The Prayer of Christ

Let me begin by setting down a passage from the now well-known One God and Father of All, by Eric Milner-White and Wilfred L. Knox (pp. 46, 47): A common argument of Roman writers on the same lines may be noticed here, since it sometimes causes great perplexity. It is said that our Lord in the .great prayer in S. John xvii prays that the Church may be one. This prayer is sometimes described as a ‘creative prayer,’ whatever the words may mean. If they mean anything, they would seem to be plain heresy, since they would mean that our Lord was simply God, not God made man and therefore subject to the limitations of humanity which made it necessary for Him to pray. More often the argument is used that our Lord at this supreme moment prayed that His Church might be one; we cannot believe that a prayer uttered at such a moment would not be answered. Therefore the Church must be one. But the Roman Church alone claims to be the one Church; therefore the one Church for which our Lord prayed is the Roman Church. But it would be equally legitimate to argue that at an even greater moment in the crisis of the Passion our Lord prayed, ‘Let this cup pass from me.’ Consequently this prayer could be used to show that, as some early heretics held, He did not really die upon the Cross, but substituted for Himself a phantom or Simon of Cyrene. Obviously our Lord’s prayer in S. John xvii proves nothing more than that the Church ought to be one—which everyone admits. The argument is ludicrous. With some things in this passage I could not, of course, agree, but with one thing at least I do agree, and that is with the dislike expressed in it for calling Christ’s prayer a ‘creative prayer

Citation · Prayer · Theology · World Wide Web · Christian Theology and Mission · Computer Science · Pentecostalism and Christianity Studies · Philosophy · Religious Tourism and Spaces