • MIT License • Frontend v2.0.0 • Privacy and Cookies • API Documentation: api.ethnos.app/docs • API Source Code: GitHub • DOI: 10.5281/zenodo.17049435 • Frontend Source Code: GitHub • DOI: 10.5281/zenodo.17050053 • cruz.rio.br • Expectantes Misericordiae