Skip to main content

ETHNOS_APP

Home • Search • Journals • List 0

Modes of governance

Towards a Conceptual Clarification

Bibliographic Data

ID6289846
AuthorsOliver Treib (0000-0002-2273-4043), Holger Bähr, Gerda Falkner
Year2007
Volume14
Issue1
Pages1-20
Publication date2007-01-01
Peer ReviewedYes
Open AccessNo
TypeARTICLE
VenueJournal of European Public Policy (JOURNAL)
Journal identifiersISSN: 1350-1763 • E-ISSN: 1466-4429
PublisherInforma UK Limited (PUBLISHER • GB)
DOI10.1080/135017606061071406
OpenAlexW2159205749
LanguageEN
Citations received178
References cited31

Recently, political science has seen an intense debate about the phenomenon of ‘governance’. The aim of this paper is to clarify the basic concepts that are at the heart of this debate, notably ‘governance’ and ‘modes of governance’. We argue that most contributions share a common concern for the relationship between state intervention and societal autonomy, but different strands of the literature highlight different facets of this continuum. Existing understandings may be classified according to whether they emphasize the politics, polity or policy dimensions of governance. We use these categories to present a structured overview of different dimensions of modes of governance as they may be found in the literature. In this context, we argue that the classification of modes of governance as ‘old’ or ‘new’ is of little analytical value. Moving from single dimensions to systematic classification schemes and typologies of modes of governance, we highlight a number of shortcomings of existing schemes and suggest an approach that could avoid these weaknesses. As a first step in this approach, we take a closer look at different policy properties of governance and develop a systematic typology of four modes of governance in the policy dimension: coercion, voluntarism, targeting and framework regulation

Autonomy · Context (archaeology · Corporate governance · Dimension (graph theory · Economics · Epistemology · Multi-level governance · Phenomenon · Political science · Politics · Polity · Positive economics · Sociology · Typology · European Union Policy and Governance · Law · Ombudsman and Human Rights · Political Systems and Governance

  • Public Rental Housing Governance in Urban China

    Open Access•Juan Yan•Architecture and the Built…•2021

  • The Neglect of Governance in Forest Sector Vulnerability Assessments

    Open Access•Adam M Wellstead, Michael Howlett et al.•Conservation Ecology•2013

  • The Adaptation Policy Paradox

    Open Access•Jacques Dupuis, Johann Dupuis et al.•Conservation Ecology•2013

  • The Value Base of Water Governance

    Open Access•C Schulz, Julia Martin-Ortega et al.•Ecological Economics•2017

  • Implementing and complying with EU governance outputs

    Open Access•Oliver Treib•Living Reviews in European…•2014

  • Governing Towards Sustainability—Conceptualizing Modes of Governance

    Philipp Lange, Peter Driessen et al.•Journal of Environmental Policy &…•2013

  • The Governance of Sustainable Development

    Open Access•Andrew J Jordan, Andrew Jordan•Environment and Planning C…•2008

  • The governance of smart mobility

    Open Access•Iain Docherty, George Marsden et al.•Transportation Research Part A…•2018

  • Questions of governance

    Open Access•George Marsden, Greg Marsden et al.•Transportation Research Part A…•2017

  • L'instrumentation de l'action publique

    Charlotte Halpern, Pierre Lascoumes et al.•L'instrumentation de l'action…•2014

  • From environmental sustainability to climate change adaptation

    Greg Dingle, Ugo Arbieu et al.•International Journal of Sport…•2026

  • The politics of social responsibility after neoliberalism

    Adrian Kay•Social Responsibility Journal•2026

  • Classification of Governance Forms

    Open Access•Hassan Ghoronh, Azam Babaki Rad•Public Organization Review•2026

  • Altos cargos y transparencia institucional

    Open Access•Manuel Ángel Santana Turégano, Josué Gutiérrez-Barroso et al.•methaodos revista de ciencias…•2025

  • Preserving the Rule of Law Through Transnational Soft Law

    Open Access•Oana Stefan•Hague Journal on the Rule of Law•2024

  • A Systematic Framework to Understand Transnational Governance for Cybersecurity Risks from Digital Trade

    Open Access•Keman Huang, Stuart Madnick et al.•Global Policy•2021

  • Governing urban sustainability transitions

    Jenni Nieminen, Anna Salomaa et al.•Journal of Environmental Planning…•2021

  • Towards an analytical governance framework within the policy dimension in China

    Bing Sun, Mark Baker•Journal of Environmental Planning…•2021

  • Europe’s Transition to Sustainability

    Open Access•Rosa María García Fernández, Jonas J Schoenefeld et al.•The International Spectator•2021

  • Are Governance Modes Alike? An Analysis Based on Bureaucratic Relationships and Skills

    Pedro Luiz Costa Cavalcante, Gabriela Lotta•International Journal of Public…•2022

  • Beyond Borders

    Open Access•Yulan Chen, Sienna Yun Chen et al.•European Journal of Education•2025

  • A bridging framework for studying transition pathways – From systems models to local action in the Swedish heating domain

    Open Access•Måns Nilsson, Adis Dzebo et al.•Technological Forecasting and…•2020

  • Discorsi emergenti nelle politiche di Lifelong Learning per i giovani adulti

    Open Access•Sebastiano Benasso, Valeria Pandolfini•Quaderni di Sociologia•2020

  • Sustainable mobility in the low carbon city

    Open Access•Paul Fenton•Sustainable Cities and Society•2017

  • NGOs, Controversies, and “Opening Up” of Regulatory Governance of Science in India

    Open Access•Poonam Pandey, Aviram Sharma•Bulletin of Science Technology &…•2017

  • Recalibration of village governance models in developing local economy

    Open Access•Ahmad Iman Sukri, Retno Kusumastuti et al.•Cogent Arts and Humanities•2025

  • Environmental governance through information

    Open Access•Arthur P J Mol•Singapore Journal of Tropical…•2009

  • The Evaluation of Complex Infrastructure Projects

    Open Access•Lasse Gerrits, Verweij et al.•Evaluation of Complex Infrastructur…•2018

  • Change or Continuity

    Open Access•Elena A Korosteleva, Elena Korosteleva•International Relations•2011

  • A typology of governance and its implications for tourism policy analysis

    C M Hall•Journal of Sustainable Tourism•2011

  • Disentangling conservation asymmetries through socio‐economic transboundary factors across the Alto Paraná Atlantic Forest of South America

    Open Access•Lía Montti, N Ignacio Gasparri et al.•People and Nature•2026

  • Dissecting the Algorithmic Leviathan

    Open Access•Pascal D König•Philosophy & Technology•2020

  • Industrial Chain Leader System for green governance

    Open Access•Yingbo Li, Zhisheng Hong et al.•Journal of Industrial Ecology•2024

  • Hierarchie und Netzwerk-Governance in russischen Regionen

    Open Access•Sabine Kropp, Johannes Schuhmann•Zeitschrift für Vergleichende…•2014

  • Governance Modes and Interests

    Open Access•Sylvia Kritzinger, Helga Pülzl•Journal of Public Policy•2008

  • Religion and European Integration

    Open Access•Kenneth Houston•Religion Compass•2011

  • Political Science's Engagement With the Sustainability Challenge

    Open Access•Fred Gales, Daniel Goodwin et al.•Sustainable Development•2025

  • Reprint of “Can Earth system interactions be governed? Governance functions for linking climate change mitigation with land use, freshwater and biodiversity protection”

    Open Access•Måns Nilsson, Åsa Persson•Ecological Economics•2012

  • Applying a ‘Value Landscapes Approach’ to Conflicts in Water Governance

    Open Access•C Schulz, Julia Martin-Ortega et al.•Ecological Economics•2017

  • Can Earth system interactions be governed? Governance functions for linking climate change mitigation with land use, freshwater and biodiversity protection

    Open Access•Måns Nilsson, Åsa Persson•Ecological Economics•2012

  • Multi-level governance readiness and regional policy capacity in supporting Indonesia’s new capital development

    Open Access•Andi Nur Fiqhi Utami, Aco Nata Saputra et al.•Frontiers in Political Science•2026

  • Farming out’ biodiversity

    Open Access•Edwin Alblas, Josephine Van Zeben•Earth System Governance•2023

  • Governance for achieving the Sustainable Development Goals

    Open Access•Lisa-Maria Glass, Jens Newig•Earth System Governance•2019

  • Towards explanations for stability and change in modes of environmental governance

    Open Access•D L T Hegger, Hens Runhaar et al.•Earth System Governance•2020

  • Resolving impasses in policy translation

    Open Access•E Minkman•Environment and Planning C…•2022

  • Pandemic responses at the subnational level

    Open Access•Jörgen Sparf, Elia Petridou et al.•European Policy Analysis•2022

  • Future governance of individual energy consumption behavior change—A framework for reflexive designs

    Open Access•Basil Bornemann, Annika Sohre et al.•Energy Research & Social Science•2017

  • It starts at home? Climate policies targeting household consumption and behavioral decisions are key to low-carbon futures

    Open Access•Ghislain Dubois, B K Sovacool et al.•Energy Research & Social Science•2019

  • The how and what of bottom-up governance to change household energy consumption behaviour

    Open Access•Annika Sohre, Iljana Schubert•Energy Research & Social Science•2022

  • The integrated offshore grid in Europe

    Open Access•João Gorenstein Dedecca, Rudi A Hakvoort et al.•Energy Research & Social Science•2019

  • Navigating emergent effects in off-grid systems

    Open Access•Lillian Donna Namujju•Energy Research & Social Science•2024

  • Energy governance and poverty

    Open Access•Morgan Bazilian, Smita Nakhooda et al.•Energy Research & Social Science•2014

  • What is prosumerism for? Exploring the normative dimensions of decentralised energy transitions

    Open Access•Donal Brown, Stephen Hall et al.•Energy Research & Social Science•2020

  • Governing the scalar politics of solar energy

    Open Access•Matthias Galan•Energy Research & Social Science•2022

  • Transmission transitions

    Open Access•Sandra Tenggren, Josefin Wangel et al.•Energy Research & Social Science•2016

  • The European Union and State Building in the Western Balkans

    Open Access•Andrew J Taylor•Politics and Governance•2013

  • Applying a Typology of Governance Modes to Climate Change Adaptation

    Open Access•Danny Bednar, Daniel Henstra•Politics and Governance•2018

  • Towards sustainable integration

    Open Access•Dhiyathad Prateeppornnarong•International Area Studies Review•2020

  • Designing artificial intelligence policy

    Open Access•Fernando Filgueiras•Latin American Policy•2023

  • Making governance networks more democratic

    Erik Hysing, Erik Lundberg•Critical Policy Studies•2015

  • Locking in and locking out

    Annette Löf•Critical Policy Studies•2015

  • Church-EU Dialogue under Article 17.3

    Open Access•Kenneth Houston•Politics and Religion•2013

  • Media Governance

    Open Access•Manuel Puppis•Communication Culture and Critique•2010

  • Effective governance of transnational adaptation initiatives

    Open Access•Adis Dzebo•International Environmental…•2019

  • Toward an International Implementation of Public Policies in Human Rights

    Open Access•Luis Eduardo Zavala de Alba•Politics & Policy•2012

  • Governance quality in Western Balkan countries

    C Kollias, Petros Messis et al.•Journal of Contemporary European…•2024

  • EU governance in times of crisis

    Open Access•Paolo R Graziano, Paolo Graziano et al.•Comparative European Politics•2015

  • The governance of public affairs

    Open Access•Stephen Bell, Andrew Hindmoor•Journal of Public Affairs•2009

  • Examination of the Filyos Valley Project from the governance approach

    Open Access•Rahman Dag, Rabia Büyükpınar•Turkish Studies•2023

  • Governance towards coordination for water resources management

    Open Access•Evelyn Lukat, Andrea Lenschow et al.•Environmental Science & Policy•2023

  • Challenges of adaptation to climate change across multiple scales

    Open Access•Sirkku Juhola, Lisa Westerhoff•Environmental Science & Policy•2011

  • Flood data platform governance

    Open Access•Mahardika Fadmastuti, David J Nowak et al.•Environmental Science & Policy•2024

  • The role of governance modes and meta-governance in the transformation towards sustainable water governance

    Open Access•Claudia Pahl‐wostl•Environmental Science & Policy•2018

  • A conceptual framework for responding to cross-border climate change impacts

    Open Access•Sara Talebian, Magnus Benzie et al.•Environmental Science & Policy•2024

  • The two orders of governance failure

    Open Access•Michael Howlett, M Ramesh•Policy and Society•2014

  • The social purpose of new governance

    Open Access•Bastiaan Van Apeldoorn, Sandy Brian Hager•Journal of International…•2010

  • Not seeing the forest for the trees? The environmental effectiveness of forest certification in Sweden

    Open Access•Peter Schlyter, Ingrid Stjernquist et al.•Forest Policy and Economics•2009

  • Centralized governance for food safety of non-timber forest products

    Open Access•Tae Hoon Kim, Hansol Lee et al.•Forest Policy and Economics•2023

  • Is voluntarism an effective and legitimate way of governing climate adaptation? A study of private forest owners in Sweden

    Open Access•Louise Eriksson, Camilla Sandström•Forest Policy and Economics•2022

  • Divergent interests and ideas around property rights

    Open Access•Anna Sténs, Camilla Sandström•Forest Policy and Economics•2012

  • Analysis of stakeholders' involvement in the implementation of the Natura 2000 network in Slovakia

    Open Access•Flavia Brescancin, Zuzana Dobšinská et al.•Forest Policy and Economics•2017

  • Network governance in national Swiss forest policy

    Open Access•Tobias Schulz, Eva Lieberherr et al.•Forest Policy and Economics•2016

  • Metagovernance and Control of Multi-level Governance Frameworks

    Antonio-Martín Porras-Gómez•Regional & Federal Studies•2013

  • Europe and the rescaling of domestic territorial governance in Ireland

    Mark Callanan•Regional & Federal Studies•2018

  • The unexpected norm-setters

    Open Access•Ilina Georgieva•Arms Control•2019

  • Dealing With Complex Causality in Realist Synthesis

    Open Access•Fritz Sager, Céline Andereggen•American Journal of Evaluation•2011

  • Sustainable Infrastructure

    Open Access•Kei Endo, Jurian Edelenbos et al.•Public Works Management & Policy•2022

  • Urban Policy in Times of Crisis

    Open Access•Roberta Cucca, Costanzo Ranci•Urban Affairs Review•2021

  • Media Governance

    Open Access•Avshalom Ginosar•Communication Theory•2013

  • Governance for Achieving the Sustainable Development Goals

    Open Access•Suriya Ponnambalam, M K Ilampoornan•Sustainable Development•2026

  • Moldova's European Choice

    Elena Korosteleva•Europe Asia Studies•2010

  • Unpacking the cultural aspects of transport automation governance in Finland

    Open Access•Janne J Olin, Miloš N Mladenović•Journal of Transport Geography•2024

  • Bus rapid transit systems as a governance reform project

    Open Access•Michael Poku‐boansi, George Marsden•Journal of Transport Geography•2018

  • Assisted network governance

    Open Access•Denise Gutiérrez, Johannes Glückler•Global Environmental Change•2022

  • Value landscapes and their impact on public water policy preferences

    Open Access•C Schulz, Julia Martin-Ortega et al.•Global Environmental Change•2018

  • Confronting the nitrogen challenge

    Open Access•Piero Morseletto•Global Environmental Change•2018

  • The question of EU legitimacy in the Social OMC peer review process

    Open Access•Dion Curry•Journal of European Social Policy•2016

  • The European Employment Strategy and National Core Executives

    Open Access•Sabina Stiller, Minna Van Gerven•Journal of European Social Policy•2012

  • Knowledge integration

    Open Access•María Evangelina Filippi, Michaela Hordijk et al.•Environment and Urbanization•2014

  • Government Officials' Perceptions of Legitimate Governance Arrangements—Does a Representative Orientation Matter

    Open Access•Stefan Sjöblom•Governance•2025

  • Policy networks

    Bernd Marin, Renate Mayntz•Policy networks•1991

  • Debating Governance

    J Pierre•Debating governance•2000

  • The Coordination of the European Union

    Andrew J Jordan, Andrew Jordan et al.•The coordination of the European…•2006

  • Complying with Europe

    Open Access•Gerda Falkner, Oliver Treib et al.•Complying with Europe•2005

  • The Transformation of Governance in the European Union

    Beate Kohler‐koch, Beate Kohler-Koch et al.•Transformation of Governance in…•1999

  • Governance, order, and change in world politics

    Open Access•James N Rosenau•Governance Without Government•1992

  • Europeanization of Social Partnership in Smaller European Democracies?

    Open Access•Gerda Falkner, Simone Leiber•European Journal of Industrial…•2004

  • Corporatism and the European Community

    Jane A Sargent•The Political Economy of…•1985

  • Governing Complex Societies

    Open Access•J Pierre, B Peters et al.•Governing Complex Societies•2005

  • Fritz W. Scharpf, Games Real Actors Play. Actor-centered Institutionalism in Policy Research, Boulder 1997

    Alexander Petring•Schlüsselwerke der Politikwissensch…•2008

  • Governing as Governance

    Jan Kooiman•Governing as governance•2003

  • Peer review of labour market programmes in the European Union

    Bernard H Casey, Michael Gold•Journal of European Public Policy•2005

  • Industrial citizenship under regime competition

    Wolfgang Streeck•Journal of European Public Policy•1997

  • Alternative Approaches to Governance in the EU

    Open Access•James S Mosher, David M Trubek•JCMS Journal of Common Market…•2003

  • The Rise of ‘New’ Policy Instruments in Comparative Perspective

    Open Access•Andrew J Jordan, Andrew Jordan et al.•Political Studies•2005

  • Government, Interest Groups and Policy Change

    Open Access•Jeremy Richardson•Political Studies•2000

  • The open method of co-ordination and new governance patterns in the EU

    Susana Borra, Kerstin Jacobsson•Journal of European Public Policy•2004

  • A new form of governance? comparing the open method of co-ordination to multilateral surveillance by the IMF and the OECD

    Alphons Schäfer, Armin Schäfer•Journal of European Public Policy•2006

  • Concluding remarks

    Susana Borra, Bent Greve•Journal of European Public Policy•2004

  • European Community Water Policy Standards

    Open Access•Andrew J Jordan, Andrew Jordan•JCMS Journal of Common Market…•1999

  • Introduction

    Open Access•Judith Goldstein, Miles Kahler et al.•International Organization•2000

  • The Concept of Legalization

    Open Access•Kenneth W Abbott, Robert O Keohane et al.•International Organization•2000

  • Governance’ as a bridge between disciplines

    Open Access•Kees Van Kersbergen, Frans Van Waarden•European Journal of Political…•2004

  • Concept Misformation in Comparative Politics

    Open Access•Giovanni Sartori•American Political Science Review•1970

  • Community, market, state-and associations

    Wolfgang Streeck, Philippe C Schmitter•European Sociological Review•1985

Unique citing works178
Citations per year9,89
Citation span2008 - 2026 (19)
Citation velocitycurrent
Highly citedYes
Citation typesNeutral: 174

Tools

Open DOISci-Hub
Ethnos_APP • Open Source Project • MIT License • Frontend v2.0.0 • Privacy and Cookies • API Documentation: api.ethnos.app/docs • API Source Code: GitHub • DOI: 10.5281/zenodo.17049435 • Frontend Source Code: GitHub • DOI: 10.5281/zenodo.17050053 • cruz.rio.br • Expectantes Misericordiae