Skip to main content

ETHNOS_APP

Home • Search • Journals • List 0

Magic, science, religion, and the scope of rationality

Bibliographic Data

ID6544032
AuthorsStanley Jeyaraja Tambiah
Year1990
Pages187
Publication date1990-01-01
Open AccessNo
TypeBOOK
VenueMagic, science, religion, and the scope of rationality (SOURCE_BOOK)
PublisherCambridge University Press (PUBLISHER • US)
Open LibraryOL2209070M
ISBN9780521374866
GOOGLE_BOOK_IDVpd6zaVreUkC
LanguageEN
Citations received214

Professor Tambiah is one of the leading anthropologists of the day, particularly known for his penetrating and scholarly studies of Buddhism. In this accessible and illuminating book he deals with the classical opposition of magic with science and religion. He reviews the great debates in classical Judaism, early Greek science, Renaissance philosophy, the Protestant Reformation, and the scientific revolution, and then reconsiders the three major interpretive approaches to magic in anthropology: the intellectualist and evolutionary theories of Tylor and Frazer, Malinowski's functionalism, and Lévy-Bruhl's philosophical anthropology, which posited a distinction between mystical and logical mentalities. He follows with a wide-ranging and suggestive discussion of rationality and relativism and concludes with a discussion of new thinking in the history and philosophy of science, suggesting fresh perspectives on the classical opposition between science and magic

Ethnology · Rationalism · 306.8/001 · Gn345 .t36 1990 · Godsdienst · History · Kulturanthropologie · Magia · Magie · Méthodologie · Philosophy · Rationalisme · Rationaliteit · Religiao e ciencia · Religion · Social aspects · Wetenschap · Wissenschaft

  • The Belief in Magic in the Age of Science

    Open Access•Eugene Subbotsky•SAGE Open•2014

  • "Memory, Desire, and "Magic

    Open Access•Signe Cohen•Religions•2020

  • Prospects for a Postsecular Heritage Practice

    Open Access•D Byrne•Religions•2019

  • Do You Work with Magic

    L Kendall•Material Religion•2018

  • Do You Believe in Magic

    Elizabeth Graham•Material Religion•2018

  • Taking spiritual experiences seriously in the religious education classroom

    Mira Cataya Rodriguez, Christian Stokke•International Journal of Children…•2019

  • Magical food and health beliefs

    Open Access•Kia Aarnio, Michael Lindeman et al.•Appetite•2004

  • The effectiveness of words

    Open Access•Roland Littlewood, Dein et al.•Culture Medicine and Psychiatry•1995

  • Introduction

    Linda F Hogle•Medical Anthropology•2002

  • Magical Thinking and Consumer Coping

    Yannik St James, Jay M Handelman et al.•Journal of Consumer Research•2011

  • Respecting Autonomy and Understanding Religion

    Open Access•Terry F Godlove•Religious Studies•1992

  • Religious Enthusiasm, the Spanish Inquisition, and the Disenchantment of the World

    Andrew W Keitt, Andrew Keitt•Journal of the History of Ideas•2004

  • "All was this land full fill'd of faerie," or Magic and the Past in Early Modern England

    Lauren Kassell•Journal of the History of Ideas•2006

  • The Ghost in the Machine

    Open Access•Eugene Subbotsky•Human Development•2011

  • Archaeological Theory and Scientific Practice

    Andrew Jones, Andrew Meirion Jones•Archaeological Theory and…•2009

  • Aids, Politics, and Music in South Africa

    Fraser G Mcneill•AIDS, Politics, and Music in…•2011

  • Fetish, Magic, Marketing

    Open Access•E Arnould, Julien Cayla et al.•Magical Capitalism•2018

  • Magical Contracts, Numinous Capitalism

    Open Access•David A Westbrook•Magical Capitalism•2018

  • Rationalität - Wissenschaft - Technik

    Open Access•Stefan Beck•Science and Technology Studies•2012

  • Science and Social Movements

    Open Access•Andrew Jamison•International Encyclopedia of the…•2015

  • Common Sense, Anthropology of

    Open Access•M Herzfeld•International Encyclopedia of the…•2015

  • When doctors and patients lie to each other

    Sylvie Fainzang•When doctors and patients lie to…•2009

  • Der sechste Sinn

    Open Access•Klaus E Müller•Der sechste Sinn•2004

  • Naturalismus a protekcionismus ve studiu náboženství

    Juraj Franek•Naturalismus a protekcionismus ve…•2017

  • International Handbook of Research on Environmental Education

    Robert B Stevenson, Michael Brody et al.•International Handbook of…•2013

  • The Process of Moralization

    Open Access•Paul Rozin•Psychological Science•1999

  • The weighing of evidence and the determinants of confidence

    Open Access•Dale W Griffin, Dale Griffin et al.•Cognitive Psychology•1992

  • Individual differences in reasoning

    Open Access•Keith E Stanovich, Richard F West•Behavioral and Brain Sciences•2000

  • Representativeness Revisited

    Open Access•Daniel Kahneman, Shane Frederick•Heuristics and biases•2002

  • Clinical Versus Actuarial Judgment

    Open Access•Robyn M Dawes, David Faust et al.•Science•1989

  • Support theory

    Amos Tversky, Derek J Koehler•Psychological Review•1994

  • The Prison Houses of Knowledge

    Open Access•Radha D’Souza•McGill Journal of Education /…•2009

  • The Bronze Object in the Middle Ages

    Open Access•Ittai Weinryb•Bronze Object in the Middle Ages•2016

  • Odds and Ends

    Open Access•T M Malaby•Culture Medicine and Psychiatry•2002

  • Contested Etiology

    Open Access•Iman Roushdy-Hammady•Culture Medicine and Psychiatry•2004

  • Applying Aristotle's Doctrine of Causation to Aboriginal and Biomedical Understandings of Diabetes

    Open Access•Julie Sunday, John Eyles et al.•Culture Medicine and Psychiatry•2001

  • Touros de genética, touros de genealogia

    Open Access•N S Leal•Perifèria Revista d investigació…•2011

  • Confucian Humanism and Theodicy

    Weigang Chen•Journal of the American Academy…•2012

  • Interpreting the Tropical Atlantic Climate

    Katherine Foxhall•Weather, Climate, and Society•2010

  • The return of the positivist theory of religion

    Open Access•Walter Kaufman•International Journal for…•2025

  • Magical contracts, numinous capitalism

    Open Access•David A Westbrook•Anthropology Today•2016

  • Fetish, magic, marketing

    Open Access•E Arnould, Julien Cayla et al.•Anthropology Today•2017

  • Vitamin Practices and Ideologies of Health and the Body

    Maryann Mccabe, Antonella Fabri•International Journal of Business…•2012

  • The interplay between loss and enchantment in the works of J. R. R. Tolkien

    John Rosegrant•Psychoanalytic Psychology•2016

  • Ambiguity and Self-Evaluation

    Open Access•David Dunning, Judith A Meyerowitz et al.•Heuristics and biases•2002

  • Feeling Through the Body

    Christine Morris, Alan Peatfield et al.•Thinking Through the Body•2002

  • Competitive Feasting, Religious Pluralism and Decentralized Power in the Late Moche Period

    Edward Swenson, Edward R Swenson•Andean Archaeology III•2006

  • The Affect Heuristic

    Open Access•Paul Slovic, Melissa L Finucane et al.•Heuristics and biases•2002

  • Witchcraft, Sorcery, Violence

    Salmah Eva-Lina Lawrence•Talking it Through•2015

  • Sensing the Everyday

    C Nadia Seremetakis•Sensing the Everyday•2019

  • The Social Brain and the Myth of Empathy

    Open Access•Alma H Young, Allan Young•Science in Context•2012

  • Le collège sacerdotal mazdéen entre tradition et innovation

    Open Access•Antonio Panaino, Antonio Clemente Domenico Panaino•Annuaire - Ecole pratique des…•2022

  • How magic survived the disenchantment of the world

    Wouter J Hanegraaff•Religion•2003

  • Living translation in US Chinese medicine

    Open Access•E Pritzker, Sonya E Pritzker•Language in Society•2012

  • Sheltered by dhamma

    Open Access•Alexandra Kent•Journal of Southeast Asian Studies•2011

  • Aladura Christianity

    Benjamin C Ray•Journal of Religion in Africa•1993

  • How alike is it versus how likely is it

    Maya Bar-Hillel, Maya Bar‐Hillel et al.•Journal of Personality and Social…•1993

  • Religion, Science, and Secularization Theory on a Danish Island

    Andrew Buckser•Journal for the Scientific Study…•1996

  • Sorcery and Evidence of Change in Maring Justice

    Open Access•Edward Lipuma•Ethnology•1994

  • Modern Magic and the War on Miracles in French Colonial Culture

    Open Access•Graham M Jones•Comparative Studies in Society…•2010

  • Do cultural factors affect causal beliefs? Rational and magical thinking in Britain and Mexico

    Open Access•Eugene Subbotsky, Graciela Quinteros•British Journal of Psychology•2002

  • Children's and adults' reactions to magical and ordinary suggestion

    Open Access•Eugene Subbotsky•British Journal of Psychology•2007

  • Curiosity and exploratory behaviour towards possible and impossible events in children and adults

    Open Access•Eugene Subbotsky•British Journal of Psychology•2010

  • Can magical intervention affect subjective experiences? Adults' reactions to magical suggestion

    Open Access•Eugene Subbotsky•British Journal of Psychology•2009

  • Indigenous knowledge of traditional medicine

    Open Access•BAGWANA Peter•Antropoloji•2015

  • Against Over-Interpretation

    Open Access•Jale Yazar, Roland Littlewood•International Journal of Social…•2001

  • The Talking Cure as Action

    Open Access•Naomi Janowitz•The American Journal of…•2011

  • Ambiguity and self-evaluation

    David Dunning, Judith A Meyerowitz et al.•Journal of Personality and Social…•1989

  • Cross-Cultural Articulations of War Magic and Warrior Religion

    Open Access•D S Farrer•Social Analysis•2014

  • Ritual and Rationality

    Open Access•Joanna Brück•European Journal of Archaeology•1999

  • Making Technology Familiar

    Open Access•Susan Martha Kahn•Culture Medicine and Psychiatry•2006

  • A social anthropology of ghosts in twenty-first-century America

    Open Access•J O Baker, Christopher D Bader•Social Compass•2014

  • The Flourishing of Religion in Post‐Mao China and the Anthropological Category of Religion

    Open Access•A B Kipnis•The Australian Journal of…•2001

  • Suffering and its professional transformation

    Open Access•A Kleinman, Joan Kleinman•Culture Medicine and Psychiatry•1991

  • “Maybe I Made Up the Whole Thing”

    Open Access•T J Kaptchuk, Jessica Shaw et al.•Culture Medicine and Psychiatry•2009

  • Tukdam, Different Ontological Bodies, and Making Tibetan Deaths Visible

    Open Access•Donagh Coleman•Culture Medicine and Psychiatry•2025

  • Le pouvoir « divinatoire » des algorithmes

    Christophe Lazaro•Anthropologie et Sociétés•2018

  • Magic

    Open Access•Matteo Benussi, F Stein et al.•Open Encyclopedia of Anthropology•2019

  • Divination

    Open Access•D E Santos, Diana Espírito Santo et al.•Open Encyclopedia of Anthropology•2019

  • Fundamental social motives and the varieties of religious experience

    Kris A Johnson, Kathryn A Johnson et al.•Religion Brain & Behavior•2015

  • Contradictions in Tourism

    Open Access•Ronald Fletcher, Robert Fletcher et al.•Environment and Society•2012

  • Constructing the placebo effect in the placebo wars

    Doug Foot, Damien Ridge•Health Sociology Review•2012

  • Visionaries and the national idea in interwar Bulgaria

    Galia Valtchinova•Acta Ethnographica Hungarica•2009

  • Semantic Frameworks

    Open Access•Steen Bergendorff•CAM•2007

  • Perspectivas cambiantes sobre un África cambiante

    Open Access•Sally Falk Moore•Antropologías del Sur•2018

  • Psychoanalysis and Magic

    Mikita Brottman•American imago•2009

  • Authors' Introduction

    Open Access•K Baraniecka-Olszewska, Magdalena Lubanska•Journal of Global Catholicism•2018

  • Divination

    Bob Trubshaw•Time and Mind•2012

  • Conflicting sensory relationships. Encounters with allergic people

    Roberta Raffaetà•Anthropology and Medicine•2012

  • Keeping the feet of the gods and the saints warm

    Els Van Dongen•Anthropology and Medicine•2008

  • Lying, secrecy and power within the doctor-patient relationship

    Sylvie Fainzang•Anthropology and Medicine•2002

  • The Cultural Evolution of Epistemic Practices

    Open Access•Z Hong, J Henrich•Human Nature•2021

  • Making Magic Consumption

    Open Access•E Arnould, Eric J Arnould et al.•Journal of Contemporary Ethnography•1999

  • Canales de poder, terrenos de conflicto

    Open Access•Paul H Gelles•Anthropologica•1998

  • Conflicto social y enfermedad en los altos de Chiapas

    Open Access•Ulises Contreras Cortés•Estudios Sociológicos de El…•2003

  • Smoking among Doctors

    Matthew Kohrman•Medical Anthropology•2008

  • Claims and disclaimers

    Linda F Hogle•Medical Anthropology•2002

  • Changing planes

    Open Access•Noel Gough•Studies in Philosophy and Education•2007

  • Galileo courtier

    Open Access•David Gentilcore•Studies in History and Philosophy…•1994

  • Escritura, espacios sociales y cosmologías indígenas en Nueva España

    Open Access•David Tavárez•Revista de Indias•2009

Unique citing works214
Citations per year5,78
Citation span1989 - 2025 (37)
Citation velocityrecent
Highly citedYes
Citation typesNeutral: 200
Ethnos_APP • Open Source Project • MIT License • Frontend v2.0.0 • Privacy and Cookies • API Documentation: api.ethnos.app/docs • API Source Code: GitHub • DOI: 10.5281/zenodo.17049435 • Frontend Source Code: GitHub • DOI: 10.5281/zenodo.17050053 • cruz.rio.br • Expectantes Misericordiae