Skip to main content

ETHNOS_APP

Home • Search • Journals • List 0

Quintilian, Seneca, Imitatio

Re-Reading Institutio Oratoria 10.1.125-31

Bibliographic Data

ID9322554
AuthorsYasuko Taoka (corresponding author)
Year2011
Volume44
Issue1
Pages123-137
Publication date2011-12-01
Peer ReviewedYes
Open AccessNo
TypeARTICLE
VenueArethusa (JOURNAL)
Journal identifiersISSN: 0004-0975 • E-ISSN: 1080-6504
PublisherJohns Hopkins University Press (PUBLISHER • US)
DOI10.1353/are.2011.a413527
OpenAlexW2125875396
LanguageEN
Citations received28
References cited16

Quintilian's assessment of Seneca at Institutio Oratoria 10.1.125–31 has often been read as a diatribe against Seneca. However, in this paper I assert that the passage reveals more about Quintilian's construction of authority than his opinion of Seneca. I read the assessment as an imitation of Seneca's Epistulae Morales 114. The imitation establishes Quintilian's authority over his readers and Seneca, and thus reduplicates the stratification that rhetorical education claims to overcome. I also suggest that the use of methods of analysis traditionally applied to didactic poetry is productive in the consideration of authority in rhetorical textbooks such as Quintilian's

Art · Imitation · Linguistics · Literature · Poetry · Reading (process · Rhetorical question · Classical Antiquity Studies · Classical Studies and Philology · Historical and Literary Analyses · Philosophy · Psychology

  • Seneca and Augustan Culture

    Open Access•James Ker•Cambridge Companion to Seneca•2015

  • The Dialogue in Seneca’s Dialogues (and Other Moral Essays)

    Open Access•Matthew Roller, Matthew B Roller•Cambridge Companion to Seneca•2015

  • Theory and Practice in Seneca’s Writings

    Open Access•Carey Seal•Cambridge Companion to Seneca•2015

  • Seneca Redivivus

    Open Access•Roland Mayer•Cambridge Companion to Seneca•2015

  • Seneca’s Apocolocyntosis

    Open Access•Kirk Freudenburg•Cambridge Companion to Seneca•2015

  • Seneca’s Shame

    Open Access•David Wray•Cambridge Companion to Seneca•2015

  • Style and Form in Seneca’s Writing

    Open Access•Gareth Williams•Cambridge Companion to Seneca•2015

  • Exploring Appearances

    Open Access•Francesca Romana Berno•Cambridge Companion to Seneca•2015

  • Senecan Emotions

    Open Access•David Konstan•Cambridge Companion to Seneca•2015

  • Seneca’s Originality

    Open Access•Elizabeth Asmis•Cambridge Companion to Seneca•2015

  • Theater and Theatricality in Seneca’s World

    Open Access•Cedric Littlewood, Cedric A J Littlewood•Cambridge Companion to Seneca•2015

  • Seneca

    Open Access•Shadi Bartsch, Alessandro Schiesaro•Cambridge Companion to Seneca•2015

  • Seneca and the Moderns

    Open Access•Francesco Citti•Cambridge Companion to Seneca•2015

  • Seneca and the Christian Tradition

    Open Access•Chiara Torre•Cambridge Companion to Seneca•2015

  • Seneca on Monarchy and the Political Life

    Open Access•Malcolm Schofield•Cambridge Companion to Seneca•2015

  • Seneca and Neronian Rome

    Open Access•Victoria Rimell•Cambridge Companion to Seneca•2015

  • Senecan Selves

    Open Access•Shadi Bartsch•Cambridge Companion to Seneca•2015

  • Absent Presence in Seneca’s Epistles

    Open Access•Catharine Edwards•Cambridge Companion to Seneca•2015

  • Senecan Tragedy

    Open Access•Christopher Trinacty•Cambridge Companion to Seneca•2015

  • Senecan Political Thought from the Middle Ages to Early Modernity

    Open Access•Peter Stacey•Cambridge Companion to Seneca•2015

  • Seneca and the Ancient World

    Open Access•Aldo Setaioli•Cambridge Companion to Seneca•2015

  • Seneca’s Images and Metaphors

    Open Access•Mireille Armisen-Marchetti•Cambridge Companion to Seneca•2015

  • Seneca Multiplex

    Open Access•Susanna Braund•Cambridge Companion to Seneca•2015

  • Seneca and Epicurus

    Open Access•Alessandro Schiesaro•Cambridge Companion to Seneca•2015

  • The Cambridge Companion to Seneca

    Open Access•Mireille Armisen-Marchetti, Susanna Braund et al.•Cambridge Companion to Seneca•2015

  • Cicero and Roman Education

    Open Access•Giuseppe La Bua•Cicero and Roman Education•2019

  • Persuasion, rhetoric and Roman poetry

    Open Access•Irene Peirano Garrison•Persuasion, Rhetoric and Roman…•2019

  • Rhétorique latine ou rhétorique romaine ? De la théorie à la culture du discours dans la Rome classique

    Charles Guérin•Littérature•2023

  • Rhetorical Education and Social Reproduction in the Republic and Early Empire

    Anthony Corbeill•A Companion to Roman Rhetoric•2007

  • Virile Tongues

    Joy Connolly•A Companion to Roman Rhetoric•2007

  • Seduction and Repetition in Ovid’s Ars Amatoria 2

    Alison Sharrock•Seduction and repetition in…•1994

  • Orationis Ratio

    A D Leeman•Orationis Ratio•1986

  • The Roman cultural revolution

    Alessandro Schiesaro, Thomas N Habinek•The Roman cultural revolution•1997

  • The Manhandling of Maecenas

    Margaret Graver•The American Journal of Philology•1998

  • Quintilian’s judgement of Seneca and the scope and purpose of Inst., 10, 1

    Marc Laureys•Antike und Abendland•1991

  • Making Men

    Maud W Gleason•Making Men•1994

  • The Cambridge Companion to Ancient Rhetoric

    Open Access•Erik Gunderson•The Cambridge companion to…•2009

  • A Commentary on the Letters of M. Cornelius Fronto

    Van Hout, van den Hout et al.•A Commentary on the Letters of M.…•1999

  • Quintilian on the Emotions ( Institutio Oratoria 6 preface and 1–2)

    Open Access•Matthew Leigh•The Journal of Roman Studies•2004

  • Declamation, Paternity, and Roman Identity

    Open Access•Lewis A Sussman, Erik Gunderson•Declamation, Paternity, and Roman…•2003

  • Hesiod's Didactic Poetry

    Open Access•Malcolm Heath•The Classical Quarterly•1985

  • Ancient Rhetoric and Oratory

    Open Access•Thomas Habinek•Ancient Rhetoric and Oratory•2005

  • A Companion to Roman Rhetoric

    Jonathan M Hall, William Dominik et al.•Companion to Roman Rhetoric•2007

  • Quintilian's De Causis Corruptae Eloquentiae and Tacitus' Dialogus De Oratoribus

    Open Access•C O Brink•The Classical Quarterly•1989

Unique citing works28
Citations per year2.55
Citation span2015 - 2023 (9)
Citation velocityhistorical
Highly citedNo
Citation typesNeutral: 28

Tools

Open DOI
Ethnos_APP • Open Source Project • MIT License • Frontend v2.0.0 • Privacy and Cookies • API Documentation: api.ethnos.app/docs • API Source Code: GitHub • DOI: 10.5281/zenodo.17049435 • Frontend Source Code: GitHub • DOI: 10.5281/zenodo.17050053 • cruz.rio.br • Expectantes Misericordiae