Skip to main content

ETHNOS_APP

Home • Search • Journals • List 0

Paving the pathways towards sustainable future? A critical assessment of STI policy roadmaps as policy instruments for sustainability transitions

Bibliographic Data

ID9846451
AuthorsMichał Miedziński (0000-0001-6514-6324, Centre for Sustainable Energy, corresponding author), Will McDowall (0000-0002-4238-0692, Energy Institute), Jesse Fahnestock (California Maritime Academy), Olga Rataj (Centre for Sustainable Energy), George Papachristos (0000-0001-7622-3364, Eindhoven University of Technology, corresponding author)
Year2022
Volume142
Pages103015
Publication date2022-09-01
Peer ReviewedYes
Open AccessYes
TypeARTICLE
VenueFutures (JOURNAL)
Journal identifiersISSN: 0016-3287 • E-ISSN: 1873-6378
PublisherElsevier BV (PUBLISHER)
DOI10.1016/j.futures.2022.103015
OpenAlexW4288906104
LanguageEN
Citations received8
References cited54

Roadmaps and roadmapping techniques receive increasing attention in the Science, Technology and Innovation policy community, notably for the development of strategies and policies to address societal challenges and ambitious goals such as the SDGs. STI policy roadmaps are used to evoke future visions, align actor expectations and formulate, document, plan and implement public policies for long-term, ambitious sustainability goals. As a sophisticated strategic planning process, roadmapping seems appropriate for policy support aiming to foster sustainability transitions. Nevertheless, there is little research on the role and limitations of roadmaps as a policy instrument to support innovation for sustainability transitions. This paper critically assesses selected national and international policy and sectoral roadmaps that focus on technology areas and societal challenges relevant to sustainability and energy transitions. The assessment of the objectives, design features and embeddedness of roadmaps in policy processes shows that current policy roadmaps have several shortfalls. The paper outlines knowledge gaps and research priorities to understand how such limitations might be overcome and draws tentative lessons for future applications of roadmaps as policy instruments for sustainability transitions

Business · Economics · Embeddedness · Management science · Political science · Process management · Sociology · Sustainability · Technology roadmap · Vision · Environmental Impact and Sustainability · Innovation Policy and RD · Marketing · Sustainability and Climate Change Governance

  • Expectations, Visions and Imaginaries

    Open Access•Harald Rohracher, Kornelia Konrad•Introduction to Sustainability…•2026

  • Stakeholder involvement in industry-level technology roadmapping

    Open Access•Edwin J Nijssen, Swagata Chakraborty et al.•Technological Forecasting and…•2025

  • What makes the contribution of science towards a sustainable future so difficult? A controversy analysis

    Open Access•Emi Minghui Gui, Alvaro Romera et al.•Humanities and Social Sciences…•2026

  • Water–energy–food–ecosystem nexus

    Open Access•Caro Eline Mooren, Stefania Munaretto et al.•Sustainability Science•2025

  • Interrogating green hydrogen roadmaps

    Open Access•T Ariztia, T Undurraga et al.•The Extractive Industries and…•2026

  • Strategies for circular economy in the Nordics

    Open Access•Mari Wardeberg, Henrik Brynthe Lund et al.•Cambridge Journal of Regions…•2024

  • Directing regional industries towards sustainability

    Open Access•Samantha Archard, Felicia Fai•Regional Studies•2026

  • The geography of circularity missions

    Open Access•Fergus Haswell, Oreane Y Edelenbosch et al.•Environmental Innovation and…•2024

  • Sociotechnical transitions for deep decarbonization

    Open Access•Frank W Geels, B K Sovacool et al.•Science•2017

  • The enactment of socio-technical transition pathways

    Open Access•Frank W Geels, Friederike Kern et al.•Research Policy•2016

  • Innovation studies and sustainability transitions

    Open Access•Adrian Smith, Jan-Peter Voß et al.•Research Policy•2010

  • More evolution than revolution

    Open Access•Jan Rotmans, Ray Kemp et al.•foresight•2001

  • Processes and patterns in transitions and system innovations

    Open Access•Frank W Geels•Technological Forecasting and…•2005

  • Next-Generation Innovation Policy and Grand Challenges

    Open Access•Stefan Kuhlmann, Arie Rip•Science and Public Policy•2018

  • Legitimizing research, technology and innovation policies for transformative change

    Open Access•K Matthias Weber, Harald Rohracher•Research Policy•2012

  • Transformative innovation policy

    Open Access•Gijs Diercks, Henrik Larsen et al.•Research Policy•2019

  • Policy mixes for sustainability transitions

    Open Access•Karoline S Rogge, Kristin Reichardt•Research Policy•2016

  • Policy mixes for sustainability transitions

    Open Access•Friederike Kern, Karoline S Rogge et al.•Research Policy•2019

  • The rise of systemic instruments in innovation policy

    Ruud Smits, Stefan Kuhlmann•International Journal of…•2004

  • Combining participative backcasting and exploratory scenario development

    Open Access•Kasper Kok, M Van Vliet et al.•Technological Forecasting and…•2011

  • Systemic instruments for systemic innovation problems

    Anna Wieczorek, A J Wieczorek et al.•Science and Public Policy•2012

  • Mission-oriented innovation policies

    Open Access•Mariana Mazzucato•Industrial and Corporate Change•2018

  • Normative expectations in systems innovation

    Frans Berkhout•Technology Analysis and Strategic…•2006

  • The governance of sustainable socio-technical transitions

    Open Access•Adrian Smith, Andy Stirling et al.•Research Policy•2005

  • Reflexive Governance for Sustainable Development

    J-P Voss, R P M Kemp et al.•Reflexive Governance for…•2006

  • Understanding and governing learning in sustainability transitions

    Open Access•Barbara Van Mierlo, Pieter J Beers•Environmental Innovation and…•2020

  • Modelling Sustainability Transitions

    Open Access•Jonathan Köhler, Fjalar De Haan et al.•Journal of Artificial Societies…•2018

  • Pathways

    Open Access•Daniel Rosenbloom•Global Environmental Change•2017

  • A mechanism based transition research methodology

    Open Access•George Papachristos•Futures•2018

  • On Technological Expectations

    Nathan Rosenberg•The Economic Journal•1976

  • Transition Management for Sustainable Development

    Open Access•Derk Loorbach, Derk A Loorbach•Governance•2010

  • Sustainability-oriented innovation systems – managing the green transformation

    Tilman Altenburg, Anna Pegels•Innovation and Development•2012

  • System interactions in socio-technical transitions

    George Papachristos, Aristotelis Sofianos et al.•Environmental Innovation and…•2013

  • A system dynamics model of socio-technical regime transitions

    Open Access•George Papachristos, Georg Papachristos•Environmental Innovation and…•2011

  • Prospects of modelling societal transitions

    Open Access•Grégoire Holtz, Georg Holtz et al.•Environmental Innovation and…•2015

  • Disrupting transitions

    Open Access•Frank Boons, Bob Doherty et al.•Environmental Innovation and…•2021

  • Opening Up" and "Closing Down

    Open Access•Andy Stirling•Science Technology & Human Values•2008

  • The Politics of Reflexive Governance

    Open Access•Jan-Peter Voß, Basil Bornemann•Conservation Ecology•2011

  • The Handbook of Science and Technology Studies

    Open Access•Andrés Aybar•Revista de Sociología•2017

Unique citing works8
Citations per year4
Citation span2024 - 2026 (3)
Citation velocitycurrent
Highly citedNo
Citation typesNeutral: 8

Tools

Open DOIOpen Access
Ethnos_APP • Open Source Project • MIT License • Frontend v2.0.0 • Privacy and Cookies • API Documentation: api.ethnos.app/docs • API Source Code: GitHub • DOI: 10.5281/zenodo.17049435 • Frontend Source Code: GitHub • DOI: 10.5281/zenodo.17050053 • cruz.rio.br • Expectantes Misericordiae