Skip to main content

ETHNOS_APP

Home • Search • Journals • List 0

Moving up, moving down

Political careers across territorial levels

Bibliographic Data

ID6258396
AuthorsKlaus Stolz (0000-0002-7486-8692, University of Göttingen, corresponding author)
Year2003
Volume42
Issue2
Pages223-248
Publication date2003-03-01
Peer ReviewedYes
Open AccessYes
TypeARTICLE
VenueEuropean Journal of Political Research (JOURNAL)
Journal identifiersISSN: 0304-4130 • E-ISSN: 1475-6765
PublisherWiley (PUBLISHER • GB)
DOI10.1111/1475-6765.00081
OpenAlexW1566518344
LanguageEN
Citations received86
References cited4

In the sparse literature on political careers in federal systems, regional positions are often seen as mere stepping stones on the way to federal office. But are they really? The recent professionalization of state politics in federal systems and the regionalization of former unitary states point to the strengthening of the regional level as a career arena in its own right. Could this lead to the emergence of a regional political class with a set of career interests distinct from those of national politicians? This article takes a first, comparative look at current patterns of career movements between regional and national parliaments in a wide range of federal and newly regionalized systems. The study shows that, contrary to general belief, the number of deputies actually moving from the regional to federal level is generally relatively low. While some cases show fairly integrated career structures, others exhibit a pattern of career development in which state or regional office functions as the main focus of political careers. The territorial structure of the political class is dependent upon a whole range of social, cultural and institutional factors. At the same time, it is also an important factor in the mechanics and institutional development of each federal system in question

Federal state · Federalism · Political economy · Political science · Politics · Professionalization · Sociology · State (computer science · Unitary state · Electoral Systems and Political Participation · Law · Political Influence and Corporate Strategies · Political Systems and Governance · Public Administration

  • Lietuvos merų politinės karjeros bruožai

    Aistė Lazauskienė•Culture & Society•2016

  • Temporal Methods in Political Elite Studies

    Open Access•Sebastian Jäckle, Matthew Kerby•The Palgrave Handbook of…•2018

  • When do politicians choose to upset the apple cart? The fairness-loyalty trade-off in whistleblowing

    Open Access•Stephen Dawson•European Journal of Political…•2026

  • Direct election of regional presidents and party change in Italy

    Open Access•Alex Wilson•Modern Italy•2015

  • Redistributive Preferences and Indicators of Social Mobility

    Open Access•G Monusova•Journal of Economic Sociology•2017

  • The Great Convergence

    Open Access•Richard Baldwin•Journal of Economic Sociology•2017

  • Deputies of the State Duma of the VI Convocation

    Open Access•Denis Tev, Денис Тев•Journal of Economic Sociology•2017

  • Obtaining Grants

    Open Access•Benjamin Descamps, Carine Smolders•Swiss Political Science Review•2025

  • Ministerial turnover in the German Länder (1991–2010)

    Open Access•Sebastian Jäckle•Zeitschrift für Vergleichende…•2013

  • Habitus, campo y capital. Elementos para una teoría general del capital político

    Open Access•Alfredo Joignant•Revista Mexicana de Sociología•2012

  • Dual polity, dual careers? The dynamic interaction of political careers and territorial order in the devolved United Kingdom

    Klaus Stolz•Territory Politics Governance•2024

  • Local politics for democratic quality and depth

    Open Access•O Fiona Yap•Asia & the Pacific Policy Studies•2021

  • Polish Regional Elite Career Paths and the Impact of a Multilevel System

    Open Access•Tatiana Majchierkiewicz•Politics in Central Europe•2020

  • Solving the problem of social background in the UK ‘political class’

    Open Access•Paul Cairney, Michael Keating et al.•British Politics•2015

  • Deputies of the State Duma of the Russian Federation

    Open Access•Денис Тев•Sotsiologicheskoe Obozrenie /…•2018

  • Survey Types, Sample Biases and the Effects of Demographic Quotas. The Results of an Experiment with a Three-Frame Survey in a Major Russian City

    Open Access•Mikhail Sokolov, Alexander Kazantsev•Journal of Economic Sociology•2017

  • A new political elite in Western Europe? The political careers of regional prime ministers in newly decentralised countries

    Open Access•Joan Botella, Juan Rodríguez-Teruel et al.•French Politics•2010

  • The survival and tenure of Australian Attorneys-General

    Edmund Handby•Commonwealth and Comparative…•2020

  • Gendered EUropean careers? Representation and the challenges in women's political careers

    Open Access•Elena Frech•European Union Politics•2024

  • The Regionalization of Political Careers in Spain and the UK

    Klaus Stolz•Regional & Federal Studies•2011

  • Multi-level Political Careers in the USA

    Gary W Copeland, Gary Copeland et al.•Regional & Federal Studies•2011

  • The patterns of political career movements of Nigerian cabinet ministers, 1999–2017

    Elena Semenova, Nkwachukwu Orji•Regional & Federal Studies•2024

  • Party Careers in Federal Systems. Vertical Linkages within Austrian, German, Canadian and Australian Parties

    Klaus Detterbeck•Regional & Federal Studies•2011

  • Patterns of political career movements in multi-level systems

    Elena Semenova, Keith Dowding•Regional & Federal Studies•2023

  • (Re-)Assessing Career Patterns in Multi-Level Systems

    Jérémy Dodeigne•Regional & Federal Studies•2014

  • Introduction

    Jens Borchert, Klaus Stolz•Regional & Federal Studies•2011

  • Hometown bias in Flanders

    Carine Smolders, Benjamin Descamps•Regional & Federal Studies•2024

  • A dual summit of power? Career movements and multilevel circulation in the Spanish executive elite

    Juan Rodríguez-Teruel•Regional & Federal Studies•2024

  • Political professionalization and transformations of political career patterns in multi-level states

    Roberto Di Capua, Andrea Pilotti et al.•Regional & Federal Studies•2020

  • German Political Careers

    Jens Borchert, Klaus Stolz•Regional & Federal Studies•2011

  • Political careers and stability in office of regional ministers in Italy

    Open Access•Matteo Boldrini, Selena Grimaldi•Regional & Federal Studies•2023

  • Fluid paths to the cabinet in federal presidential systems

    Open Access•Marcelo Camerlo, Andres Malamud et al.•Regional & Federal Studies•2022

  • Political careers in multi-level systems

    Selena Grimaldi, Michelangelo Vercesi•Regional & Federal Studies•2017

  • Political elite careers in Pakistan

    Mariam Mufti, Sameen A Mohsin Ali•Regional & Federal Studies•2025

  • The patterns of political career movements in the Russian Federation

    Open Access•Elena Semenova•Regional & Federal Studies•2023

  • Twenty thousand leagues below the Po

    Gianluca Piccolino, Sofia Marini•Regional & Federal Studies•2025

  • Setting up institutions in multilevel states

    Open Access•Patrícia Calca, Teresa Ruel•Party Politics•2023

  • Introduction

    Open Access•Nicolò Conti, Christophe Roux et al.•Modern Italy•2009

  • Candidate turnover in EP- versus national elections

    Gertjan Muyters, Bart Maddens•Journal of European Integration•2023

  • El camino hacia el poder Analizando la carrera política de los gobernadores argentinos (1983–2011)

    Open Access•Belén Campomar, Agustín de Jesús Suárez•Revista Mexicana de Ciencias…•2014

  • Between Scylla and Charybdis? Twenty-Five Years Administrating the Contested Region of Brussels

    Open Access•Karl O’connor, Joost Vaesen•Administration & Society•2018

  • Territorial Dynamics of Spanish Members of Parliament (1977–2020)

    Open Access•Pablo Domínguez, Manuel F Portillo-Pérez•Nationalities Papers•2023

  • Incumbency in Multi-Level Political Systems and Recruitment Advantage

    Open Access•J Bernard, Jiří Šafr•Czech Sociological Review•2016

  • Career Patterns in Multilevel States

    Ine Vanlangenakker, Bart Maddens et al.•Regional Studies•2013

  • Members of the European Parliament’s Political Careers across Different Levels

    Open Access•Eugenio Salvati•Political Studies Review•2024

  • (Self-)selection and expertise among decision-makers in the European Parliament

    Silje Synnøve Lyder Hermansen•Journal of Legislative Studies•2018

  • Committee Parliamentary Specialization Index. Explaining MPs’ specialisation in the Spanish Congreso de los Diputados

    Pablo Oñate, Carmen Ortega•Journal of Legislative Studies•2019

  • The (De‐)Europeanization of the Political Class in the European Parliament

    Open Access•Jérémy Dodeigne, François Randour et al.•JCMS Journal of Common Market…•2025

  • Blurred lines between electoral and parliamentary representation

    Open Access•Silje Synnøve Lyder Hermansen, Andreja Pegan•European Union Politics•2023

  • Individual Ambition and Institutional Opportunity

    Jens Borchert•Regional & Federal Studies•2011

  • Las carreras políticas de los jefes de gobierno regionales en España, Francia y el Reino Unido (1980-2010)

    Open Access•Joan Botella Coral, Juan Rodríguez-Teruel et al.•Revista Española de Investigaciones…•2024

  • Approaches and lessons in political career research

    Open Access•Michelangelo Vercesi•Revista Española de Ciencia…•2018

  • Career models in the new tripolar order. Political profiles of the Italian MPs after 2022 general elections

    Open Access•Matteo Boldrini, Selena Grimaldi•Quaderni dell Osservatorio…•2023

  • Changing patterns of ministerial circulation

    Nicola Martocchia Diodati, Luca Verzichelli•West European Politics•2017

  • Who governs? The disputed effects of regionalism on legislative career orientation in multilevel systems

    Jérémy Dodeigne•West European Politics•2018

  • Institutional Foundations of Legislative Turnover

    Open Access•Till Heinsohn, Michel Freitag et al.•Swiss Political Science Review•2012

  • Electoral Career Movements and the Flow of Political Power in the American Federal System

    Open Access•Peverill Squire•State Politics & Policy Quarterly•2014

  • El Parlament de Catalunya

    William M Downs•South European Society & Politics•2003

  • Carreras legislativas discretas en contextos de débil institucionalización partidista

    Open Access•Santiago Basabe-Serrano•Revista de ciencia política•2018

  • The Effect of Institutional Affiliation and Career Patterns on (De)centralization Preferences in Advanced Multi-Level States

    Open Access•Jérémy Dodeigne, Christoph Niessen et al.•Publius The Journal of Federalism•2021

  • Conceptualising the Multi-Level Party

    Open Access•David Moon, David S Moon et al.•Politics•2010

  • Public Office as a Stepping-Stone? Investigating the Careers of Ministerial Advisors

    Open Access•Jostein Askim, Rune Karlsen et al.•Political Studies Review•2021

  • Calling It Quits

    Open Access•Christopher D Raymond, L Marvin Overby•Political Studies•2020

  • Territorial cleavage or institutional break-up? Party integration and ideological cohesiveness among Spanish elites

    Open Access•Sandra León•Party Politics•2017

  • Multi-Level Relations in Political Parties

    Open Access•Pieter Van Houten•Party Politics•2009

  • Measuring vertical integration in parties with multi-level systems data

    Open Access•Lori Thorlakson•Party Politics•2013

  • A New Elite? Politicians and Civil Servants in Scotland after Devolution

    Michael Keating•Parliamentary Affairs•2005

  • Pathways to Power

    Open Access•Tomas Turner-Zwinkels, Tomas Turner‐zwinkel et al.•Legislative Studies Quarterly•2020

  • Institutional Determinants of Legislative Turnover in the German State Parliaments

    Till Heinsohn•Journal of Legislative Studies•2014

  • Career politicians a dozen years after regionalisation of the Czech Republic (2000–13)

    Dan Ryšavý•Journal of Legislative Studies•2016

  • The electoral personalization of Italian mayors. A study of 25 years of direct election

    Open Access•Anna Carola Freschi, Vittorio Mete•Italian Political Science…•2020

  • Multilevel governance and women's legislative representation

    Open Access•Kristina Gushchina, Andrea Kaiser et al.•European Journal of Political…•2021

  • The gender politics of executive candidate selection and reselection

    Open Access•Tània Verge Mestre, Tánia Verge et al.•European Journal of Political…•2019

  • State structure and political representation

    Open Access•Audrey André, Sam Depauw et al.•European Journal of Political…•2016

  • Post‐ministerial occupation in advanced industrial democracies

    Open Access•Sílvia Claveria, Tània Verge Mestre et al.•European Journal of Political…•2015

  • Reconsidering Vertical Integration

    Open Access•Scott Pruyser•Canadian Journal of Political…•2014

  • Do independents like to party? The rise in independent and minor party MPs in Australian parliaments since 1970

    Open Access•Mark Riboldi, Ben Spies-Butcher et al.•Australian Journal of Political…•2024

  • Blending in or standing out? Gendered political communication in 24 democracies

    Open Access•Bruno Castanho Silva, Danielle Pullan et al.•American Journal of Political…•2025

  • Career Ambitions and Legislative Participation

    Open Access•Bjørn Høyland, Sara B Hobolt et al.•British Journal of Political…•2019

  • Strength through Weakness

    Open Access•Ferdinand Karlhofer, Günther Pallaver•Swiss Political Science Review•2013

  • Between Occupation and Politics

    Open Access•Pirmin Bundi, Daniela Eberli et al.•Swiss Political Science Review•2017

  • Sub-national Constitutionalism in Austria

    Open Access•Karlhofer Ferdinand, Ferdinand Karlhofer•Perspectives on Federalism•2015

  • What Comes after Cabinet? Post-Cabinet Careers of German Regional Ministers between 1945 and 2014

    Open Access•Sebastian Jäckle•Social Sciences•2023

  • Federalismo, coalizões de governo e escolhas de carreira dos deputados federais

    Open Access•André Borges, Alvino Oliveira Sanches Filho•Opinião Pública•2016

  • The Class Ceiling in Politics

    Open Access•Olle Folke, Johanna Rickne•American Political Science Review•2025

  • Women's Career Move From Local to National Politics

    Open Access•Mi Yung Yoon, Idda Lyatonga Swai•Journal of Asian and African…•2025

  • The Concept of Political Class

    Open Access•Klaus Von Beyme•Klaus Von Beyme•2014

  • Legislative Professionalization and Membership Diversity in State Legislatures

    Open Access•Peverill Squire•Legislative Studies Quarterly•1992

  • State Legislative Development

    Open Access•Alan Rosenthal•Legislative Studies Quarterly•1996

  • Career Opportunities and Membership Stability in Legislatures

    Open Access•Peverill Squire•Legislative Studies Quarterly•1988

Unique citing works86
Citations per year3,74
Citation span2003 - 2026 (24)
Citation velocitycurrent
Highly citedNo
Citation typesNeutral: 85

Tools

Open DOISci-Hub
Ethnos_APP • Open Source Project • MIT License • Frontend v2.0.0 • Privacy and Cookies • API Documentation: api.ethnos.app/docs • API Source Code: GitHub • DOI: 10.5281/zenodo.17049435 • Frontend Source Code: GitHub • DOI: 10.5281/zenodo.17050053 • cruz.rio.br • Expectantes Misericordiae