Skip to main content

ETHNOS_APP

Home • Search • Journals • List 0

Too little, too vague

How populist parties talk about deliberation in Europe

Bibliographic Data

ID7973528
AuthorsGherghina (0000-0002-6627-5598), Bettina Mitru (0009-0006-1906-2713)
Year2025
Volume45
Issue3
Pages417-434
Publication date2025-08-01
Peer ReviewedYes
Open AccessYes
TypeARTICLE
VenuePolitics (JOURNAL)
Journal identifiersISSN: 0032-3268 • E-ISSN: 1467-9256
PublisherSAGE Publications (PUBLISHER • US)
DOI10.1177/02633957241231803
OpenAlexW4392056934
LanguageEN
Citations received19
References cited44

Populist parties place the people at the centre of polity and politics. Such parties refer to direct democracy as a suitable avenue to involve people in the decision-making process but much less is known about their approaches towards deliberation. This article seeks to address this gap in the literature and analyses how populist parties talk about deliberation in their election manifestos. It tests empirically how much they speak about deliberation and whether they have a generic discourse as opposed to specific references to forms of deliberation and levels of implementation. Our qualitative content analysis draws on the election manifestos of 84 political parties from the Manifesto Project Dataset in 23 European democracies in the national elections between 1996 and 2021. The results indicate that populists talk considerably less and use vague language about the levels of implementation compared to non-populists

Deliberation · Economics · Law and economics · Political economy · Political science · Politics · Populism · Positive economics · Sociology · Law

  • How Politicians Understand Deliberation

    Open Access•Bettina Mitru, Gherghina•Representation•2026

  • Consensus About the European Union? Understanding the Views of Citizens and Political Parties

    Open Access•Sergiu Mișcoiu, Gherghina•Politics and Governance•2026

  • Political parties and democratic innovations

    Open Access•Gherghina, Bettina Mitru et al.•Party Politics•2026

  • Populism in the EU and the trade-off between ethical claiming and mainstreaming

    Open Access•Nuria Font, Cristina Ares Castro-Conde•West European Politics•2026

  • Towards a Consultative Union? Unpacking Parliamentary Stances on Citizen Participation in EU Policy‐Making

    Open Access•Karolina Borońska-Hryniewiecka, Jan Kotýnek Krotký•JCMS Journal of Common Market…•2026

  • Rhetorical Consensus About the EU? Comparing Established and New Parties in Europe

    Open Access•Bettina Mitru, Paul Tap•Politics and Governance•2025

  • Limited Congruence

    Open Access•Gherghina, Brigitte Geissel et al.•Politics and Governance•2024

  • Standing apart

    Open Access•Bettina Mitru, Gherghina et al.•Comparative European Politics•2026

  • Thriving on poor soil? People’s attitudes towards deliberation in transition countries

    Open Access•Gherghina, Paul Tap•Contemporary Politics•2026

  • Which democracy do political parties want? The role of party personalism

    Open Access•Tristan Klingelhöfer, Gideon Rahat•Party Politics•2026

  • Democratic accountability regimes, populism, and transparency in the European Parliament

    Open Access•Nuria Font, Cristina Ares Castro-Conde•Journal of European Public Policy•2025

  • Democratic Innovation or Inertia? Ideology and Electoral Competition in Luxembourg Political Parties’ Engagement with the 2022 Climate Assembly

    Open Access•Emilien Paulis•PS Political Science & Politics•2025

  • Why Political Parties Support Deliberative Democracy in Europe

    Open Access•Gherghina, Bettina Mitru•Political Studies•2025

  • From Pitch Perfect to Epic Fail

    Open Access•Gherghina•JCMS Journal of Common Market…•2025

  • Pluralising pluralism in the study of populism

    Open Access•Alex Yates•Politics•2024

  • Maduro's Machines Against Paper Coalitions

    Open Access•Petar Bankov•Swiss Political Science Review•2025

  • Political Parties and Democratic Deliberation

    Open Access•Gherghina•PS Political Science & Politics•2025

  • When Ideology Trumps Deliberation

    Open Access•René Tapia•PS Political Science & Politics•2025

  • Political Parties and Forms of Citizens’ Involvement in Decision-Making

    Open Access•Gherghina•Political Studies Review•2025

  • The Oxford Handbook of Populism

    Cristóbal Rovira Kaltwasser, Paul Taggart et al.•The Oxford Handbook of Populism•2017

  • Foundations and Frontiers of Deliberative Governance

    John S Dryzek•Foundations and frontiers of…•2010

  • Deliberative Systems

    Open Access•John Parkinson, Jane Mansbridge•Deliberative Systems•2012

  • Democratic Innovations

    Open Access•Graham Smith•Democratic Innovations•2009

  • When the People Speak

    James S Fishkin, James Fishkin•When the People Speak•2011

  • Handbook of Democratic Innovation and Governance

    Stephen Elstub, Oliver Escobar•Handbook of Democratic Innovation…•2019

  • The Oxford Handbook of Deliberative Democracy

    André Bächtiger, John S Dryzek et al.•Oxford Handbook of Deliberative…•2018

  • Cultural Backlash

    Open Access•P Norris, Ronald Inglehart•Cultural Backlash•2019

  • Thematic analysis of qualitative data

    Michelle E Kiger, Lara Varpio•Medical Teacher•2020

  • Helping populism win? Social media use, filter bubbles, and support for populist presidential candidates in the 2016 US election campaign

    Jacob Groshek, Karolina Koc-Michalska•Information Communication & Society•2017

  • Democratic Deficit

    Open Access•P Norris•Democratic Deficit•2011

  • The participatory democracy turn

    Laurence Bherer, Pierre Dufour et al.•Journal of Civil Society•2016

  • Deliberative democracy and political parties

    Open Access•Gherghina, Sorina Soares et al.•European Political Science•2020

  • Fear and Loathing in Populist Campaigns? Comparing the Communication Style of Populists and Non-populists in Elections Worldwide

    Open Access•Alessandro Nai•Journal of Political Marketing•2018

  • Unifying and Multiplying the People

    Cecilia Biancalana, Oscar Mazzoleni•Nationalism and Ethnic Politics•2020

  • The Place of Self‐Interest and the Role of Power in Deliberative Democracy

    Open Access•Joanna Mansbridge, Jane Mansbridge et al.•Journal of Political Philosophy•2009

  • Ideology and Deliberation

    Open Access•Henrik Serup Christensen, Åsa Von Schoultz•International Journal of Public…•2017

  • Populists and Referendums in Europe

    Open Access•Gherghina, Nanuli Silagadze•The Political Quarterly•2020

  • Experimenting with a Democratic Ideal

    Open Access•James S Fishkin, James Fishkin et al.•Acta Politica•2005

  • Enraged, Engaged, or Both? A Study of the Determinants of Support for Consultative vs. Binding Mini-Publics

    Camille Bedock, Jean-Benoit Pilet•Representation•2023

  • Exclusionary vs. Inclusionary Populism

    Open Access•Cas Mudde, Cristóbal Rovira Kaltwasser•Government and Opposition•2012

  • Populism and representative politics in contemporary Europe

    Paul Taggart•Journal of Political Ideologies•2004

  • Do populist parties support referendums? A comparative analysis of election manifestos in Europe

    Open Access•Gherghina, Jean-Benoit Pilet•Electoral Studies•2021

  • Changing Democracy? Why Inertia is Winning Over Innovation

    Lidia Nunez, Caroline Close et al.•Representation•2016

  • Five Arguments for Deliberative Democracy

    Open Access•M Cooke•Political Studies•2000

  • Populism versus Democracy

    Open Access•Koen Abts, Stefan Rummen et al.•Political Studies•2007

  • Populism as a Political Strategy

    Open Access•K Weyland•Political Studies•2021

  • Trust the People! Populism and the Two Faces of Democracy

    Open Access•Margaret Canovan•Political Studies•1999

  • How Emotional Are Populists Really? Factors Explaining Emotional Appeals in the Communication of Political Parties

    Open Access•Tobias Widmann•Political Psychology•2021

  • The use and abuse of participatory governance by populist governments

    Open Access•Agnes Batory, Sara Svensson•Policy & Politics•2019

  • Right-Populists and Plebiscitary Politics in Canada

    Open Access•Darin Barney, Darin David Barney et al.•Party Politics•1999

  • Populism and Polarization in Comparative Perspective

    Open Access•Kenneth M Roberts•Government and Opposition•2022

  • Simple politics for the people? Complexity in campaign messages and political knowledge

    Open Access•Daniel Bischof, Roman Senninger•European Journal of Political…•2018

  • Dealing with populists in government

    Cristóbal Rovira Kaltwasser, Paul Taggart•Democratization•2016

  • Deliberative Democracy in an Unlikely Place

    Open Access•James S Fishkin, James Fishkin et al.•British Journal of Political…•2010

  • Support for Deliberative mini-Publics among the Losers of Representative Democracy

    Open Access•Jean-Benoit Pilet, Camille Bedock et al.•British Journal of Political…•2024

  • Participatory Institutions and Political Ideologies

    Open Access•Joan Font, Carlos Rico Motos•Political Studies Review•2025

  • Rethinking Populism

    Open Access•Benjamin Moffitt, Simon Tormey•Political Studies•2013

  • The Populist Zeitgeist

    Open Access•Cas Mudde•Government and Opposition•2004

  • Improving policy implementation through collaborative policymaking

    Christopher Ansell, Eva Sørensen et al.•Policy & Politics•2017

  • Between Facts and Norms

    Jürgen Habermas•Between Facts and Norms•1996

Unique citing works19
Citations per year9,5
Citation span2024 - 2026 (3)
Citation velocitycurrent
Highly citedNo
Citation typesNeutral: 19
Ethnos_APP • Open Source Project • MIT License • Frontend v2.0.0 • Privacy and Cookies • API Documentation: api.ethnos.app/docs • API Source Code: GitHub • DOI: 10.5281/zenodo.17049435 • Frontend Source Code: GitHub • DOI: 10.5281/zenodo.17050053 • cruz.rio.br • Expectantes Misericordiae