Individual Differences in Melancholy Gender Among Women

This research offers an empirical investigation inspired by Butler's theory of melancholy gender (1995) and a revision of this theory (Jay 2007a). Psychoanalytic feminist theory is drawn on to suggest that melancholy and gender are more likely to be associated in female development than in male development, and Freud's theory of melancholy (1917) is taken to suggest that ambivalence predicts individual differences in melancholy gender among women. In a longitudinal study of women's adult development, an examination of femininity, depressive symptoms, and ambivalence in attachment was conducted in order to evaluate these claims. Findings show that depressive symptoms and femininity are significantly correlated within the sample, but that individual differences in melancholy gender exist. To understand these differences, an analysis was conducted to determine whether ambivalence in attachment accounts for the relation between depressive symptoms and femininity; complementary analyses examined whether low ambivalence in attachment attenuates, or lessens, the relation between femininity and depressive symptoms. Results from these analyses support the notion that it is not the loss and internalization of the same-sex object choice per se that results in melancholy gender in women, as Butler argues; rather, it is the internalization of a lost, ambivalent same-sex attachment that forges the link between melancholy and gender. Narrative material is presented to personify melancholy and unmelancholy gender

Ambivalence · Art · Developmental psychology · Femininity · Narrative · Psychoanalysis · Psychoanalytic theory · Attachment and Relationship Dynamics · Gender Roles and Identity Studies · Identity, Memory, and Therapy · Psychology

• Straw Men, Straight Women, and the Role of Ambivalence in Melancholy Gender

  Meg Jay•Studies in Gender and Sexuality•2007

  Incluir item

• Melancholy Femininity and Obsessive-Compulsive Masculinity

  Meg Jay•Studies in Gender and Sexuality•2007

  Incluir item

• The Interplay of Genes, Environments, and Psychoanalysis

  Open Access•Stuart T Hauser•Journal of the American…•2008

  Incluir item

• Attachment and loss

  John Bowlby•Attachment and loss•1981

  Incluir item

• Applied Multiple Regression/Correlation Analysis for the Behavioral Sciences

  Jacob Cohen, Patricia Cohen et al.•Applied Multiple Regression/Correla…•2014

  Incluir item

• The Reproduction of Mothering

  Nancy J Chodorow, Nancy Chodorow et al.•Reproduction of Mothering•1978

  Incluir item

• Sex Differences and the Epidemiology of Depression

  Myrna M Weissman•Archives of General Psychiatry•1977

  Incluir item

• The role of rumination in depressive disorders and mixed anxiety/depressive symptoms.

  Susan Nolen-Hoeksema, Susan Nolen–hoeksema•Journal of Abnormal Psychology•2000

  Incluir item

• Testing Moderator and Mediator Effects in Counseling Psychology Research.

  Patricia A Frazier, Andrew P Tix et al.•Journal of Counseling Psychology•2004

  Incluir item

• The CES-D Scale

  Open Access•Lenore Sawyer Radloff•Applied Psychological Measurement•1977

  Incluir item

• Keeping it moving commentary on Judith Butler's “melancholy gender—refused identification”

  Adam Phillips•Psychoanalytic Dialogues•1995

  Incluir item

• Attachment and Loss. Vol. 1. Attachment

  GEORGE W REVER•Psychosomatic Medicine•1972

  Incluir item

• Melancholy gender—refused identification

  Judith Butler•Psychoanalytic Dialogues•1995

  Incluir item

• The Implications of Unmitigated Agency and Unmitigated Communion for Domains of Problem Behavior

  Open Access•Vicki S Helgeson, Heidi L Fritz•Journal of Personality•2000

  Incluir item

• Straw Men, Straight Women, and the Role of Ambivalence in Melancholy Gender

  Meg Jay•Studies in Gender and Sexuality•2007

  Incluir item

• Femininity, Depression and Stress in College Women

  Open Access•Elizabeth W Brazelton, Katherine S Greene et al.•Social Behavior and Personality…•1996

  Incluir item

• The Adjective Check List as a Personality Assessment Research Technique

  Open Access•Harrison G Gough•Psychological Reports•1960

  Incluir item

• Depression and gender

  Frances M Culbertson•American Psychologist•1997

  Incluir item

• Feminine sex role and depression in middle-aged women

  Open Access•Emiley G Tinsley, Sandra Sullivan-Guest et al.•Sex Roles•1984

  Incluir item

• The role of masculinity and femininity in depression and social satisfaction in elderly females

  Open Access•Lester Krames, Rebecca England et al.•Sex Roles•1988

  Incluir item

• Psychological distress, problem solving, and coping reactions

  Open Access•Arthur M Nezu, Christine Maguth Nezu•Sex Roles•1987

  Incluir item

• Gender, Gender Roles, and Personality

  Open Access•Liliana Lengua, Liliana J Lengua et al.•Sex Roles•2000

  Incluir item

• Sex-role orientation and psychological well-being

  Open Access•Bernard E Whitley•Sex Roles•1985

  Incluir item

• The growing evidence for personality change in adulthood

  Open Access•Ravenna Helson, Virginia S Y Kwan et al.•Journal of Research in Personality•2002

  Incluir item

• Sex Roles, Interpersonal Control, and Depression

  Open Access•Steven Sayer, Steven L Sayers et al.•Journal of Research in Personality•1993

  Incluir item

• On Deconstructing and Reconstructing Masculinity–Femininity

  Open Access•Richard A Lippa•Journal of Research in Personality•2001

  Incluir item

• Relationships of MMPI Mf and CPI Fe scales of fourfold sex role classifications

  Nancy E Betz, Ricki S Bander•Journal of Personality and Social…•1980

  Incluir item

• Broadening our conceptual frameworks

  Karlen Lyons-Ruth, Karlen Lyons‐Ruth•Developmental Psychology•1995

  Incluir item

• The Sense of Femaleness

  Robert J Stoller•The Psychoanalytic Quarterly•1968

  Incluir item

• The International Journal of Psychoanalysis

  Open Access•Dana Birksted‐Breen, R Michels•The International Journal of…•2007

  Incluir item

• Creative Alliances

  Open Access•Stuart T Hauser•Journal of the American…•2004

  Incluir item

• The moderator–mediator variable distinction in social psychological research

  Reuben M Baron, D A Kenny•Journal of Personality and Social…•1986

  Incluir item

• The moderator-mediator variable distinction in social psychological research

  Reuben M Baron, D A Kenny•Journal of Personality and Social…•1986

  Incluir item

• Depression, working models of others, and relationship functioning

  Katherine B Carnelley, Paula R Pietromonaco et al.•Journal of Personality and Social…•1994

  Incluir item

• Up and Down in Middle Age

  Ravenna Helson, Christopher J Soto•Journal of Personality and Social…•2005

  Incluir item

• Personality change over 40 years of adulthood

  Ravenna Helson, Constance Jones et al.•Journal of Personality and Social…•2002

  Incluir item

• Attachment styles among young adults

  Kim Bartholomew, Leonard M Horowitz•Journal of Personality and Social…•1991

  Incluir item

• A Developmental Line of Gender Identity, Gender Role, and Choice of Love Object

  Open Access•Phyllis Tyson•Journal of the American…•1982

  Incluir item

• Toward a critical relational theory of gender

  Virginia Goldner•Psychoanalytic Dialogues•1991

  Incluir item

• Woman and Desire Why Women MayNotWant to Want

  Dianne Elise•Studies in Gender and Sexuality•2000

  Incluir item

• Melancholy Femininity and Obsessive-Compulsive Masculinity

  Meg Jay•Studies in Gender and Sexuality•2007

  Incluir item

• Self-reported distress

  James C Coyne•Psychological Bulletin•1994

  Incluir item

• Madness and Civilization

  Michel Foucault, David Cooper et al.•Madness and Civilization•1961

  Incluir item

• Trajectories of Gender Role Orientations in Adolescence and Early Adulthood

  Anne E Barrett, Helene Raskin White•Journal of Health and Social…•2002

  Incluir item

• Madness and Civilisation

  William D Wilder, Michel Foucault et al.•Man•1972

  Incluir item

• Gender and Health

  Lois M Verbrugge•Journal of Health and Social…•1985

  Incluir item