Skip to main content

ETHNOS_APP

Home • Search • Journals • List 0

It Takes a Village

A Test of the Creative Class, Social Capital, and Human Capital Theories

Bibliographic Data

ID6404645
AuthorsMichele Hoyman (University of North Carolina at Chapel Hill), Michele M Hoyman (0000-0003-2975-9179, University of North Carolina at Chapel Hill), Christopher Faricy (University of North Carolina at Chapel Hill)
Year2009
Volume44
Issue3
Pages311-333
Publication date2009-01-01
Peer ReviewedYes
Open AccessYes
TypeARTICLE
VenueUrban Affairs Review (JOURNAL)
Journal identifiersISSN: 1078-0874 • E-ISSN: 1552-8332
PublisherSAGE Publications Inc (PUBLISHER)
DOI10.1177/1078087408321496
OpenAlexW3125876381
LanguageEN
Citations received75
References cited47

Richard Florida argues that the “creative class” is inextricably connected with surges in urban growth. This article, using data from 276 metropolitan statistical areas, empirically tests the creative class theory as compared to the human and social capital models of economic growth. Our results demonstrate that the creative class is not related to growth, whereas human capital predicts economic growth and development and social capital predicts average wage but not job growth. Additionally, we found that clusters of universities correlated highly with economic growth. Our findings should warn policy makers against the use of “creative” strategies for urban economic development

Class (philosophy · Classical economics · Creative class · Creativity · Demographic economics · Development economics · Economic geography · Economic growth · Economics · Geography · Growth theory · Human capital · Job creation · Labour economics · Market economy · Metropolitan area · Political science · Social capital · Social class · Social science · Sociology · Wage · Wage growth · Cultural Industries and Urban Development · Regional Economics and Spatial Analysis · Social and Cultural Dynamics

  • Neo-liberal urban planning policies

    Open Access•Tore Sager•Progress in Planning•2011

  • The Nexus between Creative Actors and Regional Development

    Open Access•Kamila Borsekova, Anna Vaňová et al.•Land•2021

  • Creative Workforce and Economic Development in Precrisis Europe

    Open Access•Alessandro Crociata, M Agovino et al.•International Regional Science…•2018

  • Impacts of multi-functionality of urban agriculture on the CCs in Japan

    Open Access•Lily Kiminami, Akira Kiminami et al.•Asia-Pacific Journal of Regional…•2018

  • Public policies and multilevel governance to promote the creative economy from the cultural fi eld

    Open Access•Mario Procopiuck, Schirlei Mari Freder•Nova Economia•2020

  • Urban tourism and the politic of creative class

    Yang Zhang, Xiong Yu et al.•International Journal of Tourism…•2018

  • Impacts of multi-functionality of urban agriculture on the creative classes in global mega city

    Open Access•Lily Kiminami, Shinichi Furuzawa et al.•Asia-Pacific Journal of Regional…•2019

  • Creative Cities and (Un)Sustainability

    Open Access•Sacha Kagan, Julia Hahn•Culture and Local Governance•2011

  • Home from Home? Locational Choices of International “Creative Class” Workers

    Julie Brown•European Planning Studies•2015

  • A creativity-led rural renaissance? Amenity-led migration, the creative turn and the uneven development of rural Australia

    Open Access•Neil Argent, Matthew Tonts et al.•Applied Geography•2013

  • Smart endogenous growth

    Open Access•Alberto Bucci, P L Sacco et al.•International Journal of Manpower•2014

  • Painting the Nation

    Open Access•Victoria Rodner, Victoria L Rodner et al.•Journal of Macromarketing•2016

  • Booming Bohemia? Evidence from the US High-Technology Industry

    David S Bieri, David Bieri•Industry and Innovation•2010

  • Does culture affect local productivity and urban amenities?

    Brahim Boualam•Regional Science and Urban…•2014

  • Drivers and Processes of Creative Industries in Cities and Regions

    Caroline Chapain, Lisa De Propris•Creative Industries Journal•2009

  • The effect on economic development of creative class versus human capital

    Esubalew Alehegn Tiruneh, Silvia Sacchetti et al.•European Planning Studies•2021

  • Is creativity a reality in Bulgaria cities? An empirical study in the pre-pandemic period

    Open Access•Margarida Rodrigues, Mário Franco et al.•City, Territory and Architecture•2024

  • The Renewal of a Concept

    Open Access•Karyn Cooper, Laurel Waterman•International Review of…•2024

  • The geography of the Super Creative Class in the greater Tokyo area

    Open Access•Makoto Ikegaya, Keith G Debbage et al.•City Culture and Society•2023

  • Calgary and the 'creative class'

    Open Access•Rylan Graham•City Culture and Society•2023

  • Innovativeness, creativity and public policy

    Alan Collins•Creative Industries Journal•2009

  • Development policies and creative ecologies

    Mario Procopiuck, Fabíola Bevervanço Zdepski et al.•Creative Industries Journal•2025

  • Racial and Ethnic Politics in American Suburbs

    Open Access•Lorrie Frasure-Yokley•Racial and Ethnic Politics in…•2015

  • Let’s Audit Bohemia

    Open Access•Cian O’callaghan•Geography Compass•2010

  • Towards a Practice-based Model for Community Practice

    Amnon Boehm, Ram A Cnaan•The Journal of Sociology & Social…•2012

  • Assembling the Puzzle of the Nonprofit-Economic Development Linkage

    Open Access•John F Brennan, Laurie E Paarlberg et al.•Nonprofit Policy Forum•2013

  • Creatives after the crash

    B Donald, M S Gertler et al.•Cambridge Journal of Regions…•2013

  • Fair Weather Friends? The Impact of the Creative Class on the Economic Health of Mid-sized US Metropolitan Areas, 1990-2009

    Gary Sands, Laura A Reese•Cambridge Journal of Regions…•2012

  • Global cities, global justice

    Loren King, Michael Blake•Journal of Global Ethics•2018

  • Bourdieu and urban politics

    Open Access•Yongjun Shin•Planning Theory•2012

  • The rural growth trifecta

    Open Access•David A Mcgranahan, Timothy R Wojan et al.•Journal of Economic Geography•2010

  • Determinants of rural creative microclustering

    Open Access•Jorge Andrés Vélez-Ospina, Jorge A Velez‐Ospina et al.•Papers of the Regional Science…•2023

  • After Florida

    Open Access•Max Nathan•European Urban and Regional Studies•2012

  • Gentrification and the evolution of commuting behavior within America's urban cores, 2000–2015

    Open Access•Bradley Bereitschaft•Journal of Transport Geography•2019

  • Broadband and the creative industries in rural Scotland

    Open Access•Leanne C Townsend, Leanne Townsend et al.•Journal of Rural Studies•2016

  • The creative fire

    Open Access•Bruce Balfour, Michael W-P Fortunato et al.•Journal of Rural Studies•2016

  • From Coal to Cool”

    Meghan Ashlin Rich•Journal of Urban Affairs•2012

  • Are Central Cities More Creative? the Intrametropolitan Geography of Creative Industries

    Ric Kolenda, Cathy Yang Liu•Journal of Urban Affairs•2012

  • What about Culture for the Ordinary Workforce? A Study on the Locational Preferences of the Creative Class in Prenzlauer Berg, Berlin

    Sjoerdje Van Heerden, Marco Bontje•Journal of Urban Affairs•2013

  • Geographies of sexualities in sub-Saharan Africa

    Open Access•Alan Tucker•Progress in Human Geography•2019

  • Reconstructing Urban Politics with a B ourdieusian Framework

    Open Access•Yongjun Shin•International Journal of Urban…•2014

  • If All You Have Is A Hammer

    Open Access•Laura A Reese•The American Review of Public…•2013

  • Does County Form of Government Impact Economic Growth and Development Trends? The Case of Four States

    Open Access•Stephanie A Pink‐Harper, Stephanie A Pink-Harper•The American Review of Public…•2016

  • Contingent Valuation and Estimates of Residents’ Support for Revitalization Plans

    Open Access•Mark S Rosentraub, John F Brennan•The American Review of Public…•2010

  • Creative workers' perception of place in Edmonton Canada

    Open Access•Craig Thomas, Craig J Thomas•Cities•2023

  • Marketing the unmarketable

    Open Access•Katherine VanHoose, Myrte Hoekstra et al.•Cities•2021

  • Leisure choices of the creative class

    Open Access•Eric Joseph Van Holm•Cities•2014

  • Impacts of transit and walking amenities on robust local knowledge economy

    Open Access•Ahoura Zandiatashbar, Shima Hamidi•Cities•2018

  • Agency and Empowerment under Unlikely Conditions

    Open Access•Julie Stewart•Humanity & Society•2011

  • Understanding culture-led local development

    Open Access•P L Sacco, Pierluigi Sacco et al.•Urban Studies•2014

  • Behind a bicycling boom

    Open Access•Kevin T Smiley, Wanda Rushing et al.•Urban Studies•2016

  • The Arts and Local Economic Development

    Open Access•Mario Polèse•Urban Studies•2012

  • Importance of Social Capital in Coping With and Benefiting From New Economic Conditions

    Open Access•Ayda Eraydin, BILGE ARMATLI‐KÖROĞLU et al.•Tijdschrift voor Economische en…•2012

  • Disasters and Social Capital

    Open Access•Lili Wang, N Emel Ganapati•Social Science Quarterly•2018

  • A Good Place to Live? On Municipality Characteristics and Children’s Placement Risk

    Signe H Andersen•Social Service Review•2010

  • Drinking from the Talent Pool

    Open Access•Manuel P Teodoro, Donna Switzer et al.•Public Administration Review•2016

  • Changing Degrees

    Ami Zusman•The Journal of Higher Education•2016

  • Creative industries, creative class and competitiveness

    Open Access•Marco Bontje, Sako Musterd•Geoforum•2009

  • Competing Conceptions of the Creative University

    Michael A Peters•Educational Philosophy and Theory•2013

  • Montagne in Movimento

    Open Access•Raffaele Spadano, P L Sacco•Cities•2026

  • The Spatial Mobility of the ‘Creative Class

    Open Access•HELENE MARTIN‐BRELOT, M Grossetti et al.•International Journal of Urban…•2010

  • Tolerance in the Postindustrial City

    Open Access•Jeroen Van Der Waal, Dick Houtman•Urban Affairs Review•2011

  • Placemaking as an Economic Development Strategy for Small and Midsized Cities

    Open Access•Janet Kelly, Janet M Kelly et al.•Urban Affairs Review•2017

  • Governance, Policy Innovation, and Local Economic Development in North Carolina

    Open Access•Jonathan Q Morgan•Policy Studies Journal•2010

  • Empowering peripheral communities by using place-identity

    Miriam Billig, Asaf Lebovitz•Community Development•2014

  • Rural economic development under devolution

    Jessica Crowe, Jessica A Crowe et al.•Community Development•2015

  • The Motivation and Persuasion Process (MAP)

    Richard Hoefer, Kingsley Chigbu•Journal of Community Practice•2015

  • A stop on the train

    Open Access•Daniel De O Vasconcelos, Julie T Miao•Mobilities•2024

  • A Conceptual Regulatory Framework for the Design and Evaluation of Complex, Participative Cultural Planning Strategies

    Open Access•P L Sacco, Alessandro Crociata•International Journal of Urban…•2013

  • Realising the Diversity Dividend

    Open Access•Stephen Syrett, Leandro Sepulveda•Environment and Planning A…•2011

  • Suicide and the Creative Class

    Mark H Heirigs, Matthew D Moore et al.•Deviant Behavior•2017

  • Diverse cities and good citizenship

    Myrte Hoekstra•Ethnic and Racial Studies•2015

  • Are Peripheral Regions Benefiting from National Policies Aimed at Attracting Skilled Migrants? Case Study of the Northern Territory of Australia

    Open Access•Kate Golebiowska•Journal of International…•2016

  • How Creative is Tehran? An International and National Benchmarking Analysis

    Open Access•Bagher Fotuhi Mehrabani, Bagher Fotouhi Mehrabani et al.•Social Indicators Research•2022

  • Suicide and the Creative Class

    Open Access•Matthew D Moore, Nicholas L Recker et al.•Social Indicators Research•2014

  • The Death and Life of Great American Cities

    Jane Jacobs•The Death and Life of Great…•1961

  • Political tolerance and American democracy

    John Lawrence Sullivan, JohnL Sullivan•Political tolerance and American…•1982

  • When Work Disappears

    William J Wilson•When Work Disappears•1997

  • Why Don't Poor Countries Catch Up? A Cross‐national Test of an Institutional Explanation

    Open Access•Philip Keefer, Stephen Knack•Economic Inquiry•1997

  • Human Capital and Growth

    Robert J Barros, Robert J Barro•American Economic Review•2001

  • Threshold Externalities in Economic Development

    Costas Azariadis, Allan Drazen•The Quarterly Journal of Economics•1990

  • Appropriate Technology and Growth

    Sarbani Basu, David Weil et al.•The Quarterly Journal of Economics•1998

  • On the mechanics of economic development

    Open Access•Robert E Lucas•Journal of Monetary Economics•1988

  • Social Capital in the Creation of Human Capital

    J S Coleman, J Coleman•Knowledge and social capital•2000

  • Trust

    Francis Fukuyama•Trust•1996

  • Cities and the Creative Class

    Richard Florida•Cities and the Creative Class•2005

  • The Economics of Immigration

    George J Borjas•New Immigrant in the American…•2018

  • The city as an entertainment machine

    Richard Lloyd, Terry Nichols Clark•Critical perspectives on urban…•2004

  • The Forms of Capital

    Pierre Bourdieu•Readings in Economic Sociology•2002

  • Making Democracy Work

    Robert D Putnam, Robert Leonardi et al.•Making Democracy Work•1994

  • Neo–Bohemia

    Richard Lloyd•Journal of Urban Affairs•2002

  • Amenities Drive Urban Growth

    Terry Nichols Clark, Richard Lloyd et al.•Journal of Urban Affairs•2002

  • An Economic Approach to Social Capital

    Open Access•Edward L Glaeser, David Laibson et al.•The Economic Journal•2002

  • Making Democracy Work

    Robert D Putnam, Robert Leonardi et al.•Making Democracy Work•1994

  • The Changing Dynamics of Urban Politics

    Paula D Mcclain•The Journal of Politics•1993

  • E Pluribus Unum

    Open Access•Robert D Putnam•Scandinavian Political Studies•2007

  • The Spirit of Capitalism? Religious Doctrine, Values, and Economic Attitude Constructs

    Open Access•David C Barker, Christopher J Carman•Political Behavior•2000

  • Is It Time to Disinvest in Social Capital

    Open Access•Michael W Foley, Brad Edwards et al.•Journal of Public Policy•1999

  • Civics or Structure? Revisiting the Origins of Democratic Quality in the Italian Regions

    Open Access•Frederick Solt•British Journal of Political…•2004

  • Latino Group Consciousness and Political Participation

    Open Access•Atiya Kai Stokes•American Politics Research•2003

  • Bowling Alone

    Open Access•Robert D Putnam•Journal of democracy•1995

  • Urbanism, Region, and Tolerance Revisited

    Steven A Tuch•American Sociological Review•1987

  • Religion and Economic Growth across Countries

    Robert J Barros, Robert J Barro et al.•American Sociological Review•2003

  • Struggling with the Creative Class

    Open Access•J Peck•International Journal of Urban…•2005

  • When Work Disappears

    Open Access•William Julius Wilson•Political Science Quarterly•1996

  • Urban Development and the Politics of a Creative Class

    Open Access•Ann Markusen•Environment and Planning A…•2006

  • Black Consciousness and Political Participation

    Open Access•Richard D Shingles, Richard Shingles•American Political Science Review•1981

  • Cosmopolitan Knowledge and the Production and Consumption of Sexualized Space

    Open Access•J Binnie, Beverley Skeggs•The Sociological Review•2004

  • Social Capital

    A Portes•Annual Review of Sociology•1998

  • Social Capital in the Creation of Human Capital

    James S Coleman•American Journal of Sociology•1988

  • The Strength of Weak Ties

    Mark Granovetter, Mark S Granovetter•American Journal of Sociology•1973

  • Social capital and economic development

    Open Access•Michael Woolcock•Theory and Society•1998

Unique citing works75
Citations per year4,41
Citation span2009 - 2026 (18)
Citation velocitycurrent
Highly citedNo
Citation typesNeutral: 75

Tools

Open DOISci-Hub
Ethnos_APP • Open Source Project • MIT License • Frontend v2.0.0 • Privacy and Cookies • API Documentation: api.ethnos.app/docs • API Source Code: GitHub • DOI: 10.5281/zenodo.17049435 • Frontend Source Code: GitHub • DOI: 10.5281/zenodo.17050053 • cruz.rio.br • Expectantes Misericordiae