Skip to main content

ETHNOS_APP

Home • Search • Journals • List 0

Definitely (not) belonging to culture

Europeans’ evaluations of the contents and limits of culture

Bibliographic Data

ID7959992
AuthorsSemi Purhonen (0000-0002-4604-8670, Tampere University, corresponding author), Marc Verboord (0000-0002-6098-3075, Erasmus University Rotterdam), Ossi Sirkka (0000-0002-6088-646X), Nete Nørgaard Kristensen (0000-0002-8782-7179, University of Copenhagen), Susanne Janssen (0000-0002-8984-3498, Erasmus University Rotterdam)
Year2023
Volume101
Pages101840
Publication date2023-12-01
Peer ReviewedYes
Open AccessYes
TypeARTICLE
VenuePoetics (JOURNAL)
Journal identifiersISSN: 0304-422X • E-ISSN: 1872-7514
PublisherElsevier BV (PUBLISHER)
DOI10.1016/j.poetic.2023.101840
OpenAlexW4388254784
LanguageEN
Citations received6
References cited70

Despite the long history of debating its meaning and its current unprecedented ubiquity both in scholarly and popular discourses, little is systematically known about how "culture" is conceived by ordinary people. This paper examines how evaluations of the contents and boundaries of expressive culture are patterned among people in and across present-day European societies, and to what degree these evaluations associate with sociodemographic and politico-cultural divisions. Using survey data collected in 2021 in nine European countries and applying latent class and multinomial regression methods, the analysis reconstructs Europeans' boundaries of the concept of culture – which objects, places and practices they see as belonging or not belonging to culture, and with which objects they remain ambivalent. The results show that the classical distinction between narrow (exclusive) and broad (inclusive) notions still structures Europeans' evaluations of expressive culture, but it operates in several modes and with national and sociodemographic variations. In contrast to traditional assumptions, the narrow evaluations are associated with lower-status groups, while the upper-status groups embrace broad notions of culture. Moreover, the broad evaluations are associated with factors such as cultural cosmopolitanism and liberal-progressive political attitudes, highlighting the potential of extending cultural stratification research by the "bottom-up" study of patterned evaluations and understandings of the concept of culture itself

Ambivalence · Cosmopolitanism · Epistemology · Meaning (existential · Political culture · Political science · Politics · Social science · Sociology · Typology · Anthropology · Cultural Industries and Urban Development · Gender Studies · Law · Psychology · Social and Cultural Dynamics · Social Psychology · Sport and Mega-Event Impacts

  • Indigenous knowledge in Cirebon city's road toponymy

    Open Access•Herlinah Damayanti, Indri Savitri et al.•KEMBARA Journal of Scientific…•2024

  • Dla kogo Thermomix, a dla kogo Bentley? Symboliczne i „obiektywne” dystanse klasowe w Polsce

    Open Access•Henryk Domański, Katarzyna M Wyrzykowska•Przeglad Socjologii Jakosciowej•2025

  • Media use, cultural orientations and support for radical right-wing parties

    Open Access•Marc Verboord, Riie Lotta Solveig Heikkilä et al.•Information Communication & Society•2026

  • From Ways of Life to Cultural Stratification and Culturally Oriented Political Sociology

    Open Access•Semi Purhonen, Joonas Kumpulainen•Cultural Sociology•2026

  • Do Video Games Matter? Examining Video Games’ Pathways to Legitimacy and Cultural Value Through Cultural Intermediaries

    Open Access•Charlotte Gislam, G Crawford et al.•Games and Culture•2025

  • Video Games in/as Culture

    Open Access•N Yodovich, Gaynor Bagnall et al.•International Journal of the…•2025

  • Culture

    A L Kroeber•Culture•1952

  • Entitled

    Jennifer C Lena•Entitled•2019

  • Informalization

    C Wouters•Informalization•2007

  • Culture and Anarchy and other writings

    Open Access•Matthew Arnold, Stefan Collini•Arnold•1993

  • Futures Past

    Keith Tribe, Reinhart Koselleck•Futures Past•2004

  • Distinction

    Pierre Bourdieu, Tony Bennett-undifferentiated•Distinction•1984

  • Keywords (Routledge Revivals)

    Raymond Williams•Keywords•2013

  • Routledge International Handbook of the Sociology of Art and Culture

    Sylvia Holla, Giselinde Kuipers et al.•Routledge International Handbook…•2015

  • Ambiguity and Cultural Policy

    Open Access•Clive Gray•Nordisk kulturpolitisk tidskrift•2015

  • Cultural policy in the Nordic welfare states

    Sakarias Sokka, Ola K Berge et al.•Cultural policy in the Nordic…•2022

  • Social Foundations of Postindustrial Economies

    G Esping-Andersen•Social foundations of postindustria…•1999

  • Enter Culture, Exit Arts?

    Open Access•Semi Purhonen, Riie Heikkilä et al.•Enter Culture, Exit Arts?•2018

  • Routledge Handbook of Cultural Sociology

    Ming-Cheng Lo, Laura Grindstaff et al.•Routledge Handbook of Cultural…•2018

  • Exploring patterns of children’s cultural participation

    Adrian Leguina, Irmak Karademir‐hazır et al.•Consumption and Society•2022

  • Where Do Cultural Tastes Come From? Genes, Environments, or Experiences

    Open Access•M Jæger M, Stine Møllegaard•Sociological Science•2022

  • Genres, Objects, and the Contemporary Expression of Higher-Status Tastes

    Open Access•Clayton Childress, Sara Baumann et al.•Sociological Science•2021

  • The KOF Globalisation Index – revisited

    Open Access•Savina Gygli, Florian Haelg et al.•The Review of International…•2019

  • Cosmopolitanism in contemporary European societies

    Open Access•T Katz-Gerro, Susanne Janssen et al.•Journal of Contemporary European…•2023

  • Moral Distinction

    Open Access•Haydn Aarons•Journal of Consumer Culture•2018

  • The stratification of media usage in Finland, 2007–2018

    Open Access•Riie Lotta Solveig Heikkilä, Adrian Leguina et al.•New Media & Society•2020

  • Culture is digital

    Open Access•Sabina Mihelj, Adrian Leguina et al.•New Media & Society•2019

  • The impact of peer-produced criticism on cultural evaluation

    Open Access•Marc Verboord•New Media & Society•2013

  • The slippery slope of cultural non-participation

    Open Access•Riie Lotta Solveig Heikkilä•European Journal of Cultural…•2020

  • Understanding cultural taste

    Linnea Lindsköld•International Journal of Cultural…•2016

  • On bullshit in cultural policy practice and research

    Open Access•Eleonora Belfiore•International Journal of Cultural…•2009

  • Intersections of class, lifestyle and politics. New observations from Norway

    Open Access•Magne P Flemmen, Vegard Jarne et al.•Berliner Journal für Soziologie•2022

  • European models of cultural policy

    Joaquim Rius-Ulldemolins, Alejandro Pizzi et al.•Journal of European Integration•2019

  • Popular Culture and High Culture

    Lincoln Rothschild•Leonardo•1979

  • Cultural Globalization and Arts Journalism

    Open Access•Susanne Janssen, Giselinde Kuipers et al.•American Sociological Review•2008

  • The historical transformation of cultural journalism

    Nete Nørgaard Kristensen, Nete Nrgaard Kristensen•Northern Lights Film and Media…•2010

  • Class and Politics in Denmark

    Open Access•Gitte Sommer Harrits, A Prieur et al.•Scandinavian Political Studies•2010

  • Cosmopolitanism through mobility

    Open Access•Knut Petzold•British Journal of Sociology•2017

  • Understanding cultural omnivores

    Open Access•Tak Wing Chan•British Journal of Sociology•2019

  • Social space and cultural class divisions

    Open Access•Magne P Flemmen, Magne Flemmen et al.•British Journal of Sociology•2018

  • Classification in Art

    P Dimaggio•American Sociological Review•1987

  • The anatomy of cultural omnivorousness

    Open Access•Alan Warde, Modesto Gayo-Cal et al.•Poetics•2009

  • Hollywood Highbrow

    Open Access•B Mckernan•Contemporary Sociology A Journal…•2008

  • Modes of openness to cultural diversity

    Open Access•Michèle Ollivier, Michèle Dupré Ollivier•Poetics•2008

  • Family (and) culture

    Mart Willekens, John Lievens•Poetics•2014

  • Changing Highbrow Taste

    R A Peterson, Roger M Kern•American Sociological Review•1996

  • Arts participation as cultural capital in the United States, 1982-2002

    Open Access•P Dimaggio, Toqir Mukhtar et al.•Poetics•2004

  • Improving Cultural Analysis

    Open Access•Omar Lizardo•American Sociological Review•2017

  • Varieties of American Popular Nationalism

    Open Access•B Bonikowski, P Dimaggio•American Sociological Review•2016

  • From Aristocratic to Ordinary

    Open Access•Friedman, Aaron Reeves•American Sociological Review•2020

  • Growing openness or creeping intolerance? Cultural taste orientations and tolerant social attitudes in Finland, 2007-2018

    Open Access•Taru Lindblom•Poetics•2022

  • Social capital and cultural participation

    Open Access•Craig Barton Upright•Poetics•2004

  • The rise and fall of highbrow snobbery as a status marker

    Open Access•R A Peterson•Poetics•1997

  • What's in a category? A new approach to Discourse Role Analysis

    Open Access•Oscar Stuhler•Poetics•2021

  • The techno-social reproduction of taste boundaries on digital platforms

    Open Access•Massimo Airoldi•Poetics•2021

  • Are art-museum visitors different from other people? The relationship between attendance and social and political attitudes in the United States

    Open Access•P Dimaggio•Poetics•1996

  • Binding significance to form

    Open Access•Melissa A Taylor, Dustin S Stoltz et al.•Poetics•2019

  • Music classification, genres, and taste patterns

    Open Access•Jef Vlegels, John Lievens•Poetics•2017

  • Food, music and politics

    Open Access•Semi Purhonen, Riie Heikkilä et al.•Social Science Information•2017

  • Cultural Capital

    M Lamont, A Lareau•Sociological Theory•1988

  • Exploring Cultural Disengagement

    Open Access•Modesto Gayo•Cultural Sociology•2017

  • Cultural Uniqueness and Aesthetic Cosmopolitanism

    Open Access•Motti Regev•European Journal of Social Theory•2007

  • Reconceptualizing and Theorizing 'Omnivorousness

    Open Access•Omar Lizardo, Sara Skile et al.•Sociological Theory•2012

  • From Class Politics to Classed Politics

    Open Access•Vegard Jarne, Magne P Flemmen et al.•Sociology•2019

  • Down-to-Earth' Cosmopolitanism

    Open Access•Florian Pichler•Current Sociology•2009

  • Cosmopolitans and Locals

    Open Access•Anna Olofsson, Susanna Öhman•Current Sociology•2007

  • The Study of Boundaries in the Social Sciences

    M Lamont, Molnar et al.•Annual Review of Sociology•2002

  • The Impact of Religious Identity and Social Orientations on Visual Arts Appreciation

    Koen Van Eijck•European Sociological Review•2012

  • A Dynamic Model of Cultural Reproduction

    M Jæger M, Mads Meier Jæger et al.•American Journal of Sociology•2016

  • Why Do Liberals Drink Lattes

    D Dellaposta, Yongren Shi et al.•American Journal of Sociology•2015

  • Community Population Size and Social Heterogeneity

    Thomas C Wilson•American Journal of Sociology•1986

Unique citing works6
Citations per year3
Citation span2024 - 2026 (3)
Citation velocitycurrent
Highly citedNo
Citation typesNeutral: 6

Tools

Open DOIOpen Access
Ethnos_APP • Open Source Project • MIT License • Frontend v2.0.0 • Privacy and Cookies • API Documentation: api.ethnos.app/docs • API Source Code: GitHub • DOI: 10.5281/zenodo.17049435 • Frontend Source Code: GitHub • DOI: 10.5281/zenodo.17050053 • cruz.rio.br • Expectantes Misericordiae