The obstetric dilemma
An ancient game of Russian roulette, or a variable dilemma sensitive to ecology
Bibliographic Data
| ID | 8320655 |
|---|---|
| Authors | J Wells (0000-0003-0411-8025, Institute of Child Health, corresponding author), Jonathan C K Wells, Jeremy M Desilva, Jeremy Desilva (0000-0001-7010-1155, Boston University), Jay T Stock (0000-0003-0147-8631) |
| Year | 2012 |
| Volume | 149 |
| Issue | S55 |
| Pages | 40-71 |
| Publication date | 2012-01-01 |
| Peer Reviewed | Yes |
| Open Access | Yes |
| Type | ARTICLE |
| Venue | American Journal of Physical Anthropology (JOURNAL) |
| Journal identifiers | ISSN: 0002-9483 • E-ISSN: 1096-8644 |
| Publisher | Wiley (PUBLISHER • GB) |
| DOI | 10.1002/ajpa.22160 |
| PMID | 23138755 |
| OpenAlex | W2091834144 |
| Language | EN |
| Citations received | 72 |
| References cited | 286 |
The difficult birth process of humans, often described as the “obstetric dilemma,” is commonly assumed to reflect antagonistic selective pressures favoring neonatal encephalization and maternal bipedal locomotion. However, cephalo‐pelvic disproportion is not exclusive to humans, and is present in some primate species of smaller body size. The fossil record indicates mosaic evolution of the obstetric dilemma, involving a number of different evolutionary processes, and it appears to have shifted in magnitude between Australopithecus , Pleistocene Homo , and recent human populations. Most attention to date has focused on its generic nature, rather than on its variability between populations. We re‐evaluate the nature of the human obstetric dilemma using updated hominin and primate literature, and then consider the contribution of phenotypic plasticity to variability in its magnitude. Both maternal pelvic dimensions and fetal growth patterns are sensitive to ecological factors such as diet and the thermal environment. Neonatal head girth has low plasticity, whereas neonatal mass and maternal stature have higher plasticity. Secular trends in body size may therefore exacerbate or decrease the obstetric dilemma. The emergence of agriculture may have exacerbated the dilemma, by decreasing maternal stature and increasing neonatal growth and adiposity due to dietary shifts. Paleodemographic comparisons between foragers and agriculturalists suggest that foragers have considerably lower rates of perinatal mortality. In contemporary populations, maternal stature remains strongly associated with perinatal mortality in many populations. Long‐term improvements in nutrition across future generations may relieve the dilemma, but in the meantime, variability in its magnitude is likely to persist. Am J Phys Anthropol, 2012. © 2012 Wiley Periodicals, Inc
Biology · Dilemma · Evolutionary biology · Phenotypic plasticity · Zoology · Birth, Development, and Health · Child Nutrition and Water Access · Ecology · Pregnancy and preeclampsia studies
Conflict, Constraint, Cooperation, and Allocation
Organ Size and Metabolic Rate Co‐Vary with Dimensions of the Obstetric Pelvis
Is birth attendance a uniquely human feature? New evidence suggests that Bonobo females protect and support the parturient
Sexual dimorphism of the pelvic girdle from 3D images of a living Spanish sample from Castilla-La Mancha
Age related changes in pelvis size among adolescent and adult females with reference to parturition from Naraingarh, Haryana (India)
Investigating Associations Between Developmental Integration and Physiological Stress
Pregnancy outcome and delivery in Spanish and migrant women
Revisión crítica de la utilización del ilion para el diagnóstico de sexo en restos esqueléticos de individuos subadultos mediante técnicas morfométricas
The invisible evidence of birth
The Metabolic Ghetto
The Evolutionary Biology of the Human Pelvis
Primate Life Histories
Primate Life Histories
Preterm Birth
Hominin Evolution I
Evolutionary perspectives on human height variation
Childbirth and Brain Size, Evolutionary Constraints of
Fire & Language
What a Difference a Couple Hundred Million Years Can Make
Discernment of mortality risk associated with childbirth in archaeologically derived forager skeletons
Humans as inverted bats
The study of commingled non-adult human remains
Indicators of motherhood? Sacral preauricular extensions and notches in identified skeletal collections
Life in the fast lane
Evaluation of dual‐energy X‐ray absorptiometry compared to magnetic resonance imaging for collecting measurements of the human bony pelvis
Skeletal variability in the pelvis and limb skeleton of humans
Moving Beyond the Obstetrical Dilemma Hypothesis
Care of Infants in the Past
More Than Childbirth
The Skeletal Phenotype of “Negritos” from the Andaman Islands and Philippines Relative to Global Variation among Hunter-Gatherers
Biocultural perspectives on maternal mortality and obstetrical death from the past to the present
Sexual dimorphism in populations of Southern Siberia
Testing the Energetics of Gestation and Growth Hypothesis for Human Secondary Altriciality
Similarities in pelvic dimorphisms across populations
Obstetric dimensions of the female pelvis are less integrated than locomotor dimensions and show protective scaling patterns
Associations between early marriage and preterm delivery
Maternal motives behind elective cesarean sections
Maternal physical, socioeconomic, and demographic characteristics and childbirth complications in rural lowland Nepal
Introduction
Does obstetric protection apply to small‐bodied females
Reintegrating modern birth practice within ancient birth process
Influence of climatic stress on nonmetric sexually dimorphic features of the skull and pelvis
Patterns of directional asymmetry in the pelvis and pelvic canal
Pelvic and neonatal size correlations in light of evolutionary hypotheses
Caesarean sections are associated with sonographic determined fetal size from the second trimester onwards
Beyond sex, gender, and other dilemmas
The multifactor pelvis
A lineage explanation of human normative guidance
A geometric morphometric assessment of shape variation in adult pelvic morphology
Relationships of maternal and paternal anthropometry with neonatal body size, proportions and adiposity in an Australian cohort
Shape variation in the human pelvis and limb skeleton
Sexual dimorphism in the size and shape of the non‐obstetric pelvis across anthropoids
Bony pelvic canal size and shape in relation to body proportionality in humans
Variation in obstetric dimensions of the human bony pelvis in relation to age‐at‐death and latitude
Energetic cost of walking in fossil hominins
The torso integration hypothesis revisited in Homo sapiens
Sexual dimorphism of the relationship between the gut and pelvis in humans
Sexual dimorphism in relative sacral breadth among catarrhine primates
Selective pressures in the human bony pelvis
Variability and the form–function framework in evolutionary biomechanics and human locomotion
Ilium morphological variation during growth in forager populations
Pelvic shape variation among gorilla subspecies
Human Energy Expenditure in Anthropology and Beyond
Love, lust, and physical intimacy
Infant funerary behavior and kinship in Pleistocene hunter-gatherers from Morocco
Virtual reconstruction of the Kebara 2 Neanderthal pelvis
Virtual reconstruction of the Australopithecus africanus pelvis Sts 65 with implications for obstetrics and locomotion
Are parturition scars truly signs of birth? The estimation of parity in a well-documented modern sample
The Evolution of Difficult Childbirth and Helpless Hominin Infants
Did population differences in human pelvic form evolve by drift or selection
Reconstruction of Two Mother-Infant Dyads and Obstetrical Consequences of the Mesolithic-Neolithic Transition
Bioarchaeological investigation of an obstetric death at Huigou site (3900-2900 BC), Henan, China
Human Birth
Nisa
Body size, body proportions, and encephalization in a Middle Pleistocene archaic human from northern China
Secular trends in growth
Maternal mortality for 181 countries, 1980–2008
Parent-Offspring Conflict
Origins and evolution of the Western diet
The shape of the Neandertal femur is primarily the consequence of a hyperpolar body form
Unwanted caesarean sections among public and private patients in Brazil
Neandertal birth canal shape and the evolution of human childbirth
A Partial Pelvis of Australopithecus sediba
Middle Pleistocene lower back and pelvis from an aged human individual from the Sima de los Huesos site, Spain
Tools and Human Evolution
Birth, obstetrics and human evolution
Neanderthal brain size at birth provides insights into the evolution of human life history
Genetic Conflicts in Human Pregnancy
A shift toward birthing relatively large infants early in human evolution
Type 2 (non-insulin-dependent) diabetes mellitus
A Female Homo erectus Pelvis from Gona, Ethiopia
Global nutrition transition and the pandemic of obesity in developing countries
The Symbolic Species
The Backbone of History
Obesity as malnutrition
The obstetric pelvis of A.L. 288-1 (Lucy)
Midwives, Society and Childbirth
Encephalization and Obstetrics in Primates with Particular Reference to Human Evolution
A Woman Cannot Die from a Pregnancy She Does Not Have
Nutritional ecology of pastoralists in dry tropical Africa
Assessing the net effect of young maternal age on birthweight
Bipedalism and human birth
Climatic influences on human body size and proportions
Do big females have big pelves
Eating Down in Pregnancy
Associations between pelvic anatomy, height and year of birth of men and women in Belfast
The height of women in Sub-Saharan Africa
Climate and anthropometric variations in Europe and the Mediterranean area
A Case of Maternal and Perinatal Death in Neolithic Southern Vietnam, c. 2100–1050 BCE
Coming to America
Seafood consumption in pregnancy and infant size at birth
Cesarean section and operative vaginal delivery in low-risk primiparous women, Western Australia
The evolution of maternal birthing position
The “Rich Athenian Lady” Was Pregnant
Genetic basis of human female pelvic morphology
Perinatal mortality at pre‐Columbian Teotihuacan
Maternal mortality in pre‐Columbian Indians of Arica, Chile
Mortality of pregnant females in Arikara villages
Life stresses of slavery
Natural selection and developmental sexual variation in the human pelvis
Sex differences in the pelves of primates
Birth weight and environmental heat load
The evolution of modern human childbirth
Protection of obstetric dimensions in a small‐bodied human sample
Sagittal clefting of the body and other vertebral developmental errors in Canadian Inuit skeletons
Estimation of stature and body mass from the skeleton among coastal and mid‐altitude andean populations
Body size among Holocene foragers of the Cape Ecozone, southern Africa
Labor and delivery behavior in rhesus monkeys ( Macaca mulatta )
Evaluation of the obstetric significance of some pelvic characters in an 18th century british sample of known parity status
Obstetric dimensions of the true pelvis in a Medieval population from Sudanese Nubia
Sexual dimorphism and allometry in primate ossa coxae
Ecogeographical associations between climate and human body composition
Adult proportionality in small‐bodied foragers
Relation of the pelvis to erect posture. An exploratory study
Pelvic sexual dimorphism and relative neonatal brain size really are related
Reconstruction of the STS 14 ( Australopithecus africanus ) pelvis
Biomechanics of the hip and birth in early Homo
Big-bodied males help us recognize that females have big pelves
Morphological adaptation to climate in modern and fossil hominids
Body weight, race and climate
Sexual dimorphism in the human bony pelvis, with a consideration of the Neandertal pelvis from Kebara cave, Israel
Use and misuse of the reduced major axis for line‐fitting
Possible metabolic constraints on human brain weight at birth
The influence of stature and body form on hominid energy and water budgets; a comparison of Australopithecus and early Homo physiques
Variation in Human Body Size and Shape
Lying-in
Brain size at birth throughout human evolution
Sexual dimorphism in primate neonatal body mass
Comparison of the pelves of Sts 14 and AL288-1
The negative secular trend
The shoulders follow the head
Obstetrics and posture in pelvic anatomy
AL 288-1-Lucy or Lucifer
Obstetrical interpretation of the australopithecine pelvic cavity
Chimpanzee neonatal brain size
The thermoregulatory advantages of large body size for hominids foraging in savannah environments
Functional aspects of pelvic morphology in simian Primates
Body mass in comparative primatology
Pelvic dimorphism in relation to body size and body size dimorphism in humans
Body size and body shape in early hominins - implications of the Gona Pelvis
A new reconstruction of Sts 14 pelvis (Australopithecus africanus) from computed tomography and three-dimensional modeling techniques
An evolutionary life-history framework for understanding sex differences in human mortality rates
Parto cesáreo
Adipose tissue in human infancy and childhood
Research on secular trends in auxology
Pelvic stress injuries in a small-bodied forager
Roman Period fetal skeletons from the East Cemetery (Kellis 2) of Kellis, Egypt
Anthropology of human birth
Associations of economic and gender inequality with global obesity prevalence
Some Problems Associated with Pelvic Form and Size in the Ganda of East Africa
Maternity, Medicine, and Power
La diversite humaine en Afrique subsaharienne
| Unique citing works | 72 |
|---|---|
| Citations per year | 5,54 |
| Citation span | 2013 - 2026 (14) |
| Citation velocity | current |
| Highly cited | No |
| Citation types | Neutral: 63 |