Skip to main content

ETHNOS_APP

Home • Search • Journals • List 0

Socializing the European Semester

EU social and economic policy co-ordination in crisis and beyond

Bibliographic Data

ID7880751
AuthorsJonathan Zeitlin (0000-0003-1655-0448, University of Amsterdam, corresponding author), Bart Vanhercke (0000-0003-3275-2015, European Social Observatory, Brussels, Belgium)
Year2018
Volume25
Issue2
Pages149-174
Publication date2018-02-01
Peer ReviewedYes
Open AccessYes
TypeARTICLE
VenueJournal of European Public Policy (JOURNAL)
Journal identifiersISSN: 1350-1763 • E-ISSN: 1466-4429
PublisherInforma UK Limited (PUBLISHER • GB)
DOI10.1080/13501763.2017.1363269
OpenAlexW2752897663
LanguageEN
Citations received144
References cited25

This contribution analyses how EU social objectives and policy co-ordination have been integrated into the Union’s post-crisis governance architecture. It argues that between 2011 and 2016, there was a partial but progressive ‘socialization’ of the ‘European Semester’ of policy co-ordination, in terms of increasing emphasis on social objectives in its priorities and key messages, including the Country-Specific Recommendations; intensified social monitoring and review of national reforms; and an enhanced decision-making role for EU social and employment actors. In explaining these developments, the contribution highlights the contribution of strategic agency, reflexive learning and creative adaptation by social and employment actors to the new institutional conditions of the Semester, building on recent theoretical work on ‘actor-centred constructivism’ and the ‘usages of Europe

Agency (philosophy · Corporate governance · Economic policy · Economics · European union · Management · Political economy · Political science · Public relations · Reflexivity · Social dialogue · Social science · Socialization · Sociology · European Union Policy and Governance · Public Administration · Social Policy and Reform Studies

  • Shifting ground to hold firm? EMU rebalancing and the changing politics of euro support

    Open Access•Robin Huguenot-Noël•Journal of European Public Policy•2026

  • Who's Afraid of the Welfare State Now?

    Anton Hemerijck, Matthew Matsaganis et al.•Who's Afraid of the Welfare State…•2024

  • From the European Semester to the Recovery and Resilience Facility

    Open Access•Bart Vanhercke, Amy Verdun et al.•SSRN Electronic Journal•2022

  • The emergence of a New European Labour Policy regime

    Open Access•Felix Syrovatka•Competition & Change•2022

  • Too big to fail? The dynamics of EU influence and fiscal consolidation in Italy and Spain (2008–2016)

    Diego Badell, Fabrizio Di Mascio et al.•Public Management Review•2019

  • Politics and Social Visions

    Maurizio Ferrera•Politics and Social Visions•2024

  • Health, federalism and the European Union

    Open Access•Scott L Greer•Health Economics Policy and Law•2021

  • Towards a Socialization of the EU's New Economic Governance Regime? EU Labour Policy Interventions in Germany, Ireland, Italy and Romania (2009–2019)

    Open Access•Jamie Jordan, Vincenzo Maccarrone et al.•British Journal of Industrial…•2021

  • The recovery and resilience facility as a transition stabiliser

    Open Access•David Bokhorst, Andrea Capati•Journal of European Public Policy•2026

  • The EU social turn in words and deeds

    Open Access•Robin Huguenot-Noël•Journal of European Integration•2026

  • Social dialogue in defining the European Union economic and social strategy

    Open Access•Laura Gómez Urquijo•Oñati Socio-legal Series•2024

  • Negotiating the Common Agricultural Policy

    Open Access•Matthew David Huntley•Central European Journal of…•2022

  • Governing through consensus? The European Semester, soft power and education governance in the EU

    Open Access•Katri Eeva•European Journal of Educational…•2024

  • Forming a supranational boundary-spanning policy regime – European intersectoral coordination in education and employment

    Open Access•Marcelo Marques, Lukas Graf et al.•British Journal of Education & Work•2023

  • The European Trade Union Federations within the European polity

    Open Access•Torsten Müller, Hans-Wolfgang Platzer et al.•Transfer European Review of…•2020

  • Navigating cross-border labour mobility and employment security in European shipbuilding

    Open Access•Ines Wagner, Karen Jaehrling et al.•Transfer European Review of…•2025

  • Poverty and social exclusion in the EU

    Open Access•Paul Copeland•Transfer European Review of…•2023

  • Round Table. From Lisbon to Porto

    Open Access•Pascal Pochet, Philippe Pochet•Transfer European Review of…•2021

  • Round Table. From Lisbon to Porto

    Open Access•Maurizio Ferrera•Transfer European Review of…•2021

  • The revival of Social Europe

    Open Access•Maarten Keune, Pascal Pochet et al.•Transfer European Review of…•2023

  • Greek Views of the 2015 Bailout Agreement

    Vasileios P Karakasis•The International Spectator•2022

  • Stabilisierung statt Paradigmenwechsel

    Felix Syrovatka•PROKLA Zeitschrift für kritische…•2022

  • Cross-border healthcare collaborations in Europe (2007–2017)

    Open Access•Andrea E Schmidt, Julia Bobek et al.•Health Policy•2022

  • Is the EU steering national social and health policy making? A case-study on Finland's national reform

    Open Access•Noora Heinonen, Meri Koivusalo et al.•Health Policy•2024

  • A failed insurrection? An institutional analysis of the creation of the European Union Social Convergence Framework

    Open Access•João Paulo Magalhães, Eleanor Brooks et al.•Journal of European Social Policy•2026

  • Politicizing poverty indicators

    Open Access•Marianna Zieleńska, Małgorzata Gawrońska•Policy Studies•2026

  • EU political structuring during the ‘social turn’ (2014–2024)

    Maurizio Ferrera, Beatrice Carella et al.•Journal of European Public Policy•2026

  • L’euro-isation de l’Europe

    Guillaume Sacriste, A Vauchez•Revue de l'OFCE/ La Revue de l'OFCE•2020

  • The field of European economic governance and austerity policies

    F Lebaron, Didier Georgakakis•Political anthropological…•2021

  • The European Commission’s ideas on integrating underrepresented groups into the labour market

    Lea Foverskov, Lea Acre Foverskov•European Politics and Society•2020

  • Gender blindness in the ‘Next Generation European Union’ funds

    Open Access•María Bastida, Miguel Anxo Vázquez Taín et al.•Annals of Public and Cooperative…•2025

  • Connecting internal and external dynamics in European intersectoral policy coordination – the case of education and employment

    Open Access•Marcelo Marques, Judith Rohde‐Liebenau et al.•Journal of European Integration•2024

  • Strengthening the European Semester to Achieve Economies of Wellbeing

    Open Access•Inge Stegeman, Ingrid Stegeman et al.•International Journal of…•2024

  • Structure of the population or economic conditions? Determinants of spending on social protection in the European Union

    Open Access•Agata Szymańska•Economic Research-Ekonomska…•2023

  • Shaping the prospects for adequate pensions

    Open Access•Igor Tkalec•Political Research Exchange•2020

  • The European Semester

    Open Access•Yannis Papadopoulos, Simona Piattoni•European Policy Analysis•2019

  • Policy Learning and Policy Analysis Within European Union Institutions

    Open Access•Bishoy L Zaki•European Policy Analysis•2026

  • Super Mario 2

    Open Access•Diego Garzia, Johannes Karremans•Contemporary Italian Politics•2021

  • The Italian National Recovery and Resilience Plan

    Ekaterina Domorenok, Igor Guardiancich•Contemporary Italian Politics•2022

  • The Long Road for Vulnerable Jobseekers Transitioning to Green and Socially Sustainable Employment

    Open Access•Carla Valadas•Social Inclusion•2025

  • Public Policy Europeanisation in Response to the Covid‐19 Crisis

    Open Access•André Sønstevold, Marianne Riddervold et al.•Politics and Governance•2023

  • Politicised at Home but not in Council

    Open Access•Christina Grabbe•Politics and Governance•2024

  • The National Recovery and Resilience Plans

    Open Access•Matilde Ceron•Politics and Governance•2023

  • Social Investment Policies in the EU

    Open Access•Gaby Umbach, Igor Tkalec•Politics and Governance•2021

  • The EU’s Recovery and Resilience Facility

    Open Access•Sonja Bekker•Politics and Governance•2021

  • Why Brexit Will Do Little to Change the Political Contours of the European Social Dimension

    Open Access•Paul Copeland•Politics and Governance•2019

  • The European Commission as a Policy Entrepreneur under the European Semester

    Open Access•Bernhard Zeilinger•Politics and Governance•2021

  • NextGenerationEU and the European Semester

    Open Access•Marco Guidi, Michele Piccinetti et al.•Politics and Governance•2023

  • Threats of sovereign debt overhang in the EU, the new fiscal rules and the perils of policy drift

    Open Access•Willi Semmler, Brigitte Young•Economia Politica•2023

  • When did the austerity era of European crisis management end? On the failure of National competitiveness boards

    Open Access•Felix Syrovatka•Critical Policy Studies•2023

  • Measuring Economic Reform Recommendations under the European Semester

    Open Access•Valerie J D’erman, Jörg Haas et al.•Journal of Contemporary European…•2019

  • The progressive gendering of the European Union’s economic governance architecture

    Open Access•Laura Gómez Urquijo•Journal of Contemporary European…•2021

  • Looking for the ‘Social’ in the European Semester

    Open Access•Anna Elomäki, Barbara Gaweda•Journal of Contemporary European…•2022

  • Socialising the European Semester? The limited influence of Danish social partners on EU policymaking

    Open Access•Yi Ma•Journal of Contemporary European…•2023

  • The European Commission’s entrepreneurship and the social dimension of the European Semester

    Open Access•Patrik Vesan, Francesco Corti et al.•Comparative European Politics•2021

  • What “Brussels” means by structural reforms

    Open Access•Amandine Crespy, Pierre Vanheuverzwijn•Comparative European Politics•2017

  • Enforcing social standards through RRF conditionalities

    Open Access•Edgars Eihmanis•Comparative European Politics•2025

  • How does the EU seek to encourage change in national justice systems? A framework of coordinative and coercive Europeanization at work

    Open Access•Ramona Coman•Comparative European Politics•2024

  • Constructing the EU’s political identity in policy making

    Open Access•Sabine Saurugger, Mark Thatcher•Comparative European Politics•2019

  • Improved soft law implementation with national ownership

    Open Access•Yi Ma•Comparative European Politics•2021

  • Efficiency or compensation? The global economic crisis and the development of the European Union’s social policy

    Open Access•Imke Lammers, Minna Van Gerven et al.•Global Social Policy•2018

  • From fear to support? The role of benefit guarantees in EU multilevel welfare governance

    Open Access•Ann-Kathrin Reinl•European Union Politics•2025

  • Ideational robustness of economic ideas in action

    Open Access•Martin B Carstensen, Vivien A Schmidt•Policy and Society•2024

  • Securing decent incomes at a crossroads

    Open Access•Ane Aranguiz•European Journal of Social Security•2020

  • Success in agenda setting through failure in policymaking

    Open Access•Ryszard Szarfenberg•International Journal of Social…•2022

  • The EU’s truth by omission

    Open Access•Iosif Kovras, Mustafa Kutlay•The British Journal of Politics…•2021

  • European Union economic policy on social reproduction – Differentiating between Central-Eastern Europe and the West

    Open Access•Elena Zacharenko•European Journal of Women s Studies•2026

  • Converging on social investment? Policy entrepreneurship, learning and the social dimension of post-pandemic EU economic governance

    Sven Schreur•Journal of European Public Policy•2025

  • Beyond ‘responsibility vs. responsiveness’

    Amandine Crespy, Tiago Moreira Ramalho et al.•Journal of European Public Policy•2024

  • Integración europea y relaciones laborales. Enfoques teóricos, procesos políticos y resultados institucionales

    Open Access•Sergio González Benega, Mona Aranea•Cuadernos de Relaciones Laborales•2021

  • The European Pillar of Social Rights and the Quest for EU Social Sustainability

    Open Access•Konstantinos Alexandris Polomarkakis•Social & Legal Studies•2019

  • Speaking social Europe

    Open Access•Patrik Vesan, Pamela Pansardi•Journal of European Social Policy•2021

  • Building a European care regime

    Open Access•Anna Elomäki, Paul Copeland•Journal of European Social Policy•2026

  • Beyond the European Semester

    Open Access•Igor Guardiancich, Marco Guidi et al.•Journal of European Social Policy•2022

  • The post-socialist neoliberal agenda through the prism of Europeanization in social and labour market policy

    Open Access•Igor Guardiancich, Eugenio Borgognoni•Journal of European Social Policy•2025

  • Bank supervision between risk reduction and economic renewal

    Open Access•Shawn Donnelly•Journal of European Integration•2023

  • Explaining different usages of policy monitoring in the EU

    Open Access•Pieter Zwaan, Jonas J Schoenefeld•Journal of European Integration•2024

  • Crisis and paradigm change in the European semester

    Open Access•Alice Cavalieri, Johannes Karremans•Journal of European Integration•2023

  • Economic and fiscal policy coordination after the crisis

    Open Access•Jörg Haas, Valerie J D’erman et al.•Journal of European Integration•2020

  • The depoliticisation of education

    Open Access•Manuel Souto-Otero, Jeroen Huisman•Journal of European Integration•2026

  • Beyond the neoliberal paradigm? Images of Social Europe in open method of coordination employment peer reviews

    Open Access•Minna Van Gerven, Marinus Ossewaarde•Social Policy and Administration•2018

  • Buffering national welfare states in hard times

    Open Access•Joan Miró, Anna Kyriazi et al.•Social Policy and Administration•2024

  • From austerity‐conditionality towards a new investment‐led growth strategy

    Open Access•Francesco Corti, Patrik Vesan•Social Policy and Administration•2023

  • Benchmarking labour competitiveness

    Angela Wigger•Policy Studies•2025

  • Macro‐economic coordination and elusive ownership in the European Union

    Open Access•Pierre Vanheuverzwijn, Amandine Crespy•Public Administration•2018

  • Benchmarking and the Technicization of Academic Discourse

    Open Access•Marianna Zieleńska, Magdalena Wnuk•Minerva•2024

  • The Reforms of the Economic and Monetary Union During the Euro Crisis

    Open Access•Federico Bruno•JCMS Journal of Common Market…•2025

  • Can the EU Move ‘Beyond GDP’

    Open Access•Christopher Holme, Agnieszka Widuto•JCMS Journal of Common Market…•2025

  • European Solidarity Takes the Field

    Open Access•Francesco Visconti, Alessandro Pellegata•JCMS Journal of Common Market…•2024

  • The European Union and cross-national solidarity

    Open Access•Maurizio Ferrera•Review of Social Economy•2023

  • Hardening and softening of country-specific recommendations in the European Semester

    Open Access•Sonja Bekker•West European Politics•2020

  • Dismantling labour markets from above

    Open Access•Marco Guidi, Igor Guardiancich•Socio-Economic Review•2024

  • How the Eurozone disempowers trade unions

    Open Access•Philip Rathgeb, Arianna Tassinari•Socio-Economic Review•2020

  • Governing the European Union's recovery and resilience facility

    Open Access•Jonathan Zeitlin, David Bokhorst et al.•Regulation & Governance•2024

  • Flexicurity in the European Semester

    Open Access•Sonja Bekker•Journal of European Public Policy•2018

  • It’s a total no-no

    Open Access•Anna Elomäki•International Political Science…•2023

  • Ownership of national recovery plans

    Mario Munta, Brigitte Pircher et al.•Journal of European Public Policy•2024

  • Social Europe and its limits

    Sven Schreur•Journal of European Public Policy•2025

  • Political alternatives under European economic governance

    Open Access•Johannes Karremans•Journal of European Public Policy•2021

  • Scharpf revisited

    Sven Schreur•Journal of European Public Policy•2024

  • Assessing the Open Method of Coordination

    Open Access•Egidijus Barcevičius, J Timo Weishaupt et al.•Assessing the Open Method of…•2014

  • Socializing the European Semester? Economic Governance and Social Policy Coordination in Europe 2020

    Open Access•Jonathan Zeitlin, Bart Vanhercke•SSRN Electronic Journal•2014

  • EU Governance of Economic and Social Policies

    Open Access•Sonja Bekker, Saskia Klosse•SSRN Electronic Journal•2013

  • The EU and the Domestic Politics of Welfare State Reforms

    Open Access•Paolo R Graziano, Sophie Jacquot et al.•EU and the Domestic Politics of…•2011

  • Social Policy and the Euro Crisis

    Open Access•Amandine Crespy, Georg Menz•Social Policy and the Eurocrisis•2015

  • Europeanizing Civil Society

    Open Access•Rosa Sanchez Salgado•Europeanizing Civil Society•2014

  • EU facing the crisis

    Open Access•Hans-Jürgen Bieling, Hans‐Jürgen Bieling•Transfer European Review of…•2012

  • Social Europe

    Open Access•Paul Copeland, Mary E Daly et al.•Social Policy and the Eurocrisis•2015

  • The Europeanisation of policy to address poverty under the new economic governance

    Laura Gómez Urquijo•Journal of Poverty and Social…•2017

  • Using Europe

    Open Access•Cornelia Woll, Sophie Jacquot•Comparative European Politics•2010

  • Inside the black box

    Open Access•Rita Baeten, Bart Vanhercke•Comparative European Politics•2016

  • A new era of European Integration? Governance of labour market and social policy since the sovereign debt crisis

    Open Access•Desmond Dinan, Caroline De La Porte et al.•Comparative European Politics•2014

  • Europe 2020 and the Fight against Poverty – Beyond Competence Clash, Towards ‘Hybrid’ Governance Solutions

    Open Access•Matteo Jessoula•Social Policy and Administration•2015

  • Flexicurity in the European Semester

    Open Access•Sonja Bekker•Journal of European Public Policy•2018

  • Enforcing the European Semester

    James D Savage, David Howarth•Journal of European Public Policy•2018

  • Deciding on the European Semester

    Adina Maricut, Uwe Puetter•Journal of European Public Policy•2018

  • Commission Entrepreneurship and the Debasing of Social Europe Before and After the Eurocrisis

    Open Access•Amandine Crespy, Georg Menz•JCMS Journal of Common Market…•2015

  • Sociological Approaches to the European Union in Times of Turmoil

    Open Access•Sabine Saurugger•JCMS Journal of Common Market…•2016

  • Cherry-picking external constraints

    Edgars Eihmanis•Journal of European Public Policy•2018

  • Sociological Approaches in EU Studies

    Sabine Saurugger•Journal of European Public Policy•2009

  • The Legal and Political Accountability Structure of ‘Post‐Crisis’ EU Economic Governance

    Open Access•Mark Dawson•JCMS Journal of Common Market…•2015

Unique citing works144
Citations per year16
Citation span2017 - 2026 (10)
Citation velocitycurrent
Highly citedYes
Citation typesNeutral: 143

Tools

Open DOISci-HubOpen Access
Ethnos_APP • Open Source Project • MIT License • Frontend v2.0.0 • Privacy and Cookies • API Documentation: api.ethnos.app/docs • API Source Code: GitHub • DOI: 10.5281/zenodo.17049435 • Frontend Source Code: GitHub • DOI: 10.5281/zenodo.17050053 • cruz.rio.br • Expectantes Misericordiae