Skip to main content

ETHNOS_APP

Home • Search • Journals • List 0

Scale, Sovereignty, and Strategy in Environmental Governance

Bibliographic Data

ID8091334
AuthorsJames Mccarthy (0000-0003-2878-1921), James J Mccarthy (0000-0001-8881-935X, corresponding author)
Year2005
Volume37
Issue4
Pages731-753
Publication date2005-08-24
Peer ReviewedYes
Open AccessYes
TypeARTICLE
VenueAntipode (JOURNAL)
Journal identifiersISSN: 0066-4812 • E-ISSN: 1467-8330
PublisherWiley (PUBLISHER • GB)
DOI10.1111/j.0066-4812.2005.00523.x
OpenAlexW1993909509
LanguageEN
Citations received138
References cited35

Close examination of the scalar politics of environmental organizations engaged in contesting the terms of neoliberal globalization highlights four limitations of current theorizations of scale in radical geography. First, this body of work has paid little attention to environmental NGOs and movements as important actors in scalar politics. This is not only an empirical gap, but a theoretical one: taking environmental actors and issues into account requires rethinking the ontologies and dynamics in scale theory. Second, recent attention to social reproduction in scale debates must be extended to the reproduction of environmental conditions. Third, sharp analytical distinctions between scalar structuration and the production of nature are untenable and reproduce a culture/nature dualism. Fourth, sharp distinctions between politics within or about established scales, versus politics among scales, are unstable and miss the precise strategies pursued in some politics of scale. These arguments are illustrated and explored via case material drawn from current struggles over efforts to define environmental governance as a form of regulatory expropriation in international trade agreements

Corporate governance · Dualism · Economic system · Economics · Environmental governance · Environmental politics · Epistemology · Geography · Globalization · Law and economics · Political economy · Political science · Politics · Positive economics · Scalar (mathematics · Scale (ratio · Sociology · Sovereignty · Agriculture, Land Use, Rural Development · Geographies of human-animal interactions · Water Governance and Infrastructure · Law

  • A polymorphic approach to policy analysis

    Kirby Calvert, Kirby E Calvert et al.•Geografiska Annaler Series B…•2015

  • Intervenção

    Open Access•Rebecca Lave, Matthew W Wilson et al.•Espaço Aberto•2019

  • Where the power lies

    Open Access•Dickson Boateng, Julian Bloomer et al.•Geography Compass•2023

  • Frames of Scale Challenges in Finnish and Greek Biodiversity Conservation

    Open Access•Evangelia Apostolopoulou, Riikka Paloniemi•Conservation Ecology•2012

  • Political Ecology and Scale

    Open Access•Matthew D Turner•International Encyclopedia of…•2017

  • Territorial pluralism

    Open Access•Jaime Hoogesteger, R Boelens et al.•Water International•2016

  • Global Oceans Governance

    Open Access•Lisa M Campbell, Noella J Gray et al.•Annual Review of Environment and…•2016

  • What kind of governance for what kind of equity? Towards a theorization of justice in water governance

    T Perreault•Water International•2014

  • Defining, researching and struggling for water justice

    Margreet Zwarteveen, Margreet Z Zwarteveen et al.•Water International•2014

  • Repeating Islands of Resistance

    Open Access•Sasha Davis•Human Geography•2012

  • Disaster waste governance

    Open Access•Deepika Mathur, Robin Gregory et al.•International Journal of Disaster…•2026

  • Le démantèlement des politiques environnementales brésiliennes

    Neli Aparecida De Mello-Théry•Hérodote•2021

  • Scalar politics in transboundary fisheries management

    Open Access•Angela Abolhassani•Marine Policy•2023

  • From polygons to politics

    Open Access•Heidi Hausermann•Geoforum•2012

  • The limits of devolving sustainable development to the local level

    Open Access•Ian Florin•Sociologia Ruralis•2023

  • Scalar Struggles

    Open Access•Regula Lehmann, Rosa Lehmann et al.•Latin American Research Review•2022

  • Scale, shale, and the state

    Open Access•Eleanor Andrews, James J Mccarthy•Journal of Environmental Studies…•2013

  • Repensar a Escala Como Uma Categoria Geográfica

    Open Access•Adam Moore, Adam D Moore et al.•GEOgraphia•2018

  • Sea change

    Open Access•NoellaJ Gray•Conservation and Society•2010

  • Building Participation in Large-scale Conservation

    Open Access•JesseGuite Hastings•Conservation and Society•2015

  • Second-Order Condensations of Societal Power Relations

    Open Access•Ulrich Brand, C Görg et al.•Antipode•2011

  • Multi-dimensional influence measurement of urbanization on the quality of natural living environment in China

    Open Access•Jintao Li, Changjun Jiang et al.•Environment Development and…•2021

  • The Spanish livestock model

    Open Access•Sandra M Ríos‐núñez, Sandra M Ríos-Núñez et al.•Ecological Economics•2013

  • Sustainable resource governance in global production networks – challenges for human geography

    Open Access•Thomas Schmitt, Thomas M Schmitt et al.•Erdkunde•2016

  • Pandemic State Failure, Hydrocarbon Control, and Indigenous Territorial Counteraction in the Peruvian Amazon

    Open Access•Ana Watson, Conny Davidsen•Frontiers in Human Dynamics•2021

  • Constructing scale, eroding responsibility

    Open Access•Carol Hunsberger, Yanqi Adela Li•The Extractive Industries and…•2023

  • We Can’t Be Dependent on Anybody”

    Open Access•Carlo E Sica, Matthew T Huber•The Extractive Industries and…•2017

  • Natures of concern

    Open Access•Gisselle Vila-Benites•The Extractive Industries and…•2022

  • Variegated extractivism

    Open Access•James Alejandro Artiga-Purcell•The Extractive Industries and…•2021

  • The town that said “No” to the Enbridge Northern Gateway pipeline

    Open Access•Paul Bowles, Fiona Macphail•The Extractive Industries and…•2016

  • Disclosing Influence

    Open Access•Jennifer Baka, Arielle Hesse et al.•Energy Research & Social Science•2020

  • The spatial politics of energy conflicts

    Open Access•Carol Hunsberger, Rasmus Kløcker Larsen•Energy Research & Social Science•2021

  • River Commoning and the State

    Open Access•Jaime Hoogesteger, D Suhardiman et al.•Politics and Governance•2023

  • Policy Discourses and Marginal Places

    Open Access•Seema Arora-Jonsson•Social Sciences•2017

  • Towards a “Social Justice Ecosystem Framework” for Enhancing Livelihoods and Sustainability in Pastoralist Communities

    Open Access•Charles Fonchingong, Henry Ngenyam Bang•Societies•2024

  • Practicing environmental data justice

    Open Access•Dawn Walker, Eric Nost et al.•Geo Geography and Environment•2018

  • Repeating Islands of Resistance

    Open Access•Sasha Davis•Human Geography•2012

  • Territorial Governance, Market Integration and Indigenous Citizens in China’s State-led Eco-tourism

    Zhu Qian•Journal of China Tourism Research•2021

  • Defining World Hunger

    Lucy Jarosz•Food Culture & Society•2011

  • The Regulation of Environmental Space

    Open Access•Steve Herbert, Brandon Barclay Derman et al.•Annual Review of Law and Social…•2013

  • Going out and going green

    Xiaofeng Liu, M M Bennett•Eurasian Geography and Economics•2023

  • Macropolitics of Micronesia

    Open Access•Rebecca L Gruby•Global Environmental Politics•2017

  • Boundary Objects and Global Consensus

    Noella J Gray, Rebecca L Gruby et al.•Global Environmental Politics•2014

  • Multi-level governance for large marine commons

    Rebecca L Gruby, Xavier Basurto•Environmental Science & Policy•2013

  • Multi-level governance for large marine commons

    Rebecca L Gruby, Xavier Basurto•Environmental Science & Policy•2013

  • Governing Homelessness

    J B Bullen, Jane Bullen•Housing Theory and Society•2015

  • Scales of Political Action in the Anthropocene

    Ihnji Jon•Global Society•2019

  • Hemp for Sovereignty

    Steve Smith•Space and Polity•2008

  • Post-Fordist governance of nature

    Ulrich Brand, C Görg•Review of International Political…•2008

  • Crisis and continuity of capitalist society-nature relationships

    Ulrich Brand, Markus Wissen•Review of International Political…•2012

  • Fixing marine governance in Fiji? The new scalar narrative of ecosystem-based management

    Open Access•Leila Sievanen, Rebecca L Gruby et al.•Global Environmental Change•2012

  • Environmental dimensions of conflict and paralyzed responses

    Kristina Hook, Richard Marcantonio•Small Wars and Insurgencies•2022

  • Retooling” for the New West

    Eric Compas•Society & Natural Resources•2012

  • Indigenous worldviews and Western conventions

    Open Access•Daniel Coq Huelva, Bolier Torres et al.•Agriculture and Human Values•2017

  • Tall among the trees

    Open Access•Prudham•Journal of Rural Studies•2008

  • The contested scales of indigenous and settler jurisdiction

    Tyler Mccreary, Jerome Turner et al.•Studies in Political Economy•2018

  • Rethinking scale as a geographical category

    Open Access•Adam Moore•Progress in Human Geography•2008

  • What makes ecology `political

    Open Access•Haripriya Rangan, Christian A Kull et al.•Progress in Human Geography•2008

  • Strategic geographies

    Open Access•Sam Halvorsen•Progress in Human Geography•2025

  • Political ecology

    Open Access•Roderick P Neumann•Progress in Human Geography•2008

  • Environmental issues

    Open Access•Bruce Braun•Progress in Human Geography•2006

  • Childhood and the politics of scale

    Open Access•N Ansell•Progress in Human Geography•2008

  • Water and power, water’s power

    Open Access•A Nygren•World Development•2021

  • Scalar Politics in Sectoral Reforms

    Open Access•Jaime Hoogesteger, Yisenia Tiaguaro-Rea et al.•World Development•2017

  • Of scale and discourse

    Jiang Xu, Calvin King Lam Chung•Urban Geography•2023

  • Scale and the limitations of ontological debate

    Open Access•Helga Leitner, Byron Miller•Transactions of the Institute of…•2007

  • Space, discourse and environmental peacebuilding

    Tobias Ide•Third World Quarterly•2017

  • State Spaces of Resistance

    Open Access•Miles Kenney-Lazar, Miles Kenney‐lazar et al.•Antipode•2018

  • Regularizing Extraction in Andean Peru

    Open Access•Matthew Himley•Antipode•2013

  • Spatial Poetics Under Authoritarianism

    Open Access•Nick R Smith•Antipode•2020

  • Scalar Politics and the Co‐Evolution of Social and Ecological Systems in Coastal Southern Chile

    Open Access•Daniel Coq Huelva, Daniel Coq‐huelva et al.•Tijdschrift voor Economische en…•2018

  • Pits, Peripheralization and the Politics of Scale

    Colin Chambers, L Sandberg et al.•Regional Studies•2007

  • Contesting power, trust and legitimacy in the South African e-waste transition

    Open Access•Mary Lawhon•Policy Sciences•2012

  • Exploring water (in)securities in a water-abundant setting

    Open Access•Johanna Höhl, Juliane Dame et al.•Geoforum•2025

  • From impacts to embodied experiences

    Petra Tschakert•Geografisk Tidsskrift-Danish…•2012

  • Intervention

    Open Access•Rebecca Lave, Matthew W Wilson et al.•Canadian Geographies /…•2013

  • Gatekhili Mountains, gatekhili State

    Open Access•Jesse Swann-Quinn, Jesse Quinn•Revue de géographie alpine•2017

  • Montagnes gatekhili, État gatekhili

    Open Access•Jesse Swann-Quinn, Jesse Quinn et al.•Revue de géographie alpine•2017

  • Geographical work at the boundaries of climate policy

    Open Access•Inge Bailey, Ian Bailey•Transactions of the Institute of…•2008

  • Environmental movements in space‐time

    Open Access•Philip Sarre, Petr Jehlička•Transactions of the Institute of…•2007

  • Scale, causality, complexity and emergence

    Open Access•Mitch Chapura•Transactions of the Institute of…•2009

  • Environmental governance and the hybrid regime of Australian natural resource management

    Open Access•Michael Lockwood, Julie Davidson•Geoforum•2010

  • Fate of the verde

    Open Access•Bob Bolin, Timothy W Collins et al.•Geoforum•2008

  • The politics of scale and disaster risk governance

    Open Access•Blackburn, Sophie Blackburn•Geoforum•2014

  • Grassroots scalar politics

    Open Access•Jaime Hoogesteger, Andres Verzijl•Geoforum•2015

  • The politics of river basin planning and state transformation processes in Nepal

    Open Access•Diana Suhardiman, Ram C Bastakoti et al.•Geoforum•2018

  • Contested hydrosocial territories and disputed water governance

    Open Access•Lena Hommes, R Boelens et al.•Geoforum•2016

  • Vernacular heritage and evolving environmental policy in Australia

    Open Access•Ruth Lane, Joanna Wills et al.•Geoforum•2007

  • Scaling the Baltic Sea environment

    Open Access•Henrik Gutzon Larsen•Geoforum•2008

  • Landscape governance

    Open Access•C Görg•Geoforum•2007

  • Power and politics in climate change adaptation efforts

    Open Access•Andrea J Nightingale•Geoforum•2017

  • The symbolic and political appropriation of scales

    Open Access•Romain Taravella, Xavier Arnauld De Sartre•Geoforum•2012

  • Geo-political genetics

    Open Access•Lisa M Campbell, Matthew H Godfrey•Geoforum•2010

  • Hybrid drinking water governance

    Open Access•Kathleen O’reilly, Richa Dhanju•Geoforum•2012

  • The ‘greening’ of global project financing

    Open Access•Mike Bradshaw•Canadian Geographies /…•2007

  • Canadian geopolitical culture

    Open Access•Simon Dalby•Canadian Geographies /…•2019

  • Decolonizing the map? Toponymic politics and the rescaling of the Salish Sea

    Open Access•Brian Tucker, Brian Justin Tucker et al.•Canadian Geographies /…•2015

  • Scale and colonialism in nuclear waste siting

    Open Access•Warren Max Bernauer, Elysia Petrone•Canadian Geographies /…•2025

  • Market Environmentalism, New Environmental Policy Instruments, and Climate Policy in the United Kingdom and Germany

    Inge Bailey, Ian Bailey•Annals of the Association of…•2007

  • Regional Initiatives

    Melinda Harm Benson•Annals of the Association of…•2010

  • Risk Society

    Ulrich Beck•Risk Society•2013

  • Environment and economy

    Daniel W Bromley•Environment and economy•1991

  • Takings

    Richard A Epstein•Takings•1985

  • An Uncooperative Commodity

    Karen Bakker, Karen J Bakker•An uncooperative commodity•2004

  • Making Global Rules

    Adam Tickell, J Peck•Remaking the Global Economy:…•2003

  • “Globalization,” the “Regulation Approach,” and the Politics of Scale

    Open Access•Kevin R Cox•Geographies of Power•2002

  • Remaking Scale

    N T Smith, Neil Smith•Competitive European Peripheries•1995

  • Geography, Difference and the Politics of Scale

    N T Smith, Neil Smith•Postmodernism and the Social…•1992

  • Geographies of Power

    Open Access•Andrew Herod, Melissa W Wright•Geographies of Power - Placing…•2002

  • The social construction of scale

    Open Access•Sallie A Marston•Progress in Human Geography•2000

  • Environmental issues

    Open Access•N Castree•Progress in Human Geography•2002

  • States, scales and households

    Open Access•Sallie A Marston, N T Smith et al.•Progress in Human Geography•2001

  • How do we know we have global environmental problems? Science and the globalization of environmental discourse

    Open Access•Peter J Taylor, Frederick H Buttel•Geoforum•1992

  • The neoliberalization of ecosystem services

    Open Access•Morgan M Robertson, Morgan Robertson•Geoforum•2004

  • The social regulation of resource access and environmental impact

    Open Access•Gavin Bridge•Geoforum•2000

  • Risk society

    Ulrich Beck•Risikogesellschaft•1992

  • Protest and the scale politics of telecommunications

    Open Access•Paul C Adams•Political Geography•1996

  • Labor's spatial praxis and the geography of contract bargaining in the US east coast longshore industry, 1953-1989

    Open Access•Andrew Herod•Political Geography•1997

  • The political construction of scale

    Open Access•David Delaney, Helga Leitner•Political Geography•1997

  • The dramaturgy of horizons

    Open Access•John Agnew•Political Geography•1997

  • Empowering political struggle

    Open Access•Lynn A Staeheli•Political Geography•1994

  • Privatizing conditions of production

    Open Access•James Mccarthy, James J Mccarthy•Geoforum•2004

  • Neoliberal nature and the nature of neoliberalism

    Open Access•James Mccarthy, James J Mccarthy et al.•Geoforum•2004

  • The limits to scale? Methodological reflections on scalar structuration

    Open Access•Neil Brenner•Progress in Human Geography•2001

  • Devolution in the Woods

    Open Access•James Mccarthy, James J Mccarthy•Environment and Planning A…•2005

  • Intimate Encounters

    Open Access•Gavin Bridge, Adrian Smith•Environment and Planning D…•2003

  • Political Economies of Scale

    J Peck•Economic Geography•2002

  • Commons as counterhegemonic projects

    James Mccarthy, James J Mccarthy•Capitalism Nature Socialism•2005

  • Environmentalization

    Open Access•Frederick H Buttel•Rural Sociology•1992

Unique citing works138
Citations per year6,9
Citation span2006 - 2026 (21)
Citation velocitycurrent
Highly citedYes
Citation typesNeutral: 134

Tools

Open DOISci-HubOpen Access
Ethnos_APP • Open Source Project • MIT License • Frontend v2.0.0 • Privacy and Cookies • API Documentation: api.ethnos.app/docs • API Source Code: GitHub • DOI: 10.5281/zenodo.17049435 • Frontend Source Code: GitHub • DOI: 10.5281/zenodo.17050053 • cruz.rio.br • Expectantes Misericordiae