Skip to main content

ETHNOS_APP

Home • Search • Journals • List 0

Fake It 'til You Make It

Why Community College Students’ Aspirations ‘‘Hold Steady

Bibliographic Data

ID2328384
AuthorsKelly Nielsen (0000-0001-6125-6091, University of California, San Diego, La Jolla, CA, USA, corresponding author)
Year2015
Volume88
Issue4
Pages265-283
Publication date2015-10-01
Peer ReviewedYes
Open AccessYes
TypeARTICLE
VenueSociology of Education (JOURNAL)
Journal identifiersISSN: 0038-0407 • E-ISSN: 1939-8573
PublisherSAGE Publications Inc (PUBLISHER)
DOI10.1177/0038040715601889
OpenAlexW2341050021
LanguageEN
Citations received46
References cited71

Sociologists of education have explored the relationship between students' postsecondary aspirations and their propensity to get 'cooled out' in community colleges. However, researchers have directed little attention to students whose aspirations remain stable over long periods of time or to the different roles that college degree goals play in the lives of disadvantaged students. Using four waves of longitudinal interviews, I examine the reasons why low-income women hold steady to their aspirations for college degrees over a three-and-a-half-year period. I argue that holding steady not only reflects rational expectations about future employment opportunities, but it also generates moral status in the face of marginalization and facilitates the navigation of personal relationships. I use the concept of an 'ambition imperative' to demonstrate how aspirations for college attainment are a means of asserting moral status and pursuing virtuous social membership. This article contributes to theories of aspirations and offers an alternative explanation of the institutional effects of community colleges in the lives of students

Disadvantaged · Economic growth · Economics · Educational attainment · Face (sociological concept) · Higher education · Postsecondary education · Social science · Socioeconomic status · Sociology · Status attainment · Virtuous circle and vicious circle · Critical Race Theory in Education · Higher Education and Employability · Higher Education Research Studies · Psychology · Social Psychology

  • Temporary Removal

    Open Access•April Sutton, Bernardo Mackenna et al.•Research in Social Stratification…•2025

  • High Hopes and Hidden Inequalities

    Open Access•Jennifer M Silva•Emerging Adulthood•2016

  • What the Future Holds

    Open Access•Laina Y Bay-Cheng, Laina Bay-Cheng et al.•Emerging Adulthood•2017

  • Tracking and identity

    Open Access•Dina Banerjee, Akshaj Dev Bhattacharya•Social Sciences & Humanities Open•2023

  • Field experiences for pre-service teachers post-Covid-19

    Open Access•Megan Adams, Sanjuana Rodríguez et al.•Frontiers in Education•2023

  • Positivity amid unfulfilled aspirations

    Open Access•Christina Dimakos, Colleen Loomis et al.•Social Psychology of Education•2026

  • Optimizing Intent to Transfer

    Open Access•Catherine Hartman, Rebecca M Callahan et al.•Research in Higher Education•2021

  • Less is more, or is it? Age and Gender Differences in How Students Build Momentum toward College Graduation

    Open Access•Peter Riley Bahr, Claire A Boeck et al.•Research in Higher Education•2024

  • Why do people go to college? The institutional environment and the educational dispositions of community college students

    Open Access•David B Monaghan•Theory and Research in Education•2024

  • “Stone Steppers” and “Place Makers”

    Open Access•Mary Ippolito•Teachers College Record The Voice…•2021

  • The Winding Path to Degree

    A Freeman•Journal of Women and Gender in…•2020

  • In Today’s Society, It’s a Necessity”

    Open Access•Sarah M Ovink•Social Currents•2016

  • Ambitious ideals, realistic expectations

    Open Access•Zawadi Rucks‐ahidiana•American Journal of Cultural…•2024

  • Pregnancy Intentions, Contraceptive Knowledge And Educational Aspirations Among Community College Students

    Open Access•Marta A Cabral, Rosalyn Schroeder et al.•Perspectives on Sexual and…•2018

  • Making moral migrants? Exploring the educational aspirations of Black African and Caribbean boys in a New York City public school

    Derron Wallace•International Studies in…•2019

  • Narrative Continuity/Rupture

    Open Access•Elena Ayala-Hurtado•Work and Occupations•2021

  • Higher education and the transition to adulthood

    Open Access•Blake R Silver•American Journal of Cultural…•2024

  • Moral education

    Open Access•David B Monaghan•American Journal of Cultural…•2020

  • Life, it doesn't end here”

    Open Access•Alyssa Morley•Teaching and Teacher Education•2021

  • The Achievement Narrative and Alienation in School

    Open Access•Sean J Drake, Jeffrey Guhin•Sociology of Education•2025

  • Salvation or Safety Net? Meanings of “College” among Working- and Middle-Class Young Adults in Narratives of the Future

    Open Access•Jennifer M Silva, Kaisa Snellman•Social Forces•2018

  • Desired fertility and educational aspirations

    Open Access•M Alcaraz, Sarah R Hayford et al.•Journal of Marriage and the Family•2022

  • Unrealized Educational Expectations and Mental Health

    Open Access•Emily Smith-Greenaway, Sara Yeatman•Social Forces•2019

  • I’m Doing This for Me

    Pamela Aronson, Carmel E Price•Sociological Focus•2023

  • Getting by and getting ahead

    Open Access•Kim Skobba, David J Meyers et al.•Children and Youth Services Review•2018

  • Aspirations

    Wendy Baker, William Baker•British Journal of Sociology of…•2017

  • Challenging discourses of aspiration

    Open Access•Neil Harrison, Richard Waller•British Educational Research…•2018

  • A Dream Deferred

    George Spencer, Janine De Novais et al.•The Journal of Higher Education•2023

  • Pedagogy and Profit? Efforts to Develop and Sell Digital Courseware Products for Higher Education

    Open Access•Matthew D Regele•American Educational Research…•2020

  • Who Is Anybody to Judge?” Educational Resistance through Recognition

    Open Access•Christina Ciocca Eller, Elena Ayala-Hurtado•Sociology of Education•2026

  • The Paradox of Persistence

    Open Access•Christina Ciocca Eller, T Diprete et al.•American Sociological Review•2018

  • Focused, Exploratory, or Vigilant

    Open Access•Blake R Silver, Freddy Lopez et al.•Qualitative Sociology•2022

  • Sociology towards death

    Open Access•Kelly Nielsen, Tad Skotnicki•Journal of Classical Sociology•2019

  • Schooled Families

    Open Access•David B Monaghan•Sociological Perspectives•2024

  • The Expectational Liminality of Insecure College Graduates

    Open Access•Elena Ayala-Hurtado•Sociology of Education•2025

  • Academic Orientation as a Function of Moral Fit

    Open Access•Kerby Goff, E Silver et al.•Sociology of Education•2022

  • Planning for College and Careers

    Open Access•Caitlin E Ahearn•Sociology of Education•2021

  • Educational Downgrading

    Open Access•Corey Moss-Pech, Steven H Lopez et al.•Sociology of Education•2021

  • How Political and Ecological Contexts Shape Community College Transfer

    Open Access•Lauren Schudde, Huriya Jabbar et al.•Sociology of Education•2021

  • Why Wait Years to Become Something?' Low-income African American Youth and the Costly Career Search in For-profit Trade Schools

    Open Access•Megan M Holland, Stefanie Deluca•Sociology of Education•2016

  • Adapting to Family Setbacks

    Linda Renzulli, A B Barr•Social Problems•2017

  • Different Time Frames, Different Futures

    Open Access•Yingjian Liang•Social Problems•2024

  • Effort Traps

    Tom Wooten•American Journal of Sociology•2024

  • Parents, Partners, and Professions

    L T Hamilton, E A Armstrong•American Journal of Sociology•2021

  • Located Institutions

    Monica C Bell•American Journal of Sociology•2020

  • Believing in a Positive Future as a Form of Stigma Resistance

    Simone Ispa-Landa•Deviant Behavior•2019

  • The Ambitious Generation

    Barbara Schneider, David Stevenson•The Ambitious Generation•1999

  • Rebellion in a high school

    Arthur Leonard Stinchcombe•Rebellion in a high school•1964

  • The contradictory college

    Kevin James Dougherty•The contradictory college•1994

  • Facing Up to the American Dream

    Jennifer L Hochschild•Facing up to the American Dream•1996

  • Saving the Modern Soul

    Eva Illouz, Santiago Llach•Saving the Modern Soul•2008

  • Paying for the Party

    E A Armstrong, L T Hamilton•Paying for the Party•2013

  • Promises I Can Keep

    Kathryn Edin, Maria Kefalas•Promises I Can Keep•2019

  • The Diverted Dream

    Brint, Steven Brint et al.•The diverted dream•1989

  • The Schooled Society

    David Baker, David P Baker•The Schooled Society•2014

  • On the Edge of Commitment

    Stephen Morgan, Stephen L Morgan•On the Edge of Commitment•2005

  • Hobos, Hustlers, and Backsliders

    Teresa Gowan•Hobos, hustlers, and backsliders•2010

  • Becoming Right

    Open Access•Amy J Binder, Kate Wood•Becoming right•2013

  • Unequal Childhoods

    A Lareau•Unequal childhoods•2019

  • Challenges and Opportunities for Improving Community College Student Success

    Open Access•Sara Goldrick-Rab, Sara Goldrick‐Rab•Review of Educational Research•2010

  • Community Colleges and Social Stratification

    Jérôme Karabel•Harvard Educational Review•1972

  • Habits of the heart

    Ann Swidler, Richard Madsen et al.•Habits of the heart•2007

  • Learning to Labor

    Paul E Willis, Paul Willis•Learning to Labour•2017

  • The Dignity of Working Men

    Open Access•M Lamont•Dignity of Working Men•2000

  • Flat Broke with Children

    Sharon Hays•Inequality Reader•2018

  • Coming Up Short

    Jennifer M Silva•Coming up short•2013

  • Outline of a Theory of Practice

    Open Access•Pierre Bourdieu, Richard Nice•On Violence•2007

  • The Dignity of Working Men

    Open Access•M Lamont•Dignity of Working Men•2009

  • The Minds of Marginalized Black Men

    Alford A Young, Jr Young Alford A et al.•The Minds of Marginalized Black Men•2004

  • Democratization or Diversion? The Effect of Community Colleges on Educational Attainment

    Cecilia Elena Rouse•Journal of Business and Economic…•1995

  • The Logic of Practice

    Pierre Bourdieu•The Logic of Practice•1990

  • The Community College Effect Revisited

    Open Access•J E Brand, F T Pfeffer et al.•Sociological Science•2014

  • What good are interviews for thinking about culture? Demystifying interpretive analysis

    Open Access•A J Pugh•American Journal of Cultural…•2012

  • The limits of plot

    Open Access•Francesca Polletta, Monica Trigoso et al.•American Journal of Cultural…•2013

  • College-For-All

    Open Access•James E Rosenbaum•Social Psychology of Education•1997

  • Education and its Discontents

    Vaisey, S Vaisey•Social Forces•2006

  • Few Remaining Dreams

    Open Access•Brint, Steven Brint•The Annals of the American…•2003

  • From the Liberal to the Practical Arts in American Colleges and Universities

    Brint, Steven Brint et al.•The Journal of Higher Education•2005

  • Ain't No Makin'It

    Jay Macleod•Ain't No Makin' It•2018

  • Social Theory and Social Structure

    Robert King Merton•Social Theory and Social Structure•1968

  • The end of the line

    Kathryn Marie Dudley•The end of the line•1994

  • Reflections on the Role of Social Narratives in Working-Class Formation

    G Steinmetz•Social Science History•1992

  • Carbon Democracy

    T Mitchell•The SHAFR Guide Online•2017

  • Class, Status and Power

    Wilbert E Moore, Reinhard Bendix et al.•American Sociological Review•1954

  • The Temp Economy

    Open Access•Patricia Yancey Martins, Patricia Yancey Martin•Contemporary Sociology A Journal…•2011

  • Sponsored and Contest Mobility and the School System

    Ralph H Turner•American Sociological Review•1960

  • Constraints into Preferences

    Open Access•J Correll, Shelley J Correll•American Sociological Review•2004

  • Subversive Stories and Hegemonic Tales

    Open Access•Patricia Ewick, Susan S Silbey•Law & Society Review•1995

  • Professional Role Confidence and Gendered Persistence in Engineering

    Open Access•E A Cech, Erin Cech et al.•American Sociological Review•2011

  • Is There a Downside to Shooting for the Stars? Unrealized Educational Expectations and Symptoms of Depression

    Open Access•John R Reynolds, Chardie L Baird•American Sociological Review•2010

  • The Community College

    Open Access•Thomas J Kane, Cecilia Elena Rouse•The Journal of Economic…•1999

  • Age and College Completion

    J A Jacobs, Rosalind Berkowitz King•Sociology of Education•2002

  • Race, Class, and Gender in America

    Carla O’connor, Carla O''Connor et al.•Sociology of Education•1999

  • Post-High School Experiences and College Attrition

    Kristine L Anderson•Sociology of Education•1981

  • Social Space and Symbolic Power

    Pierre Bourdieu•Sociological Theory•1989

  • Have Adolescents Become Too Ambitious? High School Seniors' Educational and Occupational Plans, 1976 to 2000

    John Reynolds, John R Reynolds et al.•Social Problems•2006

  • Situational Analyses

    Open Access•Adele E Clarke•Symbolic Interaction•2003

  • Warming Up, Cooling Out, or Holding Steady? Persistence and Change in Educational Expectations After High School

    Open Access•Karl L Alexander, Karl Alexander et al.•Sociology of Education•2008

  • Social and Economic Returns to College Education in the United States

    M Hout•Annual Review of Sociology•2012

  • Flat Broke with Children

    Open Access•Karen Seccombe•Journal of Marriage and the Family•2004

  • Coordinating Futures

    Iddo Tavory, Nina Eliasoph•American Journal of Sociology•2013

  • Bright Futures in Malawi's New Dawn

    M Frye•American Journal of Sociology•2012

  • What Is Agency

    Mustafa Emirbayer, Ann Mische•American Journal of Sociology•1998

  • The Effects of Education as an Institution

    J W Meyer•American Journal of Sociology•1977

  • The 'Cooling-Out' Function in Higher Education

    Burton R Clark•American Journal of Sociology•1960

  • An Analytical Approach to the Theory of Social Stratification

    Talcott Parsons•American Journal of Sociology•1940

  • The narrative constitution of identity

    Open Access•Margaret R Somers•Theory and Society•1994

Unique citing works46
Citations per year4,6
Citation span2016 - 2026 (11)
Citation velocitycurrent
Highly citedNo
Citation typesNeutral: 44
Ethnos_APP • Open Source Project • MIT License • Frontend v2.0.0 • Privacy and Cookies • API Documentation: api.ethnos.app/docs • API Source Code: GitHub • DOI: 10.5281/zenodo.17049435 • Frontend Source Code: GitHub • DOI: 10.5281/zenodo.17050053 • cruz.rio.br • Expectantes Misericordiae