Skip to main content

ETHNOS_APP

Home • Search • Journals • List 0

Why Democracies Collapse

The Reasons for Democratic Failure and Success

Bibliographic Data

ID6299396
AuthorsAbraham Diskin (Department of Political Science at The Hebrew University of Jerusalem,, corresponding author), Hanna Diskin (Maggie Publishers, Department of Political Science at The Hebrew University of Jerusalem, corresponding author), Reuven Y Hazan (0000-0003-4852-0649, Department of Political Science at The Hebrew University of Jerusalem,, corresponding author)
Year2005
Volume26
Issue3
Pages291-309
Publication date2005-07-01
Peer ReviewedYes
Open AccessYes
TypeARTICLE
VenueInternational Political Science Review (JOURNAL)
Journal identifiersISSN: 0192-5121 • E-ISSN: 1460-373X
PublisherSAGE Publications Inc (PUBLISHER)
DOI10.1177/0192512105053787
OpenAlexW2166650354
LanguageEN
Citations received24
References cited85

Most studies of democratic stability are based within either the socioeconomic or the politico-institutional tradition, but usually not on both. This article combines the two approaches. In all, 11 variables associated with democratic stability are divided into four groups (institutional, societal, mediating, and extraneous) and examined in 30 cases of democratic collapse and 32 cases of stable democracies. Five variables prove to be the most influential on the fate of democracies. When a country scores negatively on four of these five variables it is almost doomed to collapse. Some of the variables prove to be correlated in an opposite way to that which has been suggested in the literature

Democracy · Development economics · Economics · Political economy · Political science · Politics · Positive economics · Socioeconomic status · Sociology · Stability (learning theory · Statistics · Variables · Demography · Electoral Systems and Political Participation · Law · Mathematics · Political Conflict and Governance · Social Policy and Reform Studies

  • Political Transition and Inclusive Development in Malawi

    Open Access•Dan Banik, Blessings Chinsinga•Political Transition and…•2016

  • The Architecture of Government

    Open Access•Daniel Treisman•The Architecture of Government•2007

  • Evidencing and Explaining Democratic Congruence

    Open Access•Christian Welzel, Hans-Dieter Klingemann et al.•SSRN Electronic Journal•2008

  • Supporting liberal democracy with curious students

    Open Access•Fredrik Portin•Higher Education•2025

  • What do voters want out of elections

    Open Access•Semra Sevi, André Blais et al.•Electoral Studies•2026

  • Attitudes Toward Electoral System Reform and Party System Change in the U.S

    Open Access•Quinton Mayne, Swaran P Singh•American Political Science Review•2026

  • Sowing the Seeds of Its Own Destruction

    Open Access•Mark Chou•THEORIA An International Journal…•2012

  • Societal-System Analytics and the Problem of Factionalism in Emerging (and Declining) Democracies

    Open Access•Monty G Marshall, Benjamin R Cole•Social Evolution & History•2023

  • Reversing regimes and concepts

    Open Access•Andrea Cassani, Luca Tomini•European Political Science•2018

  • Lingual and Educational Policy toward “Homeland Minorities” in Deeply Divided Societies

    Open Access•Ayelet Harel-Shalev•Politics & Policy•2009

  • Mind the gap

    Bell Yosef•Journal of Legislative Studies•2025

  • A new integrated model of the formation of coalitions

    Dganit Ofek, Assaf Meydani•Israel Affairs•2016

  • Pakistan’s Democratic Breakdown of 1999

    Open Access•Abi Chamlagai•South Asia Research•2025

  • Long Time Coming

    Bruce E Moon•International Security•2009

  • How instability creates stability

    Open Access•Wouter Veenendaal•Third World Quarterly•2021

  • Toxic friend? The impact of the Russian invasion on democratic backsliding and PRR cooperation in Europe

    Adam Holesch, Piotr Zagórski•West European Politics•2023

  • Presidential Elections and European Party Systems (1848–2020)

    Open Access•Fernando Casal Bértoa, Till Weber•British Journal of Political…•2024

  • When Democracies Fail

    Open Access•Mark Chou•Political Studies Review•2011

  • Off balance

    Open Access•Pascal D König, Markus B Siewert•International Political Science…•2021

  • Political Culture Congruence and Political Stability

    Open Access•Tamir Sheafer, Shaul Shenhav•Journal of Conflict Resolution•2013

  • Varieties of contemporary democratic breakdown and regression

    Open Access•Luca Tomini, Claudius Wagemann•European Journal of Political…•2018

  • Do mutually reinforcing cleavages harm democracy? Inequalities between ethnic groups and autocratization

    Guido Panzano•Democratization•2024

  • Populism and democratic crisis in semi-presidential countries

    Jung-Hsiang Tsai•Democratization•2019

  • The relevance of legitimation – a new framework for analysis

    Christian Von Haldenwang•Contemporary Politics•2017

  • Empirical democratic theory

    Charles F Cnudde•Empirical democratic theory•1969

  • Coalitions in Parliamentary Government

    L Dodd•Coalitions in Parliamentary…•2015

  • Parties and party systems

    Giovanni Sartori•Parties and party systems•1976

  • Polyarchy

    Robert Alan Dahl•Polyarchy•1973

  • Presidents and Assemblies

    Open Access•Matthew Soberg Shugart, John Michael Carey•Presidents and Assemblies•1992

  • Democracies

    Arend Lijphart•Democracies•1984

  • Making and Breaking Governments

    Open Access•Michael Laver, Kenneth A Shepsle•Making and Breaking Governments•1996

  • Electoral Systems and Party Systems

    Arend Lijphart•Electoral systems and party systems•1994

  • The Failure of Presidential Democracy

    Juan J Linz, Arturo Valenzuela et al.•The Failure of Presidential…•1994

  • Multiparty Government

    Michael Laver, Norman Schofield•Multiparty government•1998

  • Political man

    Seymour Martin Lipset•Political man•1983

  • Political parties and political development

    Joseph Lapalombara, Myron Weiner•Political parties and political…•1969

  • Democracy in Plural Societies

    Arend Lijphart•Democracy in Plural Societies•1980

  • Social Choice and Individual Values

    Kenneth J Arrow, Eric S Maskin•Social Choice and Individual Values•2017

  • Contemporary Democracies

    Open Access•G Bingham Powell•Contemporary Democracies•1982

  • Democracy and Development

    Open Access•Adam Przeworski, Michael E Alvarez et al.•Democracy and Development•2000

  • Government Survival in Parliamentary Democracies

    Open Access•Paul Warwick•Government Survival in…•1995

  • Defining and measuring democracy

    Open Access•Michael Coppedge•Democratization and Research…•2012

  • National Political Development

    P Cutright•Comparative Government•1969

  • The Social Requisites of Democracy Revisited

    Seymour Martin Lipset•Einigung und Zerfall :…•1995

  • Defining and Measuring Democracy

    Renske Doorenspleet•Democratic Transitions•2005

  • Politics in Developing Countries

    Christian Coulon, Jyotirindra Das Gupta et al.•Politics in Developing Countries•1990

  • Political Culture and Democracy in Developing Countries

    Larry Diamond•Political Culture and Democracy…•1993

  • Conditions of Democracy in Europe, 1919–39

    Open Access•Dirk Berg‐schlosser, Dirk Berg-Schlosser et al.•Conditions of Democracy in Europe…•2000

  • Authoritarianism and Democracy in Europe, 1919–39

    Open Access•Dirk Berg‐schlosser, Dirk Berg-Schlosser et al.•Authoritarianism and Democracy in…•2002

  • Patterns of democracy

    Laura Morales Diez De Ulzurrun•Choice Reviews Online•2000

  • The Breakdown of Democratic Regimes

    Juan J Linz, Juan Linz•The breakdown of democratic…•1978

  • Problems of Democratic Transition and Consolidation

    Juan J Linz, Juan Linz et al.•Problems of democratic transition…•1996

  • Capitalism, Socialism and Democracy

    Gaël Fain, Joseph Alois Schumpeter et al.•Capitalism, socialism, and…•2010

  • Presidents vs. Parliaments

    Open Access•Donald L Horowitz•Journal of democracy•1990

  • Modernization and political representation

    Open Access•Phillips Cutright, James A Wiley et al.•Studies in Comparative…•1969

  • Contemporary Democracies

    Open Access•William J Long•Political Science Quarterly•1984

  • Comparative Constitutional Engineering

    Open Access•Peter C Ordeshook•Political Science Quarterly•1995

  • Modern Political Parties

    Brian Chapman•International Affairs•1956

  • Political Parties

    Brian Chapman•International Affairs•1955

  • The Southern European Examples of Democratization

    Open Access•Arend Lijphart•Government and Opposition•1990

  • Conditions of Democracy in Interwar Europe

    Dirk Berg-Schlosser, Dirk Berg‐schlosser et al.•Comparative Politics•1994

  • Multivariate Analysis of National Political Development

    Marvin E Olsen•American Sociological Review•1968

  • National Political Development

    Phillips Cutright•American Sociological Review•1963

  • Centre parties and anti‐system oppositions in polarised systems

    Giuseppe Ieraci•West European Politics•1992

  • The Debate over Electoral Systems

    Open Access•André Blais•International Political Science…•1991

  • Center Parties and Systemic Polarization

    Open Access•Reuven Y Hazan•Journal of Theoretical Politics•1995

  • What Makes Democracies Endure

    Open Access•José Antônio Cheibub, Adam Przeworski et al.•Journal of democracy•1996

  • Three Paradoxes of Democracy

    Open Access•L Diamond, Larry Jay Diamond•Journal of democracy•1990

  • The Challenge of Ethnic Conflict

    Open Access•Donald L Horowitz•Journal of democracy•1993

  • Constitutional Choices for New Democracies

    Open Access•Arend Lijphart•Journal of democracy•1991

  • The Perils of Presidentialism

    Open Access•Juan J Linz•Journal of democracy•1990

  • Debate—Proportional Representation

    Open Access•Guy Lardeyret•Journal of democracy•1991

  • Dynamic Factors in Government Coalition Formation

    Open Access•Michael Laver•European Journal of Political…•1974

  • Institutional Design and Democratic Consolidation in the Third World

    Open Access•Timothy J Power, Mark J Gasiorowski et al.•Comparative Political Studies•1997

  • The Structural Determinants of Democratic Consolidation

    Open Access•Mark J Gasiorowski, Mark Gasiorowski et al.•Comparative Political Studies•1998

  • Presidentialism, Multipartism, and Democracy

    Open Access•Scott Mainwaring•Comparative Political Studies•1993

  • Effective” Number of Parties

    Open Access•Markku Laakso, Rein Taagepera•Comparative Political Studies•1979

  • Measures of Cabinet Durability

    Open Access•Arend Lijphart•Comparative Political Studies•1984

  • Party Systems and Patterns of Government in Western Democracies

    Open Access•Jean Blondel•Canadian Journal of Political…•1968

  • The Process of Cabinet Dissolution

    Eric C Browne, John P Frendreis et al.•American Journal of Political…•1986

  • Extremist Parties and Political Turmoil

    G Bingham Powell•American Journal of Political…•1986

  • A Unified Model of Cabinet Dissolution in Parliamentary Democracies

    Gary King, James E Alt et al.•American Journal of Political…•1990

  • Democracy with Adjectives

    Open Access•Donald Collier, David Collier et al.•World Politics•1997

  • Modern Political Parties

    Ithiel De Sola Pool, Sigmund Neumann et al.•American Sociological Review•1956

  • Economic Determinants of Democracy

    Edward N Muller•American Sociological Review•1995

  • The Social Requisites of Democracy Revisited

    Seymour Martin Lipset•American Sociological Review•1994

  • Political Democracy and the Timing of Development

    K A Bollen•American Sociological Review•1979

  • Political Democracy and the Size Distribution of Income

    K A Bollen, Robert W Jackman•American Sociological Review•1985

  • Democracy, Economic Development, and Income Inequality

    Edward N Muller•American Sociological Review•1988

  • Proportionality, disproportionality and electoral systems

    Open Access•Michael Gallagher•Electoral Studies•1991

  • Contending Models of Cabinet Stability

    Open Access•Kaare W Strøm, Kaare Strom et al.•American Political Science Review•1988

  • The Renaissance of Political Culture

    Open Access•Ronald Inglehart•American Political Science Review•1988

  • Some Social Requisites of Democracy

    Open Access•Seymour Martin Lipset•American Political Science Review•1959

  • Toward a Theory of Constitutional Amendment

    Open Access•Donald S Lutz•American Political Science Review•1994

  • Concept Misformation in Comparative Politics

    Open Access•Giovanni Sartori•American Political Science Review•1970

  • Political Stability of Two-Party and Multiparty Systems

    Open Access•Manus I Midlarsky•American Political Science Review•1984

  • Party Systems and Government Stability

    Open Access•Michael Taylor, V M Herman et al.•American Political Science Review•1971

Unique citing works24
Citations per year1,26
Citation span2007 - 2026 (20)
Citation velocitycurrent
Highly citedNo
Citation typesNeutral: 23

Tools

Open DOISci-Hub
Ethnos_APP • Open Source Project • MIT License • Frontend v2.0.0 • Privacy and Cookies • API Documentation: api.ethnos.app/docs • API Source Code: GitHub • DOI: 10.5281/zenodo.17049435 • Frontend Source Code: GitHub • DOI: 10.5281/zenodo.17050053 • cruz.rio.br • Expectantes Misericordiae