Skip to main content

ETHNOS_APP

Home • Search • Journals • List 0

Experimental assessment of obsidian versus chert lanceolate projectile point durability and robusticity

Semi‐static fracture strength and dynamic impact

Bibliographic Data

ID8354583
AuthorsNicholas Gala (0000-0001-7095-0499, Department of Anthropology Kent State University Kent OH USA), Anna Mika (0000-0002-4366-5091, Department of Anthropology Kent State University Kent OH USA), Michael Wilson (0000-0003-0217-7646, ASC Group, Inc. Columbus OH USA), Michael C Wilson (0000-0001-6797-5994, Advanced Scientific Concepts (United States)), Jeremy C Williams (Kent State University), Jeremy Williams (0000-0002-5129-6513, Department of Geology Kent State University Kent OH USA), Briggs Buchanan (0000-0002-5684-9615, Department of Anthropology University of Tulsa Tulsa OK USA), Robert S Walker (0000-0002-1853-4137, Department of Anthropology University of Missouri Columbia MO USA), Michelle Bebber (0000-0002-6084-8420, Department of Anthropology Kent State University Kent OH USA), Michelle R Bebber, M I Eren (0000-0003-3576-6076, Department of Anthropology Kent State University Kent OH USA, corresponding author)
Year2022
Volume64
Issue6
Pages1307-1324
Publication date2022-12-01
Peer ReviewedYes
Open AccessYes
TypeARTICLE
VenueArchaeometry (JOURNAL)
Journal identifiersISSN: 0003-813X • E-ISSN: 1475-4754
PublisherWiley (PUBLISHER • GB)
DOI10.1111/arcm.12787
OpenAlexW4229070023
LanguageEN
Citations received8
References cited67

Stone‐tipped weaponry was important for the survival of past peoples, and many functional and non‐functional factors likely influenced their design. Two functional factors that past peoples likely considered in the design of their stone tips are durability (whether or not a stone tip breaks) and robusticity (how much damage is incurred upon breakage). Many factors have been shown experimentally to influence stone tip influence durability and robusticity, including stone raw material. Here, we further explore the relationship between stone raw material and stone tip durability and robusticity via controlled experiments comparing chert and obsidian. We first demonstrate with semi‐static fracture strength analyses that obsidian stone tips require less force to break than do chert stone tips. We then show with dynamic ballistics impact testing that obsidian stone tips are less durable and robust than chert stone tips. Our results are entirely consistent with previous experimental comparisons of chert versus obsidian stone tips, and support the hypothesis that past peoples, when presented with multiple raw materials, likely weighed their costs and benefits in the process of selection

Archaeology · Breakage · Composite material · Durability · Fracture (geology · Geotechnical engineering · Lithic technology · Projectile point · Stone Age · Archaeology and ancient environmental studies · Forensic Anthropology and Bioarchaeology Studies · Geology · History · Materials Science · Paleontology · Pleistocene-Era Hominins and Archaeology

  • Geological Approach to Lithic Landscape During the Late Pleistocene and Early Holocene in the Southern Puna of the Atacama Desert (25°–27° S, 3200–5000 m a.s.l.)

    Open Access•Angélica Soto Riveros, Valentina Flores et al.•Archaeometry•2026

  • Late Pleistocene-Early Holocene Fishtail Points from Southernmost Patagonia (South America)

    M Cardillo, J Charlin et al.•PaleoAmerica•2023

  • Toolstone characterization, description, morphometrics, and microwear of a lithic sample from Uptar, Magadan Oblast, Northeastern Siberia, Russia

    Open Access•M I Eren, Fernando Diez-Martín et al.•Archaeological Research in Asia•2023

  • North American Clovis Point Form and Performance IV

    M I Eren, G Logan Miller et al.•Lithic Technology•2024

  • Chipped-Stone Crescents from the Terminal Pleistocene–Early Holocene of Far Western North America and the Transverse Projectile Point Hypothesis

    Open Access•Daniel S Amick•Journal of Archaeological Method…•2024

  • Clovis bone versus stone weapon tip penetration

    Open Access•G Miles Conrad, Savannah Hough et al.•Journal of Archaeological Science…•2023

  • Comparison of four ballistic and thrusting target materials

    Open Access•Damon Mullen, Jase Sitton et al.•Archaeometry•2023

  • Controlled comparative tensile tests of backed versus non‐backed edges’ adhesion

    Open Access•Michael Wilson, Michael C Wilson et al.•Archaeometry•2025

  • Flintknapping

    John C Whittaker•Flintknapping•1994

  • Factors Influencing the Use of Stone Projectile Tips

    Catherine J Ellis, Christopher J Ellis•Projectile Technology•1997

  • Atlatl Dart Velocity

    John C Whittaker, Devin B Pettigrew et al.•PaleoAmerica•2017

  • Neutron activation analysis of 12,900-year-old stone artifacts confirms 450–510+ km Clovis tool-stone acquisition at Paleo Crossing (33ME274), northeast Ohio, U.S.A

    Open Access•M T Boulanger, Briggs Buchanan et al.•Journal of Archaeological Science•2015

  • Identifying Weapon Delivery Systems Using Macrofracture Analysis and Fracture Propagation Velocity

    Open Access•Radu Iovita, Holger Schönekeß et al.•Multidisciplinary Approaches to…•2016

  • Cultural Evolution

    Alex Mesoudi•Cultural Evolution•2011

  • When Lithics Hit Bones

    Open Access•G M Smith, Elisabeth S Noack et al.•Journal of Paleolithic Archaeology•2020

  • Developing a stable point

    Open Access•Michelle Bebber, Michelle Rae Bebber et al.•Journal of Anthropological…•2017

  • Early Paleoindian big-game hunting in North America

    Open Access•John D Speth, Khori Newlander et al.•Quaternary International•2013

  • Experimental assessment of lanceolate projectile point and haft robustness

    Open Access•Briggs Buchanan, Robert S Walker et al.•Journal of Archaeological Science…•2022

  • The non-invention of the ceramic arrowhead in world archaeology

    Open Access•Michelle Bebber, Michael C Wilson et al.•Journal of Archaeological Science…•2020

  • Extending Experimental Control

    Open Access•Nada Khreisheh, D Gareth Davies et al.•Advances in Archaeological Practice•2013

  • Using Porcelain Replicas for Precision Control in Flintknapping Experiments

    Open Access•Charles A Speer•Advances in Archaeological Practice•2017

  • Getting to the point

    Open Access•Susan Hughes, Susan S Hughes•Journal of Archaeological Method…•1998

  • Wound ballistics

    Open Access•Janice Wood, B Fitzhugh•Journal of Archaeological Science•2018

  • Asphaltum hafting and projectile point durability

    Open Access•Mikael Fauvelle, Erin M Smith et al.•Journal of Archaeological Science•2012

  • Rock type variability and impact fracture formation

    Open Access•J Pargeter•Journal of Archaeological Science•2013

  • Raw material impact strength and flaked stone projectile point performance

    Open Access•Chris Loendorf, Lowell Blikre et al.•Journal of Archaeological Science•2018

  • Cultural evolutionary approaches to artifact variation over time and space

    Open Access•Stephen J Lycett•Journal of Archaeological Science•2015

  • The Effect of Isometric Scaling on Flaked Stone Projectile Point Impact Durability

    Leanna Maguire, Briggs Buchanan et al.•Lithic Technology•2021

  • North American Clovis Point Form and Performance II

    M I Eren, Michelle Bebber et al.•Lithic Technology•2022

  • An Ethnoarchaeological Inquiry into the Functional Relationship between Projectile Point and Armor Technologies of the Northwest Coast

    Open Access•Nathan S Lowrey•North American Archaeologist•1999

  • Do projectile points get cold? An experimental approach examining composite and stone projectile technology

    Open Access•Jacob S Adams, William Andrefsky•North American Archaeologist•2019

  • Clovis Blades at Paleo Crossing (33ME274), Ohio

    M I Eren, Brain G Redmond•Midcontinental Journal of…•2011

  • Experiments with Spears and Arrows on Animal Targets

    George H Odell, Frank L Cowan et al.•Journal of Field Archaeology•1986

  • Projectile point technology

    Open Access•Bradley J Vierra, Michael Heilen•Journal of Archaeological Science…•2020

  • Modeling the influences of raw material availability and functional efficiency on obsidian projectile point curation

    Open Access•Geoffrey M Smith•Journal of Archaeological Science…•2015

  • The performance of heat-treated silcrete backed pieces in actualistic and controlled complex projectile experiments

    Open Access•Benjamin J Schoville, J Wilkins et al.•Journal of Archaeological Science…•2017

  • Functional efficiency and life history of Late Holocene lithic points from southern Patagonia

    Open Access•M Cardillo, J Charlin et al.•Journal of Archaeological Science…•2021

  • Understanding Decision—Making Among Prehistoric Hunter-Gatherers Via the Study of Lithic Technological Organization

    Douglas H Macdonald•Lithic Technology•2009

  • Controlled ballistics tests of ground, percussion-flaked, and pressure-flaked projectile point impact durability

    Open Access•Corey Lowe, Andrew Kramer et al.•Journal of Archaeological Science…•2019

  • Projectiles Under a New Angle

    Open Access•Justin Coppe, Christian Lepers et al.•Journal of Archaeological Method…•2022

  • Knapping quality of local versus exotic Upper Mercer chert (Ohio, USA) during the Holocene

    Open Access•Angela R Lewis, Jeremy C Williams et al.•Geoarchaeology•2022

  • Toolstone Selection and Lithic Technology in Early Great Basin Prehistory

    Charlotte Beck, George T Jones•Journal of Field Archaeology•1990

  • Quartz backed tools as arrowheads and hand-cast spearheads

    Open Access•J Pargeter, J J Shea et al.•Journal of Archaeological Science•2016

  • Projectile impact fractures and launching mechanisms

    Open Access•Radu Iovita, Holger Schönekeß et al.•Journal of Archaeological Science•2013

  • Eastern Paleoindian Lithic Resource Use

    Catherine J Ellis, Christopher J Ellis et al.•Eastern Paleoindian Lithic…•2021

  • Design and performance of microlith implemented projectiles during the Middle and the Late Epipaleolithic of the Levant

    Open Access•Alla Yaroshevich, D Kaufman et al.•Journal of Archaeological Science•2009

  • Multidisciplinary Approaches to the Study of Stone Age Weaponry

    Open Access•Radu Iovita, Katsuhiro Sano•Multidisciplinary Approaches to…•2016

  • Explaining the origin of fluting in North American Pleistocene weaponry

    Open Access•Kaitlyn A Thomas, Brett Story et al.•Journal of Archaeological Science•2017

  • The role of raw material differences in stone tool shape variation

    Open Access•M I Eren, Christopher I Roos et al.•Journal of Archaeological Science•2014

  • The origins of lithic projectile point technology

    Open Access•J J Shea•Journal of Archaeological Science•2005

  • Raw material quality and Oldowan hominin toolstone preferences

    Open Access•D R Braun, Thomas W Plummer et al.•Journal of Archaeological Science•2009

  • Experimental use and quantitative performance analysis of triangular flakes (Levallois points) used as arrowheads

    Open Access•Matthew L Sisk, Matthew Sisk et al.•Journal of Archaeological Science•2009

  • Experimental Tests of Middle Palaeolithic Spear Points Using a Calibrated Crossbow

    Open Access•J J Shea, John Shea et al.•Journal of Archaeological Science•2001

  • Hunting with Howiesons Poort segments

    Open Access•M Lombard, J Pargeter•Journal of Archaeological Science•2008

  • Projectile Point Size and Projectile Aerodynamics

    Andrew L Christenson•Plains Anthropologist•1986

  • Folsom Projectile Technology

    David A Hunzicker•Plains Anthropologist•2008

  • Ballistic Study Tackles Kinetic Energy Values of Palaeolithic Weaponry

    Open Access•Justin Coppe, Christian Lepers et al.•Archaeometry•2019

  • The northern fluted point complex

    Open Access•H L Smith, Thomas J Dewitt•Archaeological and Anthropological…•2017

  • Building experimental use-wear analogues for Clovis biface functions

    Open Access•A M Smallwood•Archaeological and Anthropological…•2015

  • Making a point

    Open Access•Nicole M Waguespack, Todd A Surovell et al.•Antiquity•2009

  • Unnotched Triangular Points on Village Sites

    Open Access•W Engelbrecht•American Antiquity•2014

  • Projectile Point Shape and Durability

    Open Access•Joseph Cheshier, Robert L Kelly•American Antiquity•2006

  • Raw-Material Availability and the Organization of Technology

    Open Access•William Andrefsky•American Antiquity•1994

  • Morphological Projectile Point Typology

    Open Access•J Jeffrey Flenniken, Anan Raymond et al.•American Antiquity•1986

  • The Three Sides of a Biface

    Open Access•Robert L Kelly•American Antiquity•1988

  • Projectile Point Reworking

    Open Access•Chris Loendorf, Thatcher Rogers et al.•American Antiquity•2019

Unique citing works8
Citations per year2,67
Citation span2023 - 2026 (4)
Citation velocitycurrent
Highly citedNo
Citation typesNeutral: 8

Tools

Open DOIOpen Access
Ethnos_APP • Open Source Project • MIT License • Frontend v2.0.0 • Privacy and Cookies • API Documentation: api.ethnos.app/docs • API Source Code: GitHub • DOI: 10.5281/zenodo.17049435 • Frontend Source Code: GitHub • DOI: 10.5281/zenodo.17050053 • cruz.rio.br • Expectantes Misericordiae