Skip to main content

ETHNOS_APP

Home • Search • Journals • List 0

Identity, contingency and rigidity

The (counter-)hegemonic constructions of the identity of the media professional

Bibliographic Data

ID7477151
AuthorsN Carpentier (0000-0002-8996-4636, Catholic University Brussels (KUB) and Free University Brussels (VUB))
Year2005
Volume6
Issue2
Pages199-219
Publication date2005-04-27
Peer ReviewedYes
Open AccessYes
TypeARTICLE
VenueJournalism (JOURNAL)
Journal identifiersISSN: 1464-8849 • E-ISSN: 1741-3001
PublisherSAGE Publishing (PUBLISHER • US)
DOI10.1177/1464884905051008
OpenAlexW2121124173
LanguageEN
Citations received53
References cited19

This article uses key notions of the discourse theory of Laclau and Mouffe to analyze the identity of the media professional. Within their post-structural framework, this identity is seen as over-determined, contingent and constructed but at the same time subjected to a hegemonic articulation, based on four nodal points: objectivity, autonomy, management of resources and employee-employer relations. Combined with a theoretical discussion on the (counter-)hegemonic articulations, this allows for the field of discursivity that surrounds the identity of the media professional to be (re)constructed, resulting in four dimensions that offer potential points of identification. This field of discursivity is then used and put to the test as a series of sensitizing concepts for the analysis of the seven phone-in broadcasts the program Ter Zake (on VRT - the North Belgian public broadcasting company) has organized, illustrating both the contingency of the identity of the media professional and the rigidity of the hegemonic articulation

Aesthetics · Contingency · Epistemology · Hegemony · Identity (music · Objectivity (philosophy · Political science · Rigidity (electromagnetism · Sociology · Cultural and Social Studies · Engineering · Globalization and Cultural Identity · Media Studies and Communication · Law · Philosophy

  • Theorizing participatory intensities

    Open Access•H Jenkins, N Carpentier•Convergence The International…•2013

  • Journalismin kriisistä amerikkalaisittain

    Open Access•Jari Väliverronen•Media & viestintä•2023

  • Bridging the Discursive and Material Dimensions of Europeanity and Europeanisation

    Open Access•N Carpentier, Miloš Hroch et al.•Observatorio (OBS•2023

  • Literary Journalism vs Conventional Journalism in the Coverage of the Syrian Conflict in the Periodicals The Guardian and The New Yorker

    Open Access•Carolina Correia, Rita Amorim et al.•TSN Transatlantic Studies Network•2026

  • Ernesto Laclau and Critical Media Studies

    Open Access•Jannick Schou•tripleC Communication Capitalism…•2016

  • Negotiating Journalistic Professional Ethos in Nordic Business Journalism

    Open Access•Johanna Suhonen•Media and Communication•2022

  • ‘Let’s Get Them Involved’ . . . to Some Extent

    Open Access•Susanne M Almgren, Susanne Almgren et al.•Social Media + Society•2015

  • Digitally crafting a resistant professional identity

    Open Access•Marcos Barros•Organization•2018

  • Shock to the system? Journalism in Irish public service media after the crash

    Open Access•Mark Cullinane•Irish Journal of Sociology•2020

  • Communication for Development and Social Change

    Jan Servaes•Communication for Development and…•2008

  • Hybrid journalistic identities? Journalism(s) and Nepad

    Andrew Kanyegirire•Ecquid Novi African Journalism…•2006

  • Journalism across cultures

    Lynette Steenveld•Ecquid Novi African Journalism…•2014

  • Facing the death of the Author. Cultural professional’s identity work and the fantasies of control

    Open Access•N Carpentier•Matrizes•2011

  • Assessing “The Regulars”—and Beyond

    Anders Olof Larsson•Journalism Practice•2017

  • Solidarity Reporting on Marginalization

    Open Access•Anita Varma•Journalism Practice•2023

  • The Journalistic Hyperlink

    Juliette De Maeyer•Journalism Practice•2012

  • Politics of mitigation

    Noha Mellor•Critical Discourse Studies•2009

  • Elevated Influences

    Joy Jenkins•Journalism Studies•2018

  • Not Partisans, But Participants

    Esa Reunanen, Kari Koljonen•Journalism Studies•2016

  • Hegemony, Democracy, Agonism and Journalism

    N Carpentier, Bart Cammaerts•Journalism Studies•2006

  • Debating News Media

    Aikaterini Nikolopoulou, Elena Psyllakou et al.•Journalism Studies•2022

  • Producing Journalistic News Satire

    Joonas Koivukoski, Sara Ödmark•Journalism Studies•2020

  • Minimum Journalism

    Lars Nyre•Journalism Studies•2007

  • For activists, for potential voters, for consumers

    Tobias Olsson•Journal of Youth Studies•2008

  • Agonistic Pluralism and Journalism

    Open Access•John Budarick•Communication Theory•2019

  • Neoliberalism and the post-hegemonic war of position

    Open Access•Bart Cammaerts•European Journal of Communication•2015

  • Australian Journalism and War

    Giles Dodson•Journalism Studies•2009

  • Liquid Modern Journalism with a Difference

    Magdalena Jaakkola, Maarit Jaakkola et al.•Journalism Practice•2015

  • Values, imaginaries and templates of journalistic practice

    Michał Krzyżanowski•Social Semiotics•2014

  • Once a Journalist, Always a Journalist

    Marika Sherwood, Merryn Sherwood et al.•Journalism Studies•2016

  • Dialogue and dissemination in news media interviews

    Open Access•Geoffrey Craig•Journalism•2010

  • More of the Same or a Different Breed Altogether

    Open Access•Jari Väliverronen•Nordicom review/NORDICOM review•2018

  • The Shift from High to Liquid Ideals

    Open Access•Kari Koljonen•Nordicom review/NORDICOM review•2013

  • Development journalism revived

    Terje Steinulfsson Skjerdal•Ecquid Novi African Journalism…•2011

  • Citizen Journalism at The Margins

    Open Access•Ann Luce, Daniel Jackson et al.•Journalism Practice•2016

  • Journalistic Autonomy

    Open Access•Helle Sjøvaag•Nordicom review/NORDICOM review•2013

  • The Constructive Role of Journalism

    Tanja Aitamurto, Anita Varma•Journalism Practice•2018

  • Boundaries in Motion? Finnish Political Journalists’ External and Internal Boundary Work in a Time of Change

    Open Access•Jari Väliverronen•Journalism Studies•2022

  • On the Performativity of Journalistic Identity

    Jo Bogaerts•Journalism Practice•2011

  • Technologies of participation

    Open Access•Eric Carlsson, Bo Nilsson•Journalism•2015

  • Who is a good journalist? Evaluations of journalistic worth in the era of social media

    Open Access•Vaios Papanagnou•Journalism•2021

  • Public journalism and professional reflexivity

    Open Access•Laura Ahva•Journalism•2012

  • Does the audience welcome an audience-oriented journalism

    Open Access•Pauljan Truyens, Ike Picone•Journalism•2023

  • Professional ideals and daily practice in journalism

    Open Access•Signe Pihl-Thingvad, Signe Pihl‐thingvad•Journalism•2014

  • News organizations, ideology, and work routines

    Open Access•Ever Josue Figueroa•Journalism•2017

  • From gardeners to revolutionaries

    Open Access•Anu Kantola•Journalism•2012

  • Racism and journalism

    Open Access•John Budarick•Journalism•2022

  • Shifting journalistic roles in democratic transitions

    Open Access•Fatima El Issawi, Bart Cammaerts•Journalism•2015

  • In objectivity we trust? Pluralism, consensus, and ideology in journalism studies

    Open Access•Daniëlle Raeijmaekers, Pieter Maeseele•Journalism•2015

  • The metaphors journalists live by

    Open Access•Gitte Gravengaard•Journalism•2012

  • Identities under construction

    Jenny Wiik•International Review of Sociology•2009

  • Bringing Discourse Theory into Media Studies

    N Carpentier, Benjamin De Cleen•Journal of Language and Politics•2007

  • Orgulho e preconceito

    Open Access•F Biroli, Luís Felipe Miguel•Opinião Pública•2012

  • Four Theories of the Press

    Fred S Siebert, Theodore Peterson et al.•Four Theories of the Press•1963

  • Objective News Reporting

    Open Access•Jorgen Westerstahl•Communication Research•1983

  • Political Impact of Mass Media

    Colin Seymour-Ure•Political Impact of Mass Media•1974

  • Symbolic Interactionism

    Herbert Blumer•Symbolic Interactionism•1986

  • Discourse Theory and Political Analysis

    David Howarth•Research strategies in the social…•1998

  • The Press and the Decline of Democracy

    Robert G Picard, Robert Picard•The Press and the Decline of…•1985

  • A tyranny of intimacy? Women, femininity and television news

    Liesbet Van Zoonen•Communication and Citizenship•2005

  • The Public Quality of Popular Journalism

    Irene Costera Meijer•Journalism Studies•2001

  • Television and the Public Sphere

    Peter Dahlgren•Television and the Public Sphere•2000

  • Managing Audience Participation

    Open Access•N Carpentier•European Journal of Communication•2001

  • The sociology of journalism

    Brian Mcnair•The sociology of journalism•1998

  • Modernization, Marginalization, and Emancipation

    Open Access•Hemant Shah•Communication Theory•1996

  • Group feedback analysis

    Frank A Heller, Frank Heller•Psychological Bulletin•1969

  • Objectivity as Strategic Ritual

    Gaye Tuchman•American Journal of Sociology•1972

Unique citing works53
Citations per year2,65
Citation span2006 - 2026 (21)
Citation velocitycurrent
Highly citedNo
Citation typesNeutral: 53

Tools

Open DOISci-Hub
Ethnos_APP • Open Source Project • MIT License • Frontend v2.0.0 • Privacy and Cookies • API Documentation: api.ethnos.app/docs • API Source Code: GitHub • DOI: 10.5281/zenodo.17049435 • Frontend Source Code: GitHub • DOI: 10.5281/zenodo.17050053 • cruz.rio.br • Expectantes Misericordiae