Skip to main content

ETHNOS_APP

Home • Search • Journals • List 0

Exploring the roles of non-profit organizations in co-production

A systematic literature review

Bibliographic Data

ID21723834
AuthorsChengzhi Yi (0000-0003-1764-3726, Shanghai Jiao Tong University), Xinyi Qiu (0009-0000-6460-2981, Shanghai Jiao Tong University, corresponding author), Huafang Li (0000-0002-5522-5173, University of Pittsburgh)
Year2026
Volume28
Issue5
Pages1283-1308
Publication date2026-05-04
Peer ReviewedYes
Open AccessNo
TypeARTICLE
VenuePublic Management Review (JOURNAL)
Journal identifiersISSN: 1471-9037 • E-ISSN: 1471-9045
PublisherInforma UK Limited (PUBLISHER • GB)
DOI10.1080/14719037.2025.2484661
OpenAlexW4408969536
LanguageEN
Citations received7
References cited105

This article presents a systematic literature review to explore the roles of non-profit organizations (NPOs) in co-production. While numerous studies have focused on NPOs’ engagement in co-production with the government, scholarly attention to their involvement with citizens remains limited. Although shared missions and collaborative efforts exist, these relationships exhibit asymmetry. There is a predominant focus on NPOs’ role in service delivery rather than their deeper involvement in policy making. Additionally, the factors that affect NPOs in co-production are often scattered and have yet to be examined. Despite the recent growth of the literature, the roles of NPOs in co-production are intricate and require further elucidation

Business · Economics · Industrial organization · MEDLINE · Microeconomics · Political science · Systematic review · Community Development and Social Impact · Nonprofit Sector and Volunteering · Public Policy and Administration Research

  • The paradox of co-production

    Open Access•Seemab Farooqi, Vicky Lambert•Public Management Review•2026

  • What Role Do Social Organizations Play in Stimulating Green and Low‐Carbon Consumption in China

    Open Access•Chuang Li, Siting Ruan et al.•Journal of International…•2026

  • How NGOs facilitate value co-creation through multilevel and processual mechanisms

    Shuang Tan, Yu Du et al.•Public Management Review•2026

  • Citizen coproduction motivations

    Yang Jia, Huafang Li et al.•Public Management Review•2026

  • Third‐Sector Organizations as Intermediaries in Climate Action

    Open Access•Farjana Nipa, André Lino et al.•Governance•2025

  • Do third parties matter for citizens’ public programme participation? Evidence from an administrative burden perspective

    Yongzheng Yang•Public Management Review•2026

  • From coexistence to collaboration

    Open Access•Shihong Guo•The British Journal of Social Work•2026

  • Towards a multi-actor theory of public value co-creation

    John M Bryson, John Bryson et al.•Public Management Review•2017

  • Co-production, the third sector and the delivery of public services

    Taco Brandsen, Victor Pestoff•Public Management Review•2006

  • The New Public Governance? 1

    Stephen P Osborne•Public Management Review•2006

  • A Systematic Review of Co-Creation and Co-Production

    W H Voorberg, V J J M Bekkers et al.•Public Management Review•2015

  • Preferred Reporting Items for Systematic Reviews and Meta-Analyses

    Open Access•David Moher, Alessandro Liberati et al.•PLoS Medicine•2009

  • Co-governance within networks and the non-profit – for-profit divide

    Ingo Bode•Public Management Review•2006

  • New Public Governance, Co-Production and Third Sector Social Services in Europe

    Victor Pestoff•New Public Governance, the Third…•2013

  • Expectations versus reality

    Caitlin Mcmullin•Public Management Review•2024

  • The politics of insufficiency

    Morten Frederiksen, Ane Grubb•Public Management Review•2023

  • Street-Level bureaucracy in public administration

    Ahrum Chang, Gene A Brewer•Public Management Review•2023

  • A systematic literature review of open innovation in the public sector

    Open Access•Rui Mu, Huanming Wang•Public Management Review•2022

  • Nonprofit Organizations Becoming Business-Like

    Open Access•Florentine Maier, Michael Meyer et al.•Journal of Voluntary Action…•2014

  • Communication for coproduction

    Huafang Li•Journal of Chinese Governance•2020

  • Reimagining the bureaucracy and post-bureaucracy debate

    Marta Ingaggiati, G Barbato et al.•Public Management Review•2025

  • How does citizen-centric co-production lead to value co-creation? A perspective of interactive governance

    Open Access•Huanming Wang, Bing Ran•Public Management Review•2025

  • Roles of professionals in value co-creation

    Open Access•Salla Maijala, Aino Rantamäki et al.•Public Management Review•2025

  • Value co-destruction through misintegration of resources within a public service ecosystem

    Open Access•Johanna Liljeroos-Cork, Mika Luhtala•Public Management Review•2025

  • Health and social care integration

    Open Access•Kirsty Strokosch, Michael James Roy et al.•Public Management Review•2025

  • Innovation in the Public Sector

    Open Access•Hanna De Vries, Victor Bekkers et al.•Public Administration•2016

  • The politics of co-implementation and their potential in shaping egalitarian cities

    Open Access•Angeliki Paidakaki, Xenia Katsigianni et al.•Environment and Planning C…•2022

  • Participatory Art as a Social Practice of Commoning to Reinvent the Right to the City

    Open Access•Philippe Eynaud, Maïté Juan et al.•Voluntas Revista Internacional de…•2018

  • The Co-production of a Community

    Open Access•Daphne Vanleene, Joris Voets et al.•Voluntas Revista Internacional de…•2017

  • Third-Sector Organizations in Area-Based Initiatives

    Open Access•Håkon Solbu Trætteberg, Tord Skogedal Lindén et al.•Voluntas Revista Internacional de…•2023

  • From Engagement to Co-production

    Open Access•Tony Bovaird, Elke Loeffler•Voluntas Revista Internacional de…•2012

  • Co-producing Across Organisational Boundaries

    Open Access•Kirsty Strokosch, Stephen P Osborne•Voluntas Revista Internacional de…•2016

  • Engaging Refugee Volunteers in Co-creation

    Open Access•Egzon Krasniqi•Voluntas Revista Internacional de…•2024

  • In search of the non-profit sector. I

    Open Access•Lester M Salamon, Helmut K Anheier•Voluntas Revista Internacional de…•1992

  • Government/Foundation Relations

    Open Access•Stefan Toepler, Alan Abramson et al.•Voluntas Revista Internacional de…•2021

  • Traits of Leaders of Rural Non-governmental Organisations as Predictors of Collaboration Between NGOs and Rural Gmina Offices

    Open Access•Katarzyna Zajda, Sławomir Pasikowski•Voluntas Revista Internacional de…•2018

  • Constructing Action

    Open Access•Karie Jo Peralta, Elissa Vaitkus•Voluntas Revista Internacional de…•2018

  • Minding the Gaps

    Open Access•Ilona Bontenbal, Nathan Lillie•Voluntas Revista Internacional de…•2021

  • Third Sector Organizations and Migration

    Open Access•Michael Garkisch, Jens Heidingsfelder et al.•Voluntas Revista Internacional de…•2017

  • Understanding the Role of Nonprofit Organizations in the Provision of Social Services in China

    Open Access•Xuan Tu•Voluntas Revista Internacional de…•2021

  • Partnerships and the Good-Governance Agenda

    Open Access•Masooda Bano•Voluntas Revista Internacional de…•2018

  • Co-production and Third Sector Social Services in Europe

    Open Access•Victor Pestoff•Voluntas Revista Internacional de…•2012

  • Social Economy and Home Care Services in Quebec

    Open Access•Christian Jetté, Yves Vaillancourt•Voluntas Revista Internacional de…•2010

  • The co‐governance of basic education

    Open Access•Charles Wharton Kaye-Essien•Governance•2024

  • Guidance on Conducting a Systematic Literature Review

    Open Access•Yu Xiao, Maria Watson•Journal of Planning Education and…•2017

  • Investing in Not‐for‐Profit Sector Capacity

    Open Access•Jim Butcher, John R Butcher•Australian Journal of Public…•2016

  • Collective action and co‐production of public services as alternative politics

    Open Access•Niva Golan‐nadir, Tom Christensen•Australian Journal of Public…•2023

  • Exploring the Determinants of Nonprofit Coproduction of Public Service Delivery

    Open Access•Laurie E Paarlberg, Sheldon Gen•The American Review of Public…•2008

  • Citizen–State Collaboration in Combating Covid-19 in China

    Open Access•Ting Zhao, Zhongsheng Wu•The American Review of Public…•2020

  • Public Administration Research in East and Southeast Asia

    Open Access•Richard M Walker, Gene A Brewer et al.•The American Review of Public…•2013

  • Communication for Coproduction

    Open Access•Huafang Li•The American Review of Public…•2020

  • Coproduction and the third sector in France

    Open Access•Caitlin Mcmullin•Social Policy and Administration•2019

  • Indigenous political participation in the deliberative systems

    Mei-Fang Fan, Sheng-Chun Sung•Policy Studies•2022

  • Collaborative Value in Public and Nonprofit Strategic Alliances

    Open Access•Jason Coupet, Kate Albrecht et al.•Administration & Society•2020

  • Individual, Group, and Collective Co-production

    Open Access•Caitlin Mcmullin•Administration & Society•2023

  • Citizenship and Service Delivery

    Charles H Levine, Glenn Fisher et al.•Public Administration Review•1984

  • The Third Sector, User Involvement and Public Service Reform

    Open Access•Graham P Martins, Graham P Martin•Public Administration•2011

  • Challenging the necessity of New Public Governance

    Open Access•Caitlin Mcmullin•Public Administration•2020

  • Co-creation within hybrid networks

    Open Access•Nassera Touati, Lara Maillet•International Review of…•2018

  • Why engage in co-production of public services? Mixing theory and empirical evidence

    Open Access•Carola Van Eijk, Trui Steen•International Review of…•2016

  • The state and the reconstruction of civil society

    Open Access•Taco Brandsen, Willem Trommel et al.•International Review of…•2017

  • Are non‐government policy actors being heard? Assessing New Public Governance in three C anadian provinces

    Open Access•Bryan Evans, Halina Sapeha•Canadian Public Administration•2015

  • Co‐producing accountability? Drawing conclusions from non‐profit child care services in Manitoba

    Open Access•Karine Levasseur•Canadian Public Administration•2018

  • Does Coproduction of Public Services Support Government's Social Equity Goals? The Case of U.S. State Parks

    Open Access•Beth Gazley, Chantalle Lafontant et al.•Public Administration Review•2020

  • Nonprofit Density and Distributional Equity in Public Service Provision

    Open Access•Yuan Cheng, Lang Yang et al.•Public Administration Review•2022

  • On Being Nonprofit

    Peter Frumkin•On Being Nonprofit•2002

  • Co‐creating ambitious climate change mitigation goals

    Open Access•Eva Sørensen, Jacob Torfing•Regulation & Governance•2022

  • Distinguishing Different Types of Coproduction

    Open Access•Taco Brandsen, Marlies Honingh•Public Administration Review•2015

  • Exploring the Role of Nonprofits in Public Service Provision

    Open Access•Yuan Cheng•Public Administration Review•2018

  • Toward a Definition of the Coproduction Concept

    Jeffrey L Brudney, Robert E England•Public Administration Review•1983

  • Varieties of Participation in Public Services

    Open Access•Tina Nabatchi, Alessandro Sancino et al.•Public Administration Review•2017

  • The Public Service Production Process

    Open Access•Elinor Ostrom, Элинор Остром et al.•Policy Studies Journal•1978

  • Conceptualizing and Measuring Citizen Co‐Production of Community Safety

    Open Access•Stephen L Percy•Policy Studies Journal•1978

  • Co-experience, co-production and co-governance

    Kirsty Strokosch, Stephen P Osborne•Policy & Politics•2020

  • Street-level practice and the co-production of third sector-led employability services

    Colin Lindsay, Sarah Pearson et al.•Policy & Politics•2018

  • I’m paid to do other things

    Caitlin Mcmullin•Local Government Studies•2023

  • Passive cooperation or active coproduction? Grassroots NGOs’ strategies in interactions with government in crisis management in Chengdu, China

    Xiaolin Wu, Wen Qin et al.•Local Government Studies•2025

  • Do Cogovernance and CSOs Supplement Municipal Capacity for Service Delivery? An Assessment of Differences in Simple versus Complex Services

    Open Access•Renzo De La Riva Agüero•Journal of Public Administration…•2022

  • Acres for the Affluent

    Open Access•Samantha Zuhlke•Journal of Public Administration…•2022

  • Coproduction of community public service

    Shihong Weng, Yunxiang Zhang•Journal of Chinese Governance•2020

  • Contextualising co-production and co-governance in the Scottish National Health Service

    Andrew Thompson•Journal of Chinese Governance•2019

  • Not the usual suspects

    Open Access•J B Cullingworth, Richard Brunner et al.•Public Policy and Administration•2024

  • The community philanthropic foundation

    Open Access•Shihong Weng, Tom Christensen•Public Policy and Administration•2019

  • Beyond Engagement and Participation

    Open Access•T Bovaird•Public Administration Review•2007

  • Crossing the great divide

    Open Access•Elinor Ostrom, Элинор Остром•World Development•1996

  • Alternative Models of Government-Nonprofit Sector Relations

    Open Access•Dennis R Young•Journal of Voluntary Action…•2000

  • Collaborative Governance in Theory and Practice

    Christopher Ansell, Chris Ansell et al.•Journal of Public Administration…•2007

  • Embedded and exterior practices of cross-sector co-production

    Open Access•Lars Skov Henriksen, Ane Grubb et al.•Journal of Social Policy•2025

  • Government profiles as perceived by governments' NPO partners in Chinese social service delivery

    Open Access•Yanwei Li, Xianlin Ni et al.•Journal of Social Policy•2023

Unique citing works7
Citations per year7
Citation span2025 - 2026 (2)
Citation velocitycurrent
Highly citedNo
Citation typesNeutral: 7
Ethnos_APP • Open Source Project • MIT License • Frontend v2.0.0 • Privacy and Cookies • API Documentation: api.ethnos.app/docs • API Source Code: GitHub • DOI: 10.5281/zenodo.17049435 • Frontend Source Code: GitHub • DOI: 10.5281/zenodo.17050053 • cruz.rio.br • Expectantes Misericordiae