Differences between the hand–wrist and the knee in assigned skeletal ages

Skeletal ages were assessed for 4,902 pairs of hand–wrist and knee radiographs of children aged 2–17 years. The FELS method was used to assess the hand–wrist, and the RWT method was used to asses the knee. These methods have the same conceptual and statistical basis. The mean absolute differences, within age‐ and sex‐specific groups, ranged from 0.34 to 0.87 years. The SD of the differences ranged from 0.31 to 0.68 years and, like the means, tended to increase with age until about 8–11 years. The means and SD were generally larger for the boys than for the girls, except after 14 years. Within age‐ and sex‐specific groups, the maximum absolute differences were from 1.45 to 2.99 years. These maximum differences changed irregularly with age but tended to increase until 11 years in the boys and 9 years in the girls. These large absolute differences between the skeletal ages of the hand–wrist and the knee cannot be explained completely by the effects of observer errors. The means of the relative (signed) differences between the skeletal ages of the hand–wrist and the knee were all close to zero, but there was a wide range within age‐ and sex‐specific groups. These skeletal ages of the hand–wrist and the knee are not interchangeable. The 95th percentiles of the absolute differences show that, in at least 5% of children, the choice of the area for skeletal age assessment will markedly influence the evaluation of individuals. They also demonstrate that descriptions of populations based on distributions of skeletal ages from one part of the skeleton may be misleading

Knee Joint · Physical medicine and rehabilitation · Physical therapy · Wrist · Anatomy · Bone fractures and treatments · Medicine · Orthopaedic implants and arthroplasty · Orthopedic Surgery and Rehabilitation · Surgery

• Assessment of skeletal maturity of the hand-wrist and knee

  Open Access•Giorgio Aicardi, M Vignolo et al.•American Journal of Human Biology•2000

  Add to list

• Effect of familial distress on growth and maturation of girls

  Open Access•Barbara Hulanicka, Lidia Gronkiewicz et al.•American Journal of Human Biology•2001

  Add to list

• Radiographic Atlas of Skeletal Development of the Hand and Wrist

  William Walter Greulich, William Greulich et al.•The American Journal of the…•1959

  Add to list

• Complete epiphyseal union of the hand

  Open Access•Stanley M Garn, Christabel G Rohmann et al.•American Journal of Physical…•1961

  Add to list