Skip to main content

ETHNOS_APP

Home • Search • Journals • List 0

Between ontology and representation

Locating Gilles Deleuze’s ‘difference-in-itself ’ in and for geographical thought

Bibliographic Data

ID8092081
AuthorsDaniel Cockayne (0000-0001-7482-8896, corresponding author), Daniel G Cockayne, Derek Ruez (0000-0002-0591-371X), Anna Secor (0000-0003-1506-4552, University of Kentucky)
Year2016
Volume41
Issue5
Pages580-599
Publication date2016-06-08
Peer ReviewedYes
Open AccessYes
TypeARTICLE
VenueProgress in Human Geography (JOURNAL)
Journal identifiersISSN: 0309-1325 • E-ISSN: 1477-0288
PublisherSAGE Publishing (PUBLISHER • US)
DOI10.1177/0309132516650028
OpenAlexW2411631772
LanguageEN
Citations received28
References cited100

The concept of difference has long been integral to geographical thought. However, it is rare for geographers to consider precisely what difference is, or how it functions, and there are several contrasting traditions through which difference is understood. We argue that geographers could helpfully extend their theorizations of difference through Deleuze’s philosophy of ‘difference-in-itself’. We examine the value of a ‘difference-in-itself’ that views difference as generative, originary, and primary, in productive tension with conceptions of difference that tend to, purposefully or otherwise, subordinate difference to presupposed identity-based, representational categories, or dialectical forms of contradiction and opposition

Aesthetics · Contradiction · Dialectic · Epistemology · Generative grammar · Identity (music · Linguistics · Ontology · Opposition (politics · Political science · Representation (politics · Significant difference · Sociology · Geographies of human-animal interactions · Historical Geography and Geographical Thought · Law · Mathematics · Philosophy · Posthumanist Ethics and Activism

  • Practising difference across geography

    Open Access•Heather J Miles•Environment and Planning F•2023

  • All Possible Pasts

    Open Access•Myung In Ji•International Journal of Urban…•2026

  • Sexual Difference Between Psychoanalysis and Vitalism

    Heidi J Nast, Anna Secor et al.•The AAG Review of Books•2016

  • Affective geopolitics

    Open Access•Banu Gökarıksel, Anna Secor•Environment and Planning C…•2018

  • Urbanity, Decline, and Regeneration in Later Medieval England

    Open Access•Ben Jervi•Open Archaeology•2024

  • What is ‘affective infrastructure’

    Open Access•Kai Bosworth•Dialogues in Human Geography•2022

  • Beyond Haraway? Addressing constructive criticisms to the ‘four epistemic gaps’ interpretation of positionality and situated knowledges

    Open Access•Dragos Simandan•Dialogues in Human Geography•2019

  • Inhabiting Two Places at the Same Time

    Open Access•G Bacchiddu, J Gómez•Island Studies Journal•2025

  • Reading is fun-da- mental

    Orlando Woods•Feminist Media Studies•2022

  • Sissy that walk’

    Orlando Woods•Continuum•2023

  • Education as site

    Open Access•Raine Aiava, Noora Pyyry et al.•Journal of Philosophy of Education•2025

  • Atmospheric geographies of (counter)terrorism

    Open Access•Sara Fregonese, P Simpson et al.•Progress in Human Geography•2024

  • Crystallising places

    Open Access•Peter Merriman•Progress in Human Geography•2023

  • Ontology, difference, and the antimicrobial resistance timeline

    Open Access•J Anthony Stallins, Sophie Strosberg•Futures•2020

  • Re‐arranging the urban

    Open Access•The Urban Re‐Arrangements Collective, Adam Abdullah et al.•Transactions of the Institute of…•2023

  • Places as refrains

    Open Access•Peter Merriman•Transactions of the Institute of…•2024

  • Interrogating scale in the Redd+ assemblage in Papua New Guinea

    Open Access•Pascoe, Sophie Pascoe•Geoforum•2018

  • Post-phenomenology, consumption and warfare on the urban leisure path, USA

    Open Access•Jacob C Miller, Aditi Das•Geoforum•2021

  • Gender, class, race, ethnicity and power in an elite girls’ state school

    Open Access•Louise Holt, Sophie Bowlby•Geoforum•2019

  • The understated turn

    Open Access•Chloe Asker, Gavin J Andrews•Canadian Geographies /…•2020

  • Spatial Justice in the Data-Driven City

    Open Access•Miriam Tedeschi, Amalia Verdu Sanmartin•Annals of the American…•2026

  • Besides affirmationism? On geography and negativity

    Open Access•Thomas Dekeyser, Thomas Jellis•Area•2020

  • Worldless futures

    Open Access•Thomas Dekeyser•Transactions of the Institute of…•2022

  • Spectacle, tourism and the performance of everyday geopolitics

    Open Access•Jacob C Miller, Vincent Del Casino•Environment and Planning C…•2020

  • Thinking space differently

    Open Access•Daniel Cockayne, Derek Ruez et al.•Transactions of the Institute of…•2019

  • Feeling otherwise

    Open Access•Derek Ruez, Daniel Cockayne•Dialogues in Human Geography•2021

  • Transport innovations in the cracks

    Open Access•E Schramm, Javier Lloveras et al.•Local Environment•2025

  • Glitches, geopoetics, and the matter of migration

    Open Access•Kahina Meziant•Geographical Journal•2025

  • Hegel and Deleuze

    Karen Houle, Jim Vernon•Hegel and Deleuze•2013

  • Poststructuralist Geographies

    Marcus A Doel, Marcus Doel•Poststructuralist Geographies•1999

  • The Reorder of Things

    Roderick A Ferguson•The Reorder of Things•2012

  • Essays on Deleuze

    Daniel W Smith, Daniel Smith et al.•Essays on Deleuze•2012

  • Uneven Development

    N T Smith, Neil Smith et al.•Uneven Development•2008

  • Planning in the multicultural city

    Open Access•Ruth Fincher, Kurt Iveson et al.•Progress in Planning•2014

  • On Not Excluding Half of the Human in Human Geography

    Janice Monk, Susan Hanson•The Professional Geographer•1982

  • Justice, nature, and the geography of difference

    David Harvey•Justice, nature, and the…•1996

  • Postmodern geographies

    Edward W Soja•Postmodern geographies•1989

  • Gender, Race, Sexuality

    Linda Peake•The Sage Handbook of Social…•2010

  • Gender and sexuality I

    Open Access•Michael G Brown, Michael Brown•Progress in Human Geography•2012

  • Geography, Difference and the Politics of Scale

    N T Smith, Neil Smith•Postmodernism and the Social…•1992

  • Vancouver’s Chinatown

    Kay Anderson, Kay J Anderson•Vancouver's Chinatown•1991

  • Hegel, Deleuze, and the Critique of Representation

    Henry Somers-Hall•Hegel, Deleuze, and the Critique…•2012

  • The Future of Hegel

    Catherine Malabou•Future of Hegel•2004

  • Nomadic subjects

    R Braidotti, M Eagleton et al.•Choice Reviews Online•1995

  • Spatial Divisions of Labor

    Doreen Massey•Spatial Divisions of Labor•2024

  • Theorizing and Researching Intersectionality

    G Valentine•The Professional Geographer•2007

  • Fatal Couplings of Power and Difference

    Ruth Wilson Gilmore•The Professional Geographer•2002

  • Terrorist Assemblages

    J K Puar, MARÍA ENGUIX TERCERO et al.•Terrorist Assemblages:…•2007

  • On the other Hand … Dialectics

    Open Access•Deborah Dixon, Deborah P Dixon et al.•Environment and Planning A…•2008

  • “How Shall I Say it … ?” Relating the Nonrelational

    Open Access•Paul Harrison•Environment and Planning A…•2007

  • Gilles Deleuze's Difference and Repetition

    James D Williams, James Williams•Gilles Deleuze's 'Difference and…•2013

  • The Sex Which Is Not One

    Brigitte Beauzamy•Innovation The European Journal…•2007

  • Geography and the construction of difference

    Geraldine Pratt, Susan Hanson•Gender Place & Culture•1994

  • Intersectionality and planning at the margins

    Clara Irazabal Zurita, Claudia Huerta•Gender Place & Culture•2015

  • Multicultural girlhood

    Decoteau J Irby•Gender and Education•2012

  • Thinking through work

    Open Access•L Mcdowell•Progress in Human Geography•2008

  • Dialectics and difference

    Open Access•Andrew Jones•Progress in Human Geography•1999

  • Political geography

    Open Access•Lynn A Staeheli•Progress in Human Geography•2008

  • Constructing Difference in Public Spaces

    Susan Ruddick•Urban Geography•1996

  • Desert Islands and Other Texts, 1953–1974

    Daniel W Smith, Daniel Smith et al.•Teaching Philosophy•2005

  • Birds, Mice and Geography

    N Castree•Transactions of the Institute of…•1996

  • The modern model family at home in Singapore

    Open Access•N Oswin•Transactions of the Institute of…•2010

  • Matter(s) in social and cultural geography

    Open Access•Ben Anderson, Divya P Tolia-Kelly et al.•Geoforum•2004

  • The Rice Steamer’

    Gilbert Caluya•Australian Geographer•2008

  • Structural Marxism and Human Geography

    Sue Duncan, James Duncan et al.•Annals of the Association of…•1982

  • The Socio-Spatial Dialectic

    Edward W Soja•Annals of the Association of…•1980

  • The Nature of Geography

    Richard Hartshorne•Annals of the Association of…•1939

  • The ambivalence of familiarity

    Open Access•Junjia Ye•Area•2016

  • Thinking with assemblage

    Open Access•Colin Mcfarlane, Ben Anderson•Area•2011

  • Black Faces, White Spaces

    Carolyn Finney•Black Faces, White Spaces•2014

  • Not Everyone Has (the) Balls

    Open Access•Carey Mott, Carrie Mott et al.•Antipode•2013

  • Emotions and affect in recent human geography

    Open Access•Steve Pile•Transactions of the Institute of…•2009

  • Situating the Anthropocene

    Sue Ruddick•Urban Geography•2015

  • Affective atmospheres

    Open Access•Ben Anderson•Emotion, space and society•2009

  • Towards an evental geography

    Open Access•Isabel Shaw, Ian G R Shaw•Progress in Human Geography•2012

  • Bodies, gender, place and culture

    Robyn Longhurst, Lesley Johnston•Gender Place & Culture•2014

  • Force‐full

    Open Access•Isabel Shaw, Ian G R Shaw et al.•Area•2013

  • The Deleuze-Guattarian assemblage

    Open Access•J-D Dewsbury•Area•2011

  • An event of geographical ethics in spaces of affect

    Open Access•Derek P Mccormack•Transactions of the Institute of…•2003

  • Feminism, bodily difference and non‐representational geographies

    Open Access•Robert Colls, Rachel Colls•Transactions of the Institute of…•2011

  • A thousand plateaus

    Félix Guattari, Gilles Deleuze•A thousand plateaus•1987

  • Geopolitics by another name

    Open Access•Caroline Nagel, C R Nagel•Political Geography•2002

  • Parables for the Virtual

    Open Access•B Massumi, Stanley Fish et al.•Parables for the Virtual•2002

  • A thousand tiny sexes

    Open Access•Elizabeth Grosz•Topoi•1993

  • Human geography without scale

    Open Access•Sallie A Marston, John Paul Jones et al.•Transactions of the Institute of…•2005

  • Geopolitical assemblages and complexity

    Open Access•Jason Dittmer•Progress in Human Geography•2013

  • Terrorist Assemblages

    J K Puar•The SHAFR Guide Online•2017

  • The Cunning of Recognition

    Elizabeth A Povinelli, George Steinmetz et al.•Cunning of Recognition•2002

  • Situating Flatness

    Open Access•John Paul Jones, Keith Woodward et al.•Transactions of the Institute of…•2007

  • Living with difference

    Open Access•G Valentine•Progress in Human Geography•2008

  • Assemblages and Actor-networks

    Open Access•Marguerite Müller, Martin Müller•Geography Compass•2015

  • Sorting Bodies

    Open Access•Dan Swanton•Environment and Planning A…•2010

  • Nonhuman Charisma

    Open Access•Jamie Lorimer•Environment and Planning D…•2007

  • Flesh, Metal, Road

    Open Access•Dan Swanton•Environment and Planning D…•2010

  • Mapping Children's Politics

    Open Access•Katharyne Mitchell, Sarah Elwood•Environment and Planning D…•2012

  • Afterimages

    Open Access•Marcus A Doel, Duncan Clarke et al.•Environment and Planning D…•2007

  • On the Role of Affect and Practice in the Production of Place

    Open Access•Cameron Duff•Environment and Planning D…•2010

  • Reontologising Race

    Open Access•Arun Saldanha•Environment and Planning D…•2006

  • Who are 'The People

    Open Access•Sallie A Marston, A Marston•Environment and Planning D…•1990

  • Disreputable Life

    Open Access•Eric Olund•Environment and Planning D…•2010

  • Towards Minor Theory

    Open Access•Cindi Katz•Environment and Planning D…•1996

  • Thinking like a Fish? Engaging with Nonhuman Difference through Recreational Angling

    Open Access•Christopher Bear, Sally Eden•Environment and Planning D…•2011

  • So High You Can't Get Over it, So Low You Can't Get Under it

    Rashad Shabazz•Souls•2009

  • Geographic Dialectics

    Open Access•Elaine Sheppard•Environment and Planning A…•2008

  • We Turks are No Germans

    Open Access•Patricia Ehrkamp•Environment and Planning A…•2006

  • Immanent Politics

    Open Access•Jason Lim•Environment and Planning A…•2010

  • Managing Strangerhood

    Open Access•Peter Hopkins•Environment and Planning A…•2014

  • Žižek's Dialectics of Difference and the Problem of Space

    Open Access•Anna Secor, Anna J Secor•Environment and Planning A…•2008

  • The Subaltern Moment in Hegel's Dialectic

    Open Access•Vinay Gidwani•Environment and Planning A…•2008

  • Writing Difference

    Open Access•Marcus A Doel•Environment and Planning A…•1994

  • On Geography and Materiality

    Open Access•Ben Anderson, Jonathan Wylie et al.•Environment and Planning A…•2009

  • Towards a Dialectics of the Positive

    Open Access•Sue Ruddick•Environment and Planning A…•2008

  • Masculinities in place

    Peter Hopkins, Greg Noble•Social & Cultural Geography•2009

  • Punks, Bulldaggers, and Welfare Queens

    Cathy J Cohen, Cathy Cohen•GLQ A Journal of Lesbian and Gay…•1997

  • The Spirit of Neoliberalism

    Jodi Melamed•Social Text•2006

  • Materialist returns

    Open Access•Sarah Whatmore•Cultural Geographies•2006

  • Engineering affective atmospheres on the moving geographies of the 1897 Andrée expedition

    Open Access•Derek P Mccormack•Cultural Geographies•2008

  • Race' in post-universalist perspective

    Open Access•Kay Anderson•Cultural Geographies•2008

  • The Politics of Affect

    Open Access•Susan Ruddick•Theory Culture & Society•2010

Unique citing works28
Citations per year2,8
Citation span2016 - 2026 (11)
Citation velocitycurrent
Highly citedNo
Citation typesNeutral: 28

Tools

Open DOISci-HubOpen Access
Ethnos_APP • Open Source Project • MIT License • Frontend v2.0.0 • Privacy and Cookies • API Documentation: api.ethnos.app/docs • API Source Code: GitHub • DOI: 10.5281/zenodo.17049435 • Frontend Source Code: GitHub • DOI: 10.5281/zenodo.17050053 • cruz.rio.br • Expectantes Misericordiae