Skip to main content

ETHNOS_APP

Home • Search • Journals • List 0

Pension Privatization

Evolution of a Paradigm

Bibliographic Data

ID6263449
AuthorsMitchell A Orenstein (0000-0002-2383-3270, Northeastern University, corresponding author)
Year2013
Volume26
Issue2
Pages259-281
Publication date2013-04-01
Peer ReviewedYes
Open AccessYes
TypeARTICLE
VenueGovernance (JOURNAL)
Journal identifiersISSN: 0952-1895 • E-ISSN: 1468-0491
PublisherWiley (PUBLISHER • GB)
DOI10.1111/gove.12024
OpenAlexW1770165407
LanguageEN
Citations received50
References cited39

From 1981 to 2004, a paradigm shift occurred in pension systems worldwide as more than 30 countries fully or partially replaced their state‐administered pay‐as‐you‐go pension systems with ones based on individual, private savings accounts. Yet in 2005, pension privatization abruptly stopped. After the 2008 crisis, several countries that had privatized their pension systems scaled back or even canceled individual accounts. Is the new pension paradigm dead? And if so, why? This article shows that fiscal and ideational factors caused a temporary halt to pension privatization worldwide and induced transnational pension policy networks to find new ways to respond to perceived failures. Adjustments to the new pension paradigm such as emphasizing minimum pensions and recommending that governments “nudge” rather than mandate pension savings will enable pension privatization to continue in years ahead, albeit in a revised form

Business · Economic policy · Economics · Mandate · Pension · Pension system · Political science · Private pension · State (computer science · Employment and Welfare Studies · Financial Literacy, Pension, Retirement Analysis · Housing, Finance, and Neoliberalism · Law · Finance

  • The Political Economy of Pension Policy Reversal in Post-Communist Countries

    Sarah Wilson Sokhey•Political Economy of Pension…•2017

  • Bringing Ideational Power into the Paradigm Approach

    Open Access•Martin B Carstensen•Policy Paradigms in Theory and…•2015

  • OECD pension reform

    Open Access•Ward E Romp, Ward Romp et al.•European Journal of Political…•2023

  • Meanings of Public and the Future of Public Services

    Open Access•David A Mcdonald•Meanings of Public and the Future…•2022

  • Insuring individuals … and politicians

    Marek Naczyk, Anke Hassel•Journal of European Public Policy•2019

  • Policy Learning Through Transfer - Individuals, Organisations and Network in the Making of Ethiopia’s Industrial Park Programme

    Open Access•Jing Zhang•International Review of Public…•2024

  • Comparative pension reform pathways in Latin America and Southern Europe

    Open Access•Marina Angelaki, Leandro N Carrera•Journal of International and…•2025

  • Institutional Design of Pension Systems Versus Labor Market Structure

    Open Access•Renata Herrerías, Guillermo Zamarripa et al.•Work Aging and Retirement•2023

  • The politics of policy anomalies

    Matt Wilder, Michael Howlett•Critical Policy Studies•2014

  • Social policy diffusion in South Asia

    Joachim Betz, Daniel Neff•Journal of Asian Public Policy•2016

  • Politics, power and policy transfer

    Nick Ellison•Journal of Asian Public Policy•2016

  • Privileging privatisation

    Open Access•Liam Clegg, C Rogers•British Politics•2021

  • Caught in a Matrix of Factors

    Open Access•Stefan Bieńkowski, Danuta Życzyńska-Ciołek•Qualitative Sociology Review•2023

  • Radical Pension Reforms after the Crisis

    Open Access•Marina Angelaki, Leandro N Carrera•Politics & Policy•2015

  • Cracking the Nest Egg

    Open Access•Daria Prisiazhniuk, Sarah Wilson Sokhey•Social Policy and Society•2023

  • Conditional solutionism

    Open Access•Achim Kemmerling, Gift Mwonzora•Global Social Policy•2025

  • The politics of pension reform in Greece and Turkey

    Open Access•Aslı Güleç•Global Social Policy•2014

  • International organizations as policy actors

    Open Access•Daniel Béland, Mitchell A Orenstein•Global Social Policy•2013

  • Organizing for impact

    Open Access•Martin Heneghan, Mitchell A Orenstein•Global Social Policy•2019

  • Exploring theoretical approaches to global social policy research

    Open Access•Alexandra Kaasch, Martin Koch et al.•Global Social Policy•2019

  • Armed conflicts and the expansion of old-age pensions in the Global South

    Open Access•Jakob Frizell, Aline Grünewald et al.•Global Social Policy•2026

  • Repackaging in South–North Policy Learning

    Open Access•Achim Kemmerling, Kristin Makszin•Journal of Comparative Policy…•2023

  • Presidents’ Strategic Action and Policy Change in Mexico

    Jose-Luis Mendez•Journal of Comparative Policy…•2017

  • Special Issue

    Achim Kemmerling•Journal of Comparative Policy…•2023

  • Russian Pension Reform under Quadruple Influence

    Linda J Cook, Linda Cook et al.•Problems of Post-Communism•2017

  • Between substantive and symbolic influence

    Nils Röper•Review of International Political…•2020

  • Another look at causes and consequences of pension privatization reform reversals in Eastern Europe

    Open Access•Nikola Altiparmakov•Journal of European Social Policy•2017

  • Creating French-style pension funds

    Open Access•Marek Naczyk•Journal of European Social Policy•2016

  • Public–private pension mixes in East Asia

    Open Access•Chung-Yang Yeh, Hyunwook Cheng et al.•Ageing and Society•2020

  • An appraisal of Turkey's voluntary individual pension system from a perspective of pension equality

    Open Access•Sertac Babat, Derya Gultekin et al.•Social Policy and Administration•2021

  • Public–Private Partnerships in European Old‐Age Pension Provision

    Open Access•Ville-Pekka Sorsa, Ville‐Pekka Sorsa•Social Policy and Administration•2016

  • Path‐dependency versus Reform in Pensions and Family Policy Re‐examined

    Open Access•Tomasz Inglot•Social Policy and Administration•2016

  • When finance captures labor's capital

    Open Access•Marek Naczyk•Social Policy and Administration•2018

  • Social policy learning inside the World Bank

    Open Access•Martin Heneghan•Social Policy and Administration•2022

  • Neoliberalism Filtered

    Open Access•David P Dolowitz, Cecilia Osorio Gonnet et al.•Latin American Perspectives•2026

  • The face of affordable housing in a neoliberal paradigm

    Open Access•Rachel Friedman, Gillad Rosen•Urban Studies•2020

  • Modelos de financiarización de las pensiones en cuatro estados de bienestar europeos

    Open Access•Natascha Van Der Zwan•Revista Internacional de Sociología•2020

  • There's something about sustainability’

    Open Access•Susan Ainsworth•Public Administration•2020

  • Warum es kaum Pensionsfonds in Deutschland gibt. Kapitalmarktrisiken, Finanzindustrie und die Politik der Mindestverzinsung

    Open Access•Anke Hassel, Marek Naczyk•KZfSS Kölner Zeitschrift für…•2018

  • Developing countries and systemic pension reforms

    Open Access•Xinmei Wang, John B Williamson et al.•International Social Security…•2016

  • Reforming against all odds

    Open Access•Dragoș Adăscăliței, Štefan Domonkos•International Social Security…•2015

  • Second‐pillar pensions in Central and Eastern Europe

    Open Access•Elaine Fultz, Kenichi Hirose•International Social Security…•2019

  • The Financial Crisis and Varieties of Pension Privatization Reversals in Eastern Europe

    Open Access•Marek Naczyk, Stefan Domonko et al.•Governance•2016

  • The political economy of pension financialisation

    Anke Hassel, Marek Naczyk et al.•Journal of European Public Policy•2019

  • How Solutions Chase Problems

    Open Access•Daniel Béland, Michael Howlett•Governance•2016

  • Invasion From Within

    Open Access•Martin B Carstensen, Nils Röper•Comparative Political Studies•2019

  • Pension financialization and workplace pension wealth inequality

    Open Access•Bruno Bonizzi, Hulya Dagdeviren et al.•Socio-Economic Review•2025

  • Financializing nursing homes? The uneven development of Health Care Reits in France, the United Kingdom and Japan

    Open Access•Natacha Aveline-Dubach•Environment and Planning A…•2022

  • Benevolent Policies

    Open Access•Carmen Jacqueline Ho•American Political Science Review•2022

  • How to Build and Wield Business Power

    Open Access•Tomás Bril-Mascarenhas, Antoine Maillet•Latin American Politics and Society•2019

  • Retiring the State

    Raúl Madrid•Retiring the State•2003

  • The Varieties of Pension Governance

    Bernhard Ebbinghaus, Kathryn Anderson•The varieties of pension governance•2011

  • Privatizing Pensions

    Mitchell A Orenstein•Privatizing Pensions•2008

  • Solidarity without the State?

    Open Access•Matthieu Leimgruber•Solidarity Without the State?•2008

  • The Political Economy of Pension Reform in Central–Eastern Europe

    Katharine Müller•The Political Economy of Pension…•1999

  • Dismantling the Welfare State?

    Open Access•Paul Pierson•Dismantling the Welfare State?•1994

  • Ideas and Politics in Social Science Research

    Daniel Béland, Robert Henry Cox•Ideas and politics in social…•2010

  • A Long Goodbye to Bismarck?

    Open Access•Bruno Palier•A Long Goodbye to Bismarck? : The…•2010

  • The New Politics of the Welfare State

    Paul Pierson•The new politics of the welfare…•2001

  • Averting the funding-gap crisis

    Open Access•Jan Drahokoupil, Štefan Domonkos•Global Social Policy•2012

  • Pension Reform in Nigeria

    Open Access•Bernard H Casey, Bernard Casey et al.•Global Social Policy•2008

  • The Battle of Future Pensions

    Open Access•Rune Ervik•Global Social Policy•2005

  • Nudge

    Open Access•Richard V Adkisson•The Social Science Journal•2008

  • The Limits of Pension Privatization

    Open Access•Camila Arza•World Development•2008

  • The New Collectivism

    Robin Blackburn•New left review•1999

  • Social Security at The Crossroads

    Open Access•Milko Matijascic, Stephen J Kay et al.•International Social Security…•2006

  • The impact of the global financial crisis on social protection in developing countries

    Open Access•Anna McCord•International Social Security…•2010

  • From reform to crisis

    Open Access•Fabio M Bertranou, Fabio Bertranou et al.•International Social Security…•2003

  • Social pensions and policy learning

    Open Access•Bernard H Casey, Bernard Casey et al.•International Social Security…•2009

  • Political risk and pension privatization

    Open Access•Stephen J Kay, Stephen Kay•International Social Security…•2009

  • Reforming pensions

    Open Access•Nicholas Barr, Peter Dia­mond•International Social Security…•2009

  • Social security in times of crisis

    Open Access•Florence Bonnet, Ellen Ehmke et al.•International Social Security…•2010

  • Reforming Pensions

    Open Access•Nicholas Barr, NBarr@imf org NBarr@imf org•International Social Security…•2000

  • Pension Reform and International Organizations

    Open Access•Monika Queisser•International Social Security…•2000

  • Theories of Policy Diffusion Lessons from Latin American Pension Reform

    Open Access•K Weyland•World Politics•2005

  • When Does Diffusion Matter? Explaining the Spread of Structural Pension Reforms Across Nations

    Sarah M Brooks•The Journal of Politics•2007

  • Interdependent and Domestic Foundations of Policy Change

    Open Access•Sarah M Brooks•International Studies Quarterly•2005

  • The Politics of When

    Open Access•Alan M Jacobs•British Journal of Political…•2008

  • Policy Paradigms, Social Learning, and the State

    Peter A Hall•Comparative Politics•1993

  • Dismantling an Earnings-Related Social Pension Scheme

    Open Access•Winfried Schmähl•Journal of Social Policy•2007

Unique citing works50
Citations per year3,85
Citation span2013 - 2026 (14)
Citation velocitycurrent
Highly citedNo
Citation typesNeutral: 50

Tools

Open DOISci-Hub
Ethnos_APP • Open Source Project • MIT License • Frontend v2.0.0 • Privacy and Cookies • API Documentation: api.ethnos.app/docs • API Source Code: GitHub • DOI: 10.5281/zenodo.17049435 • Frontend Source Code: GitHub • DOI: 10.5281/zenodo.17050053 • cruz.rio.br • Expectantes Misericordiae