Skip to main content

ETHNOS_APP

Home • Search • Journals • List 0

May's Law of Curvilinear Disparity Revisited

Leaders, Officers, Members and Voters in British Political Parties

Bibliographic Data

ID6316619
AuthorsP Norris (0000-0001-8632-4636, corresponding author)
Year1995
Volume1
Issue1
Pages29-47
Publication date1995-01-01
Peer ReviewedYes
Open AccessYes
TypeARTICLE
VenueParty Politics (JOURNAL)
Journal identifiersISSN: 1354-0688 • E-ISSN: 1460-3683
PublisherSAGE Publications Inc (PUBLISHER)
DOI10.1177/1354068895001001002
OpenAlexW2093116845
LanguageEN
Citations received97
References cited23

Explaining ideological conflict has always been a classic theme of studies of party organizations. The aim of this paper is to re-examine May's law, based on rational choice theory, which suggests that due to differential incentives sub-leaders are likely to prove the most extreme stratum in party organizations, while non-leaders are the most moderate, and top leaders are located equidistant between these groups. The study, based on large-scale surveys of politicians, local constituency officers, party members and voters in the 1992 British general election, throws considerable doubt on this proposition

Constraint (computer-aided design · Economics · Epistemology · Ideology · Incentive · Law and economics · Political science · Politics · Proposition · Sociology · Theme (computing · Electoral Systems and Political Participation · Gender Politics and Representation · Law · Political Influence and Corporate Strategies

  • Re-electing the party leader

    Open Access•Panos Koliastasis, Andrew Denham•Party Politics•2026

  • Technopopulism

    Christopher J Bickerton, Carlo Invernizzi Accetti•Technopopulism•2021

  • Rethinking Party Reform

    Fabio Wolkenstein•Rethinking Party Reform•2019

  • The Alliance Party of Northern Ireland

    Jonathan Tonge, Máire Braniff et al.•The Alliance Party of Northern…•2024

  • Party Competition between Unequals

    Open Access•Bonnie M Meguid•Party Competition Between Unequals•2008

  • Parties Without Partisans

    Martin P Wattenberg, Martin Wattenberg et al.•Parties without partisans•2002

  • The Politics of Electoral Reform

    Open Access•Alan Renwick•Politics of Electoral Reform•2010

  • Origines et impacts des hyper-utilisateurs et hyper-utilisatrices en cyberdémocratie. Le cas du pétitionnement en ligne

    J Bright, Jean-Benoit Pilet et al.•Participations•2021

  • Power users in online democracy

    J Bright, Sandra Bermúdez et al.•Information Communication & Society•2020

  • The Electoral Success of the Left in Latin America

    Open Access•Juan Andrés Moraes, Diego Luján•Latin American Research Review•2020

  • Party institutionalization and intra-party preference homogeneity

    Open Access•Matthias Mader, Nils D Steiner•Zeitschrift für Vergleichende…•2019

  • Har den interna demokratin i politiska partier försämrats över tid

    Open Access•Karl Loxbo•Sociologisk Forskning•2009

  • La relation entre le mode de sélection des candidats et la congruence idéologique entre masses et élites

    Audrey Vandeleene, Conrad Meulewaeter et al.•Politique et Sociétés•2017

  • Policy congruence and strategic loyalty

    Open Access•Marcel Lewandowsky•Political Research Exchange•2019

  • The beliefs of young parliamentary candidates on democracy and the moderation role of populism

    Open Access•Marco Lisi, João Gaio E Silva•Political Research Exchange•2025

  • Parliamentary candidate selection in the Conservative Party

    Open Access•Mark Low•British Politics•2014

  • Deliberative democracy and political parties

    Open Access•Gherghina, Sorina Soares et al.•European Political Science•2020

  • New forms of political participation. Changing demands or changing opportunities to participate in political parties

    Open Access•Florence Faucher•Comparative European Politics•2014

  • A digital principal? Substantive representation in the case of the Italian Five Star Movement

    Open Access•Lorenzo Mosca, Davide Vittori•European Societies•2022

  • Membership ballots and the value of intra-party democracy

    Fabio Wolkenstein•Critical Review of International…•2016

  • The British Labour Party’s leadership election of 2015

    Open Access•Thomas Quinn•The British Journal of Politics…•2016

  • Parliamentarians versus party members? Leadership selection systems in the British Conservative and Labour parties

    Open Access•Thomas Quinn•The British Journal of Politics…•2023

  • Electing the Leader

    Open Access•Thomas Quinn•The British Journal of Politics…•2004

  • Political Participation

    Open Access•Justin Fisher, Paul D Webb•The British Journal of Politics…•2003

  • Congruence between voters and representatives in preferences for social policies in Spain

    Antonio M Jaime‐castillo, Xavier Coller Porta•Journal of Legislative Studies•2022

  • Party research and party support aid

    Open Access•Susan E Scarrow, Fernando Casal Bértoa•Party Politics•2026

  • New people, new policy

    Open Access•Matthias Kaltenegger, Wolfgang C Müller•Party Politics•2024

  • Social media partisans vs. party members

    Karina Kosiara-Pedersen, Emilie Van Haute et al.•West European Politics•2026

  • Representative versus Responsible Government and May's Law

    Open Access•Lukáš Linek, Pat Lyons•Czech Sociological Review•2011

  • Great minds think alike? Ideological congruence between party members and leadership candidates

    Open Access•Audrey Vandeleene, Pieter Moens et al.•Acta Politica•2024

  • May’s Law in changing times—an empirical assessment of the German case

    Open Access•Frederik Springer•Acta Politica•2026

  • Analyzing ideological disparities in multi-speed membership parties

    Open Access•Bruno Marino, Antonella Seddone et al.•Acta Politica•2026

  • Declining memberships, changing members? European political party members in a new era

    Open Access•Susan E Scarrow, Burcu Gezgor•Party Politics•2010

  • Bringing agency back into the study of partisan politics

    Open Access•Georg Wenzelburger, Reimut Zohlnhöfer•Party Politics•2021

  • The impact of party organisational changes on democracy

    Elin Haugsgjerd Allern, Karina Kosiara-Pedersen et al.•West European Politics•2007

  • Party goals and interest group influence on parties

    Open Access•Maiken Røed•West European Politics•2022

  • Politicians’ Labor Market Experiences Across Party Families

    Olle Folke, Johanna Rickne et al.•The Journal of Politics•2025

  • Representation and Policy Responsiveness

    Shin-Goo Kang, G Bingham Powell•The Journal of Politics•2010

  • Why Do Parties Change Position? Party Organization and Environmental Incentives

    G Schumacher, Catherine E De Vries et al.•The Journal of Politics•2013

  • Losing Touch? The Political Representativeness of Swedish Parties, 1985–1994

    Open Access•Anders Widfeldt•Scandinavian Political Studies•1999

  • Party Reforms and Electoral Systems

    Fabio Wolkenstein•Representation•2021

  • Participating Locally and Nationally

    Open Access•Tim Bale, Paul Webb et al.•Political Studies•2019

  • Pragmatists, Ideologues and the General Law of Curvilinear Disparity

    Open Access•Fiachra Kennedy, Pat Lyons et al.•Political Studies•2006

  • A Reconceptualisation of the Antecedents of Party Activism

    Open Access•Sue Granik•Political Studies•2005

  • Not as Bad as We Feared or Even Worse Than We Imagined? Assessing and Explaining Conservative Party Members’ Views on Coalition

    Open Access•Tim Bale, Paul Webb et al.•Political Studies•2016

  • Are Political Staffers out of Touch with Grassroots Party Members? Assessing Congruence between Professionals and Volunteers

    Open Access•Pieter Moens•Political Studies•2024

  • The Death of May’s Law

    Open Access•Alan Wager, Tim Bale et al.•Political Studies•2022

  • Inclusivity and Decentralisation of Candidate Selectorates

    Open Access•Mike Cowburn, Rebecca Kerr•Political Research Quarterly•2023

  • Intra-party conflict at grassroots

    Open Access•Marko Kukec•Party Politics•2019

  • The party (un)faithful

    Open Access•Benjamin De Vet, Monica Poletti et al.•Party Politics•2019

  • May’s law may prevail

    Open Access•Oskar Hultin Bäckersten•Party Politics•2022

  • Rethinking intra-party cohesion

    Open Access•Caroline Close, Gherghina•Party Politics•2019

  • Effects of party primaries on electoral performance

    Open Access•Luis Ramiro•Party Politics•2016

  • Radical or aligned? Assessing issue congruence between youth wing elites, parliamentary candidates and voters in Norway

    Open Access•Kristoffer Kolltveit, Rune Karlsen•Party Politics•2025

  • Emancipated party members

    Open Access•Ann-Kristin Kölln, Jonathan Polk•Party Politics•2017

  • The Problem with Party Finance

    Open Access•Jonathan Hopkins•Party Politics•2004

  • Social and ideological representativeness

    Open Access•Aki Koivula, Ilkka Koiranen et al.•Party Politics•2020

  • Explaining the Party-Policy Link

    Open Access•Rosa Mulè•Party Politics•1997

  • Candidate selection methods and policy cohesion in parties

    Open Access•Daniel M Smith, Hidenori Tsutsumi•Party Politics•2016

  • From May’s Laws to May’s legacy

    Open Access•Joop Jm Van Holsteyn, Josje M Den Ridder et al.•Party Politics•2017

  • The Origins of Opinion of American Party Activists

    Open Access•Richard Herrera•Party Politics•1999

  • The lives of the party

    Open Access•Jonathan Polk, Ann-Kristin Kölln•Party Politics•2017

  • Democracy within Norwegian Political Parties

    Open Access•Jo Saglie, Knut Heidar•Party Politics•2004

  • Being the opposition in contemporary Russia

    Open Access•Ekaterina Levintova, Екатерина Левинтова•Party Politics•2012

  • The limits of organizational innovation and multi-speed membership

    Open Access•Reid Gómez, Raul Gomez et al.•Party Politics•2019

  • Ideological misfits

    Open Access•Emilie Van Haute, R Kenneth Carty•Party Politics•2012

  • The consequences of membership incentives

    Open Access•Susan Achury, Susan E Scarrow et al.•Party Politics•2020

  • Does policy motivation drive party activism? A study of party activists in three Asian democracies

    Open Access•Sejin Koo•Party Politics•2021

  • Intra-party heterogeneity in policy preferences and its effect on issue salience

    Open Access•Nils D Steiner, Matthias Mader•Party Politics•2019

  • Does the mode of candidate selection affect the representativeness of parties

    Open Access•Dennis Christopher Spies, Andrea Kaiser et al.•Party Politics•2014

  • When does the left do the right thing? A study of party position change on welfare policies

    Open Access•G Schumacher•Party Politics•2015

  • Ruling Majority and Opposition

    Mikael Gilljam, David Karlsson•Parliamentary Affairs•2015

  • Leadership Elections

    Florence Faucher•Parliamentary Affairs•2015

  • Swedish politicians’ preferences regarding the privatisation of elderly care

    Ming Guo, Sam Willner•Local Government Studies•2017

  • Congressional Leadership 1965–96

    Open Access•B Grofman, William Koetzle et al.•Legislative Studies Quarterly•2002

  • Why primaries? The party’s tradeoff between policy and valence

    Open Access•Gilles Serra•Journal of Theoretical Politics•2011

  • Attract voters or appease activists? Opposition parties’ dilemma and party policy change

    Open Access•Florence So•Journal of Theoretical Politics•2018

  • Politics matters

    Tim Bale•Journal of European Public Policy•2008

  • The Social Democratic Party of Germany (SPD) and Immigration Policies

    Suat Alper Orhan•German Politics•2025

  • Still Connected? Attitudinal Representativeness of German Party Memberships

    Tim Spier•German Politics•2019

  • What parties want from their leaders

    Open Access•Laurenz Ennser-Jedenastik, G Schumacher•European Journal of Political…•2021

  • Young radicals, moderates and aligned

    Open Access•Duncan Mcdonnell, Sofia Ammassari et al.•European Journal of Political…•2025

  • The Ideological Congruence Controversy

    Open Access•G Bingham Powell•Comparative Political Studies•2009

  • Structuring Intra-Party Politics

    Open Access•Ann-Kristin Kölln, Jonathan Polk•Comparative Political Studies•2024

  • Postmatérialisme et clivages partisans au Québec

    Open Access•Réjean Pelletier, Daniel Guerin•Canadian Journal of Political…•1996

  • Political Representation in Comparative Politics

    Open Access•G Bingham Powell•Annual Review of Political Science•2004

  • The Impact of Campaign Finance Laws on Party Competition

    Open Access•Joshua D Potter, M Tavits•British Journal of Political…•2015

  • A Test of Core Vote Theories

    Open Access•Jane Green•British Journal of Political…•2011

  • What Makes Parties Adapt to Voter Preferences? The Role of Party Organization, Goals and Ideology

    Open Access•Daniel Bischof, Markus Wagner•British Journal of Political…•2020

  • Which Factors Influence Issue Salience in Electoral Manifestos? New Insights From the Salience of Social Services in Dutch Local Elections

    Open Access•Joes De Natris•Swiss Political Science Review•2025

  • Mobilising volunteer activists in political parties

    Jennifer Lees-Marshment, Jennifer Lees‐marshment et al.•Contemporary Politics•2014

  • Australian Greens party members and supporters

    Anika Gauja, Stewart Jackson•Environmental Politics•2016

  • Fifty Shades of Green? Political differences between elites, members and supporters ofEurope Ecologie Les Verts

    Florence Faucher, Daniel Boy•Environmental Politics•2018

  • So who really does the donkey work in 'multi-speed membership parties'? Comparing the election campaign activity of party members and party supporters

    Open Access•Paul Webb, Paul D Webb et al.•Electoral Studies•2017

  • Transformação intrapartidária? Um estudo sobre as percepções de poder e gestão entre jovens filiados

    Open Access•João V Guedes Neto•Revista de Sociologia e Política•2018

  • The Crisis of Party Democracy, Cognitive Mobilization, and the Case for Making Parties More Deliberative

    Open Access•Carlo Invernizzi-Accetti, Carlo Invernizzi Accetti et al.•American Political Science Review•2017

  • Reducing the gap between leaders and voters? Elite polarization, outbidding competition, and the rise of secessionism in Catalonia

    Astrid Barrio, Juan Rodríguez-Teruel•Ethnic and Racial Studies•2017

  • The new Presidential elite

    Jeane J Kirkpatrick•The new Presidential elite•1976

  • Political Parties in Western Democracies

    Leon D Epstein•Political Parties in Western…•2020

  • British Social Attitudes

    Alison Park, John Curtice et al.•British Social Attitudes•2010

  • Democracy and the Organization of Political Parties

    Moisei Ostrogorski•Democracy and the Organization of…•2018

  • The Political Attitudes of Australian Voters and Candidates

    Open Access•I Mcallister•Australian Journal of Social Issues•1991

  • The Problem of Party Government

    Dean E Mchenry, Richard Rose•The Western Political Quarterly•1976

  • Power in the Labour Party

    Open Access•Ivan Yates•The Political Quarterly•1960

  • Labour's last chance? The 1992 election and beyond

    Martin Harrison•International Affairs•1995

  • The Internal Politics of Parties

    Open Access•Herbert Kitschelt•Political Studies•1989

  • Opinion Structure of Political Parties

    Open Access•John D’arcy May•Political Studies•1973

  • The Structure of Opinion in American Political Parties

    Open Access•Richard Herrera, Melanie K Taylor•Political Studies•1994

  • Do Candidates Make a Difference? Gender, Race, Ideology and Incumbency

    P Norris, Elizabeth Vallance et al.•Parliamentary Affairs•1992

  • The Logics of Electoral Politics

    Open Access•Trine Iversen, Torben Iversen•Comparative Political Studies•1994

  • Political Parties and Political Representation

    Open Access•Russell J Dalton•Comparative Political Studies•1985

  • American Behavioral Scientist

    Open Access•Sara Miller Mccune, George D Mccune•American Behavioral Scientist•1977

  • Issue Conflict and Consensus among Party Leaders and Followers

    Open Access•Herbert Mcclosky, Paul J Hoffmann et al.•American Political Science Review•1960

  • Did the British marginals vanish? Proportionality and exaggeration in the British electoral system revisited

    Open Access•P Norris, Ivor Crewe•Electoral Studies•1994

  • The Political Ideas of English Party Activists

    Open Access•Richard Rose•American Political Science Review•1962

  • Intraparty Attitude Conflict

    Edmond Costantini•The Western Political Quarterly•1963

  • Constituency Labour Parties in Britain

    Open Access•Stephen Mennell•Sociology•1969

Unique citing works97
Citations per year3,23
Citation span1996 - 2026 (31)
Citation velocitycurrent
Highly citedNo
Citation typesNeutral: 96

Tools

Open DOISci-Hub
Ethnos_APP • Open Source Project • MIT License • Frontend v2.0.0 • Privacy and Cookies • API Documentation: api.ethnos.app/docs • API Source Code: GitHub • DOI: 10.5281/zenodo.17049435 • Frontend Source Code: GitHub • DOI: 10.5281/zenodo.17050053 • cruz.rio.br • Expectantes Misericordiae