Skip to main content

ETHNOS_APP

Home • Search • Journals • List 0

Community accountability at peripheral health facilities

A review of the empirical literature and development of a conceptual framework

Bibliographic Data

ID14668231
AuthorsSassy Molyneux (0000-0001-9522-416X, Kenya Medical Research Institute), Martin Atela (0000-0002-1600-663X, University of London), Vibian Angwenyi (0000-0002-7554-6265, University of London), Carl Goodman (0000-0002-2241-3485, University of London)
Year2012
Volume27
Issue7
Pages541-554
Publication date2012-10-01
Peer ReviewedYes
Open AccessYes
TypeARTICLE
VenueHealth Policy and Planning (JOURNAL)
Journal identifiersISSN: 0268-1080 • E-ISSN: 1460-2237
PublisherOxford University Press (PUBLISHER • GB)
DOI10.1093/heapol/czr083
PMID22279082
PMCIDPMC3465752
OpenAlexW2099362014
LanguageEN
Citations received64
References cited35

Public accountability has re-emerged as a top priority for health systems all over the world, and particularly in developing countries where governments have often failed to provide adequate public sector services for their citizens. One approach to strengthening public accountability is through direct involvement of clients, users or the general public in health delivery, here termed 'community accountability'. The potential benefits of community accountability, both as an end in itself and as a means of improving health services, have led to significant resources being invested by governments and non-governmental organizations. Data are now needed on the implementation and impact of these initiatives on the ground. A search of PubMed using a systematic approach, supplemented by a hand search of key websites, identified 21 papers from low- or middle-income countries describing at least one measure to enhance community accountability that was linked with peripheral facilities. Mechanisms covered included committees and groups (n = 19), public report cards (n = 1) and patients' rights charters (n = 1). In this paper we summarize the data presented in these papers, including impact, and factors influencing impact, and conclude by commenting on the methods used, and the issues they raise. We highlight that the international interest in community accountability mechanisms linked to peripheral facilities has not been matched by empirical data, and present a conceptual framework and a set of ideas that might contribute to future studies.

Accountability · Business · Conceptual framework · Empirical evidence · Political science · Public health · Public relations · Public sector · Sociology · Global Maternal and Child Health · Healthcare Systems and Reforms · Medicine · Nursing · Public Administration · Vaccine Coverage and Hesitancy

  • Strengthening the community governance of healthcare services in ‘fragile’ settings

    Open Access•Jean-Benoît Falisse, Hugues Nkengurutse et al.•PLOS Global Public Health•2023

  • Promoting community participation in priority setting in district health systems

    Open Access•Peter Kamuzora, Stephen Maluka et al.•Global Health Action•2013

  • When information is not power

    Open Access•Jean-Benoît Falisse, Léonard Ntakarutimana•Social Science & Medicine•2020

  • Listening to diverse community voices

    Open Access•for the Male Circumcision Acceptability and Impact Study team, Anna Tynan et al.•BMC Public Health•2013

  • Community Participation in Health Systems Research

    Open Access•Asha S George, Vrinda Mehra et al.•PLoS ONE•2015

  • The politics of reducing malnutrition

    Open Access•Stuart Gillespie, Lawrence Haddad et al.•The Lancet•2013

  • Applying GRADE-Cerqual to qualitative evidence synthesis findings

    Open Access•Simon Lewin, Andrew Booth et al.•Implementation Science•2018

  • Are village health sanitation and nutrition committees fulfilling their roles for decentralised health planning and action? A mixed methods study from rural eastern India

    Open Access•Aradhana Srivastava, Rajkumar Gope et al.•BMC Public Health•2015

  • Reimagining public–private partnerships for primary health care in Africa

    Open Access•Thabo Lucas Seleke•Frontiers in Public Health•2026

  • Assessing the effectiveness of social accountability interventions in selected district assemblies in Ghana

    Open Access•Patrick Osei-Kufuor, Emmanuel Yamoah Tenkorang et al.•Cogent Social Sciences•2024

  • Conflict Relations and Community Participation in Health

    Open Access•Issa Sombié•Advances in Applied Sociology•2024

  • Crisis of Legitimacy and Community Mobilization in Health

    Open Access•Sombié Issa, Ilboudo Sidbéwendin David Olivier•Advances in Applied Sociology•2023

  • How can community participation strengthen a health insurance system? The case of health insurer’s user associations in Colombia

    Open Access•Mery Concepcion Bolivar Vargas, Eduardo Alfonso-Sierra et al.•BMJ Global Health•2022

  • Making health insurance responsive to citizens

    Open Access•Anas Ismail, Inke Mathauer et al.•BMJ Global Health•2025

  • Making health insurance responsive to citizens

    Open Access•Dosithée Bebe Ngo, Fulbert Nappa Kwilu et al.•BMJ Global Health•2023

  • Does mobile renewal make health insurance more responsive to clients? A case study of the National Health Insurance Scheme in Ghana

    Open Access•Patricia Akweongo, Irma Emiliozzi et al.•BMJ Global Health•2023

  • The impact of informal patient navigation initiatives on patient empowerment and National Health Insurance responsiveness in Indonesia

    Open Access•Dinna Prapto Raharja, Retna Hanani et al.•BMJ Global Health•2022

  • How do patient feedback systems work in low-income and middle-income countries? Insights from a realist evaluation in Bangladesh

    Open Access•Tolib Mirzoev, Sumit Kane et al.•BMJ Global Health•2021

  • The challenge of ensuring elderly people can access their health insurance entitlements

    Open Access•Stela Stojisavljevic, Bosiljka Đikanović et al.•BMJ Global Health•2022

  • Conducting rapid research to aid the design of a health systems governance intervention in the Somali Region of Ethiopia

    Open Access•Pieternella Pieterse•Frontiers in Sociology•2022

  • Developing middle-range theories within a realist evaluation of how health committees support community capacity for health

    Open Access•Brynne Gilmore, J R Power et al.•Evaluation•2024

  • Pathways to accountability in rural Guatemala

    Open Access•Alison Hernández, Ana Lorena Ruano et al.•World Development•2018

  • Institutional Solutions to the Asymmetric Information Problem in Health and Development Services for the Poor

    Open Access•David K Leonard, Gerald Bloom et al.•World Development•2013

  • Resilience of health systems in conflict affected governorates of Iraq, 2014–2018

    Open Access•Shaimaa Ibrahim, Sara Al-Dahir et al.•Conflict and Health•2021

  • Effects of a community scorecard on improving the local health system in Eastern Democratic Republic of Congo

    Open Access•Lara S Ho, Guillaume Labrecque et al.•Conflict and Health•2015

  • Optimising the benefits of community health workers’ unique position between communities and the health sector

    Open Access•Maryse Kok, Hermen Ormel et al.•Global Public Health•2016

  • The power of popular opinion in everyday primary care provision in urban India

    Open Access•Radhika Gore•Global Public Health•2018

  • Making free public healthcare attractive

    Open Access•Bart Jacobs, Ashish Bajracharya et al.•International Journal for Equity…•2018

  • Can community action improve equity for maternal health and how does it do so? Research findings from Gujarat, India

    Open Access•Asha George, Diwakar Mohan et al.•International Journal for Equity…•2018

  • Negotiating power relations, gender equality, and collective agency

    Open Access•Kerry Scott, Asha George et al.•International Journal for Equity…•2017

  • Local health governance in Tajikistan

    Open Access•Eelco Jacobs, Claudia Baez Camargo•International Journal for Equity…•2020

  • Understanding the roles of community health workers in improving perinatal health equity in rural Uttar Pradesh, India

    Open Access•Andrea Katryn Blanchard, Shahnaz Ansari et al.•International Journal for Equity…•2021

  • Do beneficiaries’ views matter in healthcare purchasing decisions? Experiences from the Nigerian tax-funded health system and the formal sector social health insurance program of the National Health Insurance Scheme

    Open Access•Ogochukwu Ibe, Ayako Honda et al.•International Journal for Equity…•2017

  • The health system accountability impact of prison health committees in Zambia

    Open Access•Stephanie M Topp, Anjali Sharma et al.•International Journal for Equity…•2018

  • Community engagement in health services research on soil-transmitted helminthiasis in Asia Pacific region

    Open Access•Cho Naing, Lovie Lee Borchardt et al.•PLOS Global Public Health•2023

  • Understanding health system responsiveness to public feedback at the sub-national level

    Open Access•Nancy Kagwanja, Lucy Gilson et al.•PLOS Global Public Health•2024

  • Institutionalising community participation in decision-making in maternal and newborn health services in low-and middle-income countries

    Open Access•Olive Cocoman, Debra Jackson et al.•PLOS Global Public Health•2025

  • Comprehensive review of the evidence regarding the effectiveness of community–based primary health care in improving maternal, neonatal and child health

    Open Access•Henry B Perry, Emma Sacks et al.•Journal of Global Health•2017

  • A concept in flux

    Open Access•Carlos Bruen, Ruairi Brugha et al.•Globalization and Health•2014

  • Understanding the implications of the Sustainable Development Goals for health policy and systems research

    Open Access•Sara Bennett, Nasreen Jessani et al.•Globalization and Health•2020

  • Key strategies to improve systems for managing patient complaints within health facilities – what can we learn from the existing literature

    Open Access•Tolib Mirzoev, Sumit Kane•Global Health Action•2018

  • The community is just a small circle

    Open Access•Daniel C Ogbuabor, Obinna Onwujekwe•Global Health Action•2018

  • A mapping and synthesis of tools for stakeholder and community engagement in quality improvement initiatives for reproductive, maternal, newborn, child and adolescent health

    Open Access•Jessie Spencer, Brynne Gilmore et al.•Health Expectations•2021

  • Patient Feedback Systems at the Primary Level of Health Care Centres in Bangladesh

    Open Access•Rumana Huque, Zunayed Al Azdi et al.•SAGE Open•2021

  • Modified scoping review of the enablers and barriers to implementing primary health care in the Covid-19 context

    Open Access•Alexandra Edelman, Rainer Martens et al.•Health Policy and Planning•2021

  • Power dynamics and intersectoral collaboration for health in low- and middle-income countries

    Open Access•Praveenkumar Aivalli, Sara Dada et al.•Health Policy and Planning•2025

  • Systems on the edge

    Open Access•Kate Ramsey•Health Policy and Planning•2022

  • How does power shape district health management team responsiveness to public feedback in low- and middle-income countries

    Open Access•Nancy Kagwanja, Sassy Molyneux et al.•Health Policy and Planning•2023

  • Anchoring contextual analysis in health policy and systems research

    Open Access•Asha George, Kerry Scott et al.•Social Science & Medicine•2015

  • Examining the links between community participation and health outcomes

    Open Access•Susan Beth Rifkin•Health Policy and Planning•2014

  • Health provider responsiveness to social accountability initiatives in low- and middle-income countries

    Open Access•Elsbet Lodenstein, Marjolein Dieleman et al.•Health Policy and Planning•2017

  • A review of Care’s Community Score Card experience and evidence

    Open Access•Sara Gullo, Christine Galavotti et al.•Health Policy and Planning•2016

  • Practice and power

    Open Access•Lucy Gilson, Hp Schneider et al.•Health Policy and Planning•2014

  • The role of the traditional leader in implementing maternal, newborn and child health policy in Malawi

    Open Access•Aisling Walsh, Anne Matthews et al.•Health Policy and Planning•2018

  • Can social accountability improve access to free public health care for the poor? Analysis of three Health Equity Fund configurations in Cambodia, 2015–17

    Open Access•Bart Jacobs, Sam Sam Oeun et al.•Health Policy and Planning•2020

  • Implementation of patient charges at primary care facilities in Kenya

    Open Access•A Opwora, Evelyn Waweru et al.•Health Policy and Planning•2015

  • Tracking implementation and (un)intended consequences

    Open Access•Evelyn Waweru, Carl Goodman et al.•Health Policy and Planning•2016

  • Exploring health facilities’ experiences in implementing the free health-care policy (FHCP) in Nepal

    Open Access•Midori Sato, Sato Midori et al.•Health Policy and Planning•2015

  • Towards people-centred health systems

    Open Access•Seye Abimbola, Joel Negin et al.•Health Policy and Planning•2014

  • Developing more participatory and accountable institutions for health

    Open Access•Kerry Scott, Nasreen Jessani et al.•Health Policy and Planning•2018

  • The government cannot do it all alone’

    Open Access•Seye Abimbola, Shola K Molemodile et al.•Health Policy and Planning•2016

  • Sparking, supporting and steering change

    Open Access•Asha George, Asha S George et al.•Health Policy and Planning•2016

  • Exploring the nature of governance at the level of implementation for health system strengthening

    Open Access•Vera Scott, Nikki Schaay et al.•Health Policy and Planning•2014

  • Using community-based evidence for decentralized health planning

    Open Access•Abhay Shukla, Renu Khanna et al.•Health Policy and Planning•2018

  • Power to the People

    Martina Björkman, J Svensson•The Quarterly Journal of Economics•2009

  • Accountability and health systems

    Open Access•Derick W Brinkerhoff•Health Policy and Planning•2004

  • Issues of equity are also issues of rights

    Open Access•Leslie London•BMC Public Health•2007

  • Decentralization of health systems in Ghana, Zambia, Uganda and the Philippines

    Open Access•Thomas Bossert, T J Bossert•Health Policy and Planning•2002

  • Problems of cost recovery implementation in district health care

    Open Access•L E Meuwissen•Health Policy and Planning•2002

  • Local governance and community financing of primary care

    Open Access•David Bishai•Health Policy and Planning•2002

  • Community participation in externally funded health projects

    Open Access•Bart Jacobs•Health Policy and Planning•2003

  • Service accountability and community participation in the context of health sector reforms in Asia

    Open Access•Ranjani K Murthy•Health Policy and Planning•2004

  • The terrain of health policy analysis in low and middle income countries

    Open Access•Lucy Gilson, Nika Raphaely•Health Policy and Planning•2008

  • Urban primary health care in Africa

    Open Access•Roger Few, Trudy Harpham et al.•Health & Place•2003

  • Future directions for health policy analysis

    Open Access•Lucy Gilson, Katherine Buse et al.•Health Policy and Planning•2008

  • Primary health care, community participation and community-financing

    Open Access•Ardeshir Sepehri, Jonathan Pettigrew et al.•Health Policy and Planning•1996

  • Improving access for the poorest to public sector health services

    Open Access•Bart Jacobs, Neil Price•Health Policy and Planning•2006

  • Strengthening user participation through health sector reform in Colombia

    Open Access•M Mosquera, Mabel Concepción Valencia Mosquera et al.•Health Policy and Planning•2001

  • Provider-specific report cards

    Open Access•Peggy Mcnamara•Health Policy and Planning•2006

  • Involvement of Community in Health Systems Management

    Open Access•Aijaz Ali Khuwaja•IDS Bulletin•2000

  • Public Participation in Health Systems in Zimbabwe

    Open Access•Rene Loewenson•IDS Bulletin•2000

  • Why Rights, Why Now? Reflections on the Rise of Rights in International Development Discourse

    Open Access•A Cornwall, Celestine Nyamu‐musembi et al.•IDS Bulletin•2005

  • A Ladder Of Citizen Participation

    Sherry R Arnstein•Journal of the American Institute…•1969

  • Doing' health policy analysis

    Open Access•Gerrit Van Der Waldt, G Walt et al.•Health Policy and Planning•2008

  • How do health workers and community members perceive and practice community participation in the Bamako Initiative programme in Nigeria? A case study of Oji River local government area

    Open Access•Benjamin Uzochukwu, Benjamin S C Uzochukwu et al.•Social Science & Medicine•2004

  • Health sector reform and public sector health worker motivation

    Open Access•Lynne Miller Franco, Sara Bennett et al.•Social Science & Medicine•2002

  • Primary health care

    Open Access•Susan Beth Rifkin, Frits Muller et al.•Social Science & Medicine•1988

  • Analyzing the decentralization of health systems in developing countries

    Open Access•Thomas Bossert•Social Science & Medicine•1998

  • Resource dependency and community participation in primary health care

    Open Access•J David L Zakus•Social Science & Medicine•1998

  • Cross-Cultural Comparative Approaches in Archaeology

    Peter N Peregrine•Annual Review of Anthropology•2001

Unique citing works64
Citations per year4,92
Citation span2013 - 2026 (14)
Citation velocitycurrent
Highly citedNo
Citation typesNeutral: 61
Ethnos_APP • Open Source Project • MIT License • Frontend v2.0.0 • Privacy and Cookies • API Documentation: api.ethnos.app/docs • API Source Code: GitHub • DOI: 10.5281/zenodo.17049435 • Frontend Source Code: GitHub • DOI: 10.5281/zenodo.17050053 • cruz.rio.br • Expectantes Misericordiae