Rethinking Social Security in Latin America

In the past decade, many Latin American governments have radically restructured their old age income security systems, following the lead of Chile, which undertook its major pension reform in 1981. The defining characteristic of the reforms has been a shift in the basis of public pensions from social to individual responsibility: instead of the widely used system that “collectivized” or pooled the risk of being without the capacity to earn while aged, numerous countries in the region have adopted a system that relies on individual savings accounts. The reforms have maintained a role for a modified version of public pooling; this combination of individual and social savings to finance pensions is known as the “multipillar” approach. This article is based on a report prepared for the Office of the Chief Economist of the Latin America and Caribbean Region of the World Bank (Gill, Packard and Yermo, 2004). 1 The report recognizes that the system of individual accounts, the essential aspect of the reform, has been a necessary and positive development, and one that is consistent with the economics of insurance and social welfare objectives. Beyond this recognition, however, the results of reform are much more complex. Each country has implemented its own version of the multipillar system. The article therefore draws on country evidence in order to determine: How has the new approach to public pensions in Latin America fared? In particular, have the changes left workers and their families in reform countries better off? The first section provides a brief description of the reforms. The second discusses the main macroeconomic concerns and effects. The third describes the impact on coverage levels, and other social welfare implications. The fourth evaluates the stagnation of coverage levels and presents various possible explanations. The fifth makes specific proposals to improve the multipillar pension system in Latin America. The last section concludes

Development economics · Economic growth · Economics · Latin Americans · Market economy · Order (exchange · Pension · Political science · Pooling · Social insurance · Social security · Finance · Financial Literacy, Pension, Retirement Analysis

• How Do Management Fees Affect Retirement Wealth under M exico's Personal Retirement Accounts System

  Open Access•Emma Aguila, Michael D Hurd et al.•Latin American Policy•2014

  Add to list

• Post-Civil War San Salvador

  Richard Tardanico•The Journal of Development Studies•2008

  Add to list

• Social Security at The Crossroads

  Open Access•Milko Matijascic, Stephen J Kay et al.•International Social Security…•2006

  Add to list

• New Ideas about Old Age Security

  Robert Holzmann, Joseph E Stiglitz•New Ideas about Old Age Security•2001

  Add to list

• Averting the old age crisis

  World Bank•Averting the old age crisis.•1994

  Add to list