Skip to main content

ETHNOS_APP

Home • Search • Journals • List 0

Four Tools for Critical Inquiry in History, Social Studies, and Civic Education

Bibliographic Data

ID4518436
AuthorsAngela Bermúdez (0000-0003-1405-6438, Universidad de Deusto, corresponding author)
Year2015
Issue52
Pages102-118
Publication date2015-04-01
Peer ReviewedYes
Open AccessYes
TypeARTICLE
VenueRevista de Estudios Sociales (JOURNAL)
Journal identifiersISSN: 0123-885X • E-ISSN: 1900-5180
PublisherUniversidad de los Andes (PUBLISHER • VE)
DOI10.7440/res52.2015.07
OpenAlexW2157193124
LanguageEN
Citations received18
References cited32

The promotion of critical thinking is an important but elusive goal in history, social studies, and civic education. Teachers often struggle to translate general definitions of critical thinking into specific pedagogical tools to plan learning activities and to observe and interpret student work in these subjects. They also struggle to distinguish between "teaching critical content" and "teaching students to think critically." In this paper, I draw upon scholarship on critical thinking, history education, moral education, and critical pedagogy to propose four tools for critical inquiry in the social domain: Problem-posing, Reflective skepticism, Multi-perspectivity and Systemic thinking. I describe how each tool works, discussing how they integrate the epistemic purpose of fostering good understanding with the social purpose of cultivating thoughtful, responsible, pluralist and non-violent citizens

Critical literacy · Critical pedagogy · Critical reading · Critical theory · Critical thinking · Epistemology · Literacy · Pedagogy · Political science · Promotion (chess · Reading (process · Scholarship · Skepticism · Social studies · Sociology · Education and Critical Thinking Development · Educational Assessment and Pedagogy · Educator Training and Historical Pedagogy · Psychology

  • La memoria y la enseñanza de la violencia política desde estrategias audiovisuales

    Open Access•Diego H Arias Gómez•Revista Colombiana de Educación•2016

  • Supporting multi-perspectivity and depolarisation

    Open Access•Evgenia Efimova, Thomas Nygren•Learning and Instruction•2026

  • Propuesta teórico-metodológica para decolonizar la enseñanza de la historia

    Open Access•Benjamin Rafael Sher, Isidora Sáez Rosenkranz•Education Policy Analysis Archives•2023

  • Iran’s Public Diplomacy and Religious Soft Power in Africa

    Open Access•Sayyad Sadri Alibabalu, Teymur Sarkhanov•POLITICS AND RELIGION JOURNAL•2023

  • Representations of violent pasts in memorial museums. Ethical reflection and history education ( Las representaciones de pasados violentos en museos memoriales. Reflexión ética y enseñanza de la historia )

    Angela Bermúdez, Terrie Epstein•Journal for the Study of…•2020

  • Between school and ethical–political everyday action

    Open Access•Natalia Albornoz, Cristina Sebastián•Journal of Curriculum Studies•2022

  • Construct overlap in cross-national assessment

    Open Access•Natalia Ronderos, Sarah Foster-Heinzer et al.•Journal of Curriculum Studies•2024

  • Tensions, articulations, and novelty in the ontogenetic development of historical thinking

    Open Access•Natalia Albornoz, Cristina Sebastián•Theory & Psychology•2022

  • The Right to Truth

    Michelle J Bellino, Michelle Bellino et al.•Comparative Education Review•2026

  • Can Powerful Knowledge Save Us? Critical Reflections through the Lens of Political Education

    Open Access•Johan Sandahl, Mattias Björklund•Social Sciences•2023

  • Creating something out of nothing

    Open Access•Jon Schmidt•Citizenship Social and Economics…•2021

  • Creating capacities for peacebuilding citizenship

    Kathy Bickmore, Ahmed Salehin Kaderi et al.•Journal of Peace Education•2017

  • How to teach for democracy? Identifying the classroom practices used by expert teachers of democracy

    Open Access•Jip Y Teegelbeckers, Hessel Nieuwelink et al.•Teaching and Teacher Education•2025

  • The Impact of an Action Civics Program on the Community & Political Engagement of Youth

    Brooke Blevins, Karon LeCompte et al.•The Social Studies•2020

  • Critical thinking for transformative praxis in teacher education

    Richard I Miller, Katrina Liu et al.•Educational Philosophy and Theory•2023

  • Learning to be fellow inquirers

    Victoria Davis Smith, Kevin Russel Magill•Theory & Research in Social…•2025

  • Financial citizenship education and the elusive power of critical inquiry

    Open Access•Mattias Björklund•Theory & Research in Social…•2024

  • Educación para la ciudadanía en el posacuerdo

    Open Access•María Liliana Díaz Perdomo, Nelson Darío Rojas Suárez•Eleuthera•2019

  • Why Deliberative Democracy?

    Amy Gutmann, D F Thompson et al.•Why Deliberative Democracy?•2004

  • Thinking in Education

    Open Access•Matthew Lipman•Thinking in Education•2003

  • Difference as a Resource for Democratic Communication

    Iris Marion Young•Deliberative Democracy•1997

  • Critical Theories in Education

    Thomas S Popkewitz, Thomas Popkewitz et al.•Critical Theories in Education•1999

  • Constructing Histories

    Mario Carretero, Angela Bermúdez•The Oxford handbook of culture…•2012

  • Cognitive and Instructional Processes in History and the Social Sciences

    Mario Carretero, James F Voss•Cognitive and Instructional…•2012

  • Practical Reason

    Pierre Bourdieu, Pierre Bourdieu Hulya Ugur Tanriover Bahadir Vural Savas Cekic•Practical reason•1998

  • Postmodernism and the Social Sciences

    Open Access•Mohammed H Malek, Joe Doherty et al.•Postmodernism and the Social…•1992

  • Theorizing Historical Consciousness

    Christian Laville, Peter Lee et al.•Theorizing Historical Consciousness•2004

  • Teaching History for the Common Good

    Keith C Barton, Linda S Levstik•Teaching History for the Common…•2004

  • In a Different Voice

    Judith Squires, Carol Gilligan et al.•Feminisms•1993

  • A Developmental Perspective on Community Service in Adolescence

    Open Access•Miranda Yates, James Youniss•Social Development•1996

  • Social Knowledge and Citizenship Education

    Cleo H Cherryholmes•Curriculum Inquiry•1980

  • Developing Critical Thinkers

    W Lee Humphreys, Stephen Brookfield et al.•Teaching Sociology•1989

  • Identifying implicit assumptions

    Open Access•Robert H Ennis•Synthese•1982

  • In Praise of the Cognitive Emotions' and Other Essays in the Philosophy of Education

    Terence H Mclaughlin, Israel Scheffler•The Philosophical Quarterly•1992

  • Knowledge and Human Interests

    Howard L Parsons, Jürgen Habermas et al.•Philosophy and Phenomenological…•1972

  • The Extent to Which Critical Thinking Is Subject-Specific

    Robert H Ennis•Educational Researcher•1990

  • Critical Thinking and Education

    Anthony Flew, John E McPeck•British Journal of Educational…•1982

  • Considered Judgment

    Catherine Z Elgin•Considered Judgment•1996

  • Narrative Tools of History and Identity

    Open Access•J V Wertsch•Culture & Psychology•1997

  • Education and Democratic Citizenship

    Martha C Nussbaum•Journal of Human Development•2006

  • Upheavals of Thought

    Open Access•Martha C Nussbaum, Martha Nussbaum•Upheavals of Thought: The…•2001

  • Post-Modernism and the Social Sciences

    Pauline Marie Rosenau•Post-Modernism and the Social…•1992

Unique citing works18
Citations per year1,8
Citation span2016 - 2026 (11)
Citation velocitycurrent
Highly citedNo
Citation typesNeutral: 17
Ethnos_APP • Open Source Project • MIT License • Frontend v2.0.0 • Privacy and Cookies • API Documentation: api.ethnos.app/docs • API Source Code: GitHub • DOI: 10.5281/zenodo.17049435 • Frontend Source Code: GitHub • DOI: 10.5281/zenodo.17050053 • cruz.rio.br • Expectantes Misericordiae