Skip to main content

ETHNOS_APP

Home • Search • Journals • List 0

Digital Disaster, Cyber Security, and the Copenhagen School

Bibliographic Data

ID6274044
AuthorsLene Hansen (0000-0001-7918-3943, University of Copenhagen), Helen Nissenbaum (0000-0002-6485-6997, New York University)
Year2009
Volume53
Issue4
Pages1155-1175
Publication date2009-12-01
Peer ReviewedYes
Open AccessYes
TypeARTICLE
VenueInternational Studies Quarterly (JOURNAL)
Journal identifiersISSN: 0020-8833 • E-ISSN: 1468-2478
PublisherOxford University Press (OUP) (PUBLISHER)
DOI10.1111/j.1468-2478.2009.00572.x
OpenAlexW2076744904
LanguageEN
Citations received139
References cited38

This article is devoted to an analysis of cyber security, a concept that arrived on the post-Cold War agenda in response to a mixture of technological innovations and changing geopolitical conditions. Adopting the framework of securitization theory, the article theorizes cyber security as a distinct sector with a particular constellation of threats and referent objects. It is held that “network security” and “individual security” are significant referent objects, but that their political importance arises from connections to the collective referent objects of “the state,”“society,”“the nation,” and “the economy.” These referent objects are articulated as threatened through three distinct forms of securitizations: hypersecuritization, everyday security practices, and technifications. The applicability of the theoretical framework is then shown through a case-study of what has been labeled the first war in cyber space against Estonian public and commercial institutions in 2007

Business · Computer security · Geopolitics · Militarization · Political economy · Political science · Politics · Referent · Securitization · Sociology · State (computer science · Computer Science · Cybersecurity and Cyber Warfare Studies · Global Security and Public Health · Intelligence, Security, War Strategy · Law

  • Für eine multitemporale Bestimmung von Cybersicherheit

    Open Access•Dennis Eckhardt, Nelli Feist et al.•Zeitschrift für Soziologie•2026

  • Politik in der digitalen Gesellschaft

    Jeanette Hofmann, Norbert Kersting et al.•Politik in der digitalen…

  • Copenhagen school and securitization of cyberspace in Turkey

    Open Access•Didem Aydindag, Didem Aydındağ•Propósitos y Representaciones•2021

  • Posverdad, agnotología e instrumentalidad en internet

    Open Access•Rodrigo Iván Liceaga Mendoza, Iván Liceaga•Andamios•2021

  • Data Governance

    Anke Sophia Obendiek•Data Governance•2022

  • From Cyber-Bombs to Political Fallout

    Open Access•Myriam Dunn Cavelty•International Studies Review•2013

  • The Making of Global International Relations

    Open Access•Atanu Acharya, Amitav Acharya et al.•Making of Global International…•2019

  • Strategi Indonesia Membentuk Cyber Security Dalam Menghadapi Ancaman Cyber Crime Melalui Badan Siber Dan Sandi Negara

    Open Access•Yusep Ginanjar•Jurnal Dinamika Global•2022

  • Metaverso

    Open Access•José Antonio Moya Martínez•Barataria Revista Castellano-Manche…•2024

  • A Systematic Mapping Study of Cybersecurity Vulnerabilities, Attacks, and Mitigation Strategies

    Open Access•Kavita Khanna, Kanika Khanna•ShodhKosh: Journal of Visual and…•2023

  • The Securitization of Cyberspace

    Open Access•Mirzet S Ramich, Danil A Piskunov•Vestnik RUDN International…•2022

  • Cybersecurity

    Open Access•Michael Veale, Ian Brown•Internet Policy Review•2020

  • Digital sovereignty

    Open Access•Julia Pohle, Thorsten Thiel•Internet Policy Review•2020

  • Estonia’s digital diplomacy

    Open Access•Alex Hardy•Internet Policy Review•2024

  • Macht im Cyberspace

    Open Access•Kerstin Zettl-Schabath•Zeitschrift für Friedens- und…•2022

  • The Institutionalisation of Security Norms in the Context of Cyber Alignments

    Open Access•Mahmoud Hosh, Numeir Issa•Central European Journal of…•2024

  • Small Powers, Geopolitical Crisis and Hypersecuritisation

    Open Access•Māris Andžāns•Central European Journal of…•2023

  • Siber Saldırı Önlemede Blokzinciri Teknolojisinin Fayda Maliyet Açısından Değerlendirilmesi

    Open Access•Ömer AYDIN, Suleyman YUKCU•MANAS Sosyal Araştırmalar Dergisi•2020

  • Cyber intelligence and international security

    Open Access•Dennis Broeders•Intelligence & National Security•2024

  • Clipper Meets Apple vs. FBI—A Comparison of the Cryptography Discourses from 1993 and 2016

    Open Access•Matthias Schulze•Media and Communication•2017

  • EU conditionality and desecuritization nexus in Turkey

    Sinem Akgül Açıkmeşe, Sinem Akgül Açikmeşe•Journal of Southeast European and…•2013

  • Failing better in the infosphere

    Open Access•Noran Shafik Fouad•Information Communication & Society•2025

  • Souveränität

    Thorsten Thiel

  • Fear of the (Un)known

    Open Access•Monica Kaminska, Monica Kello•Global Society•2026

  • Muddle and Match

    Open Access•Jennifer Lewallen•Review of Policy Research•2026

  • The Burden of Security

    Open Access•Vera Lazzaretti•Journal of Extreme Anthropology•2020

  • The materiality of cyberthreats

    Myriam Dunn Cavelty•Critical Studies on Security•2019

  • Canada's cyber security and the changing threat landscape

    M Zajko•Critical Studies on Security•2015

  • Everyday rules and embodied information

    Renée Marlin-Bennett, Renée Marlin‐bennett•Critical Studies on Security•2016

  • From neurotic citizen to hysteric security expert

    Jeppe T Jacobsen•Critical Studies on Security•2020

  • Critical interdisciplinary cybersecurity

    Matt Spencer•Information Communication & Society•2026

  • Tracing strategic preferences in cyberspace

    Open Access•Miguel Alberto Gomez•Comparative Strategy•2023

  • Cybersecurity Research Meets Science and Technology Studies

    Open Access•Myriam Dunn Cavelty•Politics and Governance•2018

  • Cyber Security Assemblages

    Open Access•Jamie Collier•Politics and Governance•2018

  • Enacting Expertise

    Open Access•James Shires•Politics and Governance•2018

  • Global Cybersecurity

    Open Access•T Stevens•Politics and Governance•2018

  • Fear, Uncertainty, and Dread

    Open Access•Miguel Alberto Gomez, Eula Bianca Villar•Politics and Governance•2018

  • Drawing a line

    Open Access•Marcus Michaelsen, Johannes Thumfart•European Journal of International…•2022

  • Cyberbiosecurity in the new normal

    Open Access•Noran Shafik Fouad•European Journal of International…•2024

  • A theory of actor-network for cyber-security

    Open Access•Thierry Balzacq, Myriam Dunn Cavelty•European Journal of International…•2016

  • Unpacking cyberterrorism discourse

    Open Access•Lee Jarvis, Stuart Macdonald et al.•European Journal of International…•2016

  • The post-politics of public-private security governance

    Open Access•Jeppe T Jacobsen•European Journal of International…•2020

  • The ontological politics of cyber security

    Open Access•Tobias Liebetrau, Kristoffer Kjærgaard Christensen•European Journal of International…•2020

  • The ‘dark’ side of normative argumentation – The case of counterterrorism policy

    Open Access•Regina Heller, Martin Kahl et al.•Global Constitutionalism•2012

  • The politics of securitized technology

    Juha A Vuori•Global Discourse•2018

  • Securitization and the global politics of cybersecurity

    Mark Lacy, Daniel Prince•Global Discourse•2018

  • Beyond Cyber-Doom

    Sean Lawson•Journal of Information Technology…•2012

  • The hidden threat of cyber-attacks – undermining public confidence in government

    Open Access•Ryan Shandler, Miguel Alberto Gomez•Journal of Information Technology…•2022

  • Quantum for Whom? Situating Ethical Risks in Quantum Technologies’ Innovation Context

    Open Access•M A Palacios Barea•NanoEthics•2026

  • Securitizing cyberspace

    Open Access•Hedvig Ördén•Journal of International…•2021

  • Securitization Climax

    Open Access•Amir Lupovici•Foreign Policy Analysis•2014

  • In the name of (de)securitization

    Open Access•Faye Donnelly•International Review of the Red…•2017

  • The “Attribution Problem” and the Social Construction of “Violence”

    Open Access•Amir Lupovici•International Studies Perspectives•2014

  • Security-defence nexus in flux

    Open Access•Mustafa Ali Sezal•Defence Studies•2023

  • Overcoming uncertainty in cyberspace

    Miguel Alberto Gomez•Defence Studies•2020

  • The Dog That Did Not Bark, the Dog That Did Bark, and the Dog That Should Have Barked

    Open Access•Amir Lupovici•International Studies Review•2021

  • Semiotics of threats

    Open Access•A Ventsel, Mari-Liis Madisson•Sign Systems Studies•2019

  • Cyberweapons

    Open Access•T Stevens•International Politics•2017

  • Non-state Actors and Global Crime Governance

    Open Access•Anja P Jakobi•The British Journal of Politics…•2015

  • Framing and governing cyber risks

    Ido Sivan-Sevilla, Ido Sivan‐sevilla•Journal of Risk Research•2019

  • Learning to trust Skynet

    Christopher Whyte•Arms Control•2023

  • The dual-use security dilemma and the social construction of insecurity

    Open Access•Amir Lupovici•Arms Control•2021

  • The unexpected norm-setters

    Open Access•Ilina Georgieva•Arms Control•2019

  • Saving face in the cyberspace

    Open Access•Yehonatan Abramson, Gil Baram•Arms Control•2023

  • Cyber-noir

    Open Access•James Shires•Arms Control•2019

  • Cyber security meets security politics

    Open Access•Myriam Dunn Cavelty, Alexandre Wenger et al.•Arms Control•2019

  • Bring the State Back In

    Open Access•Yoonyoung Cho, Jongpil Chung•Pacific Focus•2017

  • The Cyberterrorism Threat

    Lee Jarvis, Stuart Macdonald et al.•Studies in Conflict and Terrorism•2013

  • The macrosecuritization of antimicrobial resistance in Asia

    Catherine Yuk-ping Lo, Nicholas Thomas•Australian Journal Of International…•2018

  • A sociosemiotic interpretation of cybersecurity in U.S. legislative discourse

    Le Cheng, Jiamin Pei et al.•Social Semiotics•2019

  • Disinformation, security politics, and legislative outcomes in Africa

    Saaka Sulemana Saaka, Sulemana Alhassan Saaka•African Security Review•2026

  • Securitizing Zika

    Open Access•Clare Wenham, Deborah Barros Leal Farias et al.•Security Dialogue•2019

  • Cybersecurity, race, and the politics of truth

    Open Access•Jeffrey Whyte•Security Dialogue•2022

  • Cyclones in cyberspace

    Open Access•Ronald J Deibert, Rafal Rohozinski et al.•Security Dialogue•2012

  • Designing (de)security

    Open Access•Vibeke Schou Tjalve•Security Dialogue•2011

  • The ‘human’ as referent object

    Open Access•Scott D Watson, Scott Watson•Security Dialogue•2011

  • Vietnam’s nuanced securitization of China’s assertiveness in the South China Sea

    Open Access•Viet D Trinh•The Pacific Review•2025

  • Expertise, Uncertainty, and International Law

    Open Access•Oliver Kessler, Wouter Werner•Leiden Journal of International Law•2013

  • Cyber Gurus’

    Open Access•Kevin Quigley, Calvin Burns et al.•Government Information Quarterly•2015

  • When shutdown is no option

    Open Access•Isabel Skierka•Government Information Quarterly•2022

  • Dancing to the same tune? EU and US approaches to standards setting in the global digital sector

    Open Access•Jamal Shahin•Journal of European Integration•2024

  • Bolts from the blue

    Christopher Whyte•International Interactions•2026

  • Answering the Call

    Miguel Alberto Gomez, Gregory H Winger et al.•International Interactions•2024

  • Cyber Conflict & Domestic Audience Costs

    Ryan Shandler•International Interactions•2025

  • Reconstructing desecuritisation

    Open Access•Lene Hansen•Review of International Studies•2012

  • Securitisation, terror, and control

    Open Access•J Bright•Review of International Studies•2012

  • Intellectual property theft and national security

    Debora Halbert•The Information Society•2016

  • Digital innovation and shelter theory

    Alex Hardy•Journal of Baltic Studies•2024

  • The Meaning of the Cyber Revolution

    Lucas Kello•International Security•2013

  • What Is the Cyber Offense-Defense Balance? Conceptions, Causes, and Assessment

    Rebecca Slayton•International Security•2017

  • Understanding the gap between perceived threats to and preparedness for cybersecurity

    Open Access•Taehyun Nam•Technology in Society•2019

  • Stuxnet revisited

    Jon R Lindsay•Journal of Strategic Studies•2025

  • A Teoria de Securitização e a sua aplicação em artigos publicados em periódicos científicos

    Open Access•Carlos Carlos Vargas Silva, Alexsandro Eugenio Pereira•Revista de Sociologia e Política•2019

  • Echoes of the War in Ukraine

    Open Access•Vassilis Petsinis•Nationalities Papers•2026

  • Discourses of cyberspace securitization in Brazil and in the United States

    Open Access•Luisa Cruz Lobato, Kai Michael Kenkel•Revista Brasileira de Política…•2015

  • Irregular and Infectious? Covid‐19, Ebola and the Securitization of Migration to Southern Europe

    Open Access•Eugenio Cusumano, Martina Abisso et al.•JCMS Journal of Common Market…•2025

  • Failed Securitisation Moves during the 2015 ‘Migration Crisis’

    Open Access•Helen Hintjens•International Migration•2019

  • Internet Shutdowns

    Open Access•Julia Ryng, Guillemette Guicherd et al.•The RUSI Journal•2022

  • Notes on the militarization of Brazilian cybersecurity

    Open Access•Raquel Jorge de Oliveira•Brasiliana- Journal for Brazilian…•2022

  • Cybersecurity, Bureaucratic Vitalism and European Emergency

    Open Access•Stephanie Simon, Marieke De Goede•Theory Culture & Society•2015

  • Contemporary Security Studies

    Alan Collins•Contemporary Security Studies•2022

  • The Closed World

    Paul N Edwards•The Closed World•1996

  • Networks and netwars

    David F Ronfeldt, John Arquilla•Networks and netwars•2001

  • Old Europe, New Europe and the Transatlantic Security Agenda

    Kerry Longhurst, Marcin Zaborowski•Old Europe, New Europe and the…•2013

  • Culture and Security

    M C Williams, Michael Williams•Culture and Security•2007

  • Emerging challenge

    Open Access•H O Hundley, Robert H Anderson•IEEE Technology and Society…•1995

  • Contemporary Security Studies

    Alan Collins•Contemporary Security Studies•2018

  • Ethnic Violence and the Societal Security Dilemma

    Peter Roe, Paul Roe•Ethnic Violence and the Societal…•2004

  • Security

    Barry Buzan, Ole Waever et al.•Security•1997

  • The Politics of Insecurity

    J Huysmans•Politics of Insecurity•2006

  • Hackers and the contested ontology of cyberspace

    Open Access•Helen Nissenbaum•New Media & Society•2004

  • From Social to National Security

    Open Access•Mark Neocleous•Security Dialogue•2006

  • International Organizations, Security Dichotomies and the Trafficking of Persons and Narcotics in Post-Soviet Central Asia

    Open Access•Nicole J Jackson•Security Dialogue•2006

  • Reconfiguring Security

    Open Access•Alexandra Kent•Security Dialogue•2006

  • The Copenhagen School on Tour in Kyrgyzstan

    Open Access•Claire Wilkinson•Security Dialogue•2007

  • Vernacular Security

    Open Access•N Bubandt•Security Dialogue•2005

  • The Little Mermaid's Silent Security Dilemma and the Absence of Gender in the Copenhagen School

    Open Access•Lene Hansen•Millennium Journal of International…•2000

  • The Question of Information Technology in International Relations

    Open Access•James Der Derian•Millennium Journal of International…•2003

  • The Case Against Linking Environmental Degradation and National Security

    Open Access•Daniel Deudney•Millennium Journal of International…•1990

  • Black Code

    Open Access•Ronald J Deibert•Millennium Journal of International…•2003

  • Security, Sovereignty, and the Challenge of World Politics

    Open Access•R B J Walker•Alternatives Global Local Political•1990

  • Identity and security

    Open Access•Bill Mcsweeney•Review of International Studies•1996

  • The concept of security

    Open Access•David A Baldwin•Review of International Studies•1997

  • Cyberwar is coming

    John Arquilla, David Ronfeldt•Comparative Strategy•1993

  • In Defence of Religion

    Open Access•Carsten Bagge Laustsen, Ole Waever•Millennium Journal of International…•2000

  • Observers or Advocates

    Open Access•Johan Eriksson•Cooperation and Conflict•1999

  • Should HIV/Aids Be Securitized? The Ethical Dilemmas of Linking HIV/Aids and Security

    Open Access•Stefan Elbe•International Studies Quarterly•2006

  • Words, Images, Enemies

    Open Access•M C Williams•International Studies Quarterly•2003

  • Identity and the Politics of Security

    Open Access•M C Williams•European Journal of International…•1998

  • The Three Faces of Securitization

    Open Access•Thierry Balzacq•European Journal of International…•2005

  • Revisiting Copenhagen

    Open Access•J Huysmans•European Journal of International…•1998

  • Security and Immigration

    Open Access•D Bigo•Alternatives Global Local Political•2002

  • Governing Terrorism Through Risk

    Open Access•Claudia Aradau, Rens Van Munster•European Journal of International…•2007

  • Returning Practice to the Linguistic Turn

    Open Access•Iver B Neumann•Millennium Journal of International…•2002

Unique citing works139
Citations per year9,27
Citation span2011 - 2026 (16)
Citation velocitycurrent
Highly citedYes
Citation typesNeutral: 135
Ethnos_APP • Open Source Project • MIT License • Frontend v2.0.0 • Privacy and Cookies • API Documentation: api.ethnos.app/docs • API Source Code: GitHub • DOI: 10.5281/zenodo.17049435 • Frontend Source Code: GitHub • DOI: 10.5281/zenodo.17050053 • cruz.rio.br • Expectantes Misericordiae