Harold W Scheffler
Biographic Data
| ID | 81323 |
|---|---|
| NAME | Harold W Scheffler |
| GIVEN NAMES | Harold W |
| FAMILY NAME | Scheffler |
| SIGNATURE | SCHEFFLER H W |
| AFFILIATIONS | Yale University |
| VERIFIED | No |
| TOTAL WORKS | 69 |
| TOTAL CITATIONS | 239 |
| AUTHOR COUNT | 69 |
| EDITOR COUNT | 0 |
| FIRST PUBLICATION YEAR | 1962 |
| LATEST PUBLICATION YEAR | 2023 |
| H-INDEX | 9 |
Sexism and Naturalism in the Study of Kinship
Patrifiliation Sufficient but Not Necessary I
C. D. Forde describes Yako "patricians" as corporate, but by that he means only that each has rights to exclusive use of a dwelling area in the village and to administration of areas of farm land outside the village. A more probable candidate, at least in regard to Yako kepun and eponama, is something taken from the lexicon of local or residential groups. Where patrifiliation is a merely sufficient condition for inclusion in a group, membership i…
Cognatic Descent Groups?
This chapter considers whether, when simple filiation is a condition for inclusion in a group, it is possible for relations of descent to have jural or structural values in intra- or intergroup relations. The openness of a ramage to everyone who appears in its cognatic descent category is not generally taken literally, and it is often no more than a way of talking about kinship and its duties and obligations. However, many ramages have become ent…
Jural Structures I
Jural itself means "of or pertaining to rights and duties". Therefore, a jural rule is a specification of the rights and duties entailed by occupying a specified social position or by having a specified social status. Jural rules certainly do regulate or govern social action or conduct, and they do that by specifying the rights and duties of persons or of sets of persons vis-a-vis one another. If membership itself is a matter of little or no jura…
Jural Structures II
This chapter focuses on social sets or groups and, in particular, on those constituted by rules of filiation and affiliation. Like other kinds of social group, these may or may not be right- and duty-bearing units, that is jural entities, and if they are jural entities the rights attached to them may be either special or general or both. Social groups and other culturally constituted kinds of entity may be treated jurally as person-like by attrib…
Patrifiliation Sufficient but Not Necessary II
J. A. Barnes pointed out that, because patrifiliation is a condition for inclusion in highlands&s; groups, there may be superficial similarities between them and groups described as lineages in the African literature. What it is not difficult to find are groups for inclusion in which patrifiliation is a merely sufficient condition, and that difference accounts for many of the ways in which social groups and intergroup relations in the highlands d…
Descent Groups
The questions of how best to define "descent" and "descent groups" came to the fore once again in the 1950s, in part as a consequence of a great expansion of academic anthropology and of ethnographic fieldwork following World War II, especially in the Pacific, South and Southeast Asia, and Africa. In contrast, affiliation with a nonunilineal descent group, although perhaps in some sense "automatic by birth", is not fixed and immutable but is or c…
Kinship and Descent
W. H. R. Rivers&s;s contribution, in various publications between 1907 and his posthumous Social Organization, has been highly influential, perhaps because in some ways it does not depart greatly from ordinary English usage of the key terms kinship, relationship, descent, inheritance, and succession. Indeed, in the past several decades Rivers has been widely cited as the authority for a distinction between "kinship" and "descent" which, it is som…
Patrifiliation Necessary and Sufficient
Descent groups and local groups are conceptually and empirically two quite different kinds of social entity, and no good can come of confusing one with the other. Because of all that, and because descent groups are self perpetuating and of indefinite duration, such groups are better suited to be also jural entities or jural collectivities than are groups for inclusion in which patrifiliation is merely necessary or merely sufficient. Among the Nue…
Patrifiliation Necessary but Not Sufficient
This chapter argues that patrifiliation is necessary but not sufficient for inclusion in a group, there can be no recruitment from the outside—just as where patrifiliation is the necessary and sufficient condition. As where patrifiliation is both necessary and sufficient, recruitment from the outside is not possible, but because affiliation requires credentials in addition to patrifiliation, it is not automatic by birth. Both kinds of group are n…
Joint-Family Systems
The village communities of southeast China and Taiwan are populated by families that are joint in both the usual anthropological senses. It is conventional for a man&s;s sons to bring their wives to live with him in his house or compound, and his sons are also joint owners with him of the family estate. When a family estate is divided, some portion of it may be set aside in the name of the deceased family head to remain joint property. If a sacri…
Filiation and Affiliation
General Considerations * Kinship and Descent * Descent Groups * Jural Structures, Part One * Jural Structures, Part Two Specific Instances * Patrifiliation, Necessary and Sufficient * Patrifiliation, Necessary but Not Sufficient, Part One * Patrifiliation, Necessary but Not Sufficient, Part Two * Patrifiliation, Sufficient but Not Necessary * Joint Family Systems * Cognatic Descent Groups * Concluding Observations
Book Note
Book Note
Observations on The Fall of Kinship
Gender in Amazonia and Melanesia: An Exploration of the Comparative Method
Gender in Amazonia and Melanesia: An Exploration of the Comparative Method. Thomas A. Gregory and Donald Tuzin. eds. Berkeley: University of California Press, 2001. 392 pp
A New System for the Formal Analysis of Kinship . Sydney H. Gould
Social/Cultural Anthropology: Intimate Communications: Erotics and the Study of Culture . Gilbert Herdt and Robert J. Stoller
Eleven. Sexism and Naturalism in the Study of Kinship
Markedness in Systems of Kin Classification
J. Greenberg's hypotheses about markedness relations in systems of kin classification are reassessed and revised. It is shown that markedness may be associated with polysemy by specialization or with polysemy by generalization. The latter association is especially common in systems of kin classification because of the egocenteredness of such systems and because of the relative-product nature of the relations they include
Social/Cultural Anthropology: Households: Comparative and Historical Studies of the Domestic Group. Robert McC. Netting, Richard R. Wilk . and Eric J. Arnould . eds
Social/Cultural Anthropology: Two Crows Denies It: A History of Controversy in Omaha Sociology . R. H. Barnes
Extension Rules and "Generative" Models
This brief comment challenges Schneider's (AE 12:727-735) critique of extensionist models of kinship, arguing that his characterization of these models as "generative" is misleading. Scheffler clarifies that extensionist models do not aim to generate all possible kinship terms or systems, but rather to provide a framework for understanding the underlying logic of kinship classifications. He emphasizes the importance of distinguishing between the …
The Descent of Rights and the Descent of Persons
Explication and evaluation of the relative ethnographic and theoretical merits of several constructions of "descent" and "descent groups" (by W. H. R. Rivers, M. Fortes, and W. Goodenough, among others) reveals that relations of descent can have right and duty values only where patri- or matrifiliation is the necessary and sufficient condition for inclusion in a social group. Therefore, only unilineally constituted groups should be described as d…
A Further Note on Kinship and Logic
Theory and method in the study of kinship
Barnard, Alan, and Anthony Good. Research Practices in the Study of Kinship. New York: Academic Press, 1984. xiv + 226 pp. including subject and author indices, and bibliography. $32.50 cloth
Australian Kin Classification
This study aims to resolve the century-old debate about the nature of Australian aboriginal societies and the comparability of their structures with the structures of other tribal and kinship-based societies. It begins with a critical evaluation and refutation of the claims that Australians are 'ignorant of physical paternity' and therefore cannot have systems of kin classification. Professor Scheffler then demonstrates that systems of kin classi…
An Algebraic Account of the American Kinship Terminology [and Comments and Reply]
Although componential and transformational analyses are the generally recognized domains for the study of kinship terminology structure, neither procedure completely elucidates the structure formed by kin terms as a system of terms. Both procedures ignore that kin terms, via a kin terms product, form a structure separate from the structure imposed on a genealogical space through definition of kin terms as sets of kin types. Separation of these le…
Filiation and Affiliation
Filiation and Affiliation
General Considerations * Kinship and Descent * Descent Groups * Jural Structures, Part One * Jural Structures, Part Two Specific Instances * Patrifiliation, Necessary and Sufficient * Patrifiliation, Necessary but Not Sufficient, Part One * Patrifiliation, Necessary but Not Sufficient, Part Two * Patrifiliation, Sufficient but Not Necessary * Joint Family Systems * Cognatic Descent Groups * Concluding Observations
Baniata Kin Classification: The Case for Extensions
The system of kin classification used by the Baniata-speaking people of Rendova Island, Western British Solomons, is here subjected to structural semantic analysis. The formal semantic model thus derived is discussed and evaluated with reference to numerous claims that other models of the same general sort are invalid for a variety of reasons and that other kinds of models have greater psychological or cognitive validity. The conclusion is that t…
Theory and Method in Social Anthropology: On the Structures of Systems of Kin Classification
This essay exposes the "logic" underlying six rules formulated by Sol Tax as characteristic of the structures of systems of kin classification in general, and it clarifies the domain of relevance of the rules. The rules follow logically from more fundamental structural features of systems of kin classification, especially from the symmetry of genealogical relationship; they may not properly be used to "predict" much of anything about "kinterm app…
Kinship Semantics
Infrastructures are material forms that allow for the possibility of exchange over space. They are the physical networks through which goods, ideas, waste, power, people, and finance are trafficked. In this article I trace the range of anthropological ...Read More
The Descent of Rights and the Descent of Persons
Explication and evaluation of the relative ethnographic and theoretical merits of several constructions of "descent" and "descent groups" (by W. H. R. Rivers, M. Fortes, and W. Goodenough, among others) reveals that relations of descent can have right and duty values only where patri- or matrifiliation is the necessary and sufficient condition for inclusion in a social group. Therefore, only unilineally constituted groups should be described as d…
Markedness and Extensions: The Tamil Case
H.W. Scheffler's article, "Markedness and Extensions: The Tamil Case," challenges the conventional application of markedness theory to kinship terminology. Focusing on the Dravidian language Tamil, Scheffler argues against the prevailing view that markedness relations in kinship systems are universally determined by semantic extensions from a core denotatum. He demonstrates that in Tamil, and potentially other Dravidian languages, the criteria fo…
Kinship and Alliance in South India and Australia
Dravidien et Kariera: l'alliance de marriage dans l'Inde du Sud, et en Australie. Louis Dumont . Textes de sciences sociales 14. Paris & The Hague: Ecole des Hautes Etudes en Sciences Sociales and Mouton, 1975. 148 pp. 38 F (paper). The Adnjamathanha Personal Pronoun and the “Wailpi Kinship System.” R. Schebeck . Perception of Kinship Structure Reflected in the Adnjamathanha Pronouns. Luise A. Hercus and Isobel M. White . Papers in Australian Lin…
Kindred and Kin Groups in Simbo Island Social Structure
This article examines the kindred and kin group structures of the Simbo Island society in the Western Solomon Islands. Scheffler argues against the prevailing anthropological assumption that kindreds are universally bilateral and ego-focused. He demonstrates that Simbo social organization is based on cognatic descent groups called "vinahu," which are corporate entities owning land and other resources. These groups are not strictly unilineal but a…
The Elementary Structures of Kinship by Claude Lévi‐Strauss: A Review Article
Ambrym Revisited: A Preliminary Report
Deacon reported, and it is widely accepted, that Ambrym "relationship terms" designate the categories of a system of 6 marriage classes formed by the intersection of 3 patrilines with a set of matrimoieties. It is shown here that this is completely false. The terminological system in question is nothing more than a simple system of kin classification which features certain unusual rules of terminological extension. Variants of these rules are fou…
The Genesis and Repression of Conflict: Choiseul Island1
Markedness in Systems of Kin Classification
J. Greenberg's hypotheses about markedness relations in systems of kin classification are reassessed and revised. It is shown that markedness may be associated with polysemy by specialization or with polysemy by generalization. The latter association is especially common in systems of kin classification because of the egocenteredness of such systems and because of the relative-product nature of the relations they include
Choiseul Island Social Structure
Ethnology and General: Structure de la chefferie en Mélanésie du sud. Jean Guiart. (Université de Paris: Travaux et Mémoires de l'Institut d'Ethnologie, LXVI.)
Kin classification and social structure in North India
Choice and Constraint in a Swahili Community: Property, Hierarchy and Cognatic Descent on the East African Coast
Ethnology: Culture and Inference: A Trobriand Case Study. Edwin Hutchins
Ethnology: The Destruction of Aboriginal Society: Aboriginal Policy and Practice. Volume I. C. D. Rowley : Outcasts in White Australia: Aboriginal Policy and Practice. Volume II. C. D. Rowley : The Re…
A Further Note on the Mangaian Kopu
Observations on The Fall of Kinship
Social/Cultural Anthropology: Households: Comparative and Historical Studies of the Domestic Group. Robert McC. Netting, Richard R. Wilk . and Eric J. Arnould . eds
Structuralism in Anthropology
Kindred and Kin Groups in Simbo Island Social Structure
This article examines the kindred and kin group structures of the Simbo Island society in the Western Solomon Islands. Scheffler argues against the prevailing anthropological assumption that kindreds are universally bilateral and ego-focused. He demonstrates that Simbo social organization is based on cognatic descent groups called "vinahu," which are corporate entities owning land and other resources. These groups are not strictly unilineal but a…
A Further Note on the Mangaian Kopu
The Social Consequences of Peace on Choiseul Island
The Genesis and Repression of Conflict: Choiseul Island1
Ethnology and General: Structure de la chefferie en Mélanésie du sud. Jean Guiart. (Université de Paris: Travaux et Mémoires de l'Institut d'Ethnologie, LXVI.)
Structuralism in Anthropology
General and Ethnology: Cultivators in the Swamps: Social Structure and Horticulture in a New Guinea Society (Frederik‐Hendrik Island West New Guinea). L. M. Serpenti
Choiseul Island Social Structure
Choiseul Island Social Structure
Other: Farewell to Eden. Mathew Huxley and Cornell Capa
On Scaling Kinship Terminologies
On Concepts of Descent and Descent Groups
This article examines and clarifies the concepts of descent and descent groups, arguing for a more precise and consistent usage of these terms in anthropological analysis. Basehart and Scheffler critique the prevailing conflation of descent with various social processes like inheritance, succession, and group formation. They emphasize that descent is fundamentally a jural principle based on stipulated genealogical connections, which may or may no…
The Elementary Structures of Kinship by Claude Lévi‐Strauss: A Review Article
General and Ethnology: Kinship and the Social Order: The Legacy of Lewis Henry Morgan. M eyer F ortes. Foreword by Alfred Harris
Ambrym Revisited: A Preliminary Report
Deacon reported, and it is widely accepted, that Ambrym "relationship terms" designate the categories of a system of 6 marriage classes formed by the intersection of 3 patrilines with a set of matrimoieties. It is shown here that this is completely false. The terminological system in question is nothing more than a simple system of kin classification which features certain unusual rules of terminological extension. Variants of these rules are fou…
Kinship Semantics
Infrastructures are material forms that allow for the possibility of exchange over space. They are the physical networks through which goods, ideas, waste, power, people, and finance are trafficked. In this article I trace the range of anthropological ...Read More
Baniata Kin Classification: The Case for Extensions
The system of kin classification used by the Baniata-speaking people of Rendova Island, Western British Solomons, is here subjected to structural semantic analysis. The formal semantic model thus derived is discussed and evaluated with reference to numerous claims that other models of the same general sort are invalid for a variety of reasons and that other kinds of models have greater psychological or cognitive validity. The conclusion is that t…
"On Wordick's Review of "A Study in Structural Semantics
On Krikati and Siriono: A Reply to Lave
Ethnology: The Destruction of Aboriginal Society: Aboriginal Policy and Practice. Volume I. C. D. Rowley : Outcasts in White Australia: Aboriginal Policy and Practice. Volume II. C. D. Rowley : The Re…
Ethnology: Aboriginal Tribes of Australia: Their Terrain, Environmental Controls, Distribution, Limits, and Proper Names. Norman B. Tindale
Choice and Constraint in a Swahili Community: Property, Hierarchy and Cognatic Descent on the East African Coast
Ethnology: Coming into Being among the Australian Aborigines: A Study of the Procreative Beliefs of the Native Tribes of Australia. Ashley Montagu
Ethnology: Kinship in Bali. Hildred Geertz and Clifford Geertz
Kinship and Alliance in South India and Australia
Dravidien et Kariera: l'alliance de marriage dans l'Inde du Sud, et en Australie. Louis Dumont . Textes de sciences sociales 14. Paris & The Hague: Ecole des Hautes Etudes en Sciences Sociales and Mouton, 1975. 148 pp. 38 F (paper). The Adnjamathanha Personal Pronoun and the “Wailpi Kinship System.” R. Schebeck . Perception of Kinship Structure Reflected in the Adnjamathanha Pronouns. Luise A. Hercus and Isobel M. White . Papers in Australian Lin…
Sociology (42 works) · History (36 works) · Computer Science (34 works) · Anthropology (32 works) · Philosophy (27 works) · History (26 works) · Citation (24 works) · Genealogy (22 works) · Kinship (22 works) · Philosophy (20 works)