Surviving in the margins of a genocide case in the making

In this article, we aim to draw attention to the hopes, frustrations and disillusions that so-called ‘transitional justice’ projects produce in drastically poor, war-torn, historically marginalized but politicized Indigenous communities. Drawing on extensive ethnographic research we conducted separately between 1982 and 2010 in Guatemala and Mexico, we describe the ways in which the world came to know about Finca San Francisco’s massacre, committed by the Guatemalan army on 17 July 1982, as part of its scorched earth policy. We then look at the various forms of reparations its survivors have been the subject of. In so doing, we focus more specifically on how the Center for Human Rights Legal Action (CALDH), the non-governmental human rights organization that was behind the Ríos Montt genocide case, mobilized Finca San Francisco’s massacre survivors to become participants in the trial. After examining how the survivors of Finca San Francisco responded to CALDH’s mobilization efforts, we reflect on the kind of ‘gift’ these survivors expected in return for their stories of annihilation and destruction. Our goal is to bring to light the ‘economy of testimony’ that human rights activists, journalists or social scientists become entangled in once they ask genocide survivors to testify about the brutal deaths of their loved ones

Criminology · Economic Justice · Ethnography · Genocide · Human rights · Indigenous · Political science · Politics · Sociology · Anthropology · Cambodian History and Society · Law

• La justicia transicional desde abajo en Guatemala

  Open Access•Maira Ixchel Benítez-Jiménez, Gabriela Escobar Urrutia•European Review of Latin American…•2024

  Incluir item

• Consent, Mediation, and Complicity

  Miranda Cady Hallett, Sandra Gruner-Domic•Geopolitics•2021

  Incluir item

• How the Guatemalan civil war became a genocide

  Open Access•David Stoll•The Journal of Latin American and…•2022

  Incluir item